text:
|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français
Participation in 12-step groups (12SG) during and after formal treatment has been associated with positive outcome among substance users. However, the effectiveness of 12SG may be limited by high attrition rates and by low participation, areas on which there has been little research. Clinicians play an important role in fostering 12-step participation, and the insights which they develop in their practice can greatly contribute to informing the research process. Yet, little is known about clinicians' attitudes about 12-step groups or about their experiences in referring clients. This study surveyed clients (N = 101) and clinicians (N = 102) in outpatient treatment programs to examine 12-step related attitudes and to identify potential obstacles to participation. Data collection was conducted between May 2001 and January 2002 in New York City. Both client and clinician samples were primarily African-American and Hispanic; 32% of clients reported substance use in the previous month, with crack and marijuana cited most frequently as primary drug problem. On average, clinicians had worked in the treatment field for 8 years. Both staff and clients viewed 12SG as a helpful recovery resource. Major obstacles to participation centered on motivation and readiness for change and on perceived need for help, rather than on aspects of the 12-step program often cited as points of resistance (e.g., religious aspect and emphasis on powerlessness). Clinicians also frequently cited convenience and scheduling issues as possible obstacles to attending 12SG. Clinical implications of these findings are discussed, including the importance of fostering motivation for change, the need to assess clients' beliefs about and experiences with 12SG on a case by case basis, and to find goodness of fit between clients' needs and inclinations on the one hand, and the tools and support available within 12-step groups on the other.
Participation in 12-step groups such as Alcoholics Anonymous, both during and after formal treatment, is associated with better outcomes among substance users. Twelve-step groups (12SG) are a form of mutual-help or mutual aid based on the premise that individuals who share a common behavior which they identify as undesirable can collectively support each other and eliminate that behavior.1 One of the essential aspects of mutual-help groups, in contrast to other, more traditional forms of treatment, is the absence of professional involvement. Alcoholics Anonymous, the first and largest twelve-step organization, was started by a group of individuals dependent on alcohol at a time when little or no assistance was available to such persons. Subsequently, the organization contributed to the establishment of formal substance user treatment in the first part of the 20th century; over time, the medicalization of treatment services placed mutual-help organizations at the periphery of service delivery so that such organizations were sometimes viewed as competing with formal treatment and criticized for its lack of professionalism. In the last two decades, 12-step organizations have become largely integrated with most formal treatment models, thus becoming somewhat homogenized and mainstreamed (see next section; for a detailed discussion of the historical relationship between mutual-help organizations and treatment services addressing substance use, see (1)). While attending 12-step meetings is an important part of participating in these organizations, 12-step members are also encouraged to work the program and to embrace the 12-step ideology (see later discussion).
The effectiveness of 12-step groups may be somewhat limited by a high attrition rate. Moreover, a large minority of substance users never attends 12-step meetings. Little is known about reasons for dropping out or for non-attendance. Treatment professionals can play a critical role in fostering 12-step participation among their clients, yet, we know very little about professionals' attitudes and beliefs about 12-step fellowships. Several aspects of the 12-step program have been identified as potential stumbling blocks for both clinicians and substance users. Little is known about the prevalence of these beliefs or about whether they constitute obstacles to participation. In this study, treatment professionals and clients are surveyed about their attitudes and beliefs concerning 12-step fellowships toward identifying potential obstacles to participation.
According to the prevalent western view of substance use disorders, addiction is a chronic, relapse-prone disorder (2, 3).2 For many substance users, maintaining abstinence require ongoing support. Twelve-step groups constitute such a support: meetings are widely available and free of charge. Participation in 12SG during and after formal treatment has been associated with positive outcomes; while the majority of studies limit their investigation to substance use outcomes (4–6), the few that have assessed the influence of 12SG participation on a broader set of domains, such as psychological adjustment, have also reported positive findings (7, 8). Several researchers have noted that, as the duration and intensity of treatment services are decreasing, one of the most important tasks for clinicians is to foster stable engagement in 12SG so that clients have a support network available once they are no longer engaged in formal clinical services (9). Role of Treatment in Fostering 12-step Participation
Clinicians can contribute to the Institute of Medicine's (10) goal of broadening the base of treatment for substance use-related problems within the community in which they work (11). The importance of collaboration between service providers and 12SG has been acknowledged by several professional organizations. For example, the American Psychiatric Association has noted that "referral [to 12-step groups] is appropriate at all stages in the treatment process, even for patients who may still be substance users" (12). Further, twelve-step groups and 12-step tenets are increasingly being integrated into formal services. According to a national study by Roman and Blum (1998) on a representative sample of 450 private substance user treatment centers, 90% of the facilities based their treatment on 12-step principles and variations of this model, with nearly one half of the remaining 10% incorporating 12-step principles in combination with other approaches, including encouraged attendance at 12-step meetings (13). The prevalence of the latter was demonstrated by results from a survey on 12-step referral practices conducted among substance user treatment program directors in the Department of Veterans Affairs health care system: 79% of patients were referred to Alcoholics Anonymous and 45% to Narcotics Anonymous (14).
Results from two studies conducted by Humphreys and colleagues speak to the important role which treatment and treatment professionals play in facilitating clients' engagement in 12SG. The first study investigated how treatment programs' theoretical orientation influences clients' participation in, and benefits derived from, 12-step groups (15). Findings indicated that clients in 12-step and eclectic treatment programs (combining 12-step and cognitive-behavioral approaches) had higher rates of subsequent 12SG attendance than did clients in the cognitive-behavioral (CB) treatment programs. Moreover, program orientation moderated the effectiveness of 12SG participation: as the degree of programs' "12-stepness" increased, the positive relationship between 12SG participation and outcome (substance use and psychosocial) became stronger. The second study extended the investigation to cost effectiveness and reported that compared to patients treated in CB programs, those treated in 12-step oriented programs had significantly greater involvement in 12-step groups at follow-up, fewer outpatient continuing care visits after discharge and fewer days of inpatient care resulting in 64% higher annual costs in CB programs (16). Psychiatric and "substance abuse" outcomes were comparable across treatments, except that 12-step patients manifested higher rates of abstinence at follow-up. The authors concluded that professional treatment programs that emphasize 12-step approaches increase their patients' reliance on cost-free mutual-help groups and thereby lower subsequent health care costs without compromising outcomes. Further evidence for the important role that treatment professionals play in fostering engagement in 12-step groups comes from an AA membership survey were one-half of respondents reported being introduced to the fellowship by a treatment professional (17). Finally, the importance of treatment professionals' role in fostering clients' 12-step participation is also underlined by a recent study where the authors reported that treatment clients' attendance at 12-step groups was consistent over a 6-month treatment episode, suggesting that the pattern of attendance established early in treatment is critical (18).
In spite of the crucial role clinicians can play in drug users' treatment, there has been very little research on their beliefs and practices (19, 20). In particular, although referrals to 12-step groups are increasing (18), little is known about addiction professionals' beliefs concerning these organizations or about their experience in referring clients. Available findings suggest that addiction professionals are favorable toward 12-step groups (21). For example, results from a recent survey assessing staff members' beliefs about addiction treatment was conducted in Delaware prior to implementing NIDA's Clinical Trials Network; 82% of staff surveyed agreed with the statement "12-step groups should be used more" (82%) and 84% with "spirituality should be emphasized more" (19). Although informative, such findings are limited and additional research is needed. It is important to gain an greater understanding of what treatment professionals think and believe about 12-step organizations as these cognitions may influence referral practices and bear on client outcomes (22–24).
