text:
"Free Thought and Secularism in the Finnish Diaspora"
FinnFest 2008 | University of Minnesota at Duluth
July 24, 2008
With the extremely pervasive political and cultural influence of the fundamentalist Christian religious right in the United States in recent decades that has partially melted down Thomas Jefferson's "firewall" of Constitutional church-state separation, a vigorous intellectual reaction has recently risen to counter it. In the past few years, books by prominent free thought and atheist critics have appeared near the top of non-fiction best seller lists for months at a time.
The most influential of these books has been prominent British scientist Richard Dawkins' The God Delusion which has created the most discussion and controversy. Others have included scholar Sam Harris' The End of Faith: Religion, Terror, and the Future of Reason and Letter to a Christian Nation and writer Christopher Hitchens' God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything, and The Portable Atheist: Essential Readings for the Nonbeliever, which he edited.
Not only have these and other critics indicated their civil libertarian concerns for the separation of church and state but have challenged the very validity of religion itself and the belief in the existence of a supreme deity. They have raised the historic argument of faith versus reason to a new level. So far, the influence of these contemporary critics has primarily rung a responsive note among educated middle class intellectuals, contrasted to the eloquent 19th century American agnostic Robert Green Ingersoll, whose popular oratory and pamphlets reached deep into the ranks of the working class and small farmers.
But this new criticism of religious fundamentalism is not all that new in itself. Back in the late 19th and early 20th Century we can go to our ancestral Finland and find a similar revolt against the doctrines and practices of a then-very conservative Lutheran Church which had much greater power in the life of Finland than the American religious right has yet to achieve here. There was no such thing as church-state separation in the country, then a Grand Duchy of czarist Russia, and this separation does not exist even today in a democratic independent and much more liberal Finland.
HOW IT WAS IN 19th AND TURN-OF-CENTURY FINLAND
In the latter part of the 19th century, the church was a state-sanctioned dominant force in the lives of the Finnish people. Everyone had to belong to the official state churches, the Lutheran or Orthodox. There was no freedom to resign. However, in 1889 a "freedom of religion act" was passed that allowed dissenters to affiliate only with other Protestant churches outside the state churches, but not to leave religion altogether. It was not until 1923 before a non-believer could resign from organized religion and enter the civil register. The structure of the church was patriarchal (no female clergy then) and authoritarian. The church and state held that in the family, the father ruled and money and property disposal was in his hands. The church was a conservative upholder of the status quo advising its parishioners to obey authority and be dutiful to employers. There may be hardships in this life, but if one accepted Jesus Christ as savior, and tried to live a dutiful sin-free life, there was possibility of heavenly rewards in life after death. The church did play a positive role in mandating that schooling was needed to promote literacy, a condition for marriage. So that in contrast to many other European countries, the illiteracy rate was low. But at first, all education was through the church until the 1860s, when with the growth of a strong nationalist movement, public grammar school education was established. Johan Snellman, the leading advocate of the surging Finnish nationalism said that a developing society needed "other teaching than the ordinary religious instruction given by the church…." Even then religious education was mandated within the school program, which, with recent modifications, persists to this day. Tithing was heavy and levied against a poor peasantry barely able to sustain itself. There was no universal franchise and any attempt to ameliorate living conditions such as organizing trade unions was met with stiff resistance by the authorities with the support of the church hierarchy. Nothing was to disturb the governing social order. Civil marriage ceremonies were outside the pale, only church marriages were recognized then.
But social change was advancing everywhere in Europe and could not escape Finland, either. The growth of the political and cultural freedoms of the Enlightenment, scientific discoveries, new ideas in philosophy, Charles Darwin's theses of evolution, the development of Marxian and other forms of socialism, liberal challenges to the prevailing religion, and the modern literary trends of the Ibsens, Strindbergs, Tolstoys, and Chekhovs were reaching Finnish intellectual circles and public.
One of the most important expressions of this restiveness came from the remarkable Finnish feminist and social reformer, the writer Minna Canth (1844-1897). An omnivorous reader and a prolific writer, she devoured the ideas of Tolstoy, Ibsen, Darwin, and other innovative thinkers, which drew her into inevitable opposition to the church. Although profoundly religious in a Tolstoyan sense, she became one of the most influential critics of the dogma and hierarchy of the church. In her powerful agit-prop stage play Työmiehen vaimo (Worker's Wife) (1885), she attacked not only alcoholism, labor injustice and racism (against the Roma minority), but the subordinate role of women in the family, in strict obedience to the husband who had the right to do whatever he wished with her inheritance and their common property. The play aroused a storm, but shortly after its first showing as a result, the property laws were changed to reflect women's rights, too. Her play Papin perhe (The Pastor's Family) (1891) dealt with a rigidly doctrinaire pastor who tried to deny his daughters the right to be independent and choose their professions and clashed with his free-thinking son. She wrote numerous essays and polemics which drew bitter attacks from the conservative clergy. Canth was contemporary with people like Tolstoyan pacifist and social reform writer Arvid Järnefelt, and with the younger labor newspaper editors Matti Kurikka and A.B. (August Bernhard) Mäkelä who became part of her discussion salon of young intellectuals. Mäkelä and she for awhile co-edited a discussion periodical Vapaita Aatteita (Free Ideas) which took up every new subject under the sun. Kurikka became a controversial utopian socialist, Tolstoyan, theosophist, and Kalevala admirer, who along with Mäkelä were founders of the famous utopian communal settlement of Sointula on Malcolm Island in British Columbia in 1901. Canth's writings and plays became enormously popular within the Finnish working class, arousing its political consciousness.
In contrast and later bitter opposition to Kurikka's utopian socialism, the Continental winds of Marxism reached the Finnish working class in the late 19th century, influenced in Finland by the thinking of German Social Democratic Party theorist Karl Kautsky. The young growing working class in the early stages of Finnish industrialization identified with the Marxian class analysis and saw itself as being oppressed by a harsh and exploitative industrial capitalism. The workers also concluded that the church was hostile to their new thinking, that it aligned itself with the ruling class. So while large numbers still identified with Lutheran belief they condemned the church hierarchy many becoming anti-clerical. Thousands of others became familiar with the materialist concepts of Marxist socialism and rejected religion altogether and became atheists. My maternal grandfather, stonecutter Paavo Saikkonen from the Karelian Isthmus became an early Marxist and atheist. My mother Hanna (Saikkonen) Siitonen who worked in hard labor, low income jobs in Finland, identified with her father's views early on and became a life-long non-believer and a democratic socialist. On my father's side, my widowed grandmother Cecilia (Simpura) Siitonen raised her brood of eight young children almost by herself in poverty in Finnish Karelia. She was a devout Christian but all five of her sons became atheists and four, including my father Antti, became active working class socialists.
Also, many thousands of members of the rural work force were called torpparit (crofters) who farmed and lived on lands legally owned by wealthier landowners also identified with the industrial workers as they were forced to do sweat labor to their landlords in payment as a form of rent. They wanted legal possession of the lands for themselves to rid themselves of the onerous material tribute they had to pay annually to their landlords. They received scant support for their demands from the church hierarchy and parish clergy.
In 1899, Finnish socialists founded a Labor Party to start the ball rolling politically. In 1903 this morphed into the Social Democratic Party of Finland at a historic convention in Forssa. While the founders were mostly ideological Marxists, their Forssa Program was not all that revolutionary but reflected the demands of a pragmatic bread and butter socialism. Much like that of their German mentors who talked of social revolution in theory but were quite reformist and parliamentary. Not surprisingly the Forssa Progam called for a separation of church and state. But although significant inroads to secularization have taken place in Finland, to this day there is no complete separation of church and state, although the SDP has often led the government in a majority coalition. The only time this happened was in the Finnish Civil War of 1918, when the Red side in the war controlled southern Finland, where the socialist Peoples Commission (Kansanvaltuuskunta) declared a complete church-state separation. But a White military victory shortly thereafter brought that to a sudden end.
The SDP grew rapidly and was a key factor in the 1905 Finnish General Strike, which besides increasing the strength of the labor movement brought about Parliamentary reform which featured universal franchise that gave women the right to vote, the second country in the world to do so. In the first fully democratic Parliamentary election in 1907. to everyone's surprise, the SDP became the largest party in the Diet with eighty members. This became an important factor in accelerating the secularization process. But there was plenty of poverty and joblessness which created a huge immigration exodus between 1880 and 1920 to North America of workers and disinherited farm folks who were proletarianized, only with no work in sight.
Let's now back up to the 1880s and see what happened in the immigration of Finns to the United States and Canada.
The main immigration began about 1880, and initially consisted mostly of single men who ended up working in the woods, mines, and anywhere hard labor was needed. The Evangelical Lutheran Church was not happy about the emigration, since on that strange continent the Finnish religious institutions would have no control over them. They were accused of betraying country, family, and religion. Immorality, sin and depravity would be their lot when the churches had no control over them. Of course, in the United States there was no state church and separation of church and state prevailed. For many of these workers both state and church in the old country were seen as instruments of repression and authoritarian control over their lives. So they felt a powerful sense of freedom from it, and the majority of the Finns who immigrated joined no church at all. There were many devout among these Finns, too, some who were attracted to revivalist and apostolic Finnish religions like the Laestadians in which the congregation rather than a formal hierarchy was the pattern. From 1876 on, the Finnish state church established its counterpart in the Suomi Synod, or the American Finnish Lutheran Church, organizing formally in 1890 on U.S. soil, in Hancock, MI, of which many of the immigrants were suspicious because of their negative experiences with it back home.
Other Lutherans objected to the Synod, as well for what they saw as its rigid conservatism and founded a somewhat more liberal Finnish American National Evangelical Lutheran Church in 1898. All of them, the Synod, Apostolic and National Lutherans were bitter rivals in competing for adherents.
There wasn't much in the way of social gospel for community reform among these institutions as is true of many US Protestant denominations today, as well as in the strong undercurrent of "liberation theology" in the Catholic Church. Perhaps as something of an anomaly at the time, a Unitarian community was founded on the Minnesota Iron Range in 1911 by Finnish humanists and Unitarian ministers Milma Tikkanen Latvala, and her husband Risto Latvala. This liberal, non-dogmatic denomination had a good localized following among the Finns for many years.
But for the Synod in particular, its community work beyond the church itself was focused on the temperance movement. A huge, disheartening problem among these lonely immigrant workers was the desperation of their lives in their oppressive working and living conditions and poverty, so their primary form of association was often the saloon, which brought on drunkenness, fighting, and prostitutes to relieve their intense loneliness. So the Synod, hoping to rescue these sinners from their degradation, founded the Finnish National Temperance Brotherhood in 1888. It provided a sober social alternative and a stable social environment.
However a good many of these immigrant workers chafed and rebelled against the strict religious aura of these temperance halls. Everything was prayer and Bible-oriented for the saving of souls as the way to be weaned off John Barleycorn. By this time many young women were immigrating from Finland to work as domestics and in factory and other work, and young people wanted their share of secular recreational joy. The original Synod temperance halls were dead set against dancing, card playing, and stage plays as dangerous pastimes to lure the young.
