text:
Steven Moortel
Legislative Research Analyst
(602) 926-5987
Arizona House of Representatives
House Majority Research
1700 W. Washington
Phoenix, AZ 85007-2848
Senator Blendu, Chairman
Representative Knaperek, Vice Chairman
CC: Representative Konopnicki, Senator Waring
DATE: December 19, 2005
SUBJECT: Performance Audit & Sunset Review ofthe Government Information Technology
Agency and the Information Technology Authorization Committee
Attached is the final report of the sunset review of the Government Information Technology
Agency and the Information Technology Authorization Committee, which was conducted by the
Senate Government and House of Representatives Government Reform & Government Finance
Accountability Committee of Reference.
This report has been distributed to the following individuals and agencies:
Governor of the State of Arizona
The Honorable Janet Napolitano
President ofthe Senate
Senator Ken Bennett
Senate Members
Senator Jim Waring, Vice Chairman
Senator Bill Brotherton
Senator Jake Flake
Senator Linda Gray
Senator Harry E. Mitchell
Speaker of the House of Representatives
Representative Jim Weiers
House Members
Representative Bill Konopnicki, Chairman
Representative Ted Downing
Representative Phil Lopes
Representative John McComish
Representative Jor..n Nelson
Government Information Technology
Agency & Information Technology
Authorization Committee
Arizona State Library, Archives & Public Records
Office of the Auditor General
Senate Majority Staff
Senate Research Staff
House Majority Staff
House Research Staff
Senate Government and House of Representatives Government Reform & Finance
Accountability Committee of Reference
Committee of Reference Report
Government Information Technology Agency
Information Technology Authorization Committee
Pursuant to Arizona Revised Statutes section (A.R.S. § 41-2953), the Joint Legislative Audit
Committee (JLAC) assigned the sunset review of the Government Information Technology Agency
(GITA) and the Information Technology Authorization Committee (ITAC) to the Senate
Government and House of Representatives Government Reform & Government Finance
Accountability Committee of Reference for review. Pursuant to A.R.S. §41-1279.03, the Office of
the Auditor General (OAG) completed a performance audit.
Established in 1996 under A.R.S. §41-3502, GITA is responsible for state-wide information
technology (IT) planning and policy. These duties include; security by ensuring that agencies follow
standards to keep hackers from breaking into IT systems; privacy by ensuring agencies protect
personal information they collect and do not collect more personal information than they need;
training by ensuring that state IT personnel are trained; procurement by helping the State evaluate
IT contract proposals and planning by providing sound, strategic direction for state-wide IT needs.
GITA's mission statement is "Partnering with state agencies and private sector organizations to
improve technical and human information technology capabilities, to efficiently add value and
improve delivery of public services for the people of Arizona."
ITAC was established in the same legislation that created GITA and is composed of
members from the Legislature; state, federal, and local governments; and private industry. ITAC
has a number of responsibilities related to information technology, such as working with GITA to
review and approve agency information technology projects over $1 million, reviewing established
state-wide information technology standards, and monitoring information technology projects it
considers major or critical.
Committee ofReference Sunset Review Procedures
The Committee of Reference held one public meeting on November 1, 2005 to review
GITA's response to the 12 sunset factors, as well as four additional questions, as required by
A.R.S. § 41-2954, subsections D and F, and to accept public testimony. The Committee of
Reference received testimony from Jay Dunkleburger, Senior Performance Auditor, Arizona Office
of the Auditor General and Chris Cummiskey, Director, GITA and State CIO.
Committee ofReference Recommendations
The Committee of Reference recommended that the Government Information Technology
Agency be continued for ten years.
1. Agency Response
2. Meeting Notice
3. Minutes of the Committee of Reference Meeting
100 N. 15th Avenue, Suite 440
Phoenix AZ. 85007
October 17,2005
Steven Moortel
Arizona House of Representatives
1700 W. Washington
Phoenix, AZ 85007
Dear Mr. Moortel:
Attached you will find GITA's response to the four questions required by 41-2954 F for the
committee ofreference. Please contact me if you have any questions.
Chris Cummiskey
Director, State CIO
Government Information Technology Agency
Attachment: GITA Response to JLAC
Phone: (602) 364-GITA • Fax: (602) 364-4799
Web: http://www.gita.state.az.us
GITA Response to JLAC
October 17,2005
1. An identification of the problem or the needs that the agency is intended to address.
No Independent Evaluation or Oversight of Projects
Prior to the establishment ofGITA, there was no mechanism to obtain independent evaluation of
Information Technology (IT) projects. In this environment, agencies sometimes purchased IT
systems that were unneeded, overpriced, or incompatible with other State systems. In an effort to
control this situation, the legislature created GITA and empowered it to review and approve all IT
projects over $25,000. In addition the legislature created the Information Technology
Authorization Committee (ITAC) to approve projects with a value of over $1 million dollars.
GITA serves as the staffing agency for ITAC and provides recommendations concerning each
project's merit.
Once a project is approved, it enters the critical next phase of development. In order to reduce the
risk of failure and improve effectiveness and efficiency GITA provides oversight of the project
during this development phase.
No Common Standards
Before the establishment of GITA, there were no common standards for information technology in
the state. Standards are important because they ensure that obsolete or proprietary "dead-end"
software and hardware is not purchased by agencies. Standards also ensure that the software or
hardware will be able to communicate and exchange infonnation (where appropriate) between
agencies. GITA provides common standards between agencies to ensure that the State's computer
systems are compatible with one another. When purchasing new equipment and/or software all
executive branch agencies must meet these state standards.
No Centralized Planning
Before the establishment ofGITA, there was no centralized authority for developing statewide
strategic IT plans or requiring individual agencies to develop plans. In this environment, agencies
were not required to engage in long term IT planning, and there was no strategic IT plan for the
State. GITA was given the authority to coordinate a statewide IT plan and review the IT plans from
each agency.
No Consistent Quality Assurance and Project Management Processes
Before the establishment of GITA, there was no centralized authority for Quality Assurance (QA)
and Project Management (PM). Experience has demonstrated that the utilization ofQA and PM
approaches has significantly reduced the risk of project failure, increased project quality and ontime
completion. GITA is now working with agencies to encourage the use ofQA and PM
2. A statement, to the extent practicable, in quantitative and qualitative terms, of the
objectives of such agency and its anticipated accomplishments.
IT Project Review and Oversight
GITA developed a Project Investment Justification (PH) process to review projects prior to their
implementation. The PH process reviews the agency's business case for purchasing new
Page 1
GITA Response to JLAC
October 17,2005
technology to ensure there is a business need for the project and that their cost projections are
realistic. In addition, the PU process reviews the proposed technology to make sure it is consistent
with the State's standards.
Once a project has been approved by GITA or ITAC, when necessary, the technology
implementation is overseen by GITA staff as well. GITA staff reviews progress reports to ensure
that agencies are meeting their milestones. If agencies fall behind schedule or have budget issues,
GITA works with the agencies to get the project back on track.
The following table shows the total number of inactive projects, cancelled projects, and open
projects that are being monitored using GITA's Project Investment and Justification (PU) process.
In addition, the total number ofcompleted projects is shown.
Summary of Projects as of 10/03/05
Inactive/Cancelled Development
Projects Nbr Cost Total Cost
Total Inactive Projects 16 50,750,000 62,838,000
Total Cancelled Projects 56 32,080,000 52,739,000
Open Projects Nbr Cost Total Cost
ITAC Projects 26 258,661,000 301,895,000
GITA Projects 118 34,666,000 41,731,000
Total Open Projects 144 293,327,000 343,626,000
Completed Projects Nbr Cost Total Cost
ITAC Projects 77 207,347,000 277,026,000
GITA Projects 604 78,889,000 89,034,000
Total Completed Projects 681 286,236,000 366,059,000
Total Pro.iects 897 662,393,000 825,263,000
Page 2
GITA Response to JLAC
October 17,2005
The following table shows the total number of projects that have been submitted to GITA since its
Total Projects to Date as of 10/03/05
Pro.iects Submitted Nbr Cost Total Cost
Total Projects Submitted 977 1,073,202,000 1,569,266,000
Projects Not Approved Nbr Cost Total Cost
Disapproved 10 50,151,000 99,644,000
Not Funded 9 2,605,000 3,411,000
Returned 29 36,627,000 58,283,000
Withdrawn 34 49,018,000 69,727,000
Projects Approved Nbr Cost Total Cost
Standard Approvals 699 337,072,000 473,772,000
Conditional Approvals 189 546,786,000 796,034,000
Provisional Approvals 7 24,698,000 26,764,000
**Approvals Before GITA 2 26,141,000 41,527,000
Total Pro.iects Approved 897 934,698,000 1,338,097,000
** Projects a roved before GITA was established as an agency.
Strategic IT Planning
GITA develops a Statewide Strategic IT Plan annually. This plan sets the direction for executive
agencies to follow as they develop IT systems and plan for the future. The IT plan emphasizes the
strategic goals of interoperability, security, and silo reduction.
The strategic planning process has been reengineered for the current cycle. This new process
enables GITA to measure agency compliance in the areas of Enterprise Architecture, Quality
Assurance, and IT Security. GITA uses the plan and its TISA application to identify gaps in the
State's ability to meet security needs, determine compliance with Quality Assurance methodologies
in program and project management, and determine conformance with Enterprise Architecture
which, in turn, encourages interoperability between agencies.
Enterprise Architecture-The State's Technology Building Code
GITA has used Enterprise Architecture as the framework for developing the State's IT policies and
standards. GITA has developed 45 policies and standards and maintains them on a biannual basis.
These policies and standards serve as the technology building code for the State.
Page 3
. GITA Response to JLAC
October 17, 2005
Enterprise Architecture focuses on five key areas:
1. Network Architecture defmes the State's communication infrastructure.
2. Security Architecture identifies security technology, policies and standards necessary to
protect the assets of the state.
3. Platfonn Architecture ensures interoperability among IT systems that deliver services within
the State, regardless oftheir manufacturer or vendor.
4. Software Architecture identifies requirements for software items that automate business
processes and enhance productivity.
5. Data/Infonnation Architecture improves the business processes to help ensure that State
services are executed in a timely, efficient, and cost-effective manner.