Although the majority of substance users report some lifetime attendance at 12SG (25), few maintain stable affiliation over time. Attrition tends to be high. The few available studies report declines in participation beginning 3 to 6 months after initiation of attendance (26–28). Alcoholics Anonymous has noted that results from successive Triennial Membership Surveys show 'a slow attrition of newcomers during the first year' and acknowledged this phenomenon as 'a challenge to AA' (29–30). In addition to the large number of substance users who may stop attending 12SG, a significant minority never attends at all. For instance, in his 24-month study conducted among cocaine users, Fiorentine (31) reported that 26% of participants never attended 12-step meetings following formal treatment. To date, little is known about obstacles to participation in 12-step groups (32). Elucidating this issue has important clinical implications because empirical evidence suggests that abstinence rates decline significantly following treatment among substance users who never attend or who stop attending 12-step meetings (31). We note that in the western context where substance use and its treatment have become medicalized, 'retention' in services and in other forms of help is viewed as a desirable and positive outcome. However, much social stigma is attached to substance use and by extension, to participation in substance use services. Thus, one should consider that if help-seeking and the desire to resolve substance-use- related problems are viewed as an effort at personal growth, 'retention' in substance user services may be inconsistent with these goals because of the labeling attached to being "in drug treatment" or "in AA (or NA)."
Participation in 12-step meetings is typically voluntary, especially after treatment. Behavior is based on attitudes that rest on personal beliefs (33), and it is reasonable to suggest that substance users' attitudes and beliefs about 12-step groups play a critical role in whether they choose to participate. However, substance users' attitudes about 12-step have received scant empirical attention. Tonigan and colleagues recently wrote: "conspicuously absent [from the literature] has been the measurement of the subjective reactions of individuals to AA related practices and beliefs" (28). In particular, the authors pointed to the need to examine substance users' perceived helpfulness of AA to sobriety. In an investigation of predictors of engagement in formal treatment, Fiorentine and colleagues reported findings suggesting that perceived utility or helpfulness of services is critical to participation (34). Three studies have examined the association between perceived helpfulness of 12-step groups and meeting attendance among samples of illicit drug users, alcohol-dependent clients and dually diagnosed persons; they have shown a significant association between positive attitudes towards 12-step's helpfulness and attendance (28, 35, 36). Two large prospective studies have broadened the investigative scope beyond perceived helpfulness to embracement of 12-step ideology or disease model view of addiction (e.g., total abstinence goal, need for lifelong 12-step attendance, importance of relying on external support or "higher power"). Both research teams reported a significant association between beliefs consistent with the 12-step program and greater subsequent levels of 12-step participation (9, 37). These studies greatly contribute to broadening our understanding of predictors of 12-step participation. However, they do not address directly an equally important question: What may constitute obstacles to participation in 12-step groups? Several aspects of the 12-step program have been identified as potential stumbling blocks.
In spite of being the most frequently used resource for substance use-related problems in the US (38–40), 12-step fellowships have been and remain the subject of controversy and several aspects of the recovery program have been identified as potential stumbling blocks for both substance users and clinicians (41, 42). This is due to a multiplicity of factors. The 12-step program's views of addiction and recovery are derived from a blend of tenets from the Oxford Group practicing First Century Christianity, the advice of Dr. Jung to an early AA member, and the observations of Dr. Silkworth; as such, they are neither scientific nor rational (43). The program's emphasis on spirituality, surrender and powerlessness contradicts contemporary dominant western cultural norms of self-reliance and widespread secularism (44) and constitutes stumbling blocks for many (45, 46). Clearly, the social premium placed on self-reliance may be more an idealized principle than an adaptive strategy, particularly in light of overwhelming empirical evidence for the critical role of social support in promoting physical and mental health and in coping with stress (47). Nonetheless, the reliance on external support and particularly, on spiritual support, that is one of the cornerstones of the 12-step program has been identified as a potential cultural point of resistance to these organizations (48, 40). That this and related aspects of 12-step groups play a part in individuals' decision not to participate in 12SG was suggested recently by a small study conducted among 19 (white, highly educated and employed) members of Moderation Management (50). Participants consistently attributed their decision to drop out of AA after attending only a few meetings to an aversion to the spiritual focus of the program and to conflicts with AA's concepts of surrender and powerlessness.3
The spiritual aspect of the 12-step program is perhaps the strongest point of resistance but it is not the only one. Substance users often have questions or express concerns when 12SG are introduced - e.g., their problem is not "that bad," they know of someone who relapsed while involved in 12 step groups, they associate 12SG with "skid-row drunks" (32). Some treatment professionals may also be concerned about the "dangers" and limitations of 12-step groups (51–53). Common concerns about these groups include their lack of professionalism, lacks empirical support for their effectiveness, the risk that members become overly dependent on the group, that members get bad advice from other group members, and that the usefulness of these groups is limited in time (i.e., only needed in early recovery) or in scope (i.e., deals with only one substance while clients have multiple issues – for a review, see (41)).
Overall, many widely held beliefs about the 12-step program – whether or not these beliefs are "accurate" - may constitute obstacles to participation. While much has been written about potentially limiting or controversial aspects of the 12-step program, little research has been conducted to determine what substance users and referring clinicians think about these organizations. In particular, there has been virtually no research to determine whether controversial aspects of the 12-step program constitute obstacles to participation or on what other factors may play a role in substance users' decision to not attend 12-step groups. In this regard, it is important to include frontline clinicians in the research process as "they develop insights that might not occur to researchers" (19).
This study seeks to identify potential obstacles to participation in 12-step groups by surveying substance users and referring clinicians. The research questions addressed in the present study are:
One hundred and one clients and 102 staff members were interviewed at five separate outpatient substance user treatment programs in New York City (all programs contacted agreed to participate). The client sample was selected from the client base of the collaborating agencies using a random number table. All staff members who have clinical contact with clients were recruited to participate in the study. Participation in the study was voluntary based on informed consent. The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the National Development and Research Institutes, Inc. (NDRI) and by the review process of the agencies where participants were recruited. Data were collected using personal interviews that were conducted at the programs and lasted approximately 40 minutes for both clinicians and clients; participants received $20 for their time. Data collection was conducted between May 2001 and January 2002.4 Refusal rate was estimated at less than 5 percent for clients and 12 percent for staff.
