text:
Contact Us
Browse by:
Systems and methods for clickstream analysis to modify an off-line business process involving forecasting demand
Systems and methods for clickstream analysis to modify an off-line business process involving forecasting demand
Patent Drawings:
(20 images)
Singh, et al.
Date Issued:
October 12, 2010
October 24, 2007
Singh; Man Jit
(Los Angeles, CA)
Cancel; David
(Newburyport, MA)
Complete, Inc.
(Boston, MA)
Primary Examiner:
Nguyen; Thuong T
Assistant Examiner:
Attorney Or Agent:
Strategic Patents, P.C.
U.S. Class:
Field Of Search:
International Class:
U.S Patent Documents:
Foreign Patent Documents:
Other References:
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,454, Non-Final Office Action mailed Jan. 8, 2009", , 7 pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,454, Non-Final Office Action mailed Apr. 5, 2010", , 13. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,470, Non-Final Office Action mailed Aug. 28, 2009", , 7 pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,470, Non-Final Office Action mailed Feb. 22, 2010", , 13. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,485, Non-Final Office Action mailed Aug. 13, 2009", , 12 pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,506, Non-Final Office Action mailed Aug. 25, 2009", , 15 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,506, Final Office Action mailed Feb. 26, 2010", , 21. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,560, Non Final Office Action mailed Oct. 28, 2009", , 9. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,609, Final Office Action mailed Aug. 7, 2009", , 11 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,609 Non-Final Office Action mailed Jan. 15, 2009", , 7 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,610, Non Final Office Action mailed Sep. 2, 2009", , 19. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,610, Notice of Allowance mailed Apr. 29, 2010", , 7. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,617, Non-Final Office Action mailed Sep. 1, 2009", , 11 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,620, Non-Final Office Action mailed Sep. 29, 2009", , 19 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,621, Non-Final Office Action mailed Sep. 30, 2009", , 19 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,624, Non-Final Office Action mailed Sep. 29, 2009", , 19 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,617, Notice of Allowance mailed Mar. 23, 2010", , 7. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/938,716, Non-Final Office Action mailed Mar. 12, 2009", , 6 pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,454, Final Office Action mailed Aug. 19, 2009", , 12 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,486, Final Office Action mailed Mar. 3, 2010", , 12. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,609, Notice of Allowance mailed Jan. 29, 2010", , 14 Pgs. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,620, Final Office Action mailed Apr. 23, 2010", , 29 PGS. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,621, Final Office Action mailed Apr. 23, 2010", , 29 Pages. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/923,624, Final Office Action mailed Apr. 23, 2010", , 28. cited by other.
"U.S. Appl. No. 11/938,710, Notice of Allowance mailed Feb. 17, 2010", , 8 Pgs. cited by other.
Methods and systems are provided herein for the analysis of clickstream data of online users. The analysis methods and systems allow for the creation of new offline business methods based on online consumer behavior. In embodiments, a third party is enabled to forecast offline demand for a good or service based on the online consumer behavior.
What is claimed is:
1. A method of processing data at a host computer, comprising: receiving a data file at the host computer containing records of a plurality of HTTP (HyperText TransferProtocol) transactions of a plurality of users, each of the HTTP transactions including at least one URL (Uniform Resource Locator); converting the data file into a common file format at the host computer; cleansing the data file in the common fileformat at the host computer by applying a plurality of URL rules to remove session identifiers while accounting for the use of proxies, thereby producing a cleansed data file containing at least one modified URL; performing a panel selection process atthe host computer, comprising: conducting a periodic survey of a subset of Internet users to determine characteristics of an Internet community that includes the subset of Internet users, the characteristics including demographic characteristics; selecting a panel of users from the subset of Internet users, the panel of users having a targeted combination of the demographic characteristics; retaining the data file only when it contains a user identifier of a user in the panel of users; performing a transformation process, comprising: removing from the data file those URLs that do not contain the user identifier; determining which URLs in the data file belong to a session of the user in the panel of users; assigning a sessionidentifier to the session; creating a plurality of session data files, each of which contain the user identifier, a time stamp, the URLs in the data file that belong to the session, and the session identifier; decomposing the URLs in each of theplurality of session data files so that the URLs in each of the plurality of session data files are decomposed URLs; and hashing the decomposed URLs so that the decomposed URLs are hashed, decomposed URLs; calculating a metric of user behavior at thehost computer based upon the hashed, decomposed URLs; merging the metric of user behavior into a file containing a plurality of metrics of online user behavior at the host computer; and transmitting from the host computer to a remote machine the filecontaining the plurality of metrics of online user behavior, wherein the file containing the plurality of metrics of online user behavior enables a third party to forecast offline demand for a good or service based on the plurality of metrics of onlineuser behavior.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the good is a media content.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein forecasting comprises predicting a change in market share offline based on changes in a share of online users who research goods or services.
4. The method of claim 1, further comprising, enabling the third party to modify offline business planning in response to a demand forecast.
5. The method of claim 4, wherein the offline business planning relates to manufacturing and inventory needs.
6. The method of claim 4, wherein the offline business planning relates to allocating the correct amounts of inventory to a particular region.
7. A system, comprising: a data collection facility on a host computer that receives a data file containing records of a plurality of HTTP (HyperText Transfer Protocol) transactions of a plurality of users, each of the HTTP transactionsincluding at least one URL (Uniform Resource Locator), checks for integrity of the data file and the records, and converts the data file into a common file format; a pre-calculation facility on the host computer that performs a cleansing method, a panelselection process, and a transformation process, wherein the cleansing method comprises: cleansing the data file in the common file format by applying a plurality of URL rules to remove session identifiers while accounting for the use of proxies, therebyproducing a cleansed data file containing at least one modified URL; the panel selection process comprises: conducting a periodic survey of a subset of Internet users to determine characteristics of an Internet community that includes the subset ofInternet users, the characteristics including demographic characteristics; selecting a panel of users from the subset of Internet users, the panel of users having a targeted combination of the demographic characteristics; retaining the data file onlywhen it contains a user identifier of a user in the panel of users; the transformation process comprises: removing from the data file those URLs that do not contain the user identifier; determining which URLs in the data file belong to a session of theuser in the panel of users; assigning a session identifier to the session; creating a plurality of session data files, each of which contain the user identifier, a time stamp, the URLs in the data file that belong to the session, and the sessionidentifier; decomposing the URLs in each of the plurality of session data files so that the URLs in each of the plurality of session data files are decomposed URLs; and hashing the decomposed URLs so that the decomposed URLs are hashed, decomposedURLs; and a calculation facility on the host computer that calculates a metric of online user behavior based upon the hashed, decomposed URLs, performs a post-calculation method, and transmits to a remote machine a file containing a plurality of metricsof online user behavior, wherein the file containing the plurality of metrics of online user behavior enables a third party to forecast offline demand for a good or service based on the plurality of metrics of online user behavior, and wherein thepost-calculation method comprises: merging the metric of online user behavior into the file containing the plurality of metrics of online user behavior.
8. The system of claim 7, wherein the calculation facility comprises a cluster of machines configured to run parallel calculations on the plurality of session data files that are obtained from the pre-calculation facility.
9. The system of claim 7, wherein the data collection facility uses a rule that is generated by the host computer system.
10. The system of claim 9, wherein the good is a media content.
11. The system of claim 9, wherein forecasting comprises predicting a change in market share offline based on changes in a share of online users who research goods or services.
12. The system of claim 9, wherein the forecast enables the third party to modify offline business planning.
13. The system of claim 12, wherein the offline business planning relates to manufacturing and inventory needs.
14. The system of claim 12, wherein the offline business planning relates to allocating a correct amounts of inventory to a particular region.
This application is based on, claims priority to, and incorporates by reference the following United States Provisional Patent Applications: an application filed Mar. 7, 2002 entitled Business Method for URL Analysis, naming Man Jit Singh asinventor, and an application filed Mar. 7, 2002 entitled Technology Platform for URL Analysis.
The advent of the Internet and the Worldwide Web has produced a host of electronic commerce applications, in which users interact with content and engage in a wide variety of transactions, ranging from ordering books, CDs and other items, toparticipating in auctions, to downloading music, to a host of other activities. Methods and systems are widely used for tracking the behavior of online users, both individually and as groups. The output from those methods and systems are typically usedto adjust the structure and content of online offerings to help attract more users, or to get current users to engage in more interaction and more transactions with the provider.
Methods and systems for analyzing online user behavior range from statistical techniques, such as collaborative filtering, to use of neural nets and similar facilities. While such methods have had some success, the promise of electronic commerceremains somewhat unfulfilled. Many online businesses have failed, and those remaining find the environment increasingly competitive. Meanwhile, many businesses find that online offerings (including their own), merely take business away from offlineproduct offerings, or that the online offerings harm offline offerings in other ways, such as by forcing price reductions. Thus, methods and systems are needed for providing improved coordination between online and offline offerings. In addition,methods and systems are needed for allowing offline businesses to take advantage of information that can be discerned from online customer behavior.
Methods and systems are provided herein for the analysis of behavior of online users. The analysis methods and systems allow for the creation of new offline business methods based on online consumer behavior.
Methods and systems are also provided for providing a host computer for handling a plurality of processes, the host system having a collection facility, a network, a pre-calculation facility, a calculation facility, and a post-calculationfacility; obtaining an input data set of online user data from a plurality of data providers, wherein the input data set represents HTTP transactions of a plurality of online users; and sending an output data set to a co-location facility to permitremote access by a party other than the host.