Agencies are required to follow these policies and standards when they acquire new infonnation
technology infrastructure. Enterprise Architecture will lead to increased interoperability and silo
reduction because the State's IT infrastructure will eventually all be compatible.
IT Planning for Agencies
Agencies use the Planning Application for Reporting IT Strategy (PARTS) to identify Trends,
Issues, Agency Business Goals, IT Goals, IT Objectives, and IT Perfonnance Measures. In
addition, large agencies also complete the Technology Infrastructure and Security Assessment
(TISA) to detennine their compliance with the Statewide IT Standards.
Quality Assurance
GITA is implementing a plan to improve Quality Assurance (QA) methodologies in the State.
GITA is working to raise awareness ofQA by holding stakeholder meetings and summits. At the
first summit, over 100 state employees came to hear from industry leaders about QA
IT Security & Privacy
Infonnation Technology security is of critical importance. As more state functions are conducted
electronically, the risk of a compromise to the State's IT systems grows. GITA and the Arizona
Office ofHomeland Security (AOHS) jointly sponsor an Information Technology Security.
Advisory Committee (ITSAC) to ensure mission alignment with critical infrastructure protection
mandates, such as Statewide IT Security, Business Continuity Planning, and IT disaster
prevention/recovery efforts. ITSAC's role is the development of a statewide blueprint to educate,
identify, and prioritize investment strategies for improving enterprise IT security awareness in
Arizona. In addition, GITA is becoming more active in the area ofinfonnation technology privacy
and is developing standards and guidelines in this area.
Soon GITA will appoint a Chief Infonnation Security Officer and a Chief Privacy Officer for the
State to coordinate a comprehensive state plan for IT security & privacy.
Page 4
GITA Response to JLAC
October 17, 2005
3. An Identification of any other agencies having similar, conflicting or duplicate objectives,
and an explanation of the manner in which the agency avoids duplication or conflict with
other such agencies.
GITA's role as the strategic information technology organization is not shared with any other
agency. GITA alone is given statutory authority to develop IT standards, review agency projects,
and coordinate IT plans. Other agencies may develop internal IT standards, plans, and projects
based on their own business needs, but their actions must conform to the statewide strategy as
outlined by GITA.
Both the GITA Sunset Audit, (05-03) and the Department of Administration, Information Services
Division Audit (05-11) reference the need for increased IT Security. To avoid conflicting
objectives, GITA is meeting with the Arizona Office of Homeland Security, Arizona Department of
Emergency & Military Affairs, and the Arizona Department of Administration to coordinate
security approaches.
4. An assessment of the consequences of eliminating the agency or of consolidating it with
another agency.
If GITA were eliminated, the State would lose a centralized coordination point for information
technology. That means there would be no statewide IT standards which would lead to problems in
interoperability and information sharing. Also, without an agency with the authority to review and
oversee IT projects, the state would experience increased cost and project failure.
If GITA were consolidated into another agency, there would be no independent oversight of agency
management and decision making. GITA's independent status gives the agency and its policies
credibility with other state agencies and the legislature. GITA is often contacted by entities, such as
the JLBC, who want an independent assessment of the technology needs of the State. IfGITA were
folded into another agency, that independent voice would be eliminated.
Page 5
Senate Government and House of Representatives Government Reform
and Government Finance Accountability Committee of Reference for the
Sunset Review of: Prescott Historical Society, Arizona State Personnel
Board, Government Information and Technology Agency, and Arizona
Department of Administration
Minutes of the Meeting
Tuesday, November 1, 2005
9:30 a.m., House Hearing Room 1
Members Present:
Representative Bill Konopnicki, CoChair
Representative Ted Downing
Representative Phil Lopes
Representative John McComish
Representative John Nelson
Members Absent:
Senator Jake Flake
Senator Jim Waring, CoChair
Senator Bill Brotherton
Senator Linda Gray
Senator Harry Mitchell
Steve Moortel, House Assistant Legislative Analyst
Nadine Sapien, Senate Government Analyst
Chairman Konopnicki called the meeting to order at 9:30 A.M. and the
attendance was taken.
Richard Sims, Director, Prescott Historical Society, presented a brief
overview of the Prescott Historical Society, also known as the Sharlot Hall
Museum, its work both in and around Prescott, and some of the museum's
Senator Waring asked if the Prescott Historical Society is charging an admission
fee to the museum. Mr. Sims stated through House Bill 2490 (2004), the
Historical Society is allowed to charge an admission fee to the museum. The fee
is $5 for adults and children 18 and under are free.
Senator Waring asked Mr. Sims if it is true that the Historical Society wants to
raise membership dues. Mr. Sims stated the membership program is run·
through the non-profit society which can charge more market rate dues instead of
the low and outdated numbers in the State statute.
Representative McComishasked if the Historical Society's $4 million.
capital campaign is being run through the non-profit society. Mr. Sims stated the
campaign is being run through the non-profit.
Representative McComish asked how much of the Society's operating budget
comes from the State and the non-profit. Mr. Sims stated the Society is matching
the State funds of over $600,000 with the non-profit activities.
Senator Lopes requested that the Historical Society report back as to what the
impact is on the utilization of the museum as a result of the admission fee. Mr.
Sims stated he would be happy to report that information back to the Committee.
Senator Brotherton asked what is the Historical Society's current budget. Mr.
Sims stated the current budget is $640,000 and has been in place for the last
three years. Mr. Sims stated the budget had been reduced from $800,000 due to
budget cuts and as a result the museum had to cut five State positions.
Senator Brotherton asked if the loss of employees is an ongoing issue for the
museum. Mr. Sims stated the loss of State personnel is an ongoing problem as
a result of prior budget cuts.
Senator Brotherton asked Mr. Sims where he would want the budget to be on an
annual basis. Mr. Sims stated he would like to see the budget fully recovered
back to 18 full time employees.
Senator Gray asked how much money has come in from the $5 admission fee.
Mr. Sims stated that tracking back to last October the museum has budgeted for
a little over $50,000 based on daily attendance. Mr. Sims did not have the
figures for the current quarter but he stated that he would report back to Senator
Gray with those numbers.
Mr. Sims stated all of the money from State allocations goes towards personnel
and risk management costs and everything else needed to run the museum
comes from the non-profit revenue stream.
Representative Lucy Mason stated her appreciation for Mr. Sims' ability to run
the museum with the resources that have been allocated and urged the
commi,ttee to continue with the funding of the Historical Society.
Representative Konopnicki stated the Committee will do what it can to try to
restore the museum's funding but he is not sure how soon, or if ever, funding can
be re-established to agencies that have been cut.
Representative McComish stated the Historical Society has done a great job of
working with the private sector and non-profits. Representative McComish
added that this does bring up the question of how much responsibility the State
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 2
takes for buying certain items, such as mop heads, and how much do non-profits
Senator Waring moved to recommend the continuation of the Prescott Historical
Society for ten years and the motion was seconded by Representative Lopes.
Roll call vote was taken on the recommendation and passed 9-0-1
(Attachment 1).
Senator Brotherton stated he supports the continuation and that he would like to
see more of the non-profit monies that are raised being used for the extras that
cannot be achieved through State funds instead of so much of it going towards
the operational budget of the museum. Senator Brotherton also stated he does
not believe it is fair to cut taxes and not to give money back to State agencies
that have been cut and stretched thin for a long time.
Senator Gray commended Mr. Sims on the job that he is doing.
Representative Konopnicki commended the Prescott Historical Society on the job
that it is doing and stated that while there has been talk of a tax cut, the
Legislature has to be careful in the next few years with how they try to reestablish
State agencies.
Judy Henkel, Executive Director, Arizona State Personnel Board, presented
a brief history and overview of the Arizona State Personnel Board.
Representative Downing asked what the frequency is of whistleblower
complaints and what savings the State may have incurred because of these
complaints. Ms. Henkel stated the Board received approximately seven to ten
whistleblower complaints last fiscal year and each hearing process costs
approximately $1,100..
Representative Downing askedhow many of the whistleblowers' allegations were
upheld. Ms. Henkel responded that in a majority of the cases the employee does
not win because the whistleblower statute is very specific as to what has to be
proven and in a majority of the cases those specifics were not met.
Representative Downing commented whistleblowers play an important role in
government reform and fiscal responsibility and these people need to be
protected in order for them to come forward with information.
Senator Waring asked how many responses the Board had received from the
satisfaction surveys which are mailed to all parties involved in hearings. Ms.
Henkel stated the Board hears about 48 cases or more each year and
approximately half respond to the surveys.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 3
Representative Lopes pointed out that appeals and complaints rose from 62 in
2004 to 101 in 2005 and asked Ms. Henkel if this increase in one year isnormal
and if this statistic concerns her.
Ms. Henkel stated the fluctuation varies and in some years the numbers have
been much lower. Ms. Henkel added settlements have increased to 30% and as
a result even though the Board has received 101 complaints most likely some of
those have settled.
Ms. Henkel stated the only concern she has is if there were an increase in the
number of appeals filed it would increase the Board's budget.
Representative Lopes asked what the difference in cost is between a case that
settles and one that goes through the entire process. Ms. Henkel stated the
average cost for a hearing is $1,100 and the savings for a case that is settled is
approximately half of that.
Representative McComish asked if the Board has a procedure to give feedback
to an agency in order to learn from a complaint that has been filed. Ms. Henkel
stated in the past agencies have contacted the Board and in some cases the
Board has met with agency directors.
Senator Waring moved to recommend a continuation of the Arizona State
Personnel Board for ten years and the motion was seconded by Representative
Roll call vote was taken and the motion passed 9-0-1 (Attachment 2).
Jay Dunkleberger, Senior Performance Auditor, Arizona Office of the
Auditor General, presented a PowerPoint presentation of the Office's
Performance Audit and Sunset Review of the Government Information
Technology Agency (GITA) and Sunset Review of the Information Technology
Authorization Committee (ITAC) (Attachment A).
Senator Waring asked if it is a fair assessment that GITA is not performing the
functions in the security and privacy areas that it should. Mr. Dunkleberger
stated that he would not characterize it that way but GITA does need
improvement in enforcing policies and standards.