The study used a questionnaire consisting of structured items and inventories (adapted from previous studies as noted in each individual section below) and open-ended questions developed from qualitative interviews conducted during the preliminary phase of the study and presented elsewhere (54). Parallel versions of the instrument were developed for clients and clinicians so that the wording of the items was similar for both groups of participants. Both versions of the instrument began with a series of questions about sociodemographic and background information (substance use, treatment and 12-step attendance history for clients; education, training and professional experience for staff members). The instrument was pre-tested for feasibility and length; minor adjustments were made for clarity in the phrasing of several items. The final Client instrument consisted of 290 items, the Clinicians version, of 267 items (Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level score = 7.0 for both).. Following this introductory section, the domains and measures used for this study were:
a) Helpfulness of 12-step groups: "In your experience, how helpful or harmful are 12-step groups?" This item was previously used by Salzer and colleagues (55) in a study assessing mental health professionals' views on mutual-help groups (scale ranges from 0 = very harmful, to 10 = very helpful; 5 = neither harmful nor helpful); b) Importance of 12-step groups: "How important a role do you believe 12SG can play in a comprehensive treatment system?" and "How important a role do you believe 12SG can play in the recovery process?" Rating scale ranged from 0 = not at all important, to 10 = extremely important; c) Role of 12-step groups in the recovery process: "Which of the following best describes the role 12SG should play in the recovery process?" The answer categories, reflecting the three positions identified by Farquharson's (56) in his work with community mental health professionals were: 12SG have minimal usefulness, 12SG are a useful addition to formal treatment, and 12SG are crucial to the recovery process; and d) Level of interest in obtaining further information about 12-step groups: "How interested would you be in obtaining further training or information about 12-step groups?" (Extremely, very much, moderately, a little, not at all).
Three open-ended questions were used to collect information about perceived benefits, limitations and potential dangers of 12-step groups: "What can 12-step groups do for people (what are the benefits)?" "What can 12-step group not do for people (what are the limitations)?" "What are the potential dangers of 12-step groups?" Codes for the open-ended items used in the study were developed on the first 30 completed interviews; based on a subsample of 25 instruments coded by two independent researchers, inter-rater reliability was r = .90.
Information about potential obstacles to 12-step participation was collected using both open ended and structured items. First, clients and clinicians were asked a series of open-ended questions designed to elicit information about why substance users may choose not to attend 12-step groups. Clients who were not currently attending 12-step groups were asked their reason(s) for not attending and all clients, regardless of current attendance status, were asked about obstacles to 12-step attendance using items phrased in general terms (e.g., "What are some of the obstacles to people becoming engaged in 12-step?"). It was felt using this phrasing would elicit information that clients may be reluctant to reveal directly such as personal reasons for non-attendance (e.g., ongoing drug use, ambivalence about quitting) and aspects of 12-step meetings or of the recovery program with which clients may be uncomfortable (e.g., sharing personal information with other members, the concept of a Higher Power). Answers to these items were coded as described in the previous section.
Next, participants completed a scale consisting of items describing potential obstacles to participation. After determining through social science database searches that there was no existing instrument available to assess clients' and staff members' beliefs about 12-step groups, an instrument was developed. The instrument consists of items describing positive and negative aspects of 12-step groups; the current study uses only the negative aspect subscale. A pool of items was generated from reviews the extant literature (summarized above), as well as from pilot interviews with both clients and staff members (author's citation) and from statements previously used by Meissen and colleagues (57) in a study of future clinicians' attitudes and intentions toward mutual-help groups (e.g. "12SGs can be dangerous because the leaders are not professionally trained"). After deleting redundant items, the final list consisted of 12 items presented in the Results section (Chronbach Alpha = .74 for the client sample and .67 for the clinician sample). Respondents were asked: "Please indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with each statement". The response categories were 1 = strongly disagree, 2 = disagree, 3 = agree, 4 = strongly agree. In an effort to maximize the richness of the information collected on potential obstacles to 12-step participation, the open-ended items were asked first to ensure that answers would not be influenced by the content of the structured items.
Samples characteristics are summarized in Table 1. Study participants were mostly members of ethnic minority groups. Among the 26% of respondents describing themselves as Hispanic, 23% were Puerto Ricans, 2% were from the Dominican Republic and one from Costa Rica. Participants ranged in age from 18 to 59 (mean = 36, Std. Dev. = 10). Over one half (53%) did not complete high-school, 27% held a high school diploma or GED, and 20% had some college or vocation training beyond high school. The most frequently cited primary substance abuse problem was crack-cocaine (31%). Mean age of first substance use was 16 years. Eight out of ten (82%) reported using drugs or alcohol in the year preceding the interview, one-third (32%) in the past month. Over one half of participants (59%) reported that this was their first enrollment in treatment services for substance abuse problems. Two-thirds of participants (62%) reported some regular lifetime 12-step attendance (defined as "for one month or longer"); 43% reported current attendance. Alcoholics and Narcotics Anonymous were the fellowships most often mentioned among participants with lifetime attendance.
Participants were mostly female, African American and Hispanic (Table 1). One third held a graduate degree, 40% a bachelors' degree, 21% had some college credits, 6% a high-school diploma. Job titles were: counselor (44%), social worker (20%), case manager (17%), clinical supervisor (13%), and paraprofessional social worker (e.g., case aide – 6%). On average, participants had 5.3 years of experience in their current position (mean; St. dev. = 5.3) and a total of 7.6 years of experience in the treatment field (mean; St. dev. = 6.2). All clinicians reported referring clients to 12SG; on average, they reported referring three-quarters of their clients and estimated that 44 % of clients referred participated in 12 step-groups.
Findings (summarized in Table 2) indicate that both clients and clinicians generally held highly positive views of 12-step groups. Clinicians consistently gave significantly more positive ratings than did clients and expressed higher levels of interest in obtaining further information about 12-step groups.
First, participants were asked about the benefits of 12 step-groups (Table 3). Twenty-three percent of the clients did not know and did not provide an answer. Most frequent answers provided by both clients and clinicians were: the opportunity to help improve yourself and your life, help with sobriety and recovery, and fellowship with recovering peers.
Next, participants were asked what are the limitations of 12-step groups. Fully one half of clients did not know and provided no answer. Substance users' lack of motivation or willingness to change was cited most frequently by clients and was the second most frequent answer among clinicians ("no limitations" was the most frequent answer provided by clinicians).
With respect to potential dangers of 12-step groups, the most frequent answer among both clinicians and clients was "nothing" followed by "it does not address denial" (e.g., not listening to what other members say, not doing the right thing).
We first examined reasons for non-attendance at 12-step groups among clients who had reported no lifetime attendance and among clients who reported past but not current attendance. Among never attenders (N = 38), reasons for non attendance were: do not feel I need it (47%), treatment program is enough (21%), do not like or believe in groups (12%), still using or picked up (6%), unable to attend (e.g., time, health −6%), not required to attend (6%), and did not know about 12-step groups (2%). Among substance users who reported prior but no current attendance (N = 19), reasons for non-attendance were: do not like or believe in groups (22%), still using or picked up (22%), unable to attend (e.g., time, health - 22%), I got the message (22%), and it did not help (12%).
Second, we asked all client participants: "What are some of the reasons why people do not attend 12SG?" The most frequent answer was "People don't want to or are not ready to stop using" (39%), followed by "People can do it on their own" (21%) and negative view or ignorance about 12SG (15%). The other answers were: still using (8%) and being embarrassed or not wanting to be seen at 12-step group (7%). Ten percent were not sure.
Third, we asked both clients and clinicians: "What are some of the obstacles to people/clients becoming engaged in 12-step groups?" Results are presented in Table 4. Denial, lack of readiness to stop and "People, places and things" a 12-step expression referring to people and situations that are associated with or trigger substance use, were the most frequent obstacles cited by clients. Denial was also a frequent answer among clinicians. Over one-third of clinicians' answers centered on practical issues of scheduling and convenience: getting there (no childcare, lack of transportation, inconvenient meeting time or place – 27%), and time constraints/responsibilities (10%).