So dissident elements broke away or were expelled by the Brotherhood and formed the Finnish Friends of Temperance as a rival organization. Prayer was no longer the focus, and secular activities which later became so popular in Finnish America began to develop. Reading tastes began to diversify into modern cosmopolitan directions and the immigrants began to yearn for political and other associative approaches with which to improve their lives in the here and now, instead of waiting for the illusory bounties of an afterlife. This led to the coming of the historic Finnish-American labor movement....
The earliest version of Finnish immigrant socialism was that of the colorful visionary Matti Kurikka, we saw earlier as a protégé of Minna Canth. He had left Finland to establish a utopian communal settlement in Australia in 1900 to set an example to the world of how people could live together in peace, harmony and cooperation in contrast to the harsh predation of the rising industrial capitalism. But he got nowhere. About that time a group of Finnish miners on Vancouver Island, working under the most miserable conditions, thought of founding a settlement where they could fish, farm, log and live cooperatively away from the harsh conditions of their lives under the prevailing system. Someone showed them some pamphlets written by Kurikka extolling the possibility of his vision for a new society. Since these miners had few organizational skills to actualize such a project, they write to Australia to Kurikka to help found such a community and paid his way to come to Canada. The always enthusiastic dreamer Kurikka came and they were able to secure a grant to farm on Malcolm Island, just off the north coast of Vancouver Island, a homesteading project granted by the British Crown. They called it Sointula, a "Place of Harmony", which officially was founded in 1901. Kurikka enlisted his old Finnish comrade A.B. Mäkelä to come from Finland to join him at Sointula, as the more Marxist Mäkelä was more level-headed on practical things than the mercurial over-the-top Kurikka, who recognized his own weaknesses here.
Kurikka traveled all over the United States on a speaking tour to fire up support and settlers to come to Sointula to help build this new ideal community that would set an example for the whole world as the way forward for a just society. He was able to arouse a lot of excitement for the ideals of socialism itself, although many shook their heads at his bizarre ideas on theosophy, and of Sointula being the new land of Kaleva that Elias Lönnrot wrote about. Although an admirer in Jesus and believer in the Golden Rule, Kurikka's anti-clerical condemnation of the established church, and his reputation from his days in Finland, aroused angry attacks from the church who saw him as the worst heretic and an anti-Christ. His Marxist opponents in Finland had also condemned him as a preposterous, impractical dreamer and a fool who didn't understand Marxist class analysis. But his tour did fire up a lot of enthusiasm among the immigrant workers that "another world is possible", to borrow from today's anti-corporate globalization movement.
The original Kalevan Kansa commune only lasted as a legal entity for about three years, due to bad luck, inexperience, factionalism and the follies of Kurikka in securing a bridge building contract for the Sointulans as a low bidder, which presaged an economic disaster for the collective. Kurikka also preached that the institution of marriage was a patriarchal prison, and that people should just follow their hearts and live in love and free union without benediction of church or state. So "free love" became an issue that divided the commune. Kurikka and Mäkelä became bitter enemies and the perennial visionary and his followers left the island. The commune was disbanded as a legal entity, but about half of the people stayed to farm their own individual plots but the community has thrived in the spirit of cooperation to this day, through consumer cooperatives , mutual aid, and the fisherman's union. The more practical dreamers saved the day. But its negativity toward churches continued and no church was built on the island until the 1950s when a number of more conservative post-World War II Finns moved to Sointula from the old country. Religion still doesn't play a major role.
Matti Kurikka had always denounced the "bread socialism" of his Finnish Marxist opponents as a threat to his vision of a beautiful Tolstoyan world embodying the values of the mythic Land of Kaleva. But the more materialist class-oriented socialism drew the support of the vast majority of the Finnish immigrant labor movement that impressively sprang to life after the turn of the 20th century.
In the 1890s several reformist labor societies with a temperance bent were organized like the Saima Society of Fitchburg, Mass., and Imatra Society in Brooklyn, NY, which stressed self-improvement among workers. But then an émigré Finnish intellectual Antero F. Tanner arrived on the scene in 1899 and started a lecture series at a Finnish temperance hall in Rockport, Mass. discussing geology, astrology, chemistry and Darwinian evolution, as well as introducing his listeners to socialist ideas. The local Synod pastor denounced his talks as unchristian. But Tanner continued and soon the first Finnish immigrant socialist local in the U.S. was formed at Rockport, initially affiliating with the Socialist Labor Party of Daniel DeLeon. Tanner was soon joined by Martin Hendrickson, who became an early popular apostle of an American Finnish socialism. Together in 1900 they established the first Finnish language labor newspaper, Amerikan Työmies (American Worker) in Brooklyn, NY. Stressing labor education, the periodical was critical of religious leaders who obstructed progress of the workers' cause, but one writer said that "any religion which inspired workers to seek true freedom was compatible with their aspirations." Amerikan Työmies folded in less than a year, but it helped spark the growth of a movement.
Hendrickson went on a speaking tour around the country which fired up Finnish workers in the cause and local organizations began to be formed. Hendrickson's presence alarmed the conservative clergy which attacked him and warned workers not to listen to him. After a talk in one town in the Upper Midwest, some people swept the ground where he had walked on with brooms to exorcise this agent of the devil who had befouled their community. But "Matti Setä" (Uncle Matti) energized thousands of devotees in his wake with his secular evangelism.
But it wasn't long before other labor papers again begin to emerge. Työmies (The Worker) was established in Worcester, MA in 1903 as a non-profit explicitly socialist newspaper. It soon moved to Hancock, MI, and later to Superior, Wisconsin, where it continued a long life, lasting until the 1990s, as Työmies-Eteenpäin (Worker-Forward). It was followed in 1905 by Raivaaja (The Pioneer) inspired by another prominent émigré socialist Taavi Tainio, which became the primary organ of Finnish-American social democracy for many years, and still exists today as the oldest of the immigrant-founded papers, though it's no longer ideologically partisan. Founded in 1907 in Astoria, OR, the newspaper Toveri (Comrade) carried the banner of labor until 1930. All of them were secular papers and for years engaged in a war of words with the more conservative, non-socialist Finnish-American press, which was backed by much of the clergy.
All of this culminated in the founding of the Finnish Socialist Federation (Suomalainen Sosialistijärjestö) in 1906 at Hibbing, Minnesota, which grew at an astounding rate around the country to reach a height in membership of 15,500 members in its various Locals in April, 1914. Soon after its founding, the Federation affiliated as the first foreign language federation of the Socialist Party of America. Some of its early leaders were already prominent in Finnish politics, having fled here from political persecution. Some like the gifted Santeri Nuorteva were well educated, while most were blue collar workers who were self-educated. The literacy that the Finnish church had insisted on for its parishioners enabled these emerging socialists to read and study far beyond what the church would have desired, to discover Canth, Darwin, Marx, Kautsky and German Marxist August Bebel among others.
The FSF inspired a vibrant new movement, not only in its politics, but this "hall socialism" was rich in culture, offering theater, poetry readings, choruses, bands, dances, libraries, children's and youth activities and athletics for the participation of its members. Subsidiary journals were founded like Säkeniä, (Sparks) the theoretical magazine published by Raivaaja. Women felt more empowered in this new political culture and pushed for their own voice and activity which met resistance from some of the more culturally conservative men, for whom overcoming a patriarchal legacy was difficult even as convinced socialists. Finnish feminist Minna Canth's plays were highly popular on Finn Hall stages. These strong pioneer women founded their own radical publications like Toveritar (Woman Comrade) and Naisten Viiri (Women's Banner), and they insisted on total equality in Federation councils and assemblies.
This was the milieu my parents entered when they came to the United States in 1915, both already convinced socialists and secularists. They met at the socialist Veli (Brother) Hall in Quincy, Massachusetts, my father Antti Siitonen was working as baker for his brother August, also a Veli Hall socialist, and my mother Hanna Saikkonen as a maid for the mayor of Quincy. My father was active in the hall as an actor on the stage, and a wrestler and gymnast for its own Karhu (Bear) Athletic Club, and my mother as a gymnast for Karhu. They married in 1917, and the socialist hall was central to their lives outside of work. That was the environment to which I was born much later and brought up in, the halls of the Finnish-American labor movement.
Raivaaja, Työmies and Toveri all established their own book publishing operations (union label, of course) and printed dozens of books, many by Finnish-American authors and books in translation. American Socialist authors like Upton Sinclair and Jack London were popular. My father's favorite book was Mark Twain's Luotsina Mississipillä (Life on the Mississippi), which I first read myself from his tattered copy in Finnish translation. But since out lecture topic is on secularism in this early community, I want to list some of the books published along these lines by these presses.
Both Raivaaja and Työmies printed books translated from the writings of the famous American agnostic Robert G. Ingersoll, which were also popular in Finland during this period, with their own Finnish publishers. By the way, Ingersoll was a leading member of the American Republican Party, at one time promoted as its presidential candidate, and was one of the greatest orators in US history. Compare that to today's Republican Party which the fundamentalist Religious Right nearly controls.
I found several of these books which had been donated to our Berkeley Kaleva hall library by members decades ago. One was Ingersoll's Skulls (Pääkallot) and God in the Constitution (Jumala perustuslaissa), issued by the Raivaaja Publishing Co., in 1907. Another Raivaaja book was Helen H. Gardener's Men, Women and Gods (Miehet, naiset ja jumalat), 1885, translated by Hanna Kunnas as a Raivaaja book sometime before 1910.
Gardener (1853-1925), was a noted American free thinker and suffragette, contemporary and friends with Ingersoll and sister feminist and free thinker Elizabeth Cady Stanton.
The following statement by Helen Gardener pretty well sums up the essential thinking of our non-believer labor forebears: "I do not know of any divine commands. I do know of most important human ones ….. I do not know the needs of a god or of another world. I do know that women make skirts for seventy cents a dozen in this one. I do know that the needs of humanity in this world are infinite, unending, constant and immediate. They will take all our time, our strength and love, and our thoughts, and our work here will be only then begun."
Another Raivaaja book was Herbert N. Casson's Against Superstition (Taikauskoa vastaan). translated by Eliof Christianson and published in 1907. Casson (1869-1951) was a Methodist minister who was tried for heresy and became a non-believer.
Another book, Toward the Light (Valoa kohti), by Pekka Ervast was published by the newspaper Pohjan Tähti (The North Star), which was Raivaaja's conservative competitor in Fitchburg. Ervast was a famous Finnish theosophist and Rosicrucian, so that the spirit of the eclecticist Matti Kurikka also paid a visit to Fitchburg!
A.B. Mäkelä tried his hand at translation of the selected writings of German philologist and Orientalist F. Max`Muller (1827-1900). Mäkelä, who wrote this translation under an anglicized name he often used in Sointula, Austin McKela, which he entitled: Luonollinen uskonto: Otteita F. Max Mullerin luennoista (Natural Religion: Selections from F. Max Muller's Lectures), which was published in 1904 by the Kalevan Kansa Press in Sointula. Muller's attempt was to establish a natural religion by synthesizing the best of many comparative historic religions. Mäkelä, a reputed Marxist, must have still been under the influence of Kurikka and his eclectic approach at the time he did this translation.
Most of the immigrant workers had little formal schooling in Finland so they wanted to learn useful skills and study both English and Finnish, bookkeeping, history and many other subjects., including economic and socialist theory and education about the labor movement. In 1896 in Hancock the Synod had established its own school Suomi-Opisto which became the famous Suomi College, now known as Finlandia University. It was religiously oriented and was for years a seminary for training clergy for the Synod, so this did not appeal to the secular Finns who had become alienated from religion.
