Provably Robust Adversarial Examples
  We introduce the concept of provably robust adversarial examples for deep
neural networks - connected input regions constructed from standard adversarial
examples which are guaranteed to be robust to a set of real-world perturbations
(such as changes in pixel intensity and geometric transformations). We present
a novel method called PARADE for generating these regions in a scalable manner
which works by iteratively refining the region initially obtained via sampling
until a refined region is certified to be adversarial with existing
state-of-the-art verifiers. At each step, a novel optimization procedure is
applied to maximize the region's volume under the constraint that the convex
relaxation of the network behavior with respect to the region implies a chosen
bound on the certification objective. Our experimental evaluation shows the
effectiveness of PARADE: it successfully finds large provably robust regions
including ones containing $\approx 10^{573}$ adversarial examples for pixel
intensity and $\approx 10^{599}$ for geometric perturbations. The provability
enables our robust examples to be significantly more effective against
state-of-the-art defenses based on randomized smoothing than the individual
attacks used to construct the regions.
