While the vast majority of gallbladder cancer cases have gallstones, only a small fraction of gallstone patients ever develop gallbladder cancer. Since there is no way to identify this small proportion at risk, gallstone cases are cholecystectomized, which, given large absolute numbers of individuals with gallstones, results in overtreatment of some and under-treatment of others in a high-risk area like Chile. While cholecystectomy is standard treatment for symptomatic relief, there are more people who need surgery than there are surgeons to perform them, and individuals aged 34-49 are prioritized for treatment, regardless of symptoms. This practice may lead to overtreatment among 34-49-year-olds and under treatment of individuals aged 50 and above since they have to wait longer for surgery. At the same time, about 30% of patients with a biliary colic attack will never have another attack, and cholecystectomy does not always lead to the cessation of symptoms. In addition, cholecystectomy has been associated with an increased risk of other digestive diseases. Thus, cholecystectomy may not be needed in all gallstone patients and may in fact increase the risk of cancer in some. Better predictors of risk are clearly needed.