But in 1903 the more liberal National Lutherans, who looked more kindly upon the socialists as people of good will, established the Kansan Opisto (Peoples School) initially in Minneapolis which would not only serve its own congregation but Finnish immigrants generally and was willing to work with socialists in developing it. So it hired Alex Halonen a socialist editor, as its fundraiser who recruited other socialists to buy shares in it. Moving the school to Smithville near Duluth, the socialists became the majority shareholders who were dissatisfied with the original format of the school and wanted to make it more amenable to working class priorities. So it passed into socialist hands and was renamed Työväen Opisto (Work Peoples College) . Many of the National Lutherans became embittered toward the socialists and became hostile to their struggles from then on. This split was not surprising and Halonen, who at first was more conciliatory to his religious allies, mainly criticizing the clergy for not being progressive enough in supporting the needs of labor and temperance, hardened his outlook toward organized churches. In 1928 he declared: "Socialism which is entirely a cultural movement and represents the economic and spiritual freedom of all mankind, cannot endorse a class religion, which is used to enslave people." This Marxian "opiate of the masses" view was shared by many of his comrades. Work Peoples College thus became an official institution initially of the Finnish Socialist Federation.
WPC offered classes in English, Finnish, History, Economics, Sociology, Geography, Bookkeeping, History of Socialism and Darwinian Evolution. Later it trained potential staff people for the burgeoning consumer cooperative movement which was an important arena of activity for the Finnish socialists, as well as labor movement organizers. It employed teachers from Finland like Yrjö Sirola and Leo Laukki. Particularly with Laukki, the school took a radical direction toward the revolutionary industrial unionism espoused by the Industrial Workers of the World, founded in Chicago in 1905. Thousands of radicalized Finnish immigrants were attracted to the IWW's militancy as a labor organization and became involved in it, with Laukki a leading spokesman for it in the Federation. In the first great schism in Finnish-American radicalism Work Peoples College went with the Finnish Wobblies and remained its labor college until 1940 when it dissolved.
In Socialist Locals (Osastot), educational programs were also a high priority. There were libraries, speakers, discussion groups and debates. Most of the immigrants were young adults and had families and children. The Finnish community as a whole wanted its children to appreciate their Finnish heritage and thus significant attention was paid to their education, particularly literacy in the Finnish language. The churches had a sophisticated system of Sunday schools, in which the learning of Finnish, was done as part of Bible study, as the main emphasis was on religious education.
The socialists had their own children's Sunday school organized as the Ihanneliittos (Idealistic Leagues). Instead of Finnish Bible studies, they utilized a Työväen Aapinen (Workers' Primer) in which the Finnish lessons were based on socialist themes. My cousin Lempi Siitonen, who was born in 1911 went to the Ihanneliitto Sundays when she was a little girl at the socialist Veli Hall in Quincy. So she passed her Aapinen and other items on to me. I was born in 1926 and the days of the Idealistic Leagues were over and done with when I got to the right age. But appreciated the book with its illustrations which told of workers being unemployed and wife and children hungry, with smoke stack factories belching their black issue outside of the window of their meager tenement housing. I used to read the text out loud.
Although after 1909, the official position of the FSF was that "a person's religious outlook was a private matter", there was a lot of contention against the churches and clergy in the Finnish labor press, answered in the same measure and as angrily by the conservative pro-church publications. This was exacerbated mightily by the Minnesota Mesabi Range Strike of 1907.
Iron miners worked under horrific conditions and death and injury rates on the job were high. It was the Mesabi version of the "satanic mills" of early industrial England. So when the Western Federation of Miners union began an organizing campaign on the Range, thousands joined, led by the Finns. The plans were to make demands on the Oliver Iron Mining Division of US Steel when the union had fifty per cent of the miners signed up. But they were forced to act prematurely when wildcat strikes on the Duluth and Superior docks triggered a wholesale strike on the Range. The Finns were the most militant contingent for the union, with the overall direction of the strike led by two young Finnish WFM organizers John Mäki and John Kolu.
After a violent two-month strike involving special deputies and strikebreakers, the strike was lost. Then the wrath of the business community came down on the strikers, particularly the Finnish socialists. Newspapers on the Range led the xenophobic rage, saying "fully ninety per cent of those on the line were Finlanders — fiery followers of the Red Flag.…" The Eveleth News attacked the young Finns in the strike, "imbued with the nihilistic spirit and are nihilists and anarchists instead of the socialists they claim … The Finns that compose this class are not fit to become citizens." Many of the Finns were blacklisted and were forced to leave the area or survive by hard-scrabble farming. This all served to radicalize the Finnish workers like nothing else could.
In contrast, the conservative Finnish community was ashamed of its radical brethren, and countered with a campaign of its own deploring these "troublemakers" and "agitators", and to indicate they and the majority of Finns were good loyal Americans who worked hard and were team players for their employers and lived as decent God-fearing citizens. Members of the Suomi Synod formed a "Citizens' Committee" which condemned socialism as "Eastern-Asian barbarianism." The Committee issued a statement which read: "We abhor and condemn the actions of the Socialists in their past acts and inflammatory speeches disgracing the Christian religion and civilization, tending to destroy the moral and chaste welfare of home and society, laying the foundations for atheism, corruption and anarchy … Therefore, let it be resolved that on behalf of the majority of Finns, that we can no longer silently bear the loss of the employers' confidence which has been caused by the instigation of the Socialists, and on the returning of that confidence depends the success and welfare of our homes."
Imagine the polarization this amplified between the "Red Hall Finns" and the "Church Finns"! This example repeated itself in the Copper Country strike of 1913 in the Hancock-Houghton area of Michigan and again in the 1916 Mesabi Range strike led by the Industrial Workers of the World, both in which Finnish socialists and workers were heavily involved. Similar outcries against "socialist agitators" came from the conservative Finns, businessmen and clergy. If only these agitators weren't around to mislead the workers, everything would be more peaceful and orderly. But as the late Finnish-American historian Michael Karni pointed out, that these miners were educated "in the school of Morgan and Rockefeller" and needed no "outsiders" to tell them how they should think about their difficult lives and why they shouldn't fight to improve them through labor solidarity. These great labor struggles left bloody scars between these two sides of the Finnish community which took many decades to heal.
Despite the forgoing setbacks and ensuing hardships the Finnish radicals endured, their socialist movement grew. But then ideological schisms arose, as they did with the churches. The first of them occurred in the Socialist Party of America as well as in the FSF, over the issue of industrial unionism versus electoral. The IWW was a strong element in both the SPA and FSF. But the Wobblies believed more in the efficacy of anarcho-syndicalist direct action on the job, than in running candidates for political office, whereas the electoral-minded political socialists advocated the latter. This all came to head of the SP's 1912 convention when IWW labor leader Big Bill Haywood was removed from the Party's national committee, with the admonition that an anti-electoral position was antithetical to Party membership.
As it was, Wobblies left the SP in droves as they felt they were not wanted, as well as from the FSF. Several thousand Finns thus left the SP and took their Locals with them, mostly in the Midwest and the West Coast, along with their halls and with Work Peoples' College which was under the control of the industrial unionists. Of course, this weakened the FSF considerably. World War I subjected both the SP and IWW to further hammering for their anti-war positions. The revered SP presidential candidate Eugene Victor Debs went to jail for his stand against the war as did a number of his comrades. The SPA was one of the few socialist parties in the world which declared its opposition to the war at its St. Louis convention. But the IWW, which took no official position on the war, was attacked mercilessly by the Woodrow Wilson Administration as subversive. Union headquarters were raided and trashed and at least 166 IWW leaders from around the country were arrested and jailed and found guilty. Four of these arrested were Finns, including Leo Laukki and Fred Jaakkola of Work Peoples College. This persecution almost destroyed the IWW.
The Second Schism played even greater havoc with the FSF. This came as an aftermath of the Russian Revolution of 1917, particularly its October phase which brought the Bolsheviks to exclusive state power.
At first, much of the democratic world rejoiced in the overthrow of the Czar, including the ranks of the SPA and the FSF Finns. But then divisions arose. Those who supported the Revolution wholly and uncritically left the SPA and formed the Workers Party, and later the Communist party-USA, while those who supported the Socialist Party which began to be critical of the Bolshevik regime as it dictatorially banished and eventually outlawed the other left organizations in Russia, including the Mensheviks, Social Revolutionaries, Anarchists and others. A similar bitter split took place in the FSF. The pro-Bolsheviks won over the majority of the FSF, departed the Socialist Party, and functioned as the FSF until it affiliated with the 1920s Workers' Party which eventually morphed into the CP-USA. By far not all of the pro-Soviet Finns joined the CP, so the Finnish Workers Federation was created to encompass all of the pro-Soviet Finns in the 1920s. The more social democratic Finns who became critical of the new Russia for its undemocratic rule, regrouped as a new Federation and retained its affiliation with the SPA.
So now there were three disparate currents to the Finnish-American labor movement. The IWW Finns with their newspaper Industrialisti, the pro-CP Finns who took possession of the newspapers Työmies and Toveri in the split, and the SP Finns who managed to salvage Raivaaja as their organ. Each had their own halls, the possession of which involved bitter legal and even physical battles over who would control them.
Thousands of radicals were deported after World War I to their home countries from the United States, including some Finns. And with a wave of anti-foreign hysteria pervading the atmosphere, immigration laws were enacted which reduced newcomers to these shores to a trickle. So the mass migration of Finns here was ended, which also brought about the gradual decline of Finnish organizations in this country, whether radical, conservative or in between, or whether religious or secular.
With all the preceding factors presaging its inevitable decline, activities of all these groups still continued at a vigorous pace through the 1920s and well into the thirties. During my own childhood and youth in the 1930s and early 1940s, the hall activities in which I grew up were still lively and fulfilling. But most of the second generation Finns did not see that much relevance by and large in their parents' radicalism, as they became part of the American popular culture, and often were ashamed of it. But we did have our "Red Diaper Babies" in all the competing left political currents. I'm not sure when the Idealistic Leagues faded out for good, probably sometime in the 1920s. But I know that in the case of the 1920s Socialist Party Finns, several hundred second generation Finnish youths joined the Young Peoples' Socialist League, the historic "Yipsel", to form its New England clubs, according to Raivaaja editor F. J. Syrjälä.
The second generation pro-CP youths went to the Communists' Pioneer camps, largely in the Midwest when they were kids. Later US. Communist Party chief, the late Gus Hall, was a product of Finnish run Pioneer camps in Minnesota, according to the late Mayme Sevander. Teen-agers from that orientation often went on to join the Young Communist League, YCL.
The IWW Finns were not remiss in regard to their youth. Summer schools were held at Smithville's Work Peoples College to attract their progeny to industrial unionism and the cause of labor. While the IWW Finns weren't too prominent on the East Coast, they did have a hall in Brooklyn, CT, where they held a summer school for Junior Wobblies, the IWW's youth group.
The old confrontations between the secularist socialists and religious Finns lost their sharp edge in these ensuing years. They were never a major factor in the main Socialist Party, which had a social gospel wing, with considerable numbers of clergymen as members. Several times SP Presidential candidate Norman Thomas was a former Protestant clergymen. The SP Finns left the Party about 1937 during the Roosevelt era, due to bitter internal turmoil caused by the entry of American Trotskyites into the Party which almost ruined it before they left. But trying to relive an experience I had earlier missed, I joined the Yipsels and SP in 1952 in Chicago. That year I went to Cleveland to the SP-USA's National Convention. There I saw a number of ministers and divinity students as delegates, along with expected secularists, something that was foreign to my Finnish community experience. A carload of us drove back to Chicago afterwards, driven by John McCartney, a Methodist minister in some small town Kansas church, accompanied by a Unitarian theology student from the University of Chicago, besides us three atheist Marxists. To pass the time, we all joined in singing some boisterous socialist and labor songs. When we sang "The Internationale", the Reverend John belted it out as loud as the rest of us. And we all called each other "Comrade".