The calculation facility may comprise providing a cluster of machines distributed in a parallel processing configuration. Output data may be stored in a data warehouse or sent to a collocation facility.
Methods and systems are also provided for obtaining an input data set from a plurality of data providers, the data set comprising data representing HTTP transactions for a plurality of users; performing a pre-calculation process to produce a filein a file format suitable for performing calculations; performing calculations on the formatted file; and performing post-calculation on the results of the calculations to produce an output file.
Methods and systems are further provided for transferring the output file to at least one of a co-location facility and a data warehouse.
Methods and systems are also provided for collecting the data set for analysis by a host computer; delivering the data set to an internal network; and performing an integrity check on the data.
Methods and systems are also provided wherein the formatted file comprises data selected from the group consisting of a file identifier, a user identifier for a user who completed an HTTP transaction, a data provider identifier for the dataprovider who provided the data representing the HTTP transaction, a timestamp for the HTTP transaction, a URL for the HTTP transaction, and a protocol identifier for the protocol of the transaction.
The pre-calculation step may include reading a list of URL rules; for each character of the URL of a formatted file, walking the character of the URL through the URL rules; for each rule in the URL rules, applying the rule to the URL of theformatted file; and outputting a modified URL, the modified URL reflecting the application of the rules to the original URL. The modified URL may be appended to a modified formatted file.
The methods and systems may further comprise providing a panel selection process for selecting a panel of users, data for which will be used in an input data set. The process may include conducting a survey of user demographics for an initialuser panel; determining a statistic related to the demographics of the users in the user panel; comparing the statistics to the statistics for a past user panel; selecting a new panel of users representing a desired set of demographic characteristics;and determining whether to keep or discard a data item based on membership of a user in the panel.
The URL of the output file may include a session identifier, a domain identifier, a subdomain identifier, a path and a query string.
The output file may further include a hash, such as hash of the domain identifier, the subdomain identifier, or the path.
The methods and systems described herein may include calculating a metric based on the data in the output file. The metric may be a vertical market metric calculation, a search term metric calculation, or other metric.
The metric calculation may be a vertical market metric calculation that can include using a page extractor module for extracting data identifying a page of online content; using a fetcher module to retrieve the page content from a computernetwork; and using a classifier module to classify the page in at least one content category selected from a group of possible content categories.
Metrics may be calculated using a cluster of machines configured in a parallel-processing configuration or batch-processing configuration.
In embodiments, an input URL is decomposed based on semantic meaning of the pages viewed by the user who executes the HTTP transaction. The decomposition process may be made in the presence of redirection from a primary URL to a secondary URL orin the presence of a proxy URL for a second URL.
Methods and systems may also include obtaining an input data set reflecting clickstream activity of a plurality of online users; analyzing user behavior reflected by the clickstream activity; drawing an inference based on the user behavior; andmodifying an offline process based on the inference.
The inference may relate to cross-shopping behavior between different goods and the offline process may be a marketing promotion. The input data may relate to price sensitivity of a shopper and the offline process may be a pricing process for anoffline item. The input data may relate to ordering of a user's views of items and the offline process may relate to merchandizing and to product placement to promote viewing goods in a particular order. The input date may relate to user buyinginterest or share of interest and the offline process may relate to forecasting offline demand for a product. The input data may relate to actions of users with respect to online content choices and the offline process may relate to presenting offlinemedia content.
In embodiments the methods and systems may include obtaining a set of data reflecting online actions of a plurality of users; analyzing the data to identify characteristics of the user's behavior; and modifying an off-line business process basedon the identified characteristics.
FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing high-level entities that interact in the methods and systems disclosed herein.
FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram showing further details of a host system of the methods and systems disclosed herein.
FIG. 3 is a flow diagram showing high-level process steps for an embodiment of the methods and systems disclosed herein.
FIG. 4 is a flow diagram depicting steps of a pre-calculation process.
FIG. 5 is a flow diagram depicting certain high level steps of a pre-calculation process of the present invention.
FIG. 6 is a flow diagram for a file conversion process.
FIG. 7 is a schematic of an embodiment of a CLF file format.
FIG. 8 is a flow diagram depicting steps for processing a URL in an embodiment of the invention.
FIG. 9 is a flow diagram showing a panel selection pre-process and a panel selection process.
FIG. 10 is a flow diagram depicting steps for a transformation process of an embodiment of the present invention.
FIG. 11 depicts a breakdown of components of a typical URL.
FIG. 12 depicts a file format for a file after adding information from a session identification process and a URL decomposition process.
FIG. 13 depicts a CL5 file format that includes information of a common log format as well as hashes of certain data items.
FIG. 14 is a flow diagram depicting steps for processing data for a particular metric in an embodiment of the invention.
FIG. 15 is a diagram of a file format for output of a calculation process for a metric.
FIG. 16 is a schematic diagram depicting an array of machines for processing a metric in an embodiment of the invention.
FIG. 17 is a flow diagram depicting steps for a calculation process.
FIG. 18 is a flow diagram depicting steps for calculating a verticals metric in an embodiment of the invention.
FIG. 19 is a schematic diagram showing a verticals calculator and the components for processing the verticals calculation.
FIG. 20 is a flow diagram for a high-level business modification process of an embodiment of the invention.
Referring to FIG. 1, a schematic diagram 100 shows high-level entities that participate in various embodiments of methods and systems disclosed herein. The methods and systems are facilitated by a host 112, which may have a host computer systemfor facilitating various processes and functions described below. The host may have a plurality of clients 114 who interact with the host to obtain information, analysis, or a variety of services. In some cases the clients 114 obtain information fromthe host 112 through a separate facility, such as a co-location facility 118. The host 112 operates on data that it receives through a plurality of data providers 108. The data from the data providers 110 is typically sent to the host over a computernetwork 110, such as the Internet, or through any other conventional communications facility. The host 112 may store data in a data facility 120, such as a data warehouse. The data providers 108 may each have one or more data centers, which may consistof conventional facilities for storing data relating to use of online services. The data providers 108 may thus run a plurality of servers, which may be configured as server farms. The data providers 108 may be Internet Service providers, ecommercecompanies, content providers, media companies, or other companies that collect data regarding user interactions online. The data providers typically obtain their data from the interaction of various users 102 who trigger HTTP transactions as they engagein online behavior with various online sites 150. The users 102 interact with their computers, webTVs, PDAs or other communications-enabled devices, through a communication facility 104, which may represent the Internet, Worldwide Web, or other wired orwireless computer network. Those interactions are tracked and stored by the data provider 108, and some of them are passed along to the host 112 for analysis on behalf of various clients 114.
Referring still to FIG. 1, the online behavior of a user 102 is typically reflected in a series of HTTP (HyperText Transfer Protocol) transactions, HTTPS transactions. These transactions can represent HTML pages or any of a wide variety of othercontent. The transactions are typically made from a user's browser (such as an Internet Explorer or Netscape Navigator browser), but HTTP transactions can be made from other applications as well. The browser or other application can reside on anycomputer, such as a laptop, personal computer, server, personal digital assistant, WebTV, or other device.
The user 102 connects to online content sources by a computer network 104, such as the Internet. The online content sources typically comprise one or more servers, which may be HTTP servers. In HTTP transactions, the servers serve content overthe network in response to messages from the user's computer.
In their online behavior, users can interact with sites of one or more vendors through the data provider 108. Those data providers 108 typically track users' interactions with their sites through logs or similar facilities. The logs record userbehavior, tracking what pages of content they have viewed in what sequence and for what amounts of time. Thus, either at the desktop or at the server farm, information is being tracked about every HTTP transaction that the individual executes at anytime. When information is tracked at a server farm it is usually subject to an agreement between the user and a host (such as an ISP or other site host). The agreement typically sets out the conditions under which the host can share data with thirdparties, including demographic data about the user and data about the user's actions. A facility is then put in place at the data provider 108 to follow rules that allow capturing of users' transactions and sending some individuals data while not doingso for others.
Data about user actions can be logged in real time or collected and sent in batches by the various data providers 108. The individuals 102 visiting the various online sites 150 in turn serve as data sources to data providers 108 and/or for ahost 112 of the methods and systems described herein.
Data is conveyed from the data providers 108 to the host 112 periodically. In some cases it is pushed from the data provider 108 to the host 112, while in others it is pulled by the host 112 from the data provider 108. The transfer is typicallyover a network 110, such as the Internet. The information that gets pulled or pushed across is typically HTTP/HTTPS information for each of the users 102 of that data provider 108, along with demographic information for each of those users 102.
Referring to FIG. 2, a schematic diagram shows certain components of a host system 200. Through a series of processes and modules, the host system 200 takes data from data providers 108 and converts it into information suitable for a client 114. Inside the host system 200 a collection facility 202 collects the data from the various data providers 108. The collection facility 202 can comprise a set of machines that look at rules that are generated by the host 112 for the data provider 108 inquestion. Thus, the host system 200 expects data of a given format from a given data provider 108. The host system 200 can have a timing facility that generates alerts if the data from a given data provider 108 doesn't arrive on time.
Once the data has come across the network from the data provider 108, the host system 200 looks at individual files. Each data provider 108 follows a convention for the files they send over, which may contain demographic information, clickstreamdata, and a file signature for all files the data providers send over. To ensure that all of the data was properly transmitted, it is desirable to use a facility such as an MD5 hash of the file. If the size of the file does not match, then the host 112can determine that the file was not properly transferred.