Turning to the 'negative aspects of 12-step groups' scale, Principal components factor analysis with Varimax rotation produced four interpretable factors accounting for a total of 60% of the variance in the item responses. The four factors, consistent with prior literature identifying possible points of resistance to 12-step groups, were labeled "Negative consequences of participation," "Recovery stage limitation," "Religion and powerlessness" and "Lack of professionally trained leadership." The individual items and factor loadings are presented in Table 5. The items forming the four factors generally had moderate levels on internal reliability as measures by Chronbach Alpha (Negative consequences of participation, alpha = .62, Recovery stage limitation, alpha = .65, Religion and powerlessness, alpha = .63 and Lack of professionally trained leadership alpha =. 57). Independent t-tests conducted to compare substance users' and staff members' four factors scores were all significant (p <. 01). For ease of interpretation, significance tests between the two groups' ratings are presented for the individual items rather than for the factor scores. Data show that generally, clients are significantly more likely than are clinicians to agree with statements on the negative aspects of 12-step groups. This is true for the items concerning the recovery stage limitation of 12-step groups, emphasis on religion and powerlessness and for lack of professionally trained leadership. The only dimension on which clinicians were equally or more likely than clients to express agreement with the statements was that concerning risks of 12-step participation, particularly the risk of becoming retraumatized or triggered.
The first research question was "What are substance users and clinicians' attitudes concerning the helpfulness and usefulness of 12-step groups as a recovery resource?" Treatment clients and clinicians surveyed held positive views of 12-step groups' helpfulness, importance in the recovery process as well as in a comprehensive treatment system. These findings replicate earlier reports summarized in the Introduction (19, 36).
The second research question was: "What do substance users and clinicians perceive to be positive and negative aspects of 12-step groups?" Both groups of participants cited peer support; help with recovery and the opportunity to improve one's life as the major benefits of 12-step groups. The major limitation of 12SG, cited by both groups of participants, can be succinctly expressed by the 12-step saying, 'it works if you work it.' That is, 12-step groups cannot help persons who are not ready or willing to seek help (see later discussion). Indeed, nearly half of the clients who were not attending 12SG said they did not feel they needed it and another twenty percent felt the treatment program was sufficient. While some substance users may be able to recover without the support of 12-step fellowships (58, 59), most are not; 12-step groups are often cited as an important source of support among individuals who have achieved stable recovery (60). Yet in the present study, less than one-half of clients were attending 12SG and clinicians estimated that less than half of the clients they refer to 12SG become affiliated. This underlines the importance of addressing the third research question: "What do substance users and referring clinicians perceive to be obstacles to 12-step participation?"
In answers to the open-ended items, lack of readiness or motivation for change was cited as a major obstacle to 12-step participation by both substance users and by clinicians. Motivation has previously been identified as a critical factor in both engagement in and outcome of formal substance user treatment interventions as well (61). Over one-third of clinicians also cited practical issues of convenience (e.g., lack of transportation or child care) and scheduling as potential barriers to 12SG participation; relatively few clients cited these concerns. In the United States, 12-step meetings are generally thought be widely available to all who wish to attend because the 12-step fellowships hold numerous meetings, especially in large cities such as New York City where this study was conducted. However, it may be that practical matters such as not having access to child care or to transportation constitute obstacles that tend to be overlooked by researchers. [We note recent findings by Mankowski and colleagues (9) reporting a significant association between "geographical density" of 12-step meetings and greater levels of participation]. Present findings on this issue emphasize the importance of including frontline clinicians in the research process as they can contribute valuable insights that may otherwise remain unexplored.
Few study participants mentioned any of the "controversial" aspects of the 12-step program reviewed earlier in their spontaneous answers concerning limitations of 12-step groups or obstacles to participation. When participants were asked to indicate their level of agreement with statements describing these aspects of the 12-step program, findings varied across broad dimensions. Over one-half of both substance users and clinicians agreed that "the religious aspect of 12-step groups is an obstacle for many" and nearly one-half of clients agreed with "the emphasis on powerlessness can be dangerous." Consistent with recommendations of the American Psychiatric Association that referral to 12-step groups is appropriate at all stages in the treatment process (12), few participants from either group endorsed the belief that the usefulness of 12-step groups is limited to a specific stage of recovery. Items concerning the lack of professionally trained leadership received moderate levels of agreement. Of note is the finding that significantly more substance users than clinicians agreed with the statement "12SG should seek professional guidance." This is consistent with the pattern reported earlier (Attitudes section) where substance users consistently expressed less favorable – and here, more negative - views of 12-step groups than did clinicians. The only exception to this pattern emerged in findings concerning potential risks of participation in 12-step groups; in particular, nearly twice as many clinicians as clients expressed agreement with the statement that "clients can get retraumatized or triggered in 12-step groups." This difference between the two groups of participants may be due in part to the fact that clinicians based their answers on years of professional experience with large numbers of clients and were therefore more likely to have observed instances were clients were triggered as a result of attending a 12-step group. Clients' answers, on the other hand, are likely to have been based on their personal experience and/or that of a few members of their social network and thus to be more limited. This difference in perspectives may also partially explain the consistent pattern of findings indicating that clinicians are significantly more positive about 12-step than are clients.
Present results have important clinical implications. First, a sizable proportion of clients had little experiential knowledge of 12-step groups. Nearly four out of ten reported no prior attendance and a large minority was unable to mention benefits or limitations of 12SG. This suggest that there is a strong need for clinicians to inform and educate clients about 12-step groups. In the present sample, fifty percent of substance users expressed relatively little interest in obtaining further information about 12-step groups. It is not possible in this study to determine whether that is because they do not feel the need for such groups (and thus need no information-see below) or because they feel they "know all about it." Because 12-step concepts are ubiquitous in the treatment context and common lore among substance users, it is important that clinicians open the dialogue with clients about prior experience with 12-step groups as well as about what they know and believe about these groups and where these cognitions come from (e.g., personal experience or hear say?). Substance users are often ambivalent about recovery, especially early on, and may be quick to form an opinion about 12-step groups based on limited experience or friends' accounts.5 Clinicians should elucidate such questions, emphasize the importance of keeping an open mind and of attending different types of meetings (e.g., round robin meeting, meetings for beginners, open and closed meetings, as well as the many specialized meetings such as for women, gays and lesbians, veterans etc. as appropriate) as some formats are likely to be a better fit than others. In that respect, we note that although 12-Step group meetings share a general structure, philosophy and format, they also may be sufficiently flexible to reflect the local ecology and the different needs and interests of participating community members (62). Consequently, 12-step groups may be equally utilized and effective because they attend to the needs and interests of the gender and ethnic populations it serves (63). Thus processes of engagement, participation, retention, attrition and effectiveness are likely to be influenced not only by the general tenets and format of the 12-step program (e.g., working the 12-steps, peer support, emphasis on honesty and introspection) but also by the specific 12-step meeting(s) clients attend. This suggests that in addition to familiarizing themselves with the 12-step model, clinicians would be well-advised to be informed about the individual group meetings that are held in the communities (e.g., membership characteristics, group norms).
