TREND: Transferability based Robust ENsemble Design
  Deep Learning models hold state-of-the-art performance in many fields, but
their vulnerability to adversarial examples poses threat to their ubiquitous
deployment in practical settings. Additionally, adversarial inputs generated on
one classifier have been shown to transfer to other classifiers trained on
similar data, which makes the attacks possible even if model parameters are not
revealed to the adversary. This property of transferability has not yet been
systematically studied, leading to a gap in our understanding of robustness of
neural networks to adversarial inputs. In this work, we study the effect of
network architecture, initialization, optimizer, input, weight and activation
quantization on transferability of adversarial samples. We also study the
effect of different attacks on transferability. Our experiments reveal that
transferability is significantly hampered by input quantization and
architectural mismatch between source and target, is unaffected by
initialization but the choice of optimizer turns out to be critical. We observe
that transferability is architecture-dependent for both weight and activation
quantized models. To quantify transferability, we use simple metric and
demonstrate the utility of the metric in designing a methodology to build
ensembles with improved adversarial robustness. When attacking ensembles we
observe that "gradient domination" by a single ensemble member model hampers
existing attacks. To combat this we propose a new state-of-the-art ensemble
attack. We compare the proposed attack with existing attack techniques to show
its effectiveness. Finally, we show that an ensemble consisting of carefully
chosen diverse networks achieves better adversarial robustness than would
otherwise be possible with a single network.