In embodiments, the host system 200 can comprise a plurality of Free BSD X86 Intel machines, running software written in an object-oriented language such as C++. Referring still to FIG. 2, the host system 200 may also include an internal network204 that can handle files that come from the collection facility 202. The host system 200 may also include a pre-calculation facility, which may consist of software modules for handling certain operations that are necessary to generate a suitable formof file for handling by the host system 200. The host system 200 may also include a calculation facility 210, which may consist of software modules and a cluster 214 of machines for running a large number of parallel calculations on the files that areobtained from the pre-calculation facility 208. The calculations generate various information, such as metrics that relate to various characteristics of the behavior of users 102. The host system 200 may further include a post-calculation facility 212,which performs certain post-calculation operations on the information generated in the calculation process. Data files can be sent directly to the client 114, hosted as an ASP model, sent to a co-location facility 118, or to a data warehouse 120. Further details of the various modules, machines and facilities of the host system 200 are disclosed below.
Referring to FIG. 3, a flow diagram 300 depicts high-level steps for a flow of information from a user 102 through the host 112 to a client 114. First, at a step 302, the user engages in an HTTP transaction or other online interaction, such asby using a browser to interact with an e-commerce website. Next, at a step 304, a data provider 108 tracks and stores information about the actions of the user 108, such as in a log file or any of a wide range of similar facilities. The information isstored in a data center or similar facility of the data provider 108. Next, at a step 308, the host 112 collects data from the data provider 108, either by having the information pushed from the data provider 108, or by pulling the information from thedata provider 108. Once the data is collected, at a step 310 the host system 200 delivers it to an internal network. Then at a step 312 the host system 200 checks the data for integrity and alerts the data provider 108 if there is a problem.
Once the integrity of the data is confirmed at the step 312, at a step 314 the pre-calculation facility of the host system 200 performs various operations needed to get data from multiple data providers into a common file format, which can becalled CLF. Pre-calculation involves various sub-processes disclosed in connection with FIG. 5 and other figures below. At a step 318 the system takes the results of the pre-calculation process, a file in a standard format, and moves the files to thecalculation facility 210. At a step 320 the calculation facility calculates various metrics on the files, as desired by the operator, such as for the benefit of a given client 114 or all clients 114.
After the calculation processes of the step 320 are complete, the system executes various post-calculation processes 322, typically involving merging, sorting and deduplicating results that were obtained by multiple machines into a coherent setof files. Then the system 200 transfers the files at a step 324, such as to a data facility 120, to the client 114, or to a co-location facility. Further details of these processes are disclosed below.
Referring to FIG. 4, a flow diagram 400 sets out a series of steps for an embodiment of a collection process. First, at a step 402, the system reads a list of data providers. Next, at a step 404 the system assesses for a particular dataprovider whether the data provider pushes information. If so, then at a step 408 the system waits for the files from the data provider. Then at a step 410 a timing facility of the system determines whether the files have arrived on time. If not, thesystem determines at a step 412 whether the window of time has expired for the arrival of files from that data provider. If so, then at a step 414 the system sends an alert to an operator of the host system or other individual. If at the step 412 thewindow has not expired, then processing returns to the step 408 to wait for the files. If at the step 410 the files are on time, then the processing is handed to step 424 the confirm completion of the transfer.
If at the step 404 it is determined that the data provider does not push information, then at a step 420 the system initiates a pull transaction with the data provider. The system then determines at a step 422 whether the files are ready at thedata provider. If at the step 422 the files are ready at the data provider, then the system begins the transfer at a step 418. Processing is then sent to a step 424 until transfer is complete. Once transfer is complete (whether the data providerpushes information or the information was pulled by the host), then, at a step 428 the system checks the file signature to confirm that the files were not corrupted during transfer. If the file signature is determined at a step 430 to be okay, then at astep 432 the raw file data is archived. If the file signature is not okay at the step 430, then at the step 414 the operations team and the data provider are alerted that the file needs to be transferred again. Once the data is archived at the step432, it is determined at a step 434 whether the archiving is complete. If archiving is complete at the step 434, then at a step 438 the files are moved for further processing, such as to an internal network of the host. If there is a problem with thearchiving process, then an alert is sent to the operations team at a step 440.
If at the step 422 the files are not ready at the data provider, then at a step 442 the host system waits for a period of time and checks again. A timing facility then determines at a step 444 whether time has expired. If not, then the systemcontinues to wait at the step 442. If so, then at a step 448 an alert is sent to the data provider and the operations team that the desired files were not ready for transfer.
In normal operation the files will transfer properly (in either a push or pull transaction), and the system will arrive at the step 438 with files ready for processing on the internal systems of the host.
Once files are ready for processing, the host system can initiate a pre-calculation process. High level steps of a pre-calculation process are depicted in a flow diagram 500 of FIG. 5. The pre-calculation process has four main high level steps. The first is a conversion process 502, which converts the files of a plurality of data providers into a common file format. Off-page connector A connects the flow diagram 500 to a flow diagram 600 of FIG. 6 that includes further details of theconversion process 502. Once the files are in a common format, the files are cleansed in a cleanse process 504. The details of an embodiment of the cleanse process are set forth in a flow diagram 800 of FIG. 8, which is connected to the flow diagram500 by off-page connector B. Once files are cleansed, the system initiates a panel selection process 508. Details of an embodiment of a panel selection process are set forth in a flow diagram 900 of FIG. 9, which is connected to the flow diagram 500 byoff-page connector C. Once the panel selection process is complete, the system initiates a transformation process. Details of an embodiment of a transformation process are set forth in a flow diagram 1000 of FIG. 10, which is connected to the flowdiagram 500 by off-page connector D.
Referring to FIG. 6, the files that come from multiple data providers (DPa, DPb, DPc, DPd) are input into a conversion process shown in a flow diagram 600. This is the only part of the pre-calculation process that is data-provider dependent. The conversion process of the flow diagram 600 takes information from multiple providers in different formats and is converted to a common file format for the host system. First, at a step 602, the host system takes in the data from different dataproviders. Next, at a step 604 the convert application (which may be embodied as an API or similar facility) loads a class that has rules specific to the data provider who provided the file in question. Next, at a step 608, the application uses therules to read in the information from that format for each data provider. Finally, at a step 610, the system outputs the data into a standard file format for the host system. In embodiments this can be called the CLF file format.
FIG. 7 shows a file format 700, CLF Format, which is the standard file format for a file in an embodiment of the invention. The format 700 includes various data items, which include a file identifier 714, the identity of the user whosetransactions are stored in the file, or user id 702, the identity of the data provider 704, a time stamp 708, the URL (uniform resource locator) at which the user was at the time 710, and the protocol 712 used in the transaction (e.g., HTTP, FTP, HTTPS). In embodiments the combination of the user ID 702 and the data provider ID 704 can serve as the unique file identifier 714 for the file. The file format can result in hundreds of lines for a given user's online session, with each line representing atime and URL that the user passed during the session.
Referring to FIG. 8, a flow diagram sets out steps for completion of a file cleansing, or cleanse, process 800. The cleanse process 800 operates on files that are in the CLF format that is generated by the conversion process 700 of FIG. 7. First, at a step 802, the system reads in a list of URL rules. Next, at a step 804, the system walks each URL character through the URL rules to determine how many rules apply to that URL. In embodiments this may occur character by character for theURL in the CLF format, using a facility such as a finite state machine. For example, if the URL were www.amazon.com, the system would look at the first character and determine how many rules apply to the character "w" located in the first position of aURL. Then the system would determine how many rules apply to the second "w" in the second position, and so on, until all characters have been examined and a complete list of applicable rules has been loaded.
Once the system has determined how many rules apply at the step 804, then, at a step 808, the system applies each applicable rules against the URL. The rules can include filters for various data providers. In embodiments the rules may relate toURLs alone, or may relate to URL/data provider combinations. In embodiments, the rules might relate to the user as well. An example of a rule is as follows. If the data provider is, for example, Amazon.com, it is known that the company modifies itsURLs (in a system that is not consistent with some URL protocols) and include session identifiers in the URLs, but not in the query string where they would normally appear for some data providers. By including session identifiers in the URLs, but not inthe query string, it appears that each Amazon.com URL is from a unique provider, when in fact all of them are from Amazon.com. To avoid seeing each Amazon URL as coming from a unique provider, the system can apply a rule that pulls out the sessionidentifier from the URL and produces an output URL that doesn't have the session identifier.
Thus, at a step 810, the system outputs a cleansed URL in accordance with the various rules.
Referring to FIG. 9, a flow diagram 900 depicts a panel selection preprocess 902 and a panel selection process 904. In the panel selection pre-process, first, at a step 908 there is periodically (e.g., once per week or once per month) a surveyconducted, such as a random digit dial (RDD) survey to determine the nature of certain characteristics of the Internet community. For example, the RDD survey determines the total number of Internet users in the United States, and it breaks down thoseusers into categories based on age, income, gender and location (based on zip code or phone prefix). Next, in a statistical process 910, statisticians compile information from the RDD survey about age, income, activity level, where the user is online(home or work) and the like. Next, at a step 912 an operator of the host looks at the panel for the previous period and at a step 914 examines historical information about that panel of users. Next, upon completion of a statistical analysis of theprevious panel and the current statistics from the RDD survey, the host selects a panel of users at a step 918. Selection is performed based on finding users with targeted combinations of various demographic information. The panel can consist of userswith many different target combinations. In an embodiment, about one hundred combinations can be used with different demographic combinations. For example, one combination might be males aged 16 who are earning more than $30,000. Based on historicaldemographic data supplied to the host by the data providers, it is possible to generate a representative mix of users with the indicated characteristics for a wide variety of demographic combinations. At a step 922 the operator of the host can compile alist of panel members, completing the preprocess 902.