When discussing 12-step participation, specific clients' concerns and misconceptions should also be identified and addressed on a case-by-case basis. Overall is it paramount that clinicians work in collaboration with clients to find goodness of fit between clients' needs and inclinations on the one hand and the tools and support available within 12-step groups on the other (11, 64). The author acknowledges that such "matching" of individual needs and circumstances to specific types of help, while highly desirable, is difficult to implement in practice and rarely is in an integral part of treatment planning, implementation and/or evaluation. Services that are most often delivered in group sessions do not allow for individualization of treatment orientation or consideration of individual life and/or recovery stage. When feasible, individual sessions between client and clinician should include a discussion of prior participation in and beliefs about 12-step groups so as to maximize the likelihood that clients will consider such organizations as a resource in their change process. Finally, in discussing attendance at 12-step groups, it is important for treatment professionals to look beyond clinical issues (e.g., readiness for change-see below) and to address clients' socio-environmental context on a case-by-case basis as some obstacles to 12-step attendance may be overlooked (e.g., availability of childcare or money for transportation).
The second point of clinical relevance concerns the finding that aspects of the 12-step program previously identified as potential points of resistance, such as the spiritual emphasis, were rarely mentioned spontaneously by either substance users or by clinicians. Instead, lack of motivation to enter recovery and/or reluctance to recognize that recovery requires external support ("I don't need it") appears to be a major barrier to affiliation with 12-step groups. Caldwell (11) has discussed lack of change readiness as a possible obstacle to 12SG participation. The change process involves a fairly long initial stage in which denial about addiction needs to be broken down (43). Individuals who do not believe they have a problem or who believe that that their problem is not severe enough to require help are not likely to seek help. Asked about reasons why people may not attend 12SG, twenty percent of substance users said that "people can do it on their own" and only one-third of clients viewed 12SG as crucial to the recovery process (vs. one-half of clinicians). Denial of a problem or of a problem's severity is a major barrier to seeking and obtaining help. Decrease in denial during treatment is a significant predictor of 12SG attendance afterwards (65). Commenting on high rates of early attrition, AA has suggested that it may be that "some individuals are not convinced of their addiction" (29).
The only requirement for 12-step membership is "the honest desire to stop" substance use (66). Given that desire, the 12-step program of recovery suggests that admitting powerlessness over drugs and alcohol (that is, admitting that one can not recover by will power alone) is the first step toward recovery. Current data suggest that low levels of motivation to change (desire to stop) and the belief that one may not need external help to recover (i.e. not being powerless over a substance or substance use) represent significant reasons why substance users may elect not to participate in 12-step groups. Because findings also indicate that substance users view 12-step groups as a helpful recovery resource, interventions designed to enhance motivation for change (67) and recognition of the need for external support are suggested as means of fostering 12-step participation. Further, a number of factors have been identified as predictors of help-seeking among substance users; while most studies have investigated predictors of help-seeking in formal treatment services, findings may also help focus clinical strategies designed to enhance participation in 12-step groups during and after treatment services. Predictors of help seeking include greater severity of dependence, greater substance-related health and psycho-social problems, use of illicit drugs (vs. alcohol), especially heroin and cocaine, greater network encouragement to seek help and social pressure to cut down, belief that one is unable to quit on one's own facilitated help-seeking and belief in the efficacy of services or other form of help (68–74 It is important to note that 12-step groups may not be suited to all substance users (36) so that non-attendance or disengagement should not necessarily be interpreted as a lack of commitment to the recovery process. A number of addiction recovery mutual-help groups have emerged in an effort to provide support to individuals who find 12-step groups' goals or ideology unsuitable. These groups include Secular Organization for Sobriety (SOS), Rational Recovery, Women for Sobriety's (WFS) and Moderation Management(50, 75). However, because of the limited availability of meetings held by the organizations and the wide availability of 12-step meetings, it is important to gain a greater understanding of why some substance users do not participate. We note that because findings from the current study suggest that the main obstacles to participation in 12-step groups are not 12-step specific but rather, center on clinical issues (e.g., motivation for change), present results may apply to participation in other mutual aid groups as well. Additional research is greatly needed in this area.
This study has several limitations that should be considered in interpreting the results. In addition to the use of relatively small samples of convenience, clients' prior and current rates of 12-step attendance were lower than reported elsewhere (25). The relatively low attendance rates may be explained in part to the high percentage of participants who were receiving addiction services for the first time. In addition to these sample limitations, other study limitations point to directions which future research might take in that area. This study focused on identifying obstacles to participation in 12-step groups. It did not examine the association between clients' stage of recovery, 12-step related attitudes and 12-step attendance, nor did it consider staff's recovery status in relationship to attitudes about 12-step groups. One study examining the role of staff' recovery status on beliefs about addiction reported a positive but non-significant association between being in recovery and endorsing the disease model view of addiction (22). Another important question that this study did not examine is that of the association between staff's attitudes about 12-step groups and referral practices. In spite of these limitations, this early study constitutes an important step toward identifying and addressing obstacles to participation in 12-step groups. It is the authors' hope that findings reported here will contribute to focusing additional research on this important topic. Of particular interest would be cross-cultural comparisons of clinicians and substance users' view of 12-step groups and of other mutual-help recovery organizations, as well as comparisons between urban and rural geographical regions where the availability of services and views on substance use may vary significantly.
1Twelve-step groups such as AA, NA, GA, OA, are traditionally categorized as "self-help" groups, which is misleading. A useful, and more accurate treatment paradigm taxonomy, in a field deluged with many stereotypes and myths is: professional-based treatment; mutual-help/aid and self-help or "natural recovery."
2The author recognizes that terms such as "addiction," "treatment," and "recovery" can be viewed in other cultures and from other perspectives on substance use as labels that may carry stigmatizing connotations. Such terms are used here because they are widely accepted as convention and understood in the field, particularly in the United States and where the English language is used in scientific literature- and should not be interpreted as an endorsement of the negative labels they sometimes convey.
3The two other areas of conflict cited in the study were (a) Feeling out of place among AA members because one's drinking problem that was less severe, and (b) being unable to relate to unemployed, homeless or otherwise "down and out" members. The authors note that Moderation Management members surveyed were predominantly an "elite" of highly educated, employed, Caucasian persons.
4Analyses conducted to detect any differences in the variables under study between data collected before and after Sept. 11, 2001, yielded no significant findings.
5The term "recovery" as used most often in the literature, generally refers broadly to positive outcome among substance users but is rarely defined. While a detailed discussion of the concept of recovery is beyond the scope of this study, we note that 'recovery' is not a finite event but rather, a process that often begins with multiple attempts to change and may ultimately include total abstinence from substance use. More importantly, 'recovery' entails a lifelong complex, dynamic and multidimensional effort toward self-change. Further, the term is also bound in western culture and especially, in the ideology of 12-step programs, as members typically identify as being "in recovery' whereas persons who resolved substance use-related problems through other means such as unassisted (natural) resolution may not readily identify with that term.
The work reported here was supported by National Institutes on Drug Abuse Grant R03 DA13432.
PubMed Central Canada is a service of the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) working in partnership with the National Research Council's national science library in cooperation with the National Center for Biotechnology Information at the U.S. National Library of Medicine(NCBI/NLM). It includes content provided to the PubMed Central International archive by participating publishers.


