Assessing the risk of re-identification arising from an attack on
  anonymised data
  Objective: The use of routinely-acquired medical data for research purposes
requires the protection of patient confidentiality via data anonymisation. The
objective of this work is to calculate the risk of re-identification arising
from a malicious attack to an anonymised dataset, as described below. Methods:
We first present an analytical means of estimating the probability of
re-identification of a single patient in a k-anonymised dataset of Electronic
Health Record (EHR) data. Second, we generalize this solution to obtain the
probability of multiple patients being re-identified. We provide synthetic
validation via Monte Carlo simulations to illustrate the accuracy of the
estimates obtained. Results: The proposed analytical framework for risk
estimation provides re-identification probabilities that are in agreement with
those provided by simulation in a number of scenarios. Our work is limited by
conservative assumptions which inflate the re-identification probability.
Discussion: Our estimates show that the re-identification probability increases
with the proportion of the dataset maliciously obtained and that it has an
inverse relationship with the equivalence class size. Our recursive approach
extends the applicability domain to the general case of a multi-patient
re-identification attack in an arbitrary k-anonymisation scheme. Conclusion: We
prescribe a systematic way to parametrize the k-anonymisation process based on
a pre-determined re-identification probability. We observed that the benefits
of a reduced re-identification risk that come with increasing k-size may not be
worth the reduction in data granularity when one is considering benchmarking
the re-identification probability on the size of the portion of the dataset
maliciously obtained by the adversary.