Selection of panel members is a statistical process that involves some degree of prediction. For example, selecting a panel involves guessing that a given user will be online again for the next month, so that data can be collected. If the hostanalyzes data less frequently (e.g., only after the end of a given month), then the host can analyze based on actual information about what users were actually on line in that month. However, if the host wishes to deliver information more rapidly (suchas weekly or daily) then it can be preferable to predict what users will be online, rather than waiting to see what users were actually online before making a panel selection.
Next, at a step 924 the system reads the list of panel members generated at the step 922. For a given data file in the CLF format, at a step 928 the panel selection process reads the file line by line and determines whether the user identifiedby the user id 702 is a panel member. If not, then at a step 930 the system discards the file. If at the step 928 the user id 702 is for a panel member, then at a step 932 the system outputs the file and sends it at a step 934 to the transformationprocess depicted further in the flow diagram 1000 of FIG. 10.
Referring to FIG. 10, steps for a transformation process are provided in a flow diagram 1000. The transformation process 1000 reads a CLF format file line by line taking the output from the panel selection process 900 of FIG. 9. Thus, it takesoutput only for those files that are for panel members.
First, at a step 1002, the system sessionizes the data for a given user. Because a user may be logged on to a site all day (or longer), it can be difficult to identify clearly delineated online sessions for the user. In order to sessionize thedata, the system looks at data for a particular user for a given day and walks down all of the URLs the user clicked on, looking for inactivity greater than a given time (e.g., 30 minutes) in the timestamps. If there is inactivity greater than thepredetermined time, the end of a session is marked. Session identification can be accomplished with conventional log file analysis tools.
Once a session is identified at the step 1002, the system outputs a file in CLF format with a session id added. Thus, the file now has the user ID 702, data provider ID 704, time stamp 708, URL/URLs 710 and protocol 712, as well as the newelement, the session ID 1010.
Once the data is divided into session at the step 1002, the system decomposes the URLs in the CLF format file in a step 1004. Decomposition of a URL is accomplished by applying a complex set of rules that are based on the location of givencharacters at given positions in the URL. Referring to FIG. 11, a URL 1100 is divided into a plurality of sections denoted in FIG. 11 by the dividers 1102. The URL of FIG. 11 is www.yahoo.com/search?p=football&5644. As the Internet grows, and asstandard bodies introduce new top level domains, it is increasingly difficult to decompose URLs into readily identifiable components. In the URL 1100, certain conventional components can be identified. First, there is a subdomain 1104, which in thiscase consists of a part of a domain, such as the characters "www" indicating the presence of a particular domain as being on the Worldwide Web. Next, a URL may have a domain 1108, which typically consists of a prefix 1118 (often, but not always, thename or a contraction of the name of the entity hosting the URL) and a domain type 1120 (e.g., .com for commercial entities, .net for network companies, .gov for government entities, .org for non-profit entities, a domain type reflecting a country code,or various others). The URL may also include a path 1110, which typically reflects navigation within a structure of the entity that has the domain. The URL may have a query string 1112, which may include a structure for identifying data or contenttypes along the indicated path. For example, the query string may include a parameter (p=) consisting of a value "football" and another parameter consisting of value S644.
The URL 1100 is just one of many configurations of URL, and the components 1102 should be understood to be representative of one way of decomposing a URL and labeling constituent elements. Many other ways can be used. In some decompositions,for example, the path 1110, or a combination of the path 1110 and the query string 1112, might just be identified as a query string. In any such embodiment, the decomposition process 1004 breaks down the URL into constituent parts, based on rules thatmay be adjusted to reflect the URL types of a given data provider or other entity that generates URLs. The decomposition process 1004 can be accomplished in embodiments by a rule engine that steps through the characters of the URL and identifies rulesthat apply to the given character in the given location, as well as rules that apply to given strings of characters in given components 1102 of the URL. The rule engine essentially figures out the grammar of the URL based on a codification of the rulesfor all URLs in a wide range of domains.
Maintaining a rule engine that properly decomposes URLs is difficult because of the emergence of facilities such as redirection services that take a given input and redirect the user to a different URL. Thus, the rules must recognize thoseredirections and classify the redirecting URL as the equivalent of the target URL to which the user is redirected. In addition, many sites (Yahoo.com, for example) are now serving as proxies for other sites, thereby "swallowing" content of the othersites. Thus, if a URL such as the following is visited by a user: http://yahoo.com/proxy/http://ebay.com, the system might initially be tricked into concluding that the domain is yahoo.com. However, the real content for such a URL is actually atanother domain, ebay.com. Thus, the URL analysis rules must account for the use of proxies so that they can identify particular page content as being equivalent to other page content, regardless of the use of a proxy in one case and the absence of aproxy in the other. In some situations it may be desirable to identify and store the fact that a page was found through a proxy as well as what the page was. Thus, decomposition could identify and output a file that identifies use of proxies.
The process of decomposing URLs also consists of examining page level content for each of the paths and query strings and identifying rules for what paths and query strings mean in a wide range of contexts.
Referring to FIG. 12, the output of the decomposition step 1004 in one embodiment is a file format 1200, including the basic CLF format with the user ID 702, data provider ID 704, time stamp 708, URL/URLs 710, protocol 712, as well as the sessionID 1010, and now new elements from the decomposition step 1004, including, for example, the domain 1202, subdomain 1204, path 1208 and query string 1210.
Once a URL is decomposed at the step 1004 of FIG. 10, and the system has generated the output file in the format of FIG. 12, the system proceeds to a step 1008, at which it hashes the URLs that were decomposed at the step 1004. In an embodiment,the system takes the URLs and turns them into MD5 hashes, producing a unique hash identifier based on the character set. For each of these parts, the system generates a file that can perform as an index of URLs for later calculations.
The output of the hash step 1008 is a file in a format 1300 that can be called CL5, which is depicted in FIG. 13. The CL5 format consists of the elements of the decomposition step, namely, the user ID 702, data provider ID 704, time stamp 708,URL/URLs 710, protocol 712, as well as the session ID 1010, and now new elements from the decomposition step 1004, including, for example, the domain 1202, subdomain 1204, path 1208 and query string 1210, as well as new elements, including a domain IDhash 1302, a subdomain ID hash 1304 and a path ID hash 1308. Thus, the file format 1300 consists of the CLF format plus MD5 hashes (e.g., sixteen character hashes) for the last three items in the CLF format. This format is useful for future processingbecause, among other things, it is easier to index on a fixed number of characters.
Once the hash step 1008 is complete, the transformation process 510 of FIG. 5 is also complete. The net result is that the system has identified page level data and has decomposed it and indexed it based on what it means based on the content atthe given URLs. Thus, the system has generated the capability of analyzing URLs based on semantic meaning.
In embodiments, the pre-calculation processes of FIG. 5, i.e., the cleanse process 504, the panel selection process 508 and the transformation process 510 operate line by line on incoming data. That is, each line goes to the cleanse process 504,then to the panel selection process 508, then to the transformation process 504, and so on.
Once a data file arrives in the system, the system checks file integrity at the step 430 of FIG. 4. Then it sends the files for the pre-calculation process of FIG. 5, applying rules across URLs and users, to produce files in a file format thatcan be called CLF, or compete log format in the form identified in FIG. 7, as well as files in the format of FIG. 12. At the end, the hash step 1008 of the transformation process 504 produces a file in a format that can be called CL5, or a "gold" logformat, where some of the data is parsed out with one-way hashes to make lookups on those files easier. Taking URLs, breaking up into parts, and hashing parts of them allows the operator to create a pseudoindex to make it easy to look them up during thecalculation process described below.
Once the pre-calculation process is complete the system can initiate a calculation process. The calculation process is designed to calculate various metrics that the operator of the host system wishes to generate out of the data provided by thedata providers. Thus, the calculation process consists of many calculators, one or more for each metric that the operator wishes to calculate. The calculators can operate in parallel fashion running on clusters of machines to facilitate rapidcalculation of the various metrics. Thus, in the calculation process the system ends up with multiple intermediate files running across multiple servers.
Once the calculation processes are complete, another process can be kicked off. That post-calculation process picks up the multiple files across multiple servers to merge, sort, and deduplicate files. Essentially, the post-calculation processmerges data from the various servers that performed the calculation processes.
After post-calculation processes are complete, the resulting files can be sent out to various locations, such as a co-location server, where the files may be accessed by clients of the host system, and/or to an internal data warehouse, to allowanalysts of the host to look at them. Depending on how the host decides to partition a day's data there might be multiple data warehouses where files will reside. Once there, users can request data from the warehouse, which they do through a facilitysuch as a broker (a web-based interface that takes a request, decomposes it, identifies where in the data warehouse group of machines the data resides, and returns the data to the user through the broker). In embodiments the broker may give anintermediate result or may provide a final result that is the result of the sorting, merging and deduplicating processes. In embodiments the broker can allocate what files go on what machines and then return the files when requested by users.