Senator Mitchell commented that an Auditor General's report titled "Department
of Administration Information Services Division Telecommunications Program
Office," seems to be asking this office the same thing that the Auditor General is
asking GITA to do. Senator Mitchell asked if there are two different agencies
involved with security.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 4
Mr. Dunkleberger responded GITA's role is to set the statewide standard and the
Department of Administration (DOA) enforces security within its agency and has
a role in the privatized telecommunications network. Mr. Dunkleberger added
there is some overlap and in the recommendation, the Auditor General is looking
for GITA to provide guidance for all agencies, including DOA's administration of
the telecommunications project.
Senator Brotherton asked what mechanisms are available for enforcing policies
that are already in place. Mr. Dunkleberger stated GITA asks agencies to self
report their compliance with security standards each year and GITA will then
meet with those agencies to attempt to improve problems that have been
identified. GITA has also formed a statewide security committee that examines
how to address security issues.
Senator Brotherton asked how GITA enforces policies if agencies do not comply.
Mr. Dunkleberger stated unless there have been changes made to GITA's
statutory requirement since the Auditor General's report, there is little in statute
that allows them to make physical changes to State agencies.
Senator Brotherton commented if there is an enforcement issue, it will be
something that the Committee needs to look at.
Mr. Dunkleberger commented the Auditor General did recommend the formation
of a Chief Security Officer position and for GITA to look at the statutory need of
this position and how it can be established in statute.
Senator Waring asked how many of GITA's projects fall between $25,000 and
$200,000. Mr. Dunkleberger stated in 2004 there were 87 projects and half fell
under $200,000. .
Chris Cummiskey, Director, GITA, and State Chief Information Officer,
provided GITA's response to the Auditor General. Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA
concurs with the overall findings and recommendations of the Auditor General
and is working to track and implement strategies for each one.
Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA's role is to sit as an independent agency to review
the work product of the other 114 agencies, boards, and commissions as it
relates to Information Technology (IT) planning and projects and make sure they
are working within a set of standards and protocols that have been agreed upon
by industry and other state governments across the country as best products.
Mr. Cummiskey stated since its inception, GITA has done a good job of making
sure that projects stay on budget, on time, and within the parameters set forth by
the Legislature.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Govemment Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 5
In regards to Senator Brotherton's previous questions regarding enforcement
mechanisms, Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA's options for enforcing compliance is
limited. The Project Investment Justification process (PIJ), by statute, requires
agencies to report to GITA with a plan and seek approval before they can move
forward with a project and the bUdget offices of both the Office of Strategic
Planning and Budgeting (OSPB) and the Joint Legislative Budget Committee
(JLBC) have been good about not authorizing the release of funds until this step
has been satisfied.
Mr. Cummiskey added GITA has few options when it comes to telling agencies to
change what they are doing. Mr. Cummiskey stated there are standards to which
GITA points to and they also try to work with them to comply but their only option
is to shut down the project funding.
Senator Waring asked Mr. Cummiskey if GITA has a plan to work with DOA
regarding security and privacy issues. Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA has been
working closely with DOA because it does have operational responsibility for the
common relays for communications across the agencies. GITA is also working
with an IT Security Advisory Committee, which consists of the three mainframe
agencies, the Department of Economic Security (DES), the Department of Public
Safety (DPS), and DOA, as well as other entities such as the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (FBI) and the universities to work on what the State needs to do to
protect the network in the best ways possible. .
Mr. Cummiskey added GITA will appoint the Chief Security Officer position that
the Auditor General recommended to serve as a strategic link with DOA, the
Governor's Office for Homeland Security, and the Arizona Department of
Emergency and Military Affairs (DEMA), who all have pieces of the puzzle for
Representative Konopnicki commented that security is the most important issue
and GITA should be given more power to enforce security policies other than
shutting down project funding.
Mr. Commiskey stated GITA has received good compliance from the agencies
but because of the situation that GITA is in statutorily, the best way to get
compliance is to work with agency directors and their teams and educate them
as to why the IT standards are important as they relate to security and why they
need to be invoked. However, with 114 agencies it is taking time to educate
these agencies, especially those without large IT staffs.
Representative Konopnicki asked how important is it to firm up security issues
with the smaller agencies. Mr. Cummiskey stated it is very important not to leave
any agency or board behind. Mr. Cummiskey added GITA, in conjunction with
DOA, is in the process of shutting down access points to the internet.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 6
Representative Nelson commented that information in a response from GITA to
JLAC in October 2005 shows that a great deal of money was expended for a
number of projects that were not approved. Representative Nelson asked how
GITA got to a point where money is being spent on projects that do not move
Mr. Cummiskey stated that he could not answer what happened prior to January
2003 but since then he does not know of any projects that fall into this category.
Mr. Cummiskey added that he will have his staff research this issue in order to
find a resolution so this will not happen again in the future.
Senator Brotherton asked Mr. Cummiskey if he believed there is a need for
additional enforcement tools or if the current mechanisms are adequate if used
effectively. Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA is cautious with the Auditor General's
recommendation of auditing an agency and going beyond simply requiring an
agency to report on their progress as it relates to the standards. Mr. Cummiskey
added GITA can go in and find out why an agency is not complying with the IT
standards from a strategic standpoint as it relates to the standards, but they feel
they do not have the expertise in-house to take over an agency's operation if
they do not comply.
Senator Brotherton commented that information regarding agencies that do not
comply with security standards should be more readily available to the
Senator Brotherton asked Mr. Cummiskey to comment on the difference of
opinion between the Auditor General and GITA in regards to consulting on the
actual creation and implementation of projects.
Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA has adopted an Interagency Service Agreement
with Enterprise Procurement Services to set out rules and responsibilities and sit
in on committees that are established to look at large scale IT projects as
technical advisors. Mr. Cummiskey added the point that GITA did not want to
cross over was becoming voting members of those committees because they felt
that it would compromise their ability to be independent and communicative with
both the Governor's office as well as the Legislature.
Representative Downing asked if the Legislature receives a scorecard illustrating
agencies' compliance with security standards and if such a scorecard would be
useful. Mr. Cummiskey stated currently members of the Legislature are not
being provided that information, however, it would be a useful tool and GITA is in
the position to provide the members that information.
Representative Downing commented that having that information available to the.
members of the Legislature would be useful.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 7
Representative Downing asked if GITA provides technical support to the
Secretary of State. Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA has not provided technical
assistance to the Secretary of State. Mr. Cummiskey added typically with the
Secretary of State and other constitutionally elected officers, GITA will not
provide assistance unless requested by a particular office.
Representative Downing asked if GITA should be assigned a statutory role to
protect the security of the State's voting systems. Mr. Cummiskey stated there is
value in having an agency that tracks and manages best practices involved in
large scale technological acquisitions with the State.
Representative Downing recommended that the Legislature consider GITA
having an active technical advisory role with the State's voting systems.
Senator Brotherton asked if there is a potential security risk with those offices
that GITA does not provide technical support to. Mr. Cummiskey stated GITA
does have a partnership with most of the State entities in State government. Mr.
Cummiskey added there are some entities that decided they have enough inhouse
IT council and they do not need additional information from GITA.
However, if these entities do connect to the State network they must comply with
GITA standards and DOA has been vigilant about this.
Representative Konopnicki commented that he agreed with Senator Brotherton
and it is important to make sure that all entities must comply with GITA standards
if they connect to the State network.
Senator Waring moved to recommend a continuation of the Government
Information Technology Agency for ten years and the motion was seconded
Roll call vote was taken and the motion passed 6-0-4 (Attachment 3).
Dale Chapman, Performance Audit Manager, Arizona Office of the Auditor
General, presented a PowerPoint presentation of the Office's Performance Audit
and Sunset Review of the Arizona Department of Administration (Attachment B).
Representative Lopes asked if the audit was able to determine if DOA was able
to achieve its goals of limiting growth of health care costs and increase provider
choice through the implementation of self-funded health benefits: Mr. Chapman
stated it was too early to determine if the program has achieved any savings or
reduction of costs. Mr. Chapman added the program has increased choice for
Representative Lopes asked if there are any mechanisms in place to assure the
consistency of workers' compensation claims awarded. Mr. Chapman ~tated
DOA's processes, policies, and procedures were reviewed to determine if they
did conform with statute and if the policies and procedures were followed. Mr.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Govemment Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 8
Chapman added with a few exceptions it was found by and large that the policies
and procedures are being followed.
Representative Lopes asked if the issue of timeliness was looked at in the review
of DOA's plans for the oversight of procurement in the State. Mr. Chapman
stated at the time of th~ audit DOA was implementing this program and the
Department might be better able to answer that question.
Bill Bell, Director, Arizona Department of Administration, provided the
Department's response to the Auditor General's recommendations. Mr. Bell
stated the Auditor General's report provides an excellent diagram for how to
begin to approach some of the problems that were identified and DOA plans to
follow many of the recommendations.
Kathy Peckardt, Director of Human Resources, Arizona Department of
Administration, provided the response to the Auditor General's
recommendations for Human Resources Information System (HRIS)
(Attachment B) which were to develop a plan for the completion for HRIS and
enhance user participation.
Ms. Peckardt stated DOA has met with the large State agencies and developed a
systematic methodology to develop a process to find what is important to the
agencies as phase two of HRIS begins. This information will be used in
dev~loping a five year plan that will be completed approximately by January.
Ms. Peckardt added DOA is also working on a data warehouse that will contain
employee information such as turnover.
Senator Brotherton asked what the turnover rate is for DOA and if there is a
target percentage for where they would like the turnover rate to be. Ms. Peckardt
stated DOA's turnover rate is approximately on average with the State's overall
turnover rate of 17.6% and would like to be more in line with rates of other states
and local cities which is between 11%and 12%.
Senator Brotherton asked what issues need to be addressed in order to reduce
the turnover rate. Ms. Peckardt stated if the issue of pay is addressed it will
reduce the turnover rate significantly.
Representative Konopnicki asked where DOA is in the development of the
comprehensive plan for HRIS. Ms. Peckardt stated DOA is currently in the
process of obtaining agency involvement and asking for their input of priorities for
the next five years. This information is expected to be received by the end of
November and will then be prioritized in December. It is anticipated that a
completed plan will be finalized in January.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 9
Tim Boncoskey, Assistant Director of Enterprise Procurement Services,
Arizona Department of Administration, responded to the Auditor General's five
recommendations for improving oversight of procurement in the State
(Attachment B). Mr. Boncoskey stated all five recommendations are in the
process of being completed.