In the Finnish community, the old secular-religion argument became less of an issue. It wasn't important to those young who remained politically active on the Left. There were enough hot button political issues to address during the Depression and the coming of fascism and WWII. Some of the now slowly-dying First Generation secular Finns and some of the Second Generation did join a church, but according to the recently-deceased Finnish-American historian A. William Hoglund, two thirds of these Finns remained unaffiliated, Among the second generation Left Finns, those who did join a church were not necessarily attracted to the Lutheran Church of their parents or grandparents. I've personally known several who have joined the Unitarians, another who is a Quaker, and one who is a Buddhist.
In looking back at the rich and complex history of the secular immigrant Finns, its record seems clear, which pretty much dispels the fundamentalists' argument, that if one doesn't believe in God and has no religious faith, not only is s/he destined to end up in eternal torment in a place called Hell, but they'll be devoid of morals, unable to distinguish good from evil, lead a dissolute life, become a social scourge and descend into total nihilism. But let's look at what these working class socialists did during their history: They worked to develop a positive community through the values of mutual aid, cooperation, equality and democracy through their Socialist osastos and halls, organized major consumer and family farmers' cooperatives, were active in organizing and supporting labor unions to improve their working conditions and bring dignity to their lives on the job through worker solidarity expressed in the IWW-created watchword: "An injury to one is an injury to all." They raised the cultural level of the community through music, song, literature, theatre, poetry, dance and athletics as well as published newspapers and books for their self-education and enlightenment. They sacrificed and labored for the education of their children so they wouldn't have to spend their lives doing the hard, dirty and backbreaking work to which the parents had been subjected. And above all they projected the values of a future society in which there would be no exploitation, inequality, hatred or war, in which democracy and respect for human dignity and critical inquiry would be encouraged.
Although the basics of faith versus secularism will never be resolved, mutual respect has reduced the polarization that marked the Finnish community in those earlier years. The first big breakthrough for cooperation across the board came in the planning for and execution of the Tercentennial Delaware Celebrations in 1938, of the time when the Finns of all persuasions all over the country came to together to honor the Finnish and Swedish pioneers who 300 hundred years before landed and settled in what later became the state of Delaware. Thus all the church denominations, temperance and co-op folks, socialists, communists, and IWWs all came together to make the Tercentennial a huge success. Speaking terms were established, between some for the first time, seeing each other as good people of the same ancestry.
The second event the very next year, tragic in contrast, brought most all these elements together again to help their brethren in Finland during the Russian-Finnish Winter War of late 1939, early 1940. That was when the Soviet Union suddenly attacked Finland militarily in the middle of negotiations to Russian demands to change the border configurations of the two countries, arguably for Finland to cede some of its turf to shore up the defenses of the Leningrad area.
Hundreds of benefits were held around the country to send relief packages and supplies to the people of the besieged Finland during that war and its aftermath. Again the socialists, co-opers, the anti-authoritarian IWWs, churches, conservatives and business Finns came together to help and raise funds and goods for their ethnic kin. However, left out of this equation were most of the pro-communist Finns, who were so much in denial about the Gulag that their beloved Soviet Union had become in the Stalin era that they believed Finland had started the war. They supported the USSR in the conflict. They were as dogmatic in their convictions as are the fundamentalist Christians who believe in the absolute inerrancy of the Bible and church dogma, despite their inconsistencies and contradictions and totally refuse to subject their beliefs to critical examination. The late working class philosopher Eric Hoffer called both such religious and political dogmatists as "True Believers". These mindsets can often be found in highly intelligent, sincere, and decent human beings. Critical doubt and skepticism are powerful tools, the value of which can never be underestimated.
In our time, with the continual shrinking of Finnish America, much of the aforementioned has disappeared into the mists of history. The old Finnish radical political organizations have long vanished. The uniquely Finnish co-ops are also gone. Many Finnish churches have closed their doors and the Suomi Synod and the National Lutherans have folded into larger American religious federations. Finn halls are far and few between. Some of the churches have become less conservative, and as they aged some of he Finnish radicals moderated their views. In fact, my mother had a cousin in Oregon who was a member of the IWW in the 1910s,; in 1948 he voted Republican because he thought "labor was getting too strong." And who would have thought that originally Suomi Synod-descended Finlandia University has taken under its sponsorship the Finnish-American Reporter monthly which was founded as an English-only project of the Työmies-Eteenpain school of leftism? And that Raivaaja now periodically runs a religious column? Yet all these world problems that excited and concerned our ancestral forebears are as much on the scene today as in their time, but only in different and greater dimension. The daily news don't provide a pretty picture. We hope that our Finnish-American contemporaries will involve themselves organizationally in whatever way they can in the larger existing American movements concerned with these problems. Our forebears did their share.
But I'm glad to see that we still have our annual FinnFests, as well as regional celebrations to keep us together as a community today and for the foreseeable future. In all our diversity. there's something to interest us all in these gatherings.
The Finland our forebears left in the last century and earlier is now an entirely different place as all of us who have visited there can testify. The country is free, independent, and modern, with a highly educated population. The stability of the country is underwritten with a modern Western European welfare state, so hunger and homelessness are minimal, and with high quality medical care with a public universal health care program. Finland's social safety net is superior to ours. There's a strong labor movement, and it's respectable to be called a socialist.
The Lutheran church has become much liberalized from the days of Minna Canth. It's very much in support of the Scandinavian welfare state to provide for social needs, which Finnish socialists pioneered in the earlier 20th Century. My late friend Reino Hannula, publisher of the Finn Heritage quarterly, now also regrettably defunct, thought the Finnish churches were more socialistic than today's Social Democratic Party. In its coalition government association with the Conservative and Center parties the SDP has been party to whittling down some of the welfare state benefits as it is more and more involved with the neo-liberal economics of the European Union, and the most ardent defense to retain those benefits came and often comes from the mainstream Lutheran Church along with the Left Alliance, a party slightly to the left of the SDP, which has representation in Parliament.
In the 1980s the church allowed the ordination of women clergy against the stiff resistance of its traditionalist wing. So now a majority of theology students are women and about the third of the practicing clergy are women. When domestic partnerships for gays and lesbians were voted by Parliament, as I recall in the earlier 1990s, it wasn't looked on all that favorably by the church. As the last of the Scandinavian countries to adopt such legislation, its main support came from the SDP, Left Alliance, Greens, and part of the Center Party. The conservative National Coalition Party and the small fundamentalist Christian Democrat bloc opposed it. But just now I read that a European Forum of Christian sexual and gender minorities is to be held in Hämeenlinna next year that will support their concerns, with blessings from a mainstream bishop as well as the Orthodox metropolitan of Helsinki!
Civil marriages have long been possible, and birth records are no longer handled by the church but by public agencies. But now free unions, called avoliittos, have become popular among younger Finns, so much so that perhaps about one third of permanent domestic relationships are in that category. Even around 1918, an unmarried couple living together was called a susipari, or "wolf pair", and their child would be called an äpärä (bastard). But there is no such stigma anymore. Probably the church doesn't care for this, but it's hard to buck trends. So Matti Kurikka and his "free love" theory has come into popular play more than a century after his advocacy. World javelin champion Tero Pitkämäki and top heptathlete Niina Kelo are popular sports heroes and are proudly involved in an avoliitto, are quite happy, and no one seems to mind.
While until five years ago, about 85% of the Finns officially belonged to the Lutheran Church, only about three per cent of the population regularly attends church. Compare that to 51% in the United States. This secularization trend is common in the Scandinavian countries, as well as in the Low Countries, France and England. Religion isn't taken that seriously any more by large numbers of the population.
Still there is no separation of church and state as no political party wants to potentially risk its voting capital on the issue, whether left, right or center. The strongest advocate of church-state separation is the Finnish Vapaa-ajattelijain Liitto, or the Finnish Union of Free Thinkers, an umbrella organization for Finnish atheists, agnostics, skeptics and humanists, founded in 1937. The Free Thinkers have worked arduously to popularize their secularist ideas and also to lobby for changes in the law for more church-state separation. They have had some important successes.
1. In terms of the school system, although compulsory religious education still exists in the classroom, the Free Thinkers have been able to change the education code, so that students from nonreligious families who want to opt out of religion classes can do so, and take a secular course instead, called Elämänkatsomustiede, (Philosophy of Life Science), which would not have a religious content, and which is part of the official public school curriculum.
2. Laws prohibit discrimination against persons of any religious belief or non-belief.
3. Free Thinkers have developed a popular summer youth program of secular Prometheus Camps as an alternative to Bible study camps.
4. Free Thinkers have lobbied for the municipalization of the cemetery system which is now administered by the churches on behalf of the state with taxpayer money. Although they haven't been successful in this, they have built a number of cemeteries for free thinkers around the country which have no religious connection in rites or symbolism.
5. The Free Thinkers have succeeded in simplifying the laws enabling people to resign from the church by simply sending a postcard or an email message to the church. There was a time when one would have to appear before the parish pastor in person to do so, and give his/her reasons for it. The pastor in turn would try to dissuade the parishioner from resigning, often trying to play to a sense of guilt or shame. Or to the point of predicting the fire and brimstone to come.
And the ease with which one can resign has brought about an increase in resignations. But the Tampere chapter of the Free Thinkers has gone a step further which has opened up the floodgates. A number of bright young IT students from the Tampere Technological College have joined the chapter and have developed a Website which makes the resignation process just about automatic with a couple of clicks of the mouse, and it's free of charge. It's named http.eroakirkosta.fi (leave the church.fi). It's been in operation since 2003, and about 100,000 Finns have resigned from the church ever since over the Internet through 2007, according to the web edition of Helsingin Sanomat. Which means the percentage of Finns affiliated with the Lutheran Church has fallen to 81%. Which means religion for many thousands of Finns is about a mile wide and an inch deep. One of the material benefits of the resignations has been that no more church fees are deducted in taxes by the state from the resignees. The church, of course, is extremely worried as this all means a considerable drop in income for it, and is planning to create its own Website this fall trying to spell out the advantages of belonging to the church to attract more members.
But all this is part of the secularization process of Northern Europeans as a whole over the past decades. However, many critical issues have arisen with the immigration to several of these countries by a strong, vigorous Muslim influx of refugees as well as workers to relieve labor shortages. We've all heard about the violent clashes resulting from the Danish cartoons and the murder of Theo van Gogh in the liberal Netherlands who filmed the story of Hirsi Ali, the Somali woman who broke with the Muslim faith. Finland also has an increasing Muslim population and even has its first mosque, although there have been relatively few incidents except those promulgated by Finnish racists. I'm not into the "Clash of Civilizations" theory, but there are critical years to come in this war and violence-racked world that we need to be concerned about. However, such speculation is outside the scope of this paper.
— By Harry Siitonen Berkeley, CA, July, 2008.