More details of the calculation process are provided below. The calculation process may take place periodically, whether the period is daily, weekly, monthly or on some other time schedule. In embodiments, calculations are done daily to provideclients of the host with timely information. The calculation process can calculate many different metrics, such as the number of unique visitors to a page of content, search terms used by users, and classification of page content by industry verticals.
FIG. 14 is a flow diagram 1400 showing steps for the processing of a particular metric in a calculation process. First at a step 1402, the system takes the files that come from the pre-calculation process 500 of FIG. 5, which are in a formatsuch as the CL5 format 1300 of FIG. 13. In an embodiment, the step 1402 is accomplished by a daemon that is waiting to look for files to appear in a certain defined area. The daemon is programmed to look for the number of files that should be producedduring that period (e.g., that day).
Next, at a step 1404, a checksum process happens for the daily (or other period) CL5 files to tell whether the pre-calculation process is finished writing the files out or not. When files are completed, they can be appended with a suffix, e.g.,Filename.done. In the files are MD5 checksums of the files, so the system looks for the .done suffix and then compares the MD5 signature to the checksum to determine whether the files are ready to process. If the checksum works, then the systemindicates so by a CHECKSUM OK message.
Next, at a step 1408, a job or batch handling facility manages a set of processing nodes to handle processing of the files. The job/batch handling facility is programmed to know which nodes are free (available for processing), which ones arebusy, and which calculations can run on which nodes. (Some calculations can only run on certain nodes, while some can run on any node).
Once the handling facility hands of the processing to the nodes, the system checks periodically to determine whether the processing of a given metric is completed. For example, if the metric is the number of unique visitors to a URL, the systemcan at a step 1410 check to see whether the calculation of "uniques" is completed. If calculation for a metric is not complete, then processing continues. When the metric is complete at the step 1410, the system initiates processing for the next metricat a step 1412. Of course the system may calculate different metrics simultaneously, rather than completing one metric and then completing another. The flow diagram 1400 should be understood to set out the high level steps for only one embodiment ofbatch processing and identifying completion of a given metric calculation. Other embodiments would be readily understood by one of ordinary skill in the art.
In embodiments, each day the job processing facility knows how many work orders it has in the system. It looks up the work orders for that day. When it finds files ready to run, it begins to hand them to the nodes to run. The work orders canbe conditional. Thus, they can run a given metric if the checksum is ok for the incoming file, and they can process a given metric conditioned on completion of another metric. For a work order, the job processing facility is programmed to know how manymachines it needs, and it reserves the machines it needs. If processing a given metric, such as "uniques" requires four nodes, then the job processing facility can start running the calculation of uniques on four nodes, putting the other nodes on "wait"status. The job processing facility does this for each metric. The job processing facility can be programmed with a language of its own, similar to a compiler.
At a high level, the calculation process for a given metric checks to see if files are in the proper location, reserves machines needed for that metric, initiates processes on the appropriate machines, and outputs a file. Referring to FIG. 15,the file format 1500 for an output file from a machine contains various elements, including, in an embodiment, the date 1502, the machine 1504, the metric 1508 and a suffix or extension 1510.
Referring to FIG. 16, a schematic diagram 1600 shows a cluster of machines 1602 used for a calculation process. The machines can be assigned a status of "reserved", reflected by an "R" in FIG. 16 or "available", reflected by an A. Some machines1602 may optionally be made capable of accessing an external communications facility 1604, such as the Internet, for retrieving data for use in their calculations. Other machines 1602 (or the same ones) may be made capable of accessing a data storagefacility 1608, which may be an internal facility of the host system 200 or an external data storage facility. Thus, depending on the requirements of the calculation for the metric in question, the machines 1602 that run the calculation process can takeadvantage of external data, as well as using the files generated in the pre-calculation process.
Once the job/batch processing facility completes calculations for a given metric, a rollup process of the host system 200 can determine how many files were produced for that metric that day (or period), then combine them. For most metrics thatcan be accomplished by simply merging files. For some metrics, such as unique visitors, simply merging files may not be enough, because there may be a need to de-duplicate the files to avoid double counting a given user's visit to a URL.
Once the rollup process is complete the machine can produce a file (e.g., "date.unique") that contains the data for that metric for that date. In embodiments the file can be a GZIP file.
Referring to FIG. 17, a flow diagram 1700 shows steps for calculating another metric, referred to herein as a "search terms" metric. In some respects the calculation of the search terms metric is similar to that for other metrics, such as the"uniques" metric discussed above. However, in other respects the search terms metric requires variation of the steps described above. First, at a step 1702, the system initiates the search term metric process (which may happen upon completion ofcalculations for another metric, such as uniques, thus freeing the machines that were being used to calculate uniques). At a step 1704 the calculation facility 210 of the host system initiates a daily job/batch processing run for the search termsmetric. This is similar to the process described above for the calculation of the uniques metric, involving identification of the appropriate machines for the search terms metric, reserving the machines, and running the calculations on the files thatcame from the pre-calculation process. In the case of the search terms metric, not all data is found in the files that come from the pre-calculation process. Instead, at a step 1708 the search term calculation process accesses external data in order tocomplete the calculations for the search terms metric. Therefore, referring to FIG. 16, the machines 1602 used for the search terms metrics need to have the capability of accessing the external data facility 1608 in order to complete the calculations. The search terms metric calculator works not only on CL5 files from the pre-calculation process, but also on an external data set (from us or a third party). The calculator takes that information and uses it during the calculation.
In an embodiment, the external data is data from a dictionary of search terms from a multiplicity of web sites. In an embodiment, the host collects search terms from more than 27,000 sites for use by the search terms metric calculator. To knowwhat the search pages and types are, the operator of the host system 200 or a third party goes to various sites and to sections within sites and figures out what the search URL looks like for that site. For example, for Yahoo.com the search URL mightlook like: search.yahoo.com? There are a wide variety of formulations for search strings. Some take the basic form of "domain.com/p=query string," but others take different forms. For example, some sites are co-branded by two different parties. Forexample, if google.com and the Washington Post co-brand a site, the URL may look as follows: "Wp.google.com (parameter)p=washingtonpost.com." The dictionary of search terms must recognize this as a Washington post search string, not a google.com one. Thus, the system sets up a rule that recognizes that if the string is of the form xx.google.com/xxx? q=xxx, the credit goes to the domain identified by the query string, not to google.com.
By way of example, Yahoo.com has hundreds of search pages on their site (finance ticker, groups, mail, etc.), so the host operator can establish or access a dictionary that takes the various forms and translates them to obtain the semanticmeaning, or the host can use a rule or similar facility to accomplish a similar function.
So, when the job runs at the node level, the search terms calculator reads the external data, doing lookups on tables (held in node machines in memory) to figure out who should get credit for what URL. As with rules used in pre-calculation, itis too difficult to compare each URL with all possible search terms in the dictionary. Instead, the system can pass each line a single time, and the calculators figure out whether they should calculate something with the line or throw it out.
As with the other metrics, at a step 1710 the system rolls up the files into a single file ready for transfer to the data facility 120, the client 114 or the co-location facility 118.
Referring to FIG. 18, a flow diagram 1800 sets out steps for calculating another metric, called "verticals." This metric, like those described above, is done by a set of machines in the calculation facility 210 of the system 200. First, at astep 1802, the system initiates the "verticals" metric calculation. As with the other metrics, a checksum process ensures file integrity. Next, when machines become available, the calculation facility 200 reserves the appropriate machines for runningthe daily job/batch for the "verticals" metric calculation at a step 1804.
Next, at a step 1808, the system accesses an external communications facility. Thus, the machines used for the verticals calculation must be able to access an external communications facility, which will be used to reach an external data set. This time the system must go outside the internal network and do something in order to allow the processing.
The term "verticals" refers to industry classifications. For example, a "vertical" might be business-to-business services, with subcategories ranging from financial services, to office services, etc. Another set of verticals might bebusiness-to-consumer services, with verticals including retail, financial services, etc. The system can classify any number of verticals.
Referring to FIG. 19, a schematic diagram 1900 shows a verticals calculator 1902 and three main constituent components that are used for the three main parts of the verticals calculation. The components are a page extractor module 1904, afetcher module 1908 and a classifier module 1910. As can be seen in FIG. 19, the verticals calculation can use the external communication facility 1604 for accessing an external data facility 1912, such as to access a lexicon or set of rules stored onthe facility 1912. Therefore, it is preferably run on a machine or machines that have that capability.
Referring to FIG. 18, once the external communications facility has been accessed at the step 1808, the system launches a page extractor process at a step 1810. The page extractor process reads a list of verticals stored by in the external datafacility 1912, and for each vertical it launches a separate process to run for each of the sites that are classified in that vertical. For example, the B2B:Office vertical would run processes for sites for Office Depot, OfficeMax, Staples, and otheroffice supplies vendors. The process is run for the high-level category (e.g., B2B), the sub-category (e.g., Office) and the sites within the sub-category. In embodiments, each site ends up getting a separate process launched on a separate node of thecluster of machines 214 of the calculator facility 210. The node knows where to look up a configuration file based on the hierarchy of verticals. The page extractor process 1810 reads in title and URL key value pairs. Then the process reads in readsin the CL5 files for that day, and it looks for data that matches these URLs/Title pairs to see if URLs from the CL5 files match these pages. This happens for all verticals. At the end of the batch, the system has a subset of a CL5 file with the date,a title (e.g., office depot) and a set of URLs that match the patterns for that site.