text:
Share < br />this article:
Chord Overstreet's Best Looks Over the Years
Loraine Pavich
| February 14, 2013 - 2:27 pm
Share < br />this article:
View Full Size
Return to Story
Chord Overstreet
Recommended for you
Shirtless Chord Overstreet Gets in the #ToplessTuesdays Spirit
The Hottest Celebrity Skin Pics of the Week – 1.4.15
Celebrity Twitter Chatter: Selena Gomez is in love with Dubai, Chord Overstreet Lost His Pants and More
Celebrity Twitter Chatter: Khloe Kardashian is Obsessed with Todd Chrisley, What is Harry Styles Polishing and More
Celebrity Twitter Chatter: Life Amazes Katy Perry, What Khloe Kardashian Loves and More
So What Did Selena Gomez Think of Kaley Cuoco and Her Husband's Jelena Costume?
Around The Web
Is Selena Gomez Turning Against Taylor Swift?
WATCH: Céline Dion Slays Impressions of Rihanna, Sia and Cher on…
Cara Delevingne: 'I've Had Sex in Planes a Lot'
Taylor Kinney Cracks a Smile After Split from Lady Gaga — Here's…
Miley Cyrus Flaunts New Diamond Band on Her Wedding Ring Finger During…
Sign Up For The Latest Celebuzz News
Thank you for signing up for our newsletter. You will receive a confirmation shortly.
Sign Up
Top Photos
All »
Jennifer Aniston Tears Up When Asked About Self-Doubt
Mariah Carey's Fiancé Gets a Handful of Boob
Miley Cyrus Flaunts New Diamond Band on Her Wedding Ring Finger During Lunch Date with Liam Hemsworth
Calvin Harris Hangs with Kim Kardashian in Las Vegas, Lip-Syncs Kanye West
Tom Hiddleston Hits Comic-Con without Taylor Swift, Debuts New 'Kong: Skull Island' Trailer
Dakota Johnson Laughing Her Butt Off and 23 More of the Funniest Celebrity Paparazzi Pics of the Week
You'll Love
Kourtney Kardashian's $50 Million Airbnb
Rihanna Is Anti-Pokémon Go
Is Iggy Azalea Dating French Montana?

subset: commoncrawl


text:
MicroFridge Rentals
MicroFridge reservations for the 2016-2017 school year are now being accepted. Please complete the order form below or contact Refrigerator Leasing Company to reserve a MicroFridge.
Full-year rental cost: $200.00 (tax and $10 refundable deposit included)
Refrigerator Leasing Company
179 River St. Oneonta, NY 13820
Please check back later for the Fall 2016 delivery schedule.
Want to win a full-year MicroFridge rental? Follow UAS on any of our social media accounts by July 29th for a chance to win! Visit the contest page for more information!
The MicroFridge is the only microwave allowed on campus. The MicroFridge is a three-in-one refrigerator, microwave and freezer. Students can rent or purchase units from Refrigerator Leasing Company. Total unit dimensions: 19"x21"x44". Students are permitted to have refrigerators that are 6 cubic feet or less and meet electrical requirements stated in the Residence Hall License.
Microwave: .6 cubic feet
700 watt cooking power
Defrost and cook settings
Revolving glass plate
Freezer: 1.0 cubic feet
Zero degree
Refrigerator: 2.9 cubic feet
Interior and door storage shelves
Adjustable thermostat
For information about purchasing a MicroFridge from Refrigerator Leasing Company please click here
- UAS Home
- About
- Dining and Catering
- SUNYCard Services
- Bookstore
- Banking
- Donations & Event Planning
- Additional Campus Services
- What's Open And When?


text:
Brainwavz S5 In Ear Headphones
" Brainwavz are at it again with their new 10mm dynamic driver based IEM named "S5". I must say I was intrigued to try the new sample and where they'd come from Brainwavs B2 I owned many months ago (and loved). S5 takes on an a new elegant design, rather modern appearance and although a little larger than we've seen still fits the bill nicely with its stealth..." --H20Fidelity
Brainwavz M5
"I bought these as a grab bag deal on massdrop. The first time i listened to them I was a little disappointed at the"V" shaped response curve so they sat on the shelf for a few months. The other day I decided to give the another chance. I went through my normal lineup of music and began to notice things I had never heard before. The sounds of piano pedals, deep breathes between notes,..." --thebluebulk
Etymotic Research ER6i Isolator In-Ear Earphones (White)
" These were my first real earphones, and I bought them entirely because they'd been spreading like a plague on a forum I used. Upon first hearing them I was disappointed, but over time they grew on me, and until upgrading to the ER4, they were a firm favourite. Some of my friends couldn't get the fuss, nor understand why anybody would spend a hundred bucks on iPod earphones, but then again..." --BBBS
Brainwavz R3 Revised Edition
" Packaging & Accessories The R3's box packaging comes with clear plastic window that showcase the IEM and its cable. Kudos to Brainwavz for the generous accessories where you will find :-- 1 x Comply T500 tips- 6 Single-flange silicone tips (3 pairs gray & black)- 1 x Single pair of bi-flange & Triple-flange tips- 1 x ¼ inch adapter- 1 x Hard..." --Wokei
Etymotic Research ER6i Isolator In-Ear Earphones (Black)
" I loved these buds to bits, they were the perfect everyday headphone. Small and light and comfortable and barely protruded past the outside of your ears. I like the fact that no one can really see them easily.. Very handy and they were well suited for running. I miss mine, unfortunately they broke when someone stepped on the cord whilst I was walking.. So sad about that still. " --jcotteri
Etymotic Research HF2 Earphones / Headset (iPhone Compatible) - Black
The HF2 is a high-fidelity, hands-free noise-isolating headset and earphones combination - but it's really much, much more than that. The HF2 provides a near-perfect music experience. Made by Etymotic Research, the people who created in-ear earphones, the hf2 delivers Etymotic's world-renowned sound quality in a comfortable, convenient wireless phone headset, so you'll never...
Etymotic Research HF2 Earphones / Headset (iPhone Compatible) - Ruby
" I love these earphones! They are amazing. For the price of $100, you can't be any more happier. Some people may say these earphones don't have too much bass. But personally, I like the amount of bass in these. There is enough that will satisfy you. Trust me. One negative is the nozzle. It is pretty thin. It seems like it might just snap..." --ashinyforehead
Etymotic Research HF5 Portable In-Ear Earphones
" First off let me preface by stating that I bought these on a whim. I had read many things about Etymotic's penchant for accurate reproduction. The initial impressions I got from these were a mixed bag. First off, I love the isolation factor, putting these on in the middle of a crowded communal area was like stepping into a library. I tried the various silicone..." --Exarch
Brainwavz Jive
"At the time of the review, the Brainwavz Jive earphone was was on sale at Amazon's website for $25.00 USD. Here is a link to Their listing of the product: http://www.amazon.com/Brainwavz-Isolating-Earphones-Android-Blue-Android/dp/B013OKX8II/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1441323708&sr=8-1&keywords=brainwavz+jive Introduction I like Brainwavz because they offer a diverse range..." --Hisoundfi
Etymotic Research HF3
" After being disappointed by the Apple In-Ear Headphones with Remote and Mic, I decided to explore a set from a well-regarded company in the audio world. I had to pick something with Apple's in-line iPhone controls that could get good isolation and fit. Those were my complaints with the Apple product. The HF3 seemed to be well designed, and more importantly, they offered a custom-fit..." --Lugie


text:
Sweeping Manteca's streets will soon be done with clean machines.