Senator Gray asked what areas of House Bill 2582 (2001), which allowed
reverse bidding, have been implemented. Mr. Boncoskey stated DOA is
currently working with vendors but there has not been any reverse bidding. Mr.
Boncoskey added DOA is looking to have reverse bidding up and operating by
the end of this fiscal year.
Ray Di Ciccio, State Risk Manager, Arizona Department of Administration,
responded to the Auditor General's two recommendations for workers'
compensation (Attachment B).
Mr. DiCiccio stated the first recommendation was to improve employee
communication by providing more information through the phone system and
website. Mr. DiCiccio stated both the phone system and. website have been
updated. Mr. DiCiccio added other items have been implemented to help with
communication. These include an agency liaison that goes to the agencies and
provides employees with information, semi-annual meetings with all of the
agencies in order to discuss workers' compensation benefits, and a
representative who is sent to employee orientations to explain reporting
requirements and benefits.
In response to the second issue of the backlog of workers' compensation claims,
DOA has already put a special emphasis on that and there is no longer a
Representative Konopnicki commented that in the audit it is mentioned that the
employee makes the workers' compensation claim but in some cases the DOA
was already acting on cases before they were reported and in others DOA waited
until after the claim was reported. Representative Konopnicki stated this is an
issue that needs to be looked at because all employees should be treated the
same way.
Mr. DiCiccio stated it is important to act on the claims in a timely manner but he
is not aware of any differences in how DOA is processing the claims because
there is a manual that states the procedures to follow on each claim.
Kathy Peckardt, in response to health benefit complaints, stated DOA does have
a help desk for the sole purpose of addressing complaints from employees
regarding their health benefits.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 10
Representative Downing commented a help desk is useful for an employee that
has the capacity to complain but some employees are incapacitated and cannot
call a help desk.
Mr. Bell stated DOA will be reviewing its procedures and auditing its vendors and
if there is a structural problem, it will be fixed.
Representative Konopnicki commented that there was an immediate increase of
14% in the insurance premium, an upcoming increase of 17%, and consultant
fees were $6 or $7 million and he wanted to know when this increase in spending
will stop. Mr. Bell stated it is DOA's objective to reduce costs and make this a
cost effective project while providing the kind of service that is expected to
Michael Totherow, Assistant Director of the Information Services Division
(150) Chief Information Officer, Arizona Department of Administration,
provided DOA's response to the Auditor General's recommendations for ISD and
the Telecommunications Program Office (Attachment B).
Mr. Totherow stated in regards to the Auditor General's findings, ISD embraces
as many best practices as possible to provide security for the systems housed
within DOA's data center and the services provided for other agencies. Mr.
Totherow added ISD is a cost recovery operation not directly funded for security
services and when money is limited, many agencies will focus on serving the
constituency and security is often put to the side.
In regards to the recommendation of a state-wide security officer, Mr. Totherow
stated there is an overlap with this recommendation and the recommendation for
a chief security officer for GITA and DOA has been working with GITA to define
what the best scenario would look like.
In regards to the recommendation for the need for the Telecommunications
Office to oversee the inventory process, Mr. Totherow stated through next March
agencies will continue to transition on to AZNET. During this time agencies will
be taking what they are providing for their own telecommunications and data
wide area network (WAN) an d then turning it over to the program control of
Accenture to run in an outsource fashion. This turn over of control is where
agencies are looking at what their inventory is, signing off on what is in scope
and out of scope, and concur that requirements are met.
Representative McComish asked what can be done when agencies do not want
to pay for independent security assessments of their information systems at least
once every three years as recommended by national standards. Mr. Totherow
stated GITA adopts many of these national standards into their standards and
policies that have been enforced upon agencies and the costs have become part
of their budgetary process.
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 11
Mr. Bell stated there is a gap in security and a plan needs to be developed that
encompass all of the agencies in regards to this gap and also develop a
comprehensive program that can be administered consistently to help agencies
with security issues.
Representative Konopnicki agreed with Mr. Bell and stated the State cannot
afford to treat security like it has in the past.
Senator Brotherton asked if DOA can prevent an agency from connecting to the
State network if they do not have the proper security standards. Mr. Totherow
stated DOA does not have the authority to enforce security in other agencies,
constitutional offices, the Legislature, or the courts and this is the gap that DOA
would be working with GITA to address from a state wide perspective.
Senator Brotherton asked how talking to GITA will give DOA the authority to
enforce security. Mr. Bell stated there are gaps and confusion as to DOA's
responsibilities in regards to security and it is important for DOA to sit down with
GITA and other agencies to find an answer to this problem.
Representative Konopnicki commented that the issue of security enforcement
and responsibility needs to be solved as soon as possible and in order for that to
happen GITA needs to playa large role and DOA's responsibilities need to be
Mr. Bell stated whether it is GITA. DOA, or another agency that is responsible for
security, it is important to find a solution and provide the security that everyone is
Representative Konopnicki stated the responsibility for security needs to go to a
cabinet level agency where security polices can be set and enforced.
Senator Brotherton commented if the Legislature needs to do something, it
needs to be done this legislative session.
Representative Konopnicki stated this is a non-political issue and an issue that is
paramount to the security of Arizona. Representative Konopnicki added that
DOA should take the lead and come back to the Committee with
Mr. Bell stated DOA takes the Auditor General's report seriously and will be
working diligently to implement their recommendations.
Senator Waring moved to recommend the continuation of the Arizona
Department of Administration for ten years and was seconded by Representative
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 12
Roll call vote was taken and the motion passed 7-0-3 (Attachment 4).
Representative Konopnicki commented that the security issue jumped off the
page in everything that was looked at and the Committee would not be doing its
due diligence if they did not follow up on that issue and make something happen.
There being no further business, Representative Konopnicki adjourned the
meeting at 12:35 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Committee Secretary
(Tapes and attachments on file in the Secretary of the Senate's Office/Resource Center, Room
Senate Government and House of Representatives
Government Reform and Government Finance Accountability
Committee of Reference
November 1, 2005
Page 13
Recommendation: Continuation of the Prescott Historical Society for ten
Rep. Downing x
Rep. Lopes x
Rep. McComish x
Rep. Nelson x
Senator Brotherton x
Senator Flake x
Senator Gray x
Senator Mitchell x
Senator Waring, CoChair x
Rep. Konopnicki, CoChair x
Committee Secretary _%~~~.\=.:....:< :=:::.::f.J.f'_.,...-- _
November, 2002
Date November 1! 2005
Recommendation: Continuation of the Arizona State Personnel Board for ten
Rep. Downing x
Rep. Lopes x
Rep. McComish x
Rep. Nelson x
Senator Brotherton x
Senator Flake x
Senator Gray x
Senator Mitchell x
Senator Waring, CoChair x
Rep. Konopnicki, CoChair x
Committee Secretary
November. 2002
Sh~'~r---" Date November 1! 2005
4t~T 3~_
Recommendation: Continuation of Government Information Technology.
Agency for ten years.
Rep. Downing x
Rep. Lopes x
Rep. McComish x
Rep. Nelson x
Senator Brotherton x
Senator Flake x
Senator Gray x
Senator Mitchell x
Senator Waring, CoChair x
Rep. Konopnicki, CoChair .x
Committee Secretary ---:~~~:..=::::..::...:~'-J':s::;::~;.7~ b·-----
November. 2002
Date November 1! 2005
Recommendation: Continuation of the Arizona Department of Administration
for ten years.
Rep. Downing x
Rep. Lopes x
Rep. McComish x
Rep. Nelson x
Senator Brotherton x
Senator Flake x
Senator Gray x
Senator Mitchell x
Senator Waring, CoChair x
Rep. Konopnicki, CoChair x
Committee Secretary ---tPr,..o~eA4'!::Z-(.--1"<*7~....------
November. 2002
Date November 1! 2005
Click tabs to swap between content that is broken into logical sections.


text:
BMC Racing Team's Philippe Gilbert saw his bid for victory Thursday end inside the final kilometer when the peloton chased the reigning world road champion and two others down on a rainy, cool day at Ronde van België.
Breakaway Not Cooperating
Gilbert attacked on the last climb of the 182.3-kilometer race and only Francesco Gavazzi (Astana Pro Team) and Niki Terpstra (Omega Pharma-Quick Step) could follow. With 11 km of flat and downhill riding to go, the trio led by 11 seconds. Their advantage peaked at 22 seconds with 4 km to go, but the efforts of Lotto Belisol and Team Europcar brought them back inside 800 meters. Gilbert said he was frustrated that not everyone in the escape was working. "I don't understand why he (Terpsta) didn't want to ride," Gilbert said. "Gavazzi and I had a good understanding. I don't understand, because when you are with three in the front and attack, you want to win. I don't want to criticize their tactics, but I don't understand." André Greipel (Lotto Belisol Team) won his second straight stage to keep the overall lead while Greg Van Avermaet (17th) was the BMC Racing Team's top finisher. Assistant Director Yvon Ledanois said he was pleased to see four riders from the BMC Racing Team make the front group when the race split with 30 km to go "We had Manuel Quinziato, Marcus Burghardt, Philippe and Greg in the final and I told Philippe and Greg if there is a chance, they should try something," Ledanois said. "I don't understand why the (escape group) didn't ride with three together. I respect Terpstra's decision. But when you are in the front you want to win. Otherwise you don't attack."
Listen to complete comments from Gilbert and Ledanois on the BMC Racing Team Audio Line.

subset: commoncrawl


text:
UM-Dearborn sets aside $300,000 to help students and potential students affected by economic downturn
March 17, 2009
DEARBORN---The University of Michigan-Dearborn has set aside $300,000 to address the needs of our students whose families may have experienced job losses or other problems as a result of the current economic conditions, according to Chancellor Daniel Little.
We recognize that this is a difficult time in our economy and are offering options to address families' declining financial resources, Little said. We are working to reduce the gap between family resources and the costs of going to college. Providing additional resources at this point might help our students complete their degrees on time, and not drop out because of changes in their financial situation.
