These findings are relevant to a large proportion of patients with permanent AF, suggesting that calcium channel blockers should be the first drug of choice for rate control in patients without heart failure or coronary heart disease. Our results challenge the current widespread use of beta blockers in this setting. However, as the follow up time in the RATAF study was only 3 weeks, it is not clear if these effects are sustained over time. Furthermore, we do not know the mechanisms for the differential effects on exercise capacity, arrhythmia related symptoms and NT-proBNP levels.