On Using Active Learning and Self-Training when Mining Performance
  Discussions on Stack Overflow
  Abundant data is the key to successful machine learning. However, supervised
learning requires annotated data that are often hard to obtain. In a
classification task with limited resources, Active Learning (AL) promises to
guide annotators to examples that bring the most value for a classifier. AL can
be successfully combined with self-training, i.e., extending a training set
with the unlabelled examples for which a classifier is the most certain. We
report our experiences on using AL in a systematic manner to train an SVM
classifier for Stack Overflow posts discussing performance of software
components. We show that the training examples deemed as the most valuable to
the classifier are also the most difficult for humans to annotate. Despite
carefully evolved annotation criteria, we report low inter-rater agreement, but
we also propose mitigation strategies. Finally, based on one annotator's work,
we show that self-training can improve the classification accuracy. We conclude
the paper by discussing implication for future text miners aspiring to use AL
and self-training.