text:
Recent Recipes
Tropical Vegan Green Smoothie
Don't let the mighty green coloured drink intimidate you. Green smoothies are one of the best ways to boost your energy in the morning - especially a vegan green smoothie. They are also a great pick you up snack in the middle of the day. Many people have a...read more
Grilled mushrooms with black pepper sauce
Mushrooms are very dense in nutrients. They can be a great source of potassium, protein and selenium. They're also a good source of phosphorus, zinc, niacin, pantothenic acid, vitamin C, folic acid, niacin, vitamins B-1 and B-2 and the list go on. There...read more
Roast Tomato Soup with Basil
There are times, after a long, long day at work that coming home and tucking into a warm cozy soup, will be one of the best feelings. It really that never gets old. Dipping bread and slowly enjoying every flavor of your food. Why should you spend 1 hour...read more
Recent Blog Posts
No Results Found
The page you requested could not be found. Try refining your search, or use the navigation above to locate the post.

subset: commoncrawl


text:
Looking for a great idea or theme for your parties, birthdays, corporate events and fundraisers?
Have fun with a casino theme party!
We will bring the casino parties to YOU in Calgary, Edmonton or anywhere in Alberta!
Casino Fun wants to make your next party a fun, exciting and truly special event that will always stand out in your guests' minds as YOUR party.
We will provide everything you need for an unforgettable casino party:
meticulous planning, casino grade tables, slot machines and equipment as well as authentic pit bosses and friendly, professional dealers.
But wait, Casino Fun dealers are more than just dealers. They bring life and excitement to the table. They set the party mood. They make all your guests winners.
We know that your event is special. That's why we will create a custom casino party and entertainment package that is just right for you, your guests and for your budget too!
Talk to one of our experienced party experts and let's get you started today.
Make your next party a Casino Fun Party!


text:
Holiday Inn Express & Suites - Lancaster/Lititz
- Holiday Inn Express & Suites - Lancaster/Lititz
- 101 Cross Winds Drive
- Lititz, PA 17543
- Primary - (717) 625-2366
Built in 2005 and dedicated to showing real Pennsylvania Dutch hospitality, the Holiday Inn Express & Suites provides everything you need to assure a great stay for your group.
Group Benefits include:
• Pre-registration for efficient check-in
• Affordable rates for baggage handling
• Easy accessibility and free parking for motorcoach
• Special motorcoach driver rates
• Complimentary room for 20 rooms paid
Hotel Features include:
• Complimentary Express Start breakfast
• Three stories with elevators; interior corridors
• Indoor heated pool and whirlpool
• Business center with HSIA
• Fitness room • Guest laundry (coin-operated)
• Coffee maker, hair dryer, iron /board in each guest room
• 27? televisions w/cable and HBO
• Complimentary WiFi in each guest room
• Free local and toll-free calls
• Complimentary USA Today (weekdays)
• Large guest rooms with 1 king or 2 queen beds with snowy-white linens
• Suites to sleep up to 6 (w/sofabed)
• Easy access to Route 30 and area attractions
Whatever the size of your group and wherever you're planning to go, the Holiday Inn Express & Suites – Lititz will deliver the best accommodations and service.
Explore Nearby
On the map below, you'll find information for this item, as well as a few of the lodging, dining, shopping and activities that are close by. To see more nearby listings, click the "View Full Map" link in the legend below.
- Things to Do
- Places to Eat
- Places to Stay
- Where to Shop
- View full map