Finley's Bar and Grill was a last-minute addition to Manteca Restaurant Week.
The frost isn't on the pumpkin yet and the day time highs are still hitting the upper 80s and lower 90s.
RIPON - Sirens screaming down Ripon city streets at 1 p.m. today will be the highlight of the Emergency Vehicle Display Show and Law Enforcement Recruitment Fair set at the community center on Fourth Street.
Manteca's animal shelter is about to go downtown - almost.
Over the years, Elaine Thompson has developed a rapport with vendors come Pumpkin Fair time.
The "Racin' 4 Jason" fundraiser last Sunday was deemed a success by organizers.
It isn't 2000's torrid pace of 1,074 new housing starts but given the economic conditions Manteca is arguably in the middle of a mini-housing boom with 289 new single-family home housing starts in the first eight months of 2010.
Teen farmers at the Manteca Unified School District farm are inviting children to visit their pumpkin patch and corn maze beginning this Friday and Saturday.
Sophia Payan isn't taking the little things in life for granted.
Home grown entertainment is part of the offering Saturday and Sunday during the 26th annual Sunrise Kiwanis Pumpkin Fair in downtown.
Whether Manteca Police pay is out-of-line has emerged as an issue in the Nov. 2 election.
Pumpkin mania gets into full swing Saturday when two South County traditions - the Sunrise Kiwanis Pumpkin Fair in Manteca and the Dell'Osso Farms Pumpkin Maze in Lathrop - get underway at 10 a.m.
Crystal Downs couldn't be happier with the mural that will grace the north side of her State Farm Insurance building at 259 North Main Street.
Dev will make her national television debut on Lopez Tonight.
Page 639 of 891
I took a nutrition class once while I was going to Delta College.
The dry weeds choking the new medians on North Main Street as well as the Lathrop Road replacement interchange on Highway 99 are only temporary.
Manteca Parks & Recreation is ushering in summer on Saturday, June 4, with a three-hour event designed to help parents explore recreation class programs for their ...
Debbie Mitzman has been at Sierra High since its opening in 1994.
Ripon High this year celebrated the academic achievements of the Class of 2016 with a College Reveal Night to acknowledge those that have already been ...
One thing has been apparent ever since the City of Lathrop began the push to retrofit the levees that protect its residents from a massive ...
Page 18 of 18
Contents of this site are © 2016 Manteca Bulletin - All Rights Reserved
Privacy policy and Terms of service | Contact Us


text:
Heads up for DE/MD surfers:
Could see winds shift offshore an hour or two before dark. Hard call - keep an eye on it.
Results 1 to 4 of 4
Thread: Surf for Wed/Thur
'; // next/previous post info pn[411] = "414,412"; pn[0] = ",411"; pn[412] = "411,413"; pn[413] = "412,414"; pn[414] = "413,411"; // cached usernames pu[0] = guestphrase; pu[6] = "Swellinfo"; pu[125] = "tshontikidis"; // -->
Threaded View
Surf for Wed/Thur
Heads up Mid Atlantic! Def. looking good here for a solid swell this week....
VB and OBX look out for that wind shift on Wednesday! Thursday stays fun.
The winds look to move offshore for Jerz Thursday, with leftovers on Friday.
Delmarva - Thursday is looking good, but keep an eye on the winds late Wedneday afternoon!
This looks like a really good setup, with a decent fetch, so the swell is going to stay fairly good size for 24-48hours. Might be worth a sick day


text:
- Miss Florida 2017 stripped of crown days after win - US Weekly
- Lindsay Lohan steps out amid relationship drama - TMZ
- Was Taylor Swift snubbed by the VMAs? - Gossip Cop
- Rachel Platten sings "Fight Song" with lots of stars - Just Jared Jr
- Farrah Abraham sizzles in a revealing bikini - Radar
- New pics from the Clooneys' Italian summer - Lainey Gossip
- Fox News snubs major DNC moment - The Hollywood Reporter
07 February 2008 at 6:19 AM
Vanity Fair - "Hollywood Issue" 2008
Posted in Vanity Fair - "Hollywood Issue" 2008
About this photo set: Vanity Fair marks the 14th year of its gigantic annual Hollywood Issue. On top of all the starlets on the cover, everybody who's anybody is featured in the inside… Read More Here
Photo #: 914551
Posted to Ben Foster, Casey Affleck, Charlize Theron, Emile Hirsch, Eva Marie Saint, Gwyneth Paltrow, James McAvoy, Javier Bardem, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Jodie Foster, Josh Brolin, Julie Christie, Keira Knightley, Marion Cotillard, Naomi Watts, Omar Metwally, Renee Zellweger, Robert Downey Jr, Scarlett Johansson, Seth Rogen, Tang Wei
powered by ZergNet


text:
Kibbeh Nayeh
|Lean ground chuck
|1 Pound (Run 3 Times Through Grinder)
|1⁄2 Cup (8 tbs)
|Fresh basil leaves
|Chopped parsley leaves
|2 Tablespoon
|Red bell pepper
|1⁄2 , frozen
|Toasted walnuts
|1⁄4 Cup (4 tbs)
|White onion
|Red pepper flakes
|1 Teaspoon
|Dried mint
|1⁄2 Teaspoon
|Kibbeh spice
|20 Gram
|1 Tablespoon
|1 1⁄2 Teaspoon
|Black pepper
|1⁄2 Teaspoon
|Olive oil
|1⁄2 Cup (8 tbs)
|Cherry tomatoes
|2 Tablespoon (For Garnish)
1. Make sure the meat and bulgur are cold.
2. In a food processor, add the red bell pepper, onions, basil, parsley, salt, black pepper, red pepper flakes, dried mint, paprika, Kibbeh seasoning and 1/2 of the bulgur, blend until like a dough, then add the rest of the bulgur and blend for another 10 seconds.
3. Next add the meat in 2 parts, blending for 10-15 seconds each time.
4. Lastly add the toasted walnuts and blend for another 15 seconds.
5. Spread the kibbeh in a plate and decorate with the cherry tomatoes, walnut and olives.
6. Drizzle heavily with olive oil.
7. Serve with fresh vegetables and pita bread.
8. Store in refrigerator but best to eat the same day.
Recipe Summary
Rate It
Nutrition Rank
Nutrition Facts
Serving size
Calories 345 Calories from Fat 242
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 27 g42.3%
Saturated Fat 2.4 g12.1%
Trans Fat 0 g
Cholesterol 0 mg
Sodium 374.2 mg15.6%
Total Carbohydrates 13 g4.3%
Dietary Fiber 4.5 g17.8%
Sugars 1.3 g
Protein 14 g27.3%
Vitamin A 33.4% Vitamin C 30.6%
Calcium 3% Iron 9.1%
*Based on a 2000 Calorie diet


text:
Los Angeles-area wildfire prompts hundreds of evacuations
Updated at 9:19 am
Posted 33 minutes ago
A strong ridge of high pressure will continue to scorch the county through the weekend.
Posted 51 minutes ago
Posted at 08:08 am
Posted 51 minutes ago
Updated 13 minutes ago
Here's a quick guide to get you prepared for the event, running July 23-31.