The $300,000 special emergency fund will be distributed through the campuss Office of Financial Aid on the basis of need. Campus officials estimate that several hundred current students and students expected to enroll this fall may be eligible for the additional help.
UM-Dearborn is taking numerous additional steps to help needy students and their families, including providing more financial-aid counseling and distributing information about federal, state and institutional aid to students and their families.
In this environment, we are really working to get the word out to students and their families that college is affordable, according to Stanley E. Henderson, vice chancellor for enrollment management and student life at UM-Dearborn.
Institutional financial aid expenditures at UM-Dearborn have grown 111 percent in the past five years, much faster than tuition increases.
Many families are unfamiliar with the resources that are available, and we understand how challenging it is to navigate the system, which is why we are offering more help and more advice, Henderson said. Now more than ever, a college education is the key to prosperity, and we want to help our students and their parents achieve their goals.
CONTACT: Terry Gallagher
The Office of University Relations
Room 1040, Administration Building
University of Michigan-Dearborn


text:
Prologue: I've set up an account at:
I would appreciate any feed back, positive or otherwise. My personal site was becoming very large and hard to maintain. This also gives the ability of viewing my photos at your own pace or if you prefer using a full screen slideshow by clicking the slideshow option in the upper right hand corner of the page.
Emma along the Welch Dickey Loop Trail
Dickey Mountain 2734' and Welch Mountain 2605'
(The Welch Dickey Loop Trail)
4.4 Miles 1800' Elevation gain
Kevin, Judy and Emma
My mom's been having a tough year so we've been keeping our trips down to two days and staying a little closer to home. It still leaves a lot of room to explore and enjoy. One of our old favorites is the Welch/Dickey Loop near Waterville Valley. We headed north on Monday and watched the throngs heading south as we drove along Rte. 93. Things eased up as we got onto Rte. 49 and made our way towards Waterville. We set up camp at Waterville Valley CG and had the place to ourselves. I think even the host stayed somewhere else that night. After we got everything settled we headed out to make the traverse over these two small but wonderful hills. Each time we go we try to go the opposite way as the time before. This time we went clockwise, up the ledges to Dickey Mountain then down the col and up to Welch. There are plenty of ledges to hike along on both mountains with the ones on Welch probably being the steeper. When we arrived in the parking lot there were plenty of cars, but as we ascended to Dickey Mountain we passed enough people to fill almost all of them so all concern of crowded trails and summits soon passed. After we came out onto the ledges we only saw a handful of people the rest of the hike so it was quite quiet considering the time of year and it being a holiday. Although some of the color had washed off the trees by now there was still excellent foliage viewing to be had around us on the hike up and below us when we reached the ledges.
Foliage below us
An approaching cold front made for some interesting skies to our west and added to the all around excellence of this hike. Temps were warm enough for shorts and tank-tops while you were moving, but we had to pull on the polar-tec when we stopped to eat and enjoy the views. It was hard to pull ourselves away and return to the valley though the sun was sinking and the temps were dropping. On the way back to the campground we picked up some subs and ate some supper as we watched the full moon rise and disappear into the cloud bank which had now taken over the sky. As evening approached the fog rolled in and quickened the darkness. We climbed in the tent and listened as the Mad River rolled by our campsite. Very peaceful and the white noise of the river brought sleep on sooner than usual. There was a sprinkle or two overnight but not enough to bother a couple of old campers. In the morning we awoke to damp fog and the nearby summits were invisible.
Mountain Sandwort Minuartia groenlandica


text:
Please try the following:
If you typed the page address in the address bar, make sure that it is spelled correctly.
Open the www.ne-derbyshire.gov.uk homepage, and then look for links to the information you want.
Click the 'Back' button on the browser bar and try another link.
You can try searching our site for the information you want by entering a topic into the search box on the top of the page.


text:
Main Content
There's no question that the Super Bowl showdown between San Francisco and Baltimore will be a rousing show of on-field skill. Get ready for all the action in New Orleans with this commemorative Dueling Logos 39THIRTY fitted hat from New Era featuring embroidered dueling team logos and Super Bowl XLVII graphics! S/M fits 6 7/8 - 7 1/4. M/L fits 7 1/4 - 7 5/8. L/XL fits 7 5/8 - 8. Sizes are approximate.
- Fitted
- Mesh back panels
- Officially licensed NFL product
- Quality embroidery
- Structured fit
49ers Customers also liked:
Special event items are produced by manufacturers only after the outcome of a game or event. These are advanced sale items and will ship immediately after they are received in our warehouse.
Manufacturer direct items are shipped directly from the manufacturer. These items are not available for international or expedited shipping.
Customized items can be personalized with options such as your name, your favorite number, and/or designs. Some options may be limited by league rules.


text:
Angels Camp
Bear Valley
San Andreas
Valley Springs
Moke Hill/West Point
Business Directory
Weather & Roads
Real Estate
Weekly & Grocery Ads
Life & Style
Law Enforcement
Wine News
Health & Fitness
Home & Garden
Food & Dining
Religion & Faith
Frogtown USA
Elémentaire TV
Free Classifieds
Letters to the Editor
About Us
Coming Soon...
Murphys Community Church
Sierra Grief, Free Support Groups. By Hospice of the Sierra
Overeaters Anonymous
Overeaters Anonymous
Alcoholics Anonymous
Hospice of Amador & Calaveras "drop-in" Grief Support Groups
Debtors Anonymous
Live Music at The Prospector Brewery
Alcoholics Anonymous
"Zucca After Hours is open 5-8 p.m
Live Music and Dancing at CAMPS 209.736.8181
Historic Hotel Leger Haunted Halloween Bash
2014 Hotel Leger Haunted Halloween Bash
Walking Tour of Historic Downtown Murphys
"Zucca After Hours is open 5-8 p.m
Open Mic Night at Sidewinders Restaurant
Live Music at The Prospector Brewery
Live Music and Dancing at CAMPS 209.736.8181
Log In
Remember Me
Forgot Your Password?
Do you love Doke Sushi? Want more of it?
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 05:26 PM
Murphys, CA...We are immediately hiring for a kitchen chef and a sushi chef to get us open 7 days a week! Must have experience in the kitchen, a positive team oriented attitude and enjoy smiling. It is an exhibition kitchen and you must enjoy working in a fast paced environment with the public....
Read More
Feel Good About The Food You Eat.
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 05:15 PM
Angels Camp, CA....Sidewinders and Burger Bar are offering a $1 kids meal! Kids under 12, with the purchase of a regular meal, get a full meal for only $1. Feel good about the food you eat. We use only fresh ingredients, hand crafted and prepared daily with grass fed beef, Diestel turkey and Nathan's hot dogs....
Read More
Traffic Update....Snow Closes Hwy 4 Over Ebbetts Pass
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 05:08 PM
Bear Valley, CA...Caltrans has closed Hwy 4 over Ebbetts Pass because of snow. Hwy 108 and Hwy 88 are open. Hwy 108 would not be recommended as they usually close them almost in tandem. Earlier a big was stuck in the snow near Kirkwood so be careful when heading over the top.
5 Comments
Traffic Update...Big Rig Stuck In Snow Near Kirkwood
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 03:45 PM
Kirkwood, CA....CHP is reporting a big rig stuck in the snow near Kirkwood on Hwy 88. There have also been additional reports of other accidents in the area. Lets be careful out there...
Read More
1 Comments
Traffic Update....Head On Collision On Hwy 4 Near Pool Station
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 03:38 PM
Angels Camp, CA...Crews are working a head on collision on Hwy 4 near Pool Station. Lanes are blocked
0 Comments
It's A Carnival Without The Ride At The Haunted Barrel Of Monkeez
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 02:33 PM
Over $200,000 my family paid for the Road to NO WHERE! ~ Letter To The Editor By Kris Morris
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 02:24 PM
Arnold, CA...We have been trying to subdivide our acreage into a three way split for years. Originally we were not required to do road improvements. Over time things changed. We ended up having to build a 34 foot wide road instead of the traditional 24 foot wide road. Why? Because someone had an agenda to put bike lanes down the dead end road. We were forced to give up a portion of our land and pay for this at our expense to complete the bike connector from Pine drive to Oak Circle at Cedar Center in Arnold....
Read More
48 Comments
Traffic Update....Possible Injuy Accident Near Hwy 4 & Country Club
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 10:26 AM
Arnold, CA....Crews are working an accident near Hwy 4 and Country Club. There is also an accident off of Hwy 26 and Josephine Ln
0 Comments
Fire Update....Crews Making Quick Work Of Fire Near Million Dollar Springs
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 10:24 AM
Arnold, CA...Firefighters are working a vegetation fire near Million Dollar Springs off of 5N07. They have made quick work of the fire and have a hose lay around the fire.
10 Comments
Traffic Update....Possible Injuy Accident Near Milton Rd / Gregory Rd
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/25/2014 08:08 AM
Valley Springs, CA....Crews are working a .Possible Injuy Accident Near Milton Rd / Gregory Rd. There is also a non-injury accident at this time near Lilac Dr / Shady Cir were a vehicle has gone into a pole. Let's be careful out there...
0 Comments
(25% Off Halloween Decor Now At Ace & The Outhouse Collection) Fall Decor Is In Stock At Arnold Ace Home Center & The Outhouse Collection
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/13/2014 10:18 AM
Arnold, CA...The Outhouse Collection's Halloween clearance starts Friday October 24th. Come in early for the best selection of Halloween decor. 25% off on all Halloween except ESC figures. The Outhouse Collection is Calaveras County's premier gift, furniture and home decor shop. Stop by The Outhouse in Arnold at 925 Highway 4, across the highway from Ace Hardware, open 7 days a week.
This Week at the Arnold CHS Thrift Store Adoption Center – MOCHA!
Posted by: John_Hamilton on 10/24/2014 04:58 PM
Arnold, CA...Stop by Calaveras Humane Society's Thrift Store Adoption Center in Arnold, located in Meadowmont Center next to Big Trees Market (Phone 209-795-GIVE), open THURS.–SAT., 10 am–5 pm. Mocha will be there, along with several other kitties who would love to meet you. ATTENTION: Our Angels Camp Adoption Center will be CLOSED this week, so if you'd like to meet some kitties, please make sure you visit the Arnold Adoption Center.