text:
Personal Injury Lawyers in Pennsylvania
The attorneys of Kitay Law Offices focus much of their legal practice on personal injury matters and accident claims including, but not limited to the following:
- Car, truck, motorcycle and bicycle accidents
- Slip and fall accidents
- Birth injuries
- Spinal cord injuries
- Head injuries
- Back injuries
- Burns
- Pedestrian accidents
- Traumatic brain injuries
- Workplace injuries
If you have been hurt and are looking for an injury or accident lawyer, remember you should first seek medical attention and then contact an attorney. Most personal injury cases can only be filed within two years of the accident. This rule does not apply to all cases and depends on the facts in each individual case. Therefore, you should seek the advice of an attorney as soon as possible.
Automobile Accidents
Kitay Law Offices is home to some of Pennsylvania's top car accident attorneys. While auto accidents include collisions that take place when there is a car, they also can include trucks like a tractor trailer, 18 wheeler, motorcycle, train, bus, boat, or ATV. Unfortunately, at some time in our lives, most of us will experience an accident and might have even suffered an injury like a broken leg or whiplash. In some cases, you may need a car accident lawyer. Determining who is at fault for an auto accident usually requires the investigation and determination of damages by a professional. Sometimes, a car accident may be caused by a negligent driver, a defect in the car, bad weather conditions (Act of God), a missing or defective street sign, or a number of other factors.
You should be aware that in Pennsylvania, the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Act requires insurance companies to give the insured the option of selecting "Limited Tort" or "Full Tort," with the full tort option being only slightly more expensive than the limited tort option. If you select limited tort, you will not be able to sue for pain and suffering unless you sustain a serious or permanent injury, which has been defined by the Pennsylvania Courts as a "serious impairment of a bodily function." Although auto-insurance companies market limited tort policies as a way for you to reduce auto-insurance premiums, the limited tort option severely reduces your ability to receive compensation for injury while only marginally reducing the premium expense. If you or someone you know has been injured or incurred financial damages as the result of an auto accident, call the office of Kitay Law Offices at 1-888-KITAY-LAW for a free consultation and case evaluation.
Slip and Fall Accidents (Premises Liability)
Another name for slip and fall accident cases is premises liability. When public or private property ("premises") is unsafe, accidents can happen which can lead to a catastrophic injury. Injuries can occur in residential buildings, on construction sites, at shopping centers, parking lots and just about anywhere. The top rated premises liability attorneys of Kitay Law Offices have represented individuals who have fallen on defective stairs, when a porch collapses, because of potholes in city streets, when pipes have burst inside apartments, because of absent smoke detectors, and many other circumstances relating to unsafe conditions of property. If you or someone you know has been injured on someone else's property, call Kitay Law Offices at 1-888-KITAY-LAW for a free consultation and case evaluation.
Medical Malpractice
Tragically, a doctor's mistake can often have severe consequences for a patient. Medical malpractice occurs when a doctor or other healthcare professional fails to properly treat a patient and the improper treatment causes the patient to suffer a new injury or even a wrongful death. A new injury is required because it would be unreasonable to hold a doctor or other healthcare professional responsible for the original medical problem. Some examples of medical malpractice include:
- Failure to diagnose a medical condition
- Misdiagnosis of a medical condition
- Failure to properly treat a patient's medical condition
- Failure to safely administer anesthesia
- Failure to manage a pregnancy or deliver a baby in a safe manner
- Failure of a nurse or other staff member to keep a treating physician informed of a patient's condition
- Failure to administer medications properly
- Failure to protect a patient from a fall or other injury on hospital property
If you or someone you know has been injured as a result of the care provided by a health care practitioner, call the office of Kitay Law Offices at 1-888-KITAY-LAW for a free consultation and case evaluation.
Workplace Injuries
Sometimes people are injured at work. Most of the time, the only legal action they can bring against their employer or co-workers is a claim for workers' compensation. A person who is injured at work may also have a claim against a "third party," such as the manufacturer of unsafe machinery, the owner of the premises where the injury occurs (if different from his employer), or against another company whose employee caused the injury. If you or someone you know has been injured at work, you should have your case evaluated by an attorney. Call the office of Kitay Law Offices at 1-888-KITAY-LAW for a free consultation and case evaluation.
Where can you find our personal injury lawyers?
- Kitay Law Offices – Personal Injury Lawyers in Allentown, PA
- Kitay Law Offices – Personal Injury Lawyers in Reading, PA
- Kitay Law Offices – Personal Injury Lawyers in Lehigh Valley, PA
- Kitay Law Offices – Personal Injury Lawyers in Berks County, PA
- Kitay Law Offices – Personal Injury Lawyers in Bethlehem, PA


text:
ROBIN REID could climb back to the top of the boxing world tomorrow night if he can beat the odds and bring Sven Ottke's IBF and WBA super-middleweight titles back from Germany.
After almost four years in relative world title wilderness, the 32-year-old Merseysider will face the undefeated German in Nuremburg knowing that this is his big chance to get back on top - with the world number one spot up for grabs.
Ottke - a veteran of more than 20 world title fights - is recognised as the planet's finest 12-stone fighter, one step above Welshman Joe Calzaghe.
Yet while he is technically proficient, at 36 he's fading fast and Reid is more than capable of providing a real turn-up for the books.
"Ottke can't go on forever - he's 36," Reid told the ECHO before jetting off to Germany. "He was given a bad decision in his last fight against the Dane Mads Larsen, and David Starie (the former British champion) could easily have beaten him. And I know I am better than Starie.
"Ottke is good, don't get me wrong, but he nicks fights. I think I have the boxing skills to match him and I think I can hit harder. How often has he been hit to the body? Let's see what he makes of that."
The 'Reaper Man' almost retired after his disappointing defeat to Italian Silvio Branco in June 2000, and spent more than a year out of the ring as he looked for other ways to earn a living.
But he has bounced back with a vengeance, with eight knockouts in 10 straight victories.
"It's been hard," Reid admitted. "I haven't earned a lot - nothing like what I once did.
"Losing to Branco was a disaster for me. But now I have got another chance."
Success in Germany would certainly reignite the domestic 12-stone scene - provided promotional difficulties could be overcome in the build-up to an all-British world title unification clash with Calzaghe - who himself always blamed promotional difficulties for his own unwillingness to meet Ottke.
Reid admits he always wanted a rematch with the WBO champion after a narrow defeat to the Welsh boxer and rejected other bouts as he held out for the fight he wanted.
"I thought I was better than that," he added. "Why should I be fighting eight-rounders on the undercard of fighters like Naseem Hamed? What I wanted was Calzaghe, but the fight never happened."
* Highlights of Ottke-Reid will be shown on BBC1 tomorrow from 11.55pm.


text: OOIColor software from Ocean Optics Inc. is a Microsoft Excel worksheet template that contains the necessary code to access data directly from the company's line of miniature fiber optic spectrometers. When coupled with fiber optic probes, this worksheet and spectrometer combination can measure reflective or emissive color. Color space values are reported in numeric form, with some values available in graph form. All data acquisition and analysis can be performed within the OOIColor worksheet.


text:
GPET website
Convention homepage
Keynote speakers
Convention themes
Convention objectives
About the Program
Social Program
Getting there
General information
The venue
2014 Satellite Meetings
Contact us
Join the #GPSuperheroes campaign - simply tweet a superhero deed!
3-4 September 2014
Royal International Convention Centre,
600 Gregory Terrace, Bowen Hills, Brisbane Queensland
View the full list of all nominees for this year's GPET Awards!
On behalf of General Practice Education and Training Limited (GPET)
I would like to invite you to participate in the last GPET Convention.
As always the Convention will bring together registrars, supervisors, prevocational doctors, medical and cultural educators, training provider staff, cultural mentors,
practice managers and other key GP education and training representatives to share experiences
and knowledge and to showcase programs, research and ideas.
Brisbane provides the perfect setting for this year's Convention themed 'Inspiring Partnerships'. This city connected by paths, bridges and the winding Brisbane River, is the ideal location to gather together and discuss how the partnerships and linkages we develop with individuals and organisations complement our work – providing challenges and opportunities for the further development of GP education and training.
The Convention theme and sub-themes have been incorporated into a range of plenary sessions, concurrent workshops, paper presentations and posters to be presented by you. I encourage you to view the program and register for the Convention today.
I look forward to seeing you in Brisbane at the 2014 GPET Convention.
Dr Georga Cooke
GPET board member, GP and Convention Co-Convenor
for the Gotham City Ball Comic strip competition. Voting closes Friday 22 August!
Schedule your own personal program and find information on speakers, session abstracts and social functions. The app is compatible with both Android and Apple mobile and tablet devices. Access the app by
Simply entering the URL: http://gpet14.events123.com.au/ into Safari or Explorer on your mobile device,
Once in the webpage, add the URL to your home screen by tapping on the arrow icon (Apple devices) or menu (Android devices) and selecting the 'Add to home screen' option.


text:
"We're counting down days until Christmas is here,
And gifting you cool security tips to be of good cheer,
And make sure this season is the best of your year."
Join us every day for a new Norton tip to keep your holidays merry and bright. A secure holiday is a happy holiday with Norton.
Strong, secure passwords are one thing that stands between you and a potential data breach. Here are some tips on how to make your passwords more secure and ways to manage them all.
Connected cars are a relatively new technology in the Internet of Things, however, we've dug a little deeper into this tech. Read on to learn just how secure these technologies are and what you can do to safeguard your personal information.
Mobile devices are popular with employees and travel, granting them the ability to work while on the go. However, the information on these devices is very vulnerable if it were to fall into the wrong hands. Here are some tips on traveling with your company's data.
What would your company do if an employee's device was lost, or even worse, stolen? Does your business have measures in place to protect the data on the device?
Your business shares sensitive data with the vendors it works with, such as CPAs and payroll companies. Is your business asking the right questions to these vendors to ensure that data stays secure?
With reports of data breaches becoming more frequent, now is the time to look into ways to make your accounts more secure.
Our favorite holiday IT elf is back with some more holiday shopping tips! This week he reviews "paper or plastic," and we're not talking about grocery bags.
Early on a Wednesday evening, I received a call from my doctor. Her voice, frantic on the line, proclaims, "I'm so happy to hear your voice- the strangest thing happened today. You were marked in our system as deceased for about 20 minutes." I paused for a moment out of shock, and assured her I was very much alive and well. She went on to explain how she'd never seen anything like it before. As the initial shock wore off, we started to have a bit of a laugh on how bizarre this was.
If you are experiencing an issue that needs urgent assistance please visit our customer support area:
There are currently 2 users online.


