Embedded training of neural-network sub-grid-scale turbulence models
  The weights of a deep neural network model are optimized in conjunction with
the governing flow equations to provide a model for sub-grid-scale stresses in
a temporally developing plane turbulent jet at Reynolds number $Re_0=6\,000$.
The objective function for training is first based on the instantaneous
filtered velocity fields from a corresponding direct numerical simulation, and
the training is by a stochastic gradient descent method, which uses the adjoint
Navier--Stokes equations to provide the end-to-end sensitivities of the model
weights to the velocity fields. In-sample and out-of-sample testing on multiple
dual-jet configurations show that its required mesh density in each coordinate
direction for prediction of mean flow, Reynolds stresses, and spectra is half
that needed by the dynamic Smagorinsky model for comparable accuracy. The same
neural-network model trained directly to match filtered sub-grid-scale stresses
-- without the constraint of being embedded within the flow equations during
the training -- fails to provide a qualitatively correct prediction. The
coupled formulation is generalized to train based only on mean-flow and
Reynolds stresses, which are more readily available in experiments. The
mean-flow training provides a robust model, which is important, though a
somewhat less accurate prediction for the same coarse meshes, as might be
anticipated due to the reduced information available for training in this case.
The anticipated advantage of the formulation is that the inclusion of resolved
physics in the training increases its capacity to extrapolate. This is assessed
for the case of passive scalar transport, for which it outperforms established
models due to improved mixing predictions.