Click photo to view more of our cats
Read More
0 Comments
Three Sheriff's Deputies & Citizen Shot In Sacramento Area
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/24/2014 03:21 PM
Three police deputies shot in Sacramento, CA
9 Comments
Additional Information On Jamestown Shooting & Dog Bite
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/24/2014 09:24 AM
Jamestown, CA...On 10/23/14 about 6:25 P.M. Tuolumne County Sheriff's Office Deputies were dispatched to the 18000 Block of Seco Street in Jamestown, CA on a report of a homeowner who had just "shot a burglar". Upon arrival Deputies met with the male homeowner who advised that he had just returned home and found a burglar in his residence. The homeowner was armed with a handgun due to a previous burglary on his property. The home owner confronted the male intruder who "ran at " the homeowner. The homeowner fired one shot which struck the male intruder in the leg. The intruder then fled the scene...
Read More
22 Comments
Michael Oliveira Resident Deputy Letter
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/24/2014 08:14 AM
Paid For By The Committee To Elect Michael Oliveira
Make The Wise Choice For VUSD Board
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/24/2014 07:40 AM
Go Giants!!!! 49er Motors Big Fall Blowout Sale!! 209.736.4949
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/20/2014 02:08 PM
Angels Camp, CA...49er motors Fall Blowout sale!! We are overstocked and need to make room for new inventory that is arriving daily!! Come on down and take advantage of our HUGE Inventory and drive home a new Car, Truck or SUV today!! We can Finance most anyone with a down payment and an income source. These are just a SMALL sampling of what we have!!
2011 Nissan Altima 3.5 SR. One Owner clean car fax, still under factory warranty!! This like new Nissan has Power windows and locks and drives like a dream. With great gas mileage, this could be a great commuter or a nice family car!! ON SALE $15,949 VIN-1n4bl2ap6bn445314
2004 GMC Sierra 2500 HD 4x4. This lifted beauty is a 2 owner well maintained Truck. This truck looks almost new inside and out!! We have just finished major reconditioning so that you have a trouble free pickup. Leather, Running boards, Nice tires and wheels. You wont find one as nice as this for this price!! ON SALE $9949 VIN- 1GTHK23U64F194561
2005 Chevy Silverado Crew Cab 1500 LS, 4x4, ONE OWNER!! Extra clean, power windows, power door locks, Z71, cd, power seat, tow package, and so much more, Brand new tires with a nice lift!! You dont see one this nice every day! Super Clean! ON SALE $16,949 VIN# 2GCEK13T851248052
2008 Cadillac CTS, V6 DI 3.6L, Auto 6spd, 4 dr, StabiliTrak, abs, Leather, Bose sound, Power seat, Power windows, Power door locks, MP3, Performance package, Premium Wheels, Pure Luxury!! ON SALE $15,949 Vin# 1G6DR57V180190380
2009 Ford Edge SEL AWD, Auto, Clean Carfax, power windows, power door locks, automatic folding rear seats, traction control, panoramic moonroof, premium wheels, 6 disc MP3, sleek design, much more! ON SALE $13,949 VIN# 2FMDK48C89BA64053
2006 GMC Yukon Denali AWD, 3rd row seating, leather, tons of extras, heated seats, dvd entertainment system, moonroof, tinted windows, tow package, premium wheels, roof rack, low miles! Just beautiful!! ONE OWNER, CLEAN CARFAX! ON SALE $16,949 VIN# 1GKEK63U86J129564
Read More
Tom Pratt For VUSD Board
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/20/2014 02:01 PM
Paid For By The Committee To Elect Tom Pratt
Let Hands On Extreme Hang Your Christmas Lights & Detail Your Windows!
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/20/2014 12:22 PM
The Third Annual "Wines On Main" Is October 25th
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/14/2014 05:06 PM
San Andreas, CA...The Calaveras County Chamber of Commerce is excited to announce our 3rd Annual "Wines on Main". Saturday October 25th 3:00pm-6:00pm. Main Street in San Andreas. This year's event is sponsored by Mark Twain Medical CenterWe have several food vendors providing a variety of delicious delicacies as well as local wineries providing samples of their amazing wines....
Read More
Vote To Re Elect Merita Callaway In November
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/06/2014 10:09 AM
Re-Elect Don Stump For CCWD Board
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/05/2014 09:16 AM
Hathaway Pines, CA...I take my position as a Board member for CCWD very seriously. Please visit my web page at www.donstump4ccwd.com for more detailed information or follow me on Facebook at Don Stump for CCWD Dist3. My email address is
. What my Board has accomplished: Hired an outstanding General Manager-Joone Lopez, Built a new Headquarters Building, Created a funding mechanism to upgrade our infrastructure, Started the Re-Licensing strategy of our North Fork Project, Created important relationships with top State officials and Legislators, Helped develop strategies to retain our Water Rights....
Paid Ad by Don Stump Campaign
Read More
Dana Pfeil For Superior Court Judge Department One
Posted by: thepinetree on 09/29/2014 01:45 PM
Tim Healy For Superior Court Judge - Dept. 2
Posted by: thepinetree on 09/14/2014 12:20 PM
Independence Hall Quilters Announce Quilt Faire Honors
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 11:14 PM
Murphys, CA...Independence Hall Quilters held a successful Quilt Faire at Ironstone Vineyards on October 10, 11 and 12. Following is a list of Viewer's Choice winners: Ironstone Choice: Barbara Cleveland's lovely fan quilt made with blocks found on our "free table". Quilts: 1. Edie Miller (Times & Seasons), 2. Candy Gutierrez (Garden Party), Kathy Merrick (Diamonds are Forever) Hand Quilted: 1. Koni Popke (Dresden Plate), 2. Laura McGauren (Sew Pinwheel), 3. Carol Bierderman (Jacobean Applique) Wall Hanging: 1. Sally Sowle-Taylor (My Backyard Friends),2. Sandra Turner (Whooping Crane Romance), 3. Susan Scott (Forest Floor) and Candy Gutierrez (Coneflowers) Wearable Art: 1. Linda Van Berckelaer (Chopkey Wonder purse), 2. Candy Gutierrez (Autumn Colors purse), 3. Joanne Padelford (Brown Vest) Wonky: 1. Eileen Roberson (Movin' Right Along), 2. Nancy Macomber (Kitchen Garden), 3. Chriss Bernasconi (Animals Who Sleep by the Side of the Road) Doll: 1. Barbara Cleveland (Lady Grace), 2. Rosemary O'Malley (Rose) and Carol Bauer, 3. Karen Crabtree (Statue of Liberty Doll) Challenge: 1. Becky Smith (Name That Beatles Tune), 2. Chris Bernasconi (Tessanne Chin), 3. Linda Van Berchelaer (You're a Grand Ol' Flag) Congratulations to all...
Read More
0 Comments
Shooting On Seco St. In Jamestown (Suspect In Custody)
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 08:19 PM
Jamestown, CA....The initial raw bit of information are that a homeowner shot an intruder on Seco Street. The intruder was wounded but escaped. Deputies are searching area and focusing on a shed nearby. Local hospitals have been notified to be on lookout for an injured patient. As with most breaking stories the details probably will change as the Sheriff's Office does their report...(Update as of 8:20pm...Scanner traffic indicates a suspect may be in custody)
8 Comments
Traffic Update....Overturned Vehicle Near Jacksonville Rd / Harney
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 07:53 PM
Jamestown, CA...Crews are working a non-injury overturned vehicle accident on Jacksonville Rd / Harney. Vics is on scene now but there were large vehicle parts and the entire vehicle blocking the roadway. Let's be careful out there....
Read More
0 Comments
Patient at New York's Bellevue Hospital With Possible Ebola Symptoms
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 05:11 PM
New York, NY...Today, EMS HAZ TAC Units transferred to Bellevue Hospital a patient who presented a fever and gastrointestinal symptoms. The patient is a health care worker who returned to the U.S. within the past 21 days from one of the three countries currently facing the outbreak of this virus. The patient was transported by a specially trained HAZ TAC unit wearing Personal Protective Equipment (PPE). After consulting with the hospital and the CDC, DOHMH has decided to conduct a test for the Ebola virus because of this patient's recent travel history, pattern of symptoms, and past work. DOHMH and HHC are also evaluating the patient for other causes of illness, as these symptoms can also be consistent with salmonella, malaria, or the stomach flu...
Read More
21 Comments
Murphys to Markleeville – "The Schedule" – October 24 to November 1
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 04:55 PM
Arnold, CA...Murphys to Markleeville – "The Schedule" – October 24 to November 1 "The Schedule" is published every Thursday by the Ebbetts Pass Visitors Center and includes everything happening from Murphys to Markleeville. For more detailed info visit The Schedule. Please come by and pick one up or contact the Visitors Center at
to have your event included in "The Schedule."
Read More
Decoding Prop 47, "The Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act" ~ By Barbara M. Yook, District Attorney
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 01:56 PM
San Andreas, CA....Prop 47 reduces some felonies to misdemeanors but assures us the public will remain safe because no dangerous offenders will benefit. Once the clever language of Prop 47 is decoded however, the impacts of Prop 47 are opposite its assurance and title. Domestic violence, child abuse, stalking, involuntary manslaughter, and resisting an officer causing death are already considered "non-serious" and "non-violent" crimes under the law. Residential burglary, carjacking, robbery, and arson are considered "serious" or "violent" crimes under the law and these are commonly called "strikes". Under Prop 47, none of the above crimes will be considered a "danger" to public safety....
Read More
3 Comments
CCWD Restores Water Service After Long Night For Repair Crews
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 10:53 AM
Arnold, CA...After a long night of hard work by Calaveras County Water District field staff members, two leaks in an aging 12-inch water main were repaired and water service was restored to the Arnold area. The first of the two leaks was reported just before noon on Wednesday, October 22, and was estimated to affect about 500 people. A break in the main water line was sending a stream of water down a natural drainage in the area. CCWD crews began turning off the water serving most of downtown Arnold and the surrounding subdivisions at around 2 p.m. Wednesday. While crews were repairing the first leak, a second leak in the same pipeline was reported beneath the pavement of Blagen Road about 1 mile from the initial break....