Once the page extractor process 1810 is complete, the fetcher module 1908 is engaged to run a fetcher process in a step 1812. The fetcher process reads a line in the file for a given site and determines whether it needs to update the data forthat site. If so, then the fetcher process 1812 downloads the identified page. If the process has seen the identified page before, it can skip to the next one. If the fetcher process finds a new page, it downloads the page and puts it in the directorof pages for that site. In embodiments the fetcher process only runs on certain nodes, because the host system must avoid flooding a site with downloads. The fetcher accesses an external network and in embodiments only runs on one or a few machines. The fetcher module can be programmed to now the maximum rate at which it should pull pages. In embodiments the fetcher module knows how to take codes for changed pages, moved pages, and indications that a site is not in operation. In each case it canproduce alerts for the operator of the host system 200 to change something.
The next step in the verticals metrics calculation engages the classifier module 1910 is a classifying step 1814. Once the fetcher module 1908 has downloaded any new page identifiers, then for every URL in a given file (e.g., a file for OfficeDepot pages), the classifier module 1910 writes out a record to a fetcher database. In embodiments this can be a flat file hierarchy held locally and mirroring the live site, e.g.--officedepot.com/category/product/ID. Such a file can serve as anarchive of the hierarchy of pages at the given site, including, for example, product directory files for all products offered at the site. The classifier module 1910 figures out for that day how many unique products it saw. In embodiments, it goes intoflat file database and knows how to open the identified page and pull out the product information (title, description, price, shipping status, etc.). How to do that for a given site can be stored in the configuration file for the page extractor. It maybe different for every site and page that the host system 200 tracks. Thus, the host system operator may have to come up with different patterns for the various pages and sites that it covers.
The classifying step 1814 takes the information and writes out another file. An example of a file structure would include elements such as the product name, the price, the quantity obtained for that price, the user ID, and the date. Forexample, it might appear as follows: Red stapler/$10.00/quantity 2/ID/date. The classifier module 1910 can do this for all of the different pages that are visited by users in the CL5 files for all of the CL5 files. In embodiments the classifier module1910 can aggregate records across a category (e.g., B2B: Office). In such embodiments, a user of the data can compare products, such as all staplers, to see which ones users are viewing and buying. The classifying step 1814 can do this for officesites, retail, financial services, stock tickers, and other pages. In embodiments it can map a ticker back to the real name for the company.
Once a classifying step 1814 is complete, then at a step 1818 the system can rollup the files for the verticals calculation, as it does for the other metrics that are involved in job/batch processing.
The methods and systems described above cover three out of many possible metrics that can be calculated. Some metrics may be run with data just from the CL5 files that are generated in the pre-calculation processes disclosed above. Othersrequire reference to an external data set as well as data from the CL5 files. Still others require access to page information, such as fetched from the Internet with the fetcher module 1908. Examples of metrics include, without limitation, uniquevisitors, search terms, verticals, cross-correlations between sites, uses of particular patterns of pages, and many others. Each different metric can have a unique calculator, typically running on a node of the cluster 214, using a program coded forthat metric.
The various metrics can be used by analysts to deduce information that is relevant to many different kinds of business processes. For example, data about how users interact with pages that relate to applications for a quote on an insurancepolicy can produce insight into what is involved in converting an insurance shopper into an insurance buyer.
The data obtained can be quite comprehensive. In embodiments, it may consist of user interactions with many thousands of pages divided into hundreds or thousands of vertical categories.
Referring to FIG. 20, a flow diagram 2000 depicts high-level steps for a business process using data from the methods and systems disclosed herein. At a step 2002 the system obtains clickstream data about user behavior, such as throughpre-calculation and calculation processes described above. Next, at a step 2004, an analyst analyzes user behavior based on the nature of the clickstream data. Next, at a step 2008, the analyst draws an inference about user behavior based on the natureof the clickstream data. Finally, at a step 2010, the analyst modifies a business process based on the inference. In embodiments, the analyst modifies an offline business process in response to inferences drawn from online user behavior.
The system 200 may further have a post-calculation facility 212 for merging, sorting and deduplicating the files that are generated in the calculation process. After the post-calculation facility 212 completes these tasks, the files can bedeployed internally to data warehouses, or externally to external data facilities, such as a co-location facility 118 that can be accessed by a client.
Data that is collected and processed by the methods and systems disclosed herein can be used as a basis for modifying a wide range of business processes. One area is in the promotion of goods and services. It is well known that demographicinformation can be used as a basis for designing product promotion; that is, certain groups of customers are more likely to purchase certain goods and services than others. For example, parents are more likely than teenagers to purchase baby strollers. Other information about user behavior can be used to assist in designing product promotion as well.
One embodiment of the method and systems disclosed herein is an improved method of promoting automobiles. Automobiles are typically promoted with incentives, such as low-interest financing, rebates, and the like. Presenting the right promotionat the right time increases the likelihood of making a sale while minimizing the cost of promotions. Understanding what vehicles a particular car model is being cross-shopped against regionally enables the design of incentives to take account of thevarying competitive set. For example, if a customer shops for a Toyota Camry, is that customer more likely to look at a Nissan Maxima, or a Nissan Altima, either of which could be viewed as similar. Knowing what cross-shopping is likely to occur allowsa vendor to present incentives in a manner that accounts for the likely comparisons that the customer will make between the vendor's products and services and potentially competitive ones. The methods and systems disclosed herein allow an analyst totrack cross-shopping behavior and allow a vendor to modify incentives in response to inferences drawn from cross-shopping behavior. By identifying regional variations and changes in the vehicles cross-shopped, an analyst can recommend incentives to fitthe changed circumstances, thereby maximizing sales at the lowest incentive cost.
A second example would be brand positioning. One relevant factor in presenting a marketing message is the order in which the user has shopped various product offerings. For example, if an offering is the first one that a user has shopped, thenit should be advertised in a fashion that encourages users to purchase immediately, rather than consider other offers. If the user has already seen more than one offer, then the subsequent offers need to be positioned differently. If a vendor ispresenting an offer after many others have been considered, then the offer needs to be sufficiently arresting to get the attention of customer late in the process. So, for purposes of branding, messaging, and marketing communications, it is valuable fora vendor to know whether that vendor is typically the first vendor shopped, or whether the vendor typically comes later in the process. This is true whether the marketing message is presented online or offline.
By identifying patterns of online shopping for the products or services offered by a particular vendor, the methods and systems disclosed herein allow an analyst to determine the order in which a customer typically shops for products or servicesof that type. Then the vendor can select and present messages, promotions, and branding that is consistent with the position of the vendor in the typical shopping pattern. This approach can be used in any product or service sector, ranging fromautomotive, to retail, financial, and others.
Knowing customer patterns can also be useful for other business purposes, such as demand forecasting. For example, analysis of customer interest can determine if a predictable share of customers who have looked at a set of competitive productsand services will purchase a particular vendor's product or service. Changes in the share of online users who research goods or services can be used to predict change in market share offline. Thus, by allowing tracking changes in online market share,the methods and systems disclosed herein can assist in offline business planning for changes that depend on changes in sales or market share, such as manufacturing and inventory needs.
Thus, data about online behavior can also help in forecasting demand. For example, in the auto market, knowing what people are researching (e.g., measuring frequency, recency and duration of online shopping for particular models), allows thebusiness to forecast demand for particular make, model and trim in particular geographic regions. That forecast can be used allow a business to set inventory and manufacturing at optimal levels. Also online interest share changes (showing interest in aparticular product) can be correlated to offline sales. Then the business can manage its supply chain and manufacturing to allocate the correct amounts of inventory to the right places at the right time.
Another area in which tracking online user behavior can allow strategic modification of offline business processes is in the area of retail store operation. Retail stores are designed to encourage users to see merchandise in a particularpattern. Stores are particularly designed to present complementary products near each other. For example, tortilla chips and salsa are usually presented in the same area of a supermarket. Also, the order in which a customer sees merchandise can make adifference in the likelihood the customer will buy a particular item. For example, studies have shown that people perceive the price of an item to be lower if they have previously been presented with a higher-priced item. For example, a forty-dollartie seems less expensive if the customer has just selected a five hundred dollar suit. Moreover, the need for the tie may be more clear to the customer if the decision to purchase the suit has already occurred.
It is expensive and time consuming to rearrange a retail store to try to figure out which items should be presented together, and what order should be used to present items. In embodiments of the methods and systems disclosed herein, trackinguser behavior online allows an analyst to draw an inference about what items should be presented together, and what items should be presented in what order, in a retail store. For example, if it is discovered that most online users who purchase personalcomputers also shop for printers, then an analyst might conclude that computers and printers should be presented together. In some cases the connection between the items might have been obvious, but in other situations a correlation between shopping forone item and shopping for another may not be readily apparent without the ability to track and recognize statistical correlations among items, a process that is made possible by tracking user behavior in the methods and systems disclosed herein. Thus,the methods and systems disclosed herein allow the user to organize merchandise in the physical world based on online behavior.
In addition to locating merchandise within a retail environment, it is also possible to draw inferences about how to locate an entire store based on analysis of user behavior online. For example, if goods and services of two different vendorsare identified through statistical techniques as complementary, then one vendor may wish to select a location near the other vendor, even if the connection between the two is not intuitively obvious.