text:
In the past week I've been very excited (and rather busy) by the starting of a new European project, called PHEME ( PhemeEU). The aim is to develop automatic methods to help people (e.g. journalists, health professionals, patients, government services) assess the truthfulness of information that is spreading through social networks and other online media.
With partners from seven different countries, the project will combine big data analytics with advanced linguistic and visual methods. The results will be suitable for direct application in medical information systems and digital journalism.
Veracity: The Fourth Challenge of Big DataSocial media poses three major computational challenges, dubbed by Gartner the 3Vs of big data: volume, velocity, and variety.
PHEME will focus on a fourth crucial, but hitherto largely unstudied, challenge: veracity.
While writing the proposal, I coined the term phemes to describe memes which are enhanced with truthfulness information. It is a reference also to Pheme - the Greek goddess of fame and rumours.
Identifying Phemes (Rumorous Memes)We are concentrating on identifying four types of phemes and modelling their spread across social networks and online media: speculation, controversy, misinformation, and disinformation. However, it is particularly difficult to assess whether a piece of information falls into one of these categories in the context of social media. The quality of the information here is highly dependent on its social context and, up to now, it has proven very challenging to identify and interpret this context automatically.
An Interdisciplinary Approach
PHEME has partners from the fields of natural language processing and text mining, web science, social network analysis, and information visualization. Together, we will use three factors to analyse veracity: first, the information inherent in a document itself – that is lexical, semantic and syntactic information. This is then cross-referenced with data sources that are assessed as particularly trustworthy, for example in the case of medical information, PubMed, the biggest online database in the world for original medical publications. Finally, the diffusion of a piece of information is analysed – who receives what information and from whom, and whether and to whom they pass it on?
"Rumor intelligence", that is the ability to identify rumours in good time will be tested, inter alia, in the area of medical information systems. For digital journalism, results will be tested with swissinfo.ch (the international service of the Swiss Broadcasting Corporation (SBC)) and Ushahidi's SwiftRiver media filtering and verification platform. The new technology will help journalists assesss the veracity of user-generated content – an activity that is largely carried out manually to date, requiring significant resources. Other news organisations who have expressed support the project are the BBC, the Guardian, and the German regional broadcasting corporation Südwestrundfunk.
So this is all going to be great - identifying rumours across social media and helping filter out the misinformation. Keep up with our progress - follow PHEME on Twitter!


text:
7800 Lemmon Avenue
Directions Dallas, TX 75209
Sewell. Obsessed with Service since 1911.
7800 Lemmon Avenue
Dallas, TX 75209
Being conveniently located near Dallas Love Field Airport makes our central location in the Fort Worth, Irving and Arlington area a great place for Subaru drivers to visit for maintenance and repairs. We'll keep on top of your specific model's maintenance schedule which helps you to get the most out of your Outback, Legacy, Forester or Impreza, and we'll be here with Genuine Subaru Parts when you might need a major repair. Our state of the art service facility is staffed by highly trained and certified Subaru technicians, so any model from any year will be best left with our trustworthy staff, and we'll have you back out on the road in no time.
There's plenty to love about what we offer here at Sewell Subaru, one of the Dallas-Fort Worth area's premier auto dealerships. We're easy to find from Irving, Arlington and beyond, and our online resources make setting up visits and appointments quick, convenient and hassle-free. Use the directions found on this page to find your way over and we'll be happy to get you started.
Sewell Subaru
7800 Lemmon Avenue
Directions Dallas, TX 75209


text:
Birch leaves have in particular a blood purifier, diuretic and stimulating function. Mate leaves are stimulating to the nerves, muscles and metabolism, diuretic, saliva and gastric juice, and thus promoting the formation helpful in digestion, diaphoretic, activating due to the caffeine content and circulation tonic. In combination with the other herbs the detoxification tea will help to clean up your system.
blackberry leaves bee balm apple rosehip leaf mate green tea peppermint birch leaves verbena fennel marigold leaves
Browse the site or visit our local store finder


text:
Tournament of 68 college basketball teams, in which all teams battle in a single elimination format. If you lose you are out. The last team left is the National College Athletic Association (NCAA) Division One Champion.
(Image, right, logos of basketball teams. Click on the image to see a bigger size.)
2. When is March Madness?
The month of March and early April
3. Why is it called March Madness?
Because the early rounds of the tournament include many upsets, historically via a game winning shot as time expires. Also, because the tournament pairs larger more reputable colleges with smaller more obscure colleges, those upsets are all the more noteworthy.
4. What teams usually play in March Madness?
NCAA Division 1 college programs. D-I schools include the major collegiate athletic powers, with larger budgets, more elaborate facilities, and more athletic scholarships than Divisions II and III as well as many smaller schools committed to the highest level of intercollegiate competition.
Of the 68 programs receiving an invitation to the tournament, 32 gain automatic entry through winning their conference's championship (commonly through winning a conference tournament or, in the sole case of the Ivy League, the regular season title. The remaining 36 programs rely on the selection committee to award them an "at-large" bid in the tournament. The selection process primarily takes place on Selection Sunday when the brackets and seeds are released to the public. The tournament begins the following Thursday at noon.
5. Are there March Madness celebrations?
Fans gather for March Madness mostly in bars and pubs. Many bars are affiliated with a particular college, so its a great way for alumni to gather and root their team on together. Since the majority of games during the first two days of the tournament take place during a work day, many fans joke that production suffers because they are watching the games on their computers while at their desks. Streaming online service providers even create a "boss button" so fans can click on it in an emergency to hide the game and instead display a phony spreadsheet if their boss walks in to their office.
6. I have heard of fights or brawls after basketball games. Does this happen a lot? If I want to go to a basketball game, is it safe?
Violence is really not a part of the basketball viewing culture. The reason for this is because fans traditionally do not tailgate before games and are therefore less driven by alcohol.
7. What kinds of foods or drinks do people have during basketball games?
Common foods are hamburgers and hot dogs, while soda and beer are the most popular drink selections.
8. Is it expensive to go to a basketball game or the March Madness games?
Because college basketball is usually played in arenas that reside on college campuses and whose audience consists mostly of college students, ticket prices tend to be more affordable. However, because the March Madness tournament is held at neutral locations and in arenas where professional sports are played while also catering to a corporate clientele, the prices tend to run much higher, along with a drastically inflated secondary market (ticket scalping).
9. How can I make small talk about basketball or March Madness with my US colleagues?
The most common questions are:
"Did you fill out a bracket?"
This means, did you try to predict the victors or each game and try to guess who will win the championship.
"Are you participating in a pool?"
Not everyone who fills out a bracket is participating in a pool. But many do. A pool is a group of people who all fill out brackets and keep score to see who wins. Often times they bet money. Companies actually use March Madness pools as a way to improve office morale, where everyone from the secretaries to the company president compete against each other.
"Who is in your final four?"
Each round of the tournament has a moniker:
The first round
the round of 32
the sweet 16
the great 8
the final 4
the championship game.
|Sweet 16
|Great 8
|Final Four
10. Are there any idioms or phrases people used related to basketball?
The tournament brackets consists of 4 groupings. The seeding in each bracket is 1 - 16, with 1 being the strongest team and 16 being the least strong. Its a way to reward programs for their performance over the course of the season. So, you will hear a phrase like "the 10 seed upset the 4 seed today".
"Box out"
When a player uses his body to block another player from getting to the basket
"All Airport Team"
A joke used when saying a tall player might lack talent but he sure looks impressive when walking through an airport.
A word fans use in excitement when a player on their team makes a basket and the ball doesn't hit any of the rim or backboard, thus making a swish sound when going through the net.
Author, Matt Wade, CEO of GamePlan is a thought leader in academic and career planning, a product evangelist, and a vanguard of higher education's progressive movement.
Related Posts:
About "American" Football and the Super Bowl
Small Talk Made Easy
Transition from Small Talk to Business Talk
TV Channels in the US


text:
This is a page on the Hagia Sophia website of links to other websites with related topics or information. Sometimes site visitors want to learn more
Church of the Crucifixion
Beneath the Church of the Savior-on-High is the Church of the Crucifixion, built under the reign of Tsar Fyodor Alexeievich in 1681.
The icons of this church are the incomparable work of ardent faith and pious fervor. The figures of these icons, attached to linen, were painted in the 17th century by the painter of the Tsar's workshop, Poznansky; the "stuffings" are made from silk fabric, artistically embroidered by the Tsarevnas. The whole work is of very delicate coloring and a beautiful design.
In an oratory which takes up a small part of the church on seen beneath a mica covering, the highly artistically valuable icons which are the work of the Tsar's icon painters, Ivan Saltyanov and Ivan Bezmin in the 17th century.
The Oratory
At the bottom of the oratory is Christ on the Cross made of cedar wood, spruce and cypress, made in 1687 modeled on the Holy Life Giving Cross and is of the same size.
The Church of the Crucifixion is an annex of the Cathedral of the Resurrection of the Savior.
It is on the same level with the platforms of this church, as it is with the church of the Crucifixion in Jerusalem, in the Temple of the Resurrection.
The Holy Door
The door giving access to the platforms of the church of the Resurrection is an ancient Holy Door, of great beauty.
In 1903 Their Imperial Majesties Emperor Nicholas II and Empress Alexandra Feodorovna worshipped in this church.