Read More
5 Comments
Calaveras County Fair Wins Tourism Award
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 09:45 AM
Angels Camp, CA...The Calaveras County Fair & Jumping Frog Jubilee was honored at the Calaveras Visitor's Bureau annual dinner earlier this week. The event which was held at the Black Bear Inn in Arnold CA recognizes businesses who have made innovations in tourism. The Fair received and "Innovations in Tourism" award for the 2014 Calaveras County Fair & Jumping Frog Jubilee. In addition the Fair received recognition from the California State Assembly and Senate....
Read More
0 Comments
Mark Twain Medical Center Welcomes A New Pediatrician To Area
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/23/2014 08:17 AM
Shop Local! Sierra Hills, Angels Food & Sierra Hills Natural Food Markets. Weekly Specials Weekly Specials October 22 - 28. Whole Body Savings 20% off all Body Care, Cosmetics, Vitamins, Supplements, Sports Nutrition
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 11:49 PM
Murphys & Angels Camp, CA... Sierra Hills, Angels Food & Sierra Hills Natural Food Markets have been part of the Calaveras community since 1935. High Quality, Great Customer Service and Great Hometown Prices. Weekly Specials October 15 - 21. Sierra Hills Natural Foods Whole Body Savings 20% off all Body Care, Cosmetics, Vitamins, Supplements, Sports Nutrition, October 22 - 29
Click Above For Their Weekly Savings. Do you know you can now text your deli orders to the stores? For Sierra Hills Market the number is 209-753-7115. For Angels Food Market the number is (209)-753-7331. Now that is easy!! Senior Days now Tuesdays and Wednesdays! Save 10% When you buy 4 or more bottles of liquor or wine. Remember we already have the best prices on liquor and the biggest local wine selection.
Read More
Prime Minister Stephen Harper's Statement After Today's Terrorist Attack
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 10:18 PM
Ottawa, Ontario...22 October 2014 Prime Minister Stephen Harper today delivered the following remarks: "My fellow Canadians, for the second time this week there has been a brutal and violent attack on our soil. Today, our thoughts and prayers are with the family and friends of Corporal Nathan Cirillo of the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders of Canada. Corporal Cirillo was killed today – murdered in cold blood – as he provided a ceremonial Honour Guard at Canada's National War Memorial. That sacred place that pays tribute to those who gave their lives so that we can live in a free, democratic and safe society. Likewise, our thoughts and prayers remain also with the family and friends of Warrant Officer Patrice Vincent, who was killed earlier this week by an ISIL-inspired terrorist....
Read More
8 Comments
Toyon Warrior Faire Coming Up November 8th!
Posted by: Kim_Hamilton on 10/22/2014 09:47 PM
With Five-Run Sixth, Royals Knot World Series At One ~ By Dick Kaegel / MLB.com
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 09:45 PM
KANSAS CITY -- Now we've got a Series. The Royals bounced back from their first loss of the postseason with a 7-2 victory over the Giants in Game 2 at Kauffman Stadium on Wednesday night, knotting up the series at a game apiece as the teams head for San Francisco. They did it in Royal style, erupting for five runs in the bottom of the sixth after fireman extraordinaire
Kelvin Herrera
got starter
Yordano Ventura
off the hook in the top half of the inning.
Billy Butler
's RBI single broke a 2-2 tie and ignited the outburst.
Salvador Perez
then pounded a two-run double and
Omar Infante
followed with a two-run homer off Giants reliever
Hunter Strickland
-- the fifth home run he's allowed this October -- in the breakout inning as a crowd of 40,446 roared on a delightful 67-degree evening....
Air time
First pitch
Gm 1
Oct. 21
Gm 2
Oct. 22
Gm 3
Oct. 24
KC vs. SF
Gm 4
Oct. 25
KC vs. SF
Gm 5
Oct. 26
KC vs. SF
Gm 6*
Oct. 28
SF vs. KC
Gm 7*
Oct. 29
SF vs. KC
*if necessary.
Read More
0 Comments
Angels Camp Police Department Receives Grant for Bi-County DUI Enforcement Campaign
Posted by: Kim_Hamilton on 10/22/2014 08:36 PM
Angels Camp, CA...Drunk and drugged driving remains the number one killer on our roadways, with 802 DUI deaths and nearly 24,000 Alcohol Involved Injuries reported statewide. The "Avoid the 2" DUI Task Force will be combating this deadly problem through DUI enforcement efforts in Calaveras and Tuolumne Counties. The Angels Camp Police Department will be administering a recent $119,000 grant from the California Office of Traffic Safety for the cities of Angels Camp and Sonora. ..
Read More
I Am Voting For Michael Oliveira ~ By Lisa Muetterties
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 08:34 PM
Arnold, CA...I have been campaigning for Michael Oliveira for Supervisor. I would like to address the recent paid advertisement Supervisor Merita Callaway's Campaign written by Mike Borean. It is very sad that Mike Borean has chosen to make false and inaccurate comments about Michael Oliveira. Mike Borean and Merita's campaign has taken to trying to discredit Michael Oliveira and it saddens me. I do know Michael Oliveira will be posting factual information and documentation to correct the many inaccurate statements made by Mike Borean. Michael Oliveira bought his home in Arnold in 2002. He went to work in the Sheriff Department in 2007 and also served as Bailiff. He was appointed to the Resident Deputy position in 2011. I attended the meeting held at the Moose Lodge in Arnold by Sheriff Kuntz where he introduced Michael and explained he would be our Resident Deputy. This meeting was also attended by Merita Callaway....
Read More
68 Comments
Larry White Featured at Hovey in November
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 05:54 PM
Murphys, Oct. 22, 2014 – The highly acclaimed and award-winning photography of Larry White will be featured the month of November at Hovey Winery Tasting Room, 350 A Main St., Murphys. An artist's reception will be held in his honor from 4:30 to 6 p.m. Sunday, Nov. 9. Complimentary appetizers will be served and wine will be available by the glass for $5....
Read More
You're Invited! To The Chamber of Commerce October Mixer
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 05:30 PM
Angels Camp, CA...You're Invited! Please attend the October Mixer Thursday October 23, 2014 5:30pm-7:00pm @ Angels Camp Calaveras Humane Society Thrift Store. The spacious Angels Camp CHS Thrift Store is now open for business. The store is located in Angels Towne Center (240 S. Main St. Hwy 49) in Angels Camp. Come enjoy tasty appetizers, local wines & great company! This is a fabulous way to get to know your business community through networking and supporting each other....
Read More
Do Your Part To To Fight Breast Cancer Schedule Your Mammogram Today
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 05:16 PM
Ottawa Police Chief comments on Ottawa Shooting
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 01:12 PM
Ottawa, Canada....Below is a statement from the Ottawa Police Chief on the shootings in Canada this morning...
4 Comments
Dear Voters of Calaveras County District Three ~ By Mike Borean
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 12:53 PM
Hathaway Pines, CA...Why I have chosen to support Merita Callaway for Calaveras County District 3 Supervisor and why I strongly oppose the candidacy of Michael Oliveira. First, the positives. I have known Merita Callaway for many years and have dealt with her on several County issues. I have always found Merita to be honorable and honest. Merita expends an incredible amount of time and energy with her duties as a County Supervisor. She is constantly out in the community and attends several meetings and events every week. In the primary election campaign, Merita was gracious to me as a competing candidate. I am especially grateful that she ran an honorable campaign. I have publicly endorsed Merita and she has my full support....
Paid for by the committee to re-elect Merita Callaway
Read More
Water Leak Repair Will Interrupt Service To CCWD Customers In Downtown Arnold
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 12:41 PM
Arnold, CA....A main 12-inch water line began leaking in the area of Cedar Center in downtown Arnold just before noon on Wednesday, October 22. Calaveras County Water District field staff members quickly analyzed the severity of the leak and determined the main line would need to be shut down in order to make repairs. The shutdown will take place at around 2 p.m. today, October 22. The repair could take up to eight hours to complete, however field crews are working hard to complete the job quickly and restore water service. Much of downtown Arnold will be without water service until the repair is complete, including Mill Woods, Lilac Park and Cedar Center. The outage will also affect portions of Pine Drive, Linebaugh Road, Blagen Road and Dunbar Road.
Read More
5 Comments
Glaxo May Have First Ebola Vaccine Ready By Year's End
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 12:23 PM
London UK...With the Ebola crisis in west Africa continuing, GSK is working closely with the World Health Organization (WHO), regulators and other partners to respond to the outbreak, to accelerate development of our investigational Ebola vaccine and to ramp up production as quickly as possible. Development of the vaccine candidate is progressing at an unprecedented rate, with first phase 1 safety trials with the vaccine candidate underway in the USA, UK and Mali, and further trials due to start in the coming weeks....
Read More
0 Comments
Letter to The Editor~by Gene and Shellie Cervantes
Posted by: Kim_Hamilton on 10/22/2014 11:35 AM
Murphys, CA...As local business owners in Murphys and Victim Advocates for Citizens Against Homicide, we endorse Tim Healy for Superior Court Judge in Department 2. Tim is the only candidate for Department 2, who has practiced law in the courtroom within the past 15 years. He is the only candidate for Department 2, who has EVER practiced criminal law in the courtroom. Experience is so important when considering who to vote for Superior Court Judge in this year's election. You want the candidate who ....
Read More
17 Comments
What's Happening in Murphys this Week October 22 through November 1
Posted by: Kim_Hamilton on 10/22/2014 11:15 AM
Murphys, CA...November 1, 2014 - Dia de los Muertos - Come celebrate the Day of the Dead in the Land of the Skulls. Murphys businesses and tasting rooms will be celebrating the Day of the Dead again this year with traditional decorations, treats and celebrations. Join us in celebrating the lives of those who have passed but are with us in heart and spirit on this day. Join the walking tour, view the Folk Art Exhibition, compete in the Catrin/Catrina dress contest, enjoy music and dancers in the Park, have......
Read More
Moore/Bellfour Understory Burn Cancelled
Posted by: Kim_Hamilton on 10/22/2014 11:12 AM
Sonora, CA...Due to fuels moisture levels, Fire managers on the Stanislaus National Forest did not go forward with the Moore/Bellfour Understory Burn on the Calaveras Ranger District; it is still too dry. Crews continue to monitor Forest weather and fuels conditions, the Moore/Bellfour Understory Burn as well as other planned ignitions will move forward when conditions permit....