In other embodiments, data from online behavior can be used to draw inferences to develop offline business processes in the financial services area. For example, businesses need to determine what products and services should be offered throughwhat distribution channel, whether it is an online channel, a call center, a branch, or an ATM channel. For example, financial advice and stock quotes might best be delivered through different channels. If online behavior shows that customers examineindividual stock information online, but get confused with mutual funds, then a business can decide to put the individual stock information online, but to offer mutual funds through other channels, such as advisors in branch offices. Thus, figuring outthe proper offline distribution channel can be done with the assistance of inferences drawn from online behavior.
Location decisions also benefit from online information. For example, if a business can learn where its competitor's online shoppers come from by zip code, a business can decide to locate its physical facilities in locations where thecompetitor's online shopper density is highest or lowest, as desired. This can help the business get new business from competitors, rather than cannibalizing its own customer base.
Other retail business processes can also be helped. By determining interest share by zip code, a catalog provider can, for example, drop the customized versions of a catalog by zip code to meet regional needs. Similarly, other direct marketingcampaigns, such as mail campaigns, can be targeted to the right demographic and location based on online interest.
Pricing decisions also benefit from analysis of online behavior. For example, knowing how the number of transactions is affected when a price is changed can help a business determine an optimal price for goods or services. It can be also usefulto know how many people shop elsewhere after a price increase, as compared to before. By looking at behavior across multiple sites it is possible to set prices at the highest point of price indifference. Thus prices can be tuned for online and offlineofferings based on online behavior data.
It is also possible to watch behavior of a competitor's customers after the competitor increases prices. Also, a business can introduce price changes online to a limited set of customers to determine sensitivity before making more extensiveprice changes offline.
The methods and systems disclosed herein can assist media businesses as well. By determining the patterns and reasons for online migration between different online content sources, it is possible to draw inferences about the customer's behaviorthat allow the content to be designed to keep the user at a given content source. For example, if a readers of Forbes regularly depart its online site to look at particular portions of Fortune's online site, it is possible to redesign the content of theForbes site to contain similar content, thus diminishing the chance the reader will depart. Thus, behavior online can be used to help redesign media content to retain customers. Media businesses can also use online behavior to identify geographic areasof interest and other demographic areas of interest for books, music, news, film and other content. In turn, offline channels of distribution for media content can be altered to target particular geographic or demographic groups. Also, media businessescan target attracting customers based on their online behavior profile with a view to maximizing the attraction of the "best" or most loyal customers.
It is also possible to forecast demand for media content. For example, web traffic at particular sites related to upcoming movie content may tell film distributors which films should be shown on which screens and for how long. Media providerscan also determine what kind of related merchandise to sell along with the media, and what kinds of promotions to engage in. The data can be used to determine appropriate franchising arrangements as well, such as how much to charge for a franchise todistribute toys or other novelties that reflect characters in a film.
Similar forecasting can be used before release of a new musical composition, book, or other media work.
All patents, patent applications, technical specifications, books, and other documents identified herein are hereby incorporated by reference. While the invention has been described in connection with certain preferred embodiments, otherembodiments would be readily understood by one of ordinary skill in the art and are encompassed herein.
* * * * *
Recently Added Patents
System and method for providing program recommendations through multimedia searching based on established viewer preferences
Client network device and method for adjusting parameters of client traffic windows based on discovery of other network devices
Apparatus and method for extracting cascading style sheet rules
Use of natural query events to improve online advertising campaigns
High dynamic range pixel structure
Estimating optical characteristics of a camera component using sharpness sweep data
Molecular sieve
Randomly Featured Patents
Front bumper for motor vehicle
Adhesive backed measuring tape
Automatic balling gun
Voltage transformer with voltage divider for measuring voltage in medium high and high voltage installations
Exterior surface configuration of a ventilation insert for the front bumper of an automobile
Recording head with tilted orientation
Radio frequency identification of component connections
Methods of forming output prediction logic circuits with ultra-thin vertical transistors
Multi-fingered type hand device
Input device and electronic apparatus using same
© 2006-2011. PatentGenius.com All Rights Reserved.


text:
KFI 42" Round Mahogany HPL Table with 4 Black Vinyl Cafe Chairs (42R025MHIM316BV)
Item #: 901-2121765KFI
Model #: 42R025MHIM316BV
Brand: KFI Seating
Not yet rated.Be the first to Write a Review!
$849.99 Each
Delivery Date:
Enter Zip CodeParcel
Help with furniture delivery, assembly,...Read more + Read less -
protection plans and more.
Plus, you've got choices! You'll find options for those DIYers on a budget, those that want us to do all the work and everyone in-between. Want all the details? Get them right here.
KFI's table and chairs combination include a 42" round pedestal table with a mahogany HPL top with 4 Ladder Back chairs with a Black Steel Frame and Black Vinyl Seat is perfect for restaurants, cafes, and break rooms. It has a 1.25" thick high pressure laminate top that's durable and easy to clean. The top has an attractive black T-Mold edge that won't crack or peel and protects the table from bumps and dents. The steel column has a 3" diameter and is made of 16 gauge steel. The top and base are all s hipped in one box, and the pedestal table is easy to assemble. Made in the USA and GSA approved. Made for Commercial Use.
- Mahogany HPL top, Black Vinyl Chairs
- Chair-2" Upholstered Seat
- Capacity: 250 lbs-Chair
- Assemble Required on table only
- Warranty:12 year on frame and base
- Chair-Ladder Back Cafe Chair
- Chair-Black Vinyl
- Chair-1.25" Square Steel Frame
- Table-1.25" High Pressure Laminate Top
|Warranty : 12-year mfg. limited warranty
|Weight (lbs.) : 78
|Capacity (lbs.) : 250
|Height in Inches : 29
|Furnishing Color : Mahogany
|Furnishing Material : Laminate
|Seat Capacity : 4
|Table Shape : Round
|Table Type : Table Sets
|Diameter-inches : 42
|True Color : Midnight Black
|Brand : KFI Seating
|Customizable : No
|Weight : 78.00 lbs. per Each

subset: commoncrawl


text:
Florida Citrus and Vodka-Cured Salmon with Florida Orange and Beet Vinaigrette
|Seafood, Vegetables
|Day Part
|Cuisine Type
Tantalize Taste Buds with Flavors from Under the Sea. Customers will indulge in savory vodka-cured salmon paired with zesty vinaigrette for an expertly crafted colorful cuisine.
2 pounds salmon fillet, center cut, skin on, no bones
2 tablespoons Florida orange zest
2 tablespoons fresh thyme
2 teaspoons Florida grapefruit zest
¼ cup Florida orange juice
3 tablespoons Florida grapefruit juice
2 tablespoons vodka
2 cups salt
1 cup sugar
Florida Orange and Beet Vinaigrette:
2 beets, peeled
1 cup Florida orange juice
¼ cup sherry vinegar
2 cups watercress, leaves only
Crackers, optional
Place salmon in a nonreactive casserole dish. Spread Florida orange zest, thyme, and Florida grapefruit zest evenly over salmon; sprinkle with Florida orange and grapefruit juices and vodka. Combine salt and sugar; cover flesh side of salmon with salt mixture. Cover and refrigerate for 4 to 5 hours, depending on thickness of fillet (longer for thicker fillets, less time for thinner fillets).
While salmon is curing, prepare Florida Orange Beet Vinaigrette: Grate beets finely with a grater. Wrap grated beets in cheesecloth; squeeze juice from beets into a bowl. Reserve juice; discard beet pulp. Place beet juice in saucepan; add Florida orange juice and sherry vinegar. Stir to combine; bring mixture to a simmer; simmer until volume is reduced by two-thirds. Chill and reserve.
Remove salmon from refrigerator and rinse under cold water to remove salt mixture; pat salmon dry with paper towels. Remove skin and any dark flesh; cut salmon into thin slices. To serve, place 4 to 5 salmon slices salmon on each plate. Drizzle with Florida Orange and Beet Vinaigrette. Garnish with watercress leaves; serve with crackers, if desired.
Serve with The Floridian.


text:
|Episode Description
|Saturday, Oct 20, 2012 - 5:00 AM
Romney closing the gender gap: After this week's debate the Presidential candidates are focusing on undecided women in swingstates. The most recent Gallup poll shows Romney within one point of the President among women who are likely to vote. Spotlight on College Rape : A former Amherst College student brings attention to rape on college campuses after an article about her claim the school downplayed her rape allegation goes viral. D
|More on WORLD (MT)
|No upcoming shows in database
|Previous on WORLD (MT)
|No Past shows in database


text:
via the blog Joe.my.god
White guys really are out of touch... they need some outreach. Some hugs. Maybe that'll get them up to date with reality. Speaking as a white guy. I like hugs. Also, as a WA person, by choice, I maybe it's different here. Long winter nights. Snuggletime :)
Views: 610
That was interesting - thanks Sentient.
Yeah the Republicans are saying that they just couldn't get people out to vote.
With Romney as the Republican candidate, I could believe that. If I were in the U.S., I probably wouldn't have voted for either Romney or Obama. I'm not particularly fond of either ones politics.
I'd correct that supposition to read: "If Only SCARED White Guys Had Voted." There are plenty of white male Democrats out there who find Romney, Rove, Faux Noise and the whole right-wing politico-religious gang despicable and worthy of sanction. It is the scared white men, those who can't deal with diversity or change, that would have supported that first set of election results.
I just hope they're dying off. Frankly, they're an embarrassment.
