["My dad's wife asked me to give her back the glassware she gave us at our wedding.", "That's interesting.  Why on Earth would she want it back?", "I honestly have no idea.  It's been 10 years!  I don't even know if we still have it.  I think it's a crazy request."]
That is crazy!  There has to be an explaination!
My dad's wife asked me to give her back the glassware she gave us at our wedding.  We've been married 10 years!  I think this is an insane request.