Needle in a Haystack: Label-Efficient Evaluation under Extreme Class
  Imbalance
  Important tasks like record linkage and extreme classification demonstrate
extreme class imbalance, with 1 minority instance to every 1 million or more
majority instances. Obtaining a sufficient sample of all classes, even just to
achieve statistically-significant evaluation, is so challenging that most
current approaches yield poor estimates or incur impractical cost. Where
importance sampling has been levied against this challenge, restrictive
constraints are placed on performance metrics, estimates do not come with
appropriate guarantees, or evaluations cannot adapt to incoming labels. This
paper develops a framework for online evaluation based on adaptive importance
sampling. Given a target performance metric and model for $p(y|x)$, the
framework adapts a distribution over items to label in order to maximize
statistical precision. We establish strong consistency and a central limit
theorem for the resulting performance estimates, and instantiate our framework
with worked examples that leverage Dirichlet-tree models. Experiments
demonstrate an average MSE superior to state-of-the-art on fixed label budgets.