Loren, you are right. And there are also plenty of white women who voted against equality, and for Romney. That split goes a bit the other way, but maybe not. None of is is the monolithic Borg clone of our demographic.
It's been interesting that some people comment to me in person about the election. White medicare folks, men and women, have expressed absolute dismay. Interesting to hear.
One of the more interesting comments I have heard is from my older (I'm no spring chicken), white, teabagger, brother. Mind you, he gets medicare, veteran's benefits, and social security. However, according to him, we've got to get rid of government entitlement programs (except, of course, the aforementioned - as it applies to him). The old "Keep your government hands off my medicare" idiocy we've heard in the past. If not, and prior to the election, he had a "dire warning for America" should the black guy get re-elected. Yeah. Right. Oh, and he adamantly denies being a racist, yet sends out the most vile and disgusting racial emails about the President that I'm sure he receives from all his other scared-shitless, old, white neighbors in his gated community.
It's really hard for me to see my "demographic" behaving so badly. If my parents were still alive they would also be on the racialized right wing republican side. It's not absolute. We are not the Borg. But it's hard to see.
Those RWRs (right wing republicans) really shot themselves in the foot. They've been spreading so much misinformation, seducing people (yes a lot of white males but also a lot of white females and the occasional "special cases" like Herman Cain and Clarence Thomas) into thinking they are "wronged" by "intruders". They've led their followers into a nonthinking kneejerk self-deluding hate-filed scapegoating hypocritical contradictory ignorant hateful fantasy-ridden lala land. We need to start a remedial outreach education program for them to lift them out of their slime-filled pits of rage and start thinking rationally.
OK, there's just a little part of me that feels downright gleeful in witnessing the implosion that occurred last Tuesday. Watching old fat white men sputter in confusion and deny that it was their fault just makes my heart skip a beat. You do have to wonder what the next four years are going to be like-if the republican party manages to have a make over or sink itself further into the mud pit that it's made for itself.
Also, it's cold here. It went from 60 to 30 in about 5 hours. So my own white guy is getting his snuggles. He seems to like it, but then he voted for Obama....
Seems Atheists are starting to make a difference. Check this out... http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2012/11/15/survey-religiously-unaffil...
© 2018 Atheist Nexus. All rights reserved. Admin: The Nexus Group. Powered by


text:
Suburban Chicago Suites Minutes from Woodfield Mall
Located just outside of Chicago, the Woodfield Mall is home to about 300 stores and restaurants. It's one of the country's 10 largest malls, occupying more than two million square feet of retail space in suburban Schaumburg. Anchor stores include Macy's and JCPenney, and there are also fashion-forward boutiques such as Coach and Tumi. Just five minutes away, Comfort Suites Schaumburg puts guests in perfect position for a suburban shopping spree.
The all-suite hotel houses comfortable and spacious accommodations, each with a 32-inch TV, a mini fridge, and a wet bar. An indoor heated pool and hot tub can be found in a sunlight-filled room downstairs. Each morning, you can pay a visit to the hot breakfast buffet, which has a make-your-own-waffle station.
If you choose the romance package, you'll stay in a deluxe or jacuzzi suite and enjoy a heart-shaped pizza, wine, and rose petals. The family-friendly option includes four passes to the nearby Legoland Discovery Center and a gift card for pizza at Lou Malnati's.
Schaumburg, Illinois: Family-Friendly Northwestern Suburb Home to Woodfield Mall and Nature Preserve
Schaumburg is conveniently close to Chicago—it's 28 miles northwest of downtown and minutes from the intersection of I-90 and I-290—but it still has its own identity as well as a variety of family-friendly attractions. Schaumburg is best known as the home of the Woodfield Mall, the nation's ninth-largest shopping center. Among roughly 300 stores and restaurants, Woodfield's anchor attractions include an Apple Store, Macy's, and Nordstrom.
Just around the corner, The Streets of Woodfield offers an outdoor, pedestrian-friendly experience with a movie theater, coffee shops, clothing stores, and the Legoland Discovery Center. Here, kids can tour an interactive Lego "factory," catch a 3-D flick, and build their own Lego creations such as miniature cars that can be put to the test on a racetrack. Come evening, journey back to the Middle Ages at Medieval Times, a restaurant that stages nightly jousting tournaments with horseback-riding knights and falconry demonstrations.
Experience the outdoors at the Ned Brown Forest Preserve—popularly known as Busse Woods—a 3,700-acre expanse on the border of Schaumburg and Elk Grove Village. Bikers and joggers can take advantage of an 8-mile paved loop as fishers post up around Busse Lake in pursuit of channel catfish, largemouth bass, and northern pike. Be sure to swing by the elk pasture, where the preserve's resident herd of elk live.


text:
Jurgen Klopp says he does not know anything about media speculation linking Loris Karius with a move away from Liverpool.
Reports emerged on Monday that the German goalkeeper was close to signing a two-year loan deal with Turkish side Besiktas.
Karius was not part of Liverpool's squad as Klopp's men won 2-0 at Crystal Palace in the Premier League on Monday, though he did attend the game.
The 25-year-old became first choice at the club last season but was replaced by Brazil international Alisson, who joined for a world-record fee from Roma, after making two crucial errors against Real Madrid in the Champions League final.
However, in a news conference after his side's hard-fought victory at Selhurst Park, Klopp denied Karius is on his way out of Anfield.
"Nothing to say," Klopp told reporters. "Nobody told me anything on a transfer."
Simon Mignolet was on the bench for Liverpool at Palace, while the club allowed Danny Ward to join Leicester City during the transfer window.
|Hamilton questions approach to Formula One expansion
|Ranieri honoured to lead ´exceptional´ Fulham squad
|Solari saw Isco out of shape - Ceballos
|Ranieri replaces Jokanovic at Fulham
|Durant keeps details of Green spat ´in-house´ but envisages resolution
|Rooney: Kane and Sterling are England superstars
|Messi will make Argentina return, says Maradona
|Warriors drop Hawks as Green serves suspension
|In-form Healy sends Australia into semis
|Former NBA star McGrady says Carmelo Anthony should retire
|Celtics´ Smart: We have to look at ourselves in the mirror
|Federer plays down preferential treatment talk
|Mourinho is better than Guardiola – Maradona
|Mbappe plays down Pele comparisons
|Don´t worry bro – Mendy responds to Trump
|Melvin, Snitker win manager of the year awards
|Warriors´ Green suspended for Hawks clash
|Asensio: It´s not for me to lead Madrid
|Rooney ready to enjoy England farewell after pressure of ´Golden Generation´
|Ludwigsburg stun high-flying Murcia in BCL
|Rams v Chiefs moved to LA due to Mexico City field conditions
|Skriniar discussing new Inter contract, confirms agent
|Former Barcelona boss Martino named MLS Coach of the Year
|Bell fails to report to Steelers, will sit out rest of season
|Federer back on track after dismal Thiem display
|Udinese appoint Nicola after sacking Velazquez
|Monaco deny they broke rules regarding youth recruitment
|Del Bosque, Zidane, Lopetegui - The former Castilla coaches Solari follows into Real Madrid hot seat
|Ozil rejected ´crazy offers´ from Asia, reveals agent
|Real Madrid appoint Solari on permanent basis
|LeVert avoids need for surgery, should return this season
|Neuer confident despite concerns over Bayern Munich form
|All I ever wanted to do is win, says Sixers signing Butler
|Pogba: Coming home to United was the best feeling ever
|Watson among four signing new Bath deals
|Susanna Dinnage to replace Scudamore as Premier League chief executive
|Murray commits to Brighton until 2020
|Rooney rejected chance of pre-World Cup farewell
|Impressive Anderson thrashes Nishikori
|Ozil´s Germany absence a ´pity´, says Sane
|Rooney: I´ll finish my career in the US
|McIlroy unsure of 2019 European Tour membership
|Australian Open dismisses concerns of Federer scheduling bias
|Hue Jackson joins Bengals staff as ´special assistant´
|Real Madrid confirm Reguilon injury
|Higuain handed two-match ban for Juve meltdown
|Kruis ruled out for England as Jones calls up uncapped quartet
|A year on from Italy failure, Ventura leaves Chievo after four games
|Bairstow misses out as unchanged England promote Stokes
|Recalled Alba denies Luis Enrique bust-up
|´Unhappy´ Christensen won´t push for Chelsea exit
|Nadal to make Abu Dhabi comeback in December
|Taijul helps Bangladesh tighten their grip despite Taylor ton
|Neymar joining Real Madrid wouldn´t hurt Iniesta
|It´s just team spirit - Livingston not worried by Durant-Green exchange
|Trippier out of England squad with groin injury
|Ex-Sri Lanka international Lokuhettige charged by ICC
|Former England and Chelsea star Joe Cole retires
|Nets offer support to LeVert following serious leg injury
|Panenka proud Sergio Ramos imitates his penalties
|Liverpool´s Alisson seeks patience to reach potential
|Anthony Davis leads Pelicans, Clippers hold off Warriors in OT
|Lindelof rues international break for Man Utd
|Shaqiri confident in more goals for Liverpool
|Giants too good for 49ers in crunch time
|Southgate named honorary Yorkshireman
|Nicky Butt: Manchester United are low on confidence
|Criticism of Barcelona star Dembele is overblown - agent
|Thibodeau discusses Butler trade: We thought this was the best deal for us
|Acuna, Ohtani win rookie of the year awards