The Importance of Modeling Data Missingness in Algorithmic Fairness: A
  Causal Perspective
  Training datasets for machine learning often have some form of missingness.
For example, to learn a model for deciding whom to give a loan, the available
training data includes individuals who were given a loan in the past, but not
those who were not. This missingness, if ignored, nullifies any fairness
guarantee of the training procedure when the model is deployed. Using causal
graphs, we characterize the missingness mechanisms in different real-world
scenarios. We show conditions under which various distributions, used in
popular fairness algorithms, can or can not be recovered from the training
data. Our theoretical results imply that many of these algorithms can not
guarantee fairness in practice. Modeling missingness also helps to identify
correct design principles for fair algorithms. For example, in multi-stage
settings where decisions are made in multiple screening rounds, we use our
framework to derive the minimal distributions required to design a fair
algorithm. Our proposed algorithm decentralizes the decision-making process and
still achieves similar performance to the optimal algorithm that requires
centralization and non-recoverable distributions.
