Estimating Graph Dimension with Cross-validated Eigenvalues
  In applied multivariate statistics, estimating the number of latent
dimensions or the number of clusters is a fundamental and recurring problem.
One common diagnostic is the scree plot, which shows the largest eigenvalues of
the data matrix; the user searches for a "gap" or "elbow" in the decreasing
eigenvalues; unfortunately, these patterns can hide beneath the bias of the
sample eigenvalues. This methodological problem is conceptually difficult
because, in many situations, there is only enough signal to detect a subset of
the $k$ population dimensions/eigenvectors. In this situation, one could argue
that the correct choice of $k$ is the number of detectable dimensions. We
alleviate these problems with cross-validated eigenvalues. Under a large class
of random graph models, without any parametric assumptions, we provide a
p-value for each sample eigenvector. It tests the null hypothesis that this
sample eigenvector is orthogonal to (i.e., uncorrelated with) the true latent
dimensions. This approach naturally adapts to problems where some dimensions
are not statistically detectable. In scenarios where all $k$ dimensions can be
estimated, we prove that our procedure consistently estimates $k$. In
simulations and a data example, the proposed estimator compares favorably to
alternative approaches in both computational and statistical performance.