Read More
Traffic Update....Overnight Accident Near Railroad Flat Rd / Swiss Ranch Rd
Posted by: thepinetree on 10/22/2014 07:50 AM
Rail Road Flat, CA....CHP is working what now appears as an accident that occurred overnight near Railroad Flat Rd / Swiss Ranch Rd. When crews arrived they found the damaged vehicle but the engine was cold to the touch. Please use caution while crews are in the area clearing the incident.
19 Comments
Welcome to ThePineTree.net
If you see anything newsworthy, give us a call or send it along!
Our goal is to report Current, Up-To-Date, Accurate news 24/7! We are also here to promote one of the best places on the planet...Calaveras and Western Alpine Counties. We cover news and events along the Ebbetts Pass Corridor, Angels Camp, Arnold, Bear Valley, Copperopolis, Mountain Ranch, San Andreas, Valley Springs and more. If you see or know of something newsworthy, just drop us a note to
or give us a call on our news line at (209)768.3929 or #TREE FROM YOUR GOLDEN STATE CELLULAR PHONE. We would also love to post your local video and pictures. If you have clips or photos that you think our viewers would like to see... just let us know!
If you are interested in becoming a sponsor for ThePineTree.net give us a jingle or email us at
, we are the most cost
way of advertising in the area. We have been here providing you with News, Video commercials, Banner Ads, Town Sponsors, etc for 5 years and our customers are getting PROVEN results!
Created on 02/22/2006 11:32 PM by thepinetree
Updated on 11/15/2012 04:26 AM by thepinetree
Past 50 Local News
Gold Rush Day & Street Faire 2014
Streaky good: MadBum, Giants cruise in Game 1 ~ By Chris Haft / MLB.com
What People Are Saying About Michael Oliveira
Trunk Or Treat In San Andreas
City of Angels Camp City Council Meeting Reconvenes on Tuesday, October 21st at Bret Harte Theatre (Update As Of 8:35pm...Mark Twain Medical Facility Voted Down Again)
Elect Judge Hugh K. Swift
Grant Barrett For Superior Court Judge
Yosemite National Park Proposed Entrance Fee and Campground Fee Increases
The Amgen Tour of California will make its grand return to Sacramento, the State Capital of California, to kick off the 10th Anniversary Race!
Man Arrested After Threatening to Burn Down House
American Jeffrey Fowle Released From North Korea
Thank You!!!!!!, More Server Horsepower Added & A Programing Note
Existing-Home Sales Rebound in September
Calaveras County Sheriff's Logs For October 13 - 20, 2014
New Melones Fishing Report for October 20th~by Glory Hole Sports
Major Improvements on Interstate 5 at French Camp Road Completed With Help of Proposition 1B
Caltrans Launches Interactive Game to Teach Teen Drivers Safe Driving Skills in Highway Work Zones
Traffic Update....Rollover Accident On Italian Bar & Removing Injured Deer On Twain Harte Grade
Why I Am Voting For Judge Swift ~ By Chris Muetterties
Attorney General Kamala D. Harris Announces Major 500lb. Meth Bust Linked to Mexican Cartel
Fire Update....Fire Reported Near Alameda Dr / El Naranjo St
369 Pounds of Medications Collected in Calaveras County During "Drop The Drugs" Day
Early Sunday Morning Fatal Rollover Ends Life Of Young San Andreas Man
Calaveras Sheriff Volunteers in Gold Rush Day, Angels Camp
Launch of Calaveras Save Campaign
U.S. Forest Service plans prescribed burn on Stanislaus National Forest
CUSD Will Hold Their Regular Board Meeting, Monday October 21st
Mother Lode Bonsai Club Moves Meeting to November 8th
TRAFFIC ADVISORY....State Route Hwy 4 From Ebbetts Pass to Upper Cascade Creek in Alpine County
State Route 4 Paving Project in Calaveras County for Week of October 20th
Traffic Update.....Accident on Hwy 4. Motorcycle Down Near OByrnes Ferry
Vallecito Teachers Association Endorses Three Candidates. Updated With Ali Heermance Interview
Hospice's 2nd Annual "CALAVERAS LIVE!" - A Live Variety Show
Watch a Movie This Week at the Best Theatre in the Mother Lode...Angels Six Theatres!
Barricaded Subject In Valley Springs (Update...Peaceful Outcome)
Bomb Threat In Valley Springs
Traffic Update...Injury Accident Near Kennedy Meadows
President Obama's Weekly Address: What You Need To Know About Ebola
GE Appliances Buy One, Receive One Free At Middleton's In Angels Camp
Fall colors have arrived at The Clothes Mine in Angels Camp!
Shop Local! Sierra Hills, Angels Food & Sierra Hills Natural Food Markets. Weekly Specials October 15 - 21 "We are dedicated to providing the best to our customers. " - Mike Croshaw
Big Fall Coupon Sale Going On Now At Arnold Ace Home Center
Make Plans For The Murphys Diggins Craft Faire 2014
Angels Trading Post Has Everything To Keep You Moving!!!
I Trust Merita Callaway ~ By Doug Shinn
Construction Schedule For Hwy 4 Paving Project In Calaveras County
Beautiful Arnold Home In Arnold Is Awaiting You! ~ Featured Home From Cedar Creek Realty
CAL FIRE Plans Memorial Service for Airtanker Pilot
Traffic Update...Injury Accident Near Lime Kiln Rd / Jacobs Rd
Murphys to Markleeville – "The Schedule" – October 17 to October 25
Featured Business
Mountain Ranch Realty, Inc.
Mountain Ranch
Real Estate
Mountain Ranch
Browse All Businesses
Who Will It Be For Supervisor In District Three?
The District Three Calaveas County Supervisor In 2015 Will Be?
Incumbent Merita Callaway?
Challenger Michael Oliveira
[View Result]
Mark Phillips the GM of
The Bear Valley Lodge
narrates a wonderful video that was created for the Ebbetts Pass Historical Association. The Video runs about 50 minutes and gives a fascinating & entertaining view of the history of the Bear Valley Area.
National News
NY governor admits Ebola policy could be unenforceable - Fox News
Tribe reels from Washington state school shooting - seattlepi.com
Officials say suspect in killings of California deputies was deported twice - Fox News
A Unique College Pedigree Within the Royals' Bullpen - New York Times
UPDATE 1-Ukraine votes in poll likely to strengthen president's hand - Reuters
Hawaii volcano lava prompts evacuation concerns - MiamiHerald.com
Holder: US acknowledges gay marriage in six more states, total now 33 ... - Fox News
Breakdown of the Hannah Graham Case and what's Next for Jesse Matthew - WHSV
HK protesters to hold street vote on next steps - Sin Chew Jit Poh
LSU's game-winning strategy is primitive but proven: Jeff Duncan - The Times-Picayune - NOLA.com
Copyright © The Pine Tree 2005-2013


text:
Search results for 'cognac'
Château de Beaulon - 7 years
A 7 year old CognacLearn More
A Château de Beaulon classic.Excl. Tax: €37.50 Incl. Tax: €45.00
Château de Beaulon - 12 years
Grande FineLearn More
A 12 year old Cognac
Excellence Trophy, Olympiades Vinexpo 2003Excl. Tax: €57.50 Incl. Tax: €69.00
Château de Beaulon - Napoléon
NapoleonLearn More
An extremely good 20 year old cognac. Very good value
In its traditional box.Excl. Tax: €115.83 Incl. Tax: €139.00
Château de Beaulon - Extra Rare
Extra RareLearn More
From the Paradise Cellar of Château de Beaulon.
For cognac connoisseurs. A masterpiece of time.
Certificate of Authenticity.Excl. Tax: €529.17 Incl. Tax: €635.00
Léopold Gourmel - Promenade en Cognac 3 x 20cl
Age of Fruit - Age of Flowers - Age of Spices. For the first time recognize the three natural aromatic stages, memorize them easily and select them according to the different instances.Learn MoreExcl. Tax: €65.83 Incl. Tax: €79.00
Out of stock
Roullet - Amber Gold VS
A rare unblended cognac from grapes grown and converted into wine within a single domain, distilled and matured there and Estate bottled.Learn MoreExcl. Tax: €22.50 Incl. Tax: €27.00
Roullet - VSOP Réserve
A rich bouquet with flavours of chocolate and spice typical of fine mature cognac.Learn More
Minimum age: 10 years old.Excl. Tax: €32.50 Incl. Tax: €39.00
Roullet - XO Gold
An extra old liqueur blend matured in Roullet's '' Paradis '' cellars for a minimum of 35 years. Superb balance and great delicacy.Learn MoreExcl. Tax: €92.50 Incl. Tax: €111.00
Jean Grosperrin - N° 67 Fins Bois
Collection Cognac
Expressive, mushroom and mocha nose. Powerful and oily on the palate, notes of wood, liquorice. Generous and rich finish, slightly peppery. Rather rustic character.Learn More
Rough from cask.Excl. Tax: €190.83 Incl. Tax: €229.00
Jean Grosperrin -1968- Fins Bois
Collection Cognac – Artisan Vintage
"Very clear colour. The nose is very peppery and lemony, with later notes of violet and coffee and then of smoke. It is light and fresh, very slightly rough, and savoury on the palate, with the alcohol still sensible, and a constantly present mineral texture. It is a very fine product resulting from Fins Bois in calcareous soil. A discrete, secret and fine cognac," Le Rouge et le Blanc, 2001.Learn More
Reduced.Excl. Tax: €240.00 Incl. Tax: €288.00


text:
I have a complaint about the care and treatment at a New York State-operated or licensed facility or program for people with mental disabilities. What should I do?
It's always best to start with the program. We suggest you first contact an administrator at the program to discuss concerns. If you are not able to reach a resolution this way, most programs have a well-defined dispute resolution process you can follow. If either of these two methods is not successful, contact the Commission on Quality of Care at 1-800-624-4143, or their website, for assistance.
More Info
Complaints About Care and Treatment for People with Disabilities
A description of services provided by the Commission on Quality of Care for Persons with Disabilities and their families. Case examples. Contact information.
URL: http://cqc.ny.gov/oversight/caretreatment
Phone: (518) 388-1281