text:
Let take a look at the best website designers in Nigeria. Whether you are looking for someone to design your businss or comoany website or develops an application for you in Nigeria? this aricle we will be of great help to you in making the right choose of a professional developer in Nigeria.
By now you must have known the importance of a business website. You don't have to settle for the less, we understand that you need the best web designsr in affordable price, that is why this article is here to help sort for he best professionals web designers and developers in Nigeria.
It we be good you have some ideas how this names work. A web developer is someone we develops softwares for computers such as adube flash, photoshop, corel draw, anti-virus etc. An application Developer is someone who develops smart phones apps such as whatsapp, 2go, facebook app, twitter app etc. in general this people are called programmers. Now lets head on to web designers, a web designer is someone who design the look and beauty of a website, most times a web designers are referred as workers of website front end. The good thing is that we have so may professionals who studied every thing together. and they are some firm working as team that has programmers and web designers together.
Best Web Designers/Developers in Nigeria
Repent for the kingdom of God is at hand
Below are best web designers in Nigeria informationhood could get hold of.
Sero Internet World Ltd
This is a teams of programmers that base in developing any thing yo want and how you want it. They are lagos based company that render service to all over Nigeria and outside Nigeria.
Sero's Nigeria internet leaders are capable of developing computer softwares, Mobile applications, and any kind of website you desire. What makes them come first in our list is because of their great effort of support and reliability.
This is a Nigeria developer that has a good reputation in websites, softwares, apps development. Spylrypixel will give your website a strong responsive view and a nice look on both mobile and computer screen.
Website: www.sprypixels.com
contact email: firstname.lastname@example.com
Level Seven
Level Seven Nigeria Ltd is a web developing company that, the company was nominated for Africa best web developing company in 2015. The company specializes in providing state-of-the-art professional website design and development services. they boast a team of very experienced Nigerian web designers, the level seven Nigeria is based in Lagos b they can work with you in no mater your location, Nigeria's technology powerhouse.
To contact Level Seven Limited visit the contact page http://levelsevenltd.com/website-designers-contact-us/
or send email to firstname.lastname@example.com
These are the few web designers/developers information is able to get hold of at this time. The article is subjected to update at any time.


text:
January 2017
By Jim Chapman, Attorney, Public Agency Training Council
Article Source | Printable Version | Follow PATC
Article Sharing, Duplication & Distribution Policy
In State v. Lutton, ___ Idaho ___, ___ P.3d ___, 2017 WL 192846 (Ct. App. Jan. 18, 2017), the Court of Appeals of Idaho affirmed the trial court's denial of Lawrence R. Lutton's motion to suppress. In affirming the trial court's decision, the Court of Appeals held that the trial court did not err in denying Lutton's motion to suppress because the warrantless blood draw on Lutton did not violate Lutton's Fourth Amendment right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. The relevant, undisputed facts are as follows.
At around 9 p.m., after enjoying a day at the reservoir with his children and some friends, Lutton began the drive back to town. Lutton had his sons (ages two and four) in his vehicle and was following his friend's vehicle. At some point on the dirt road leading to the highway, Lutton lost control of his vehicle. The vehicle left the road and went into the reservoir.
Lutton was able to escape the submerging vehicle and was also able to rescue his four-year-old son. The boy was not breathing when Lutton pulled his son from the water. Lutton's friend, having returned to where Lutton's vehicle left the road, was able to revive the boy by performing CPR. Lutton returned to the water to rescue his two-year-old son who was still strapped inside the submerged vehicle. After unbuckling and freeing him from his car seat, Lutton lost hold of the child. Lutton was unable to find his son in the water despite repeated attempts to locate him. Lutton's friend eventually forced Lutton to exit the water out of concern for Lutton's safety because Lutton was showing signs of hypothermia. Other people who had stopped to help continued to look for the two-year-old boy.
Believing that Lutton and the four-year-old needed immediate medical treatment, Lutton's friend drove Lutton and his son from the accident site toward the hospital in town. Before they were able to reach the hospital, however, police officers observed the vehicle speeding with its hazard lights flashing. The officers stopped the vehicle to investigate—one officer making contact with the driver and the other officer making contact with Lutton in the passenger's seat.
Lutton and his friend told the officers about the crash and the need for medical attention. The officer who spoke with Lutton detected a slight odor of alcohol coming from the vehicle. Lutton was distraught and sobbing, but he admitted to having consumed three beers between one and three o'clock that afternoon. Lutton's friend also admitted to drinking earlier in the day. The officers called for an ambulance to transport Lutton and his four-year-old son to the hospital. The officers dispatched an Idaho State Police (ISP) trooper to respond to the hospital in order to investigate Lutton for possible driving under the influence (DUI). After the ambulance arrived, the other officer spoke with Lutton while he was in the ambulance. The officer did not smell alcohol coming from Lutton's person. After the ambulance departed, the two officers remained at the scene to interview Lutton's friend further before traveling to the hospital themselves.
Although there are differing accounts as to what happened at the hospital, the trial court found the following facts to be true after conducting an evidentiary hearing. At the hospital, the original responding officers reconnected with Lutton in his treatment room. Lutton was seated on the bed wrapped in a blanket and was not wearing clothes. The officer that initially made contact with Lutton in the vehicle continued the investigation, asking Lutton questions about the day's activities and details about the accident. The officer did not detect any odor of alcohol or any other signs of intoxication. The officer did not conduct any sobriety tests. At this time, Lutton was no longer sobbing, did not appear as distraught as he had been earlier, and was able to understand and answer the officer's questions. The officer informed Lutton that an ISP trooper had been called to assist in the investigation and that the trooper would be reading Lutton an advisory form and obtaining a blood sample. When the ISP trooper arrived, the two officers stationed themselves outside the door of Lutton's treatment room.
The trooper read the administrative license suspension advisory form to Lutton. While the trooper spoke with Lutton, the two-year-old boy arrived in the emergency room on a gurney and was placed in an adjacent treatment room. After seeing his son, Lutton was distraught and crying. At no time did the trooper restrict Lutton from seeing his son on the condition that Lutton first complete a blood draw. Lutton, subsequently, cooperated with a hospital nurse in providing a blood sample. Lutton did not affirmatively object, refuse, or physically resist the blood draw. Lutton was advised of the consequences of refusing the blood draw and agreed to provide a sample. The blood sample showed an alcohol concentration of 0.092. The two-year-old child later died.
The State of Idaho ultimately charged Lutton with vehicular manslaughter and with driving under the influence. Lutton moved to suppress the evidence of the warrantless blood draw. The trial court denied Lutton's motion on the basis that Lutton impliedly consented to the draw. Pursuant to a plea agreement, Lutton pled guilty to vehicular manslaughter, and the State dismissed the driving under the influence charge. Lutton reserved his right to appeal the trial court's denial of his motion to suppress and his motion to reconsider. The trial court entered an order withholding judgment, suspended Lutton's driver's license for six months, and placed Lutton on unsupervised probation for a period of four years. Lutton timely appealed the denial of his suppression motion.
On appeal, the Court of Appeals of Idaho acknowledged that requiring individuals to submit to a blood alcohol test is a search and seizure for purposes of the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution. The Court of Appeals further acknowledged that warrantless searches and seizures are presumptively unreasonable under the Fourth Amendment. However, the Court of Appeals noted that exceptions exist and that searches that fall within one of the well-recognized exceptions to the warrant requirement can overcome the presumption of unreasonableness.
The issue that was before the Court of Appeals was the issue of consent because the warrant requirement does not apply if the person subjected to the search has consented. Mere acquiescence to a claim of authority by a law enforcement officer does not constitute consent. Consent must be voluntary and not the result of duress or coercion, either direct or implied. A voluntary decision is one that is the product of an essentially free and unconstrained choice by its maker. The voluntariness of an individual's consent is evaluated based upon the totality of the circumstances.
The Court of Appeals opined that the consent analysis requires consideration of subtle, coercive police tactics and questions as well as the subjective state of the party granting consent to search, noting that the State bears the burden to prove that consent was voluntary by a preponderance of the evidence. The Court of Appeals stated that the State may carry its burden of establishing the consent exception through the actual, voluntary consent of an individual or through statutorily implied consent.
The Court of Appeals sidestepped the issue of whether the trial court erred in finding that Lutton gave statutorily implied consent because it found that Lutton gave actual, voluntary consent to the blood draw. After reviewing the record, the Court of Appeals concluded that the trial court's findings, although disputed by Lutton, were supported by substantial evidence. Specifically, after hearing the various witnesses testify during the suppression hearing, the trial court made express credibility determinations. The trial court accepted the testimony of the state trooper as credible, discounting Lutton's testimony on contradictory factual allegations as not credible. The state trooper testified that Lutton was never mandated to provide a blood sample; that Lutton never objected to having his blood drawn; that Lutton was not prohibited from seeing his son until he consented to a blood draw; that Lutton was advised of his right to refuse to provide a sample; and that Lutton said "okay" to having his blood taken. The trial court heard a recording of Lutton being questioned by police officers. This recording demonstrated, consistent with the trial court's finding, that Lutton was able to understand and respond to police questioning and was cooperative.
In sum, the Court of Appeals held that, although the evidence considered by the trial court was disputed, the findings made by the trial court were supported by substantial evidence. Accordingly, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court's denial of Lutton's motion to suppress and affirmed Lutton's conviction after relying upon the actual consent exception to the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement.
Note: Court holdings can vary significantly between jurisdictions. As such, it is advisable to seek the advice of a local prosecutor or legal adviser regarding questions on specific cases. This article is not intended to constitute legal advice on a specific case.
Gatlinburg Conference March 10-12, 2020
Las Vegas Conference
April 6-9, 2020
View Legal Article Archive
Click Here to See Our FAQ!
Legal Updates
Internal Affairs
Click below to sign up for emails and brochures!
Public Agency Training Council - 5235 Decatur Blvd - Indianapolis, IN 46241 - 800.365.0119
About PATC | PATC Publishing/Bookstore | Training Partners | E-Newsletter | Contact Us | Home | Site Terms of Use Policy