Updated on July 19, 2016
Updated on July 14, 2016
Updated at 10:55 am
Updated at 9:50 amMore »
Updated on July 21, 2016
Updated at 1:22 pmMore »
Updated at 4:50 pm
Updated at 12:51 pmMore »
Updated at 9:19 am
Updated at 8:26 am
Updated at 10:40 pm
Updated 52 minutes ago
Updated at 8:25 am
Updated at 7:59 pm
Updated at 8:27 am
Updated at 9:11 pm
Updated at 5:50 pm
Updated 46 minutes ago
Cassandra Peterson plans to keep playing the character she's been doing for 35 years, but may stop the fan meet-and-greets.
Updated at 3:55 pm
By PETER LARSEN
By JESSICA KWONG
By JOSEPH PIMENTEL
By ERIKA I. RITCHIE
From the Zika virus to a safety recall that rendered hundreds of units of blood useless, several factors have caused Southern California's blood supply to dip to dangerous lows, local health...
Shed the wetsuit. High ocean temperatures are changing the definition of "normal" when it comes to the fish, mammals and birds that live off our shores.
The company that would become a fast-food burger empire ironically got its start 75 years ago selling hot dogs.
If the Baseball Hall of Fame believes in honesty, Mike Piazza's plaque will feature a New York Mets logo on his cap and a chip on his shoulder, placed there by the Dodgers.
Memories from the U.S. Open of Surfing through the years evoke a wave of emotions for Santa Ana surfer Courtney Conlogue.
ST. LOUIS – Brandon McCarthy left Friday's game in the seventh inning due to cramping in his right calf. His cramps eventually passed. But the Dodgers offense tightened up uncomfortably at...
Tall walls were going up in the area under construction for "Star Wars" land at Disneyland during the week leading up to the park's 61st anniversary on July 17.
Updated at 9:59 am
Updated at 8:21 am
Updated on July 18, 2016
Updated on July 13, 2016
Updated on July 5, 2016
Updated 47 minutes ago
Updated on July 21, 2016
Updated at 6:15 pm
Updated 47 minutes ago
Updated 44 minutes ago
Updated at 8:47 am
Updated at 8:09 am
Updated on July 22, 2016
Updated at 10:40 pm
Updated at 8:06 am
Updated at 5:57 pm


text:
Much like John, Pat?<quoted text>No date... no life... nothing to do but post/talk to oneself. 5150 material for sure!
161 - 180 of 243 Comments Last updated Aug 1, 2014
#161 Mar 22, 2013
#162 Mar 23, 2013
Hey John, you still haven't explained why you don't make the slightest effort to become a productive member of society?
And why the taxpayers are stuck paying for your "FREE" ride that you're always complaining about?
What would happen if EVERYBODY decided that they're entitled to be supported by someone else?
#163 Mar 27, 2013
#164 Mar 30, 2013
The Boardwalk is hiring this time of year.
Maybe you could sweep up after all the Tourists leave for the night?
#165 Mar 30, 2013
What would happen if everyone realized they could physically protect themselves as every mammal has the instinct to do, and stopped paying taxes you support PIGS like you with your fascist agenda?
#166 Apr 1, 2013
How's the job search going John?
Or will you keep on leeching from the labors of others?
#167 Apr 5, 2013
ColbyLOSER is whining on Indycrap in the "needle exchange" thread.
No John, your sorry-ass OPINION is not the same thing as A FACT.
Now who do you think the City powers-that-be are more likely to listen to:(A)A local business owner and/or employed, productive contributor, or (B) A whiny,miserable 20 year Welfare parasite/tax burden?
#168 Apr 5, 2013
I gotta say...
People that start these kind of "topics" and contribute to them seem to have as MUCH TIME to WASTE as those they are posting about...
Think about it ....
and be a part of the solution for your community.
Time to put on your big boy and big girl underpants!
#169 Apr 9, 2013
#170 Apr 9, 2013
But they're not out- of-state career welfare mooches who suck up resources that should be going to help the local needy get back on their feet.
#172 Apr 10, 2013
Please note adjusted, accuracy-corrected numbers.
What is it that Topix depends on for new material?
1. Infallible posts by your personal Topix savior John Colby. 5%.
2. Posts mocking John Colby. 85%.
3. All other posts. 10%.
#173 Apr 10, 2013
Like the loony ravings about imaginary Methcookers on the patio that are really undercover SCPD????
#174 Apr 11, 2013
It is plain as day that John Colby is essential to the survival of Topix, elsewise he would not generate such interest. He has many, many adorers. There are many followers of John Colby whose recreational lives would be crushed were he not here to kick around. Alas, even his bowel movements are speculated upon. Such fascination is usually reserved for only the most famous. Hence, John Colby is famous, Lindsay Lohan famous, and he dwells among us, here in Santa Cruz.
#175 Apr 11, 2013
Jay Cee AKA John ColbyLoser/Loon loves re-spamming "copy" and "pastes" to himself. It's both creepy and pathetic that he is the only one out there that will sing his praises. I think he needs more attention from his therapy cats. Not getting much love there. Oh well, there's always FAT PAT!
#176 Apr 11, 2013
ColbyLOON is whining on the Sentinel under his fake name "John Cohen", about the alleged misdeeds of Deputy chief Steve Clark.
Hey John, why don't YOU get off of your FAT, LAZY-20-YEARS-OF WELFARE_LEECHING BUTT and get "A"(1) job, before you can tell ANYONE how they should do theirs???
#177 Apr 12, 2013
From time to time it is fitting to restate calculations with current accumulated data. Interest in John Colby is now at an all-time high. Of course, all one need do is count the number of threads dedicated to the Topix marvel. But, for those who prefer data-driven statistical analysis, the following is offered, in hope that you, too, will join DBS aka Buzz in ceaseless infatuation of their personal Topix savior.
What is it that Topix depends on for new material?
1. Infallible posts by personal Topix savior John Colby. 3%.
2. Posts mocking John Colby. 90%.
3. All other posts. 7%.
United States
#178 Apr 12, 2013
You'd actually make a great urinal cake, John.
#179 Apr 12, 2013
For years... post after post, mocking John Colby! And now... silence!
Topix would not exist, there would be no followers, no "users," were it not for the infallible originality of John Colby.
Prostrate prayers may allure blessed John Colby to return from sabbatical, and share with us his observances. So be ready to beg for his return, and an end to this deafening, mind-numbing silence! Then, and only then, can DBS aka Buzz respond, with alacrity, in the traditional and expected wit and candor.
Then, and only then, will the specter of silence be broken, and we, who appreciate the Topix platform, can bask in a new day of wisdom, dispensed for our enlightenment by...
DBA aka Buzz nemesis JOHN COLBY.
#180 Apr 12, 2013
Many came before John, and many will come after, as his turn is over.
Stick a fork in it, he's done.
Maybe Pat will be his replacement as topix' resident urinal?
#181 Apr 12, 2013
Tell me when this thread is updated:Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker
Add your comments below
Santa Cruz Discussions
|Last By
|What does John Colby contribute to society? (Nov '15)
|3 hr
|The sad part about the "homeless" complaints in...
|4 hr
|ColbySTALKER getting Whacked on the Sentinel BI... (Oct '14)
|6 hr
|Waterboarded for Whack a Mole
|7 hr
|Joe Landon
|Famous quotes by ColbyLOON the evicted Welfare ...
|9 hr
|Joe Landon
|Butch Baker was a Bad Cop (Mar '13)
|What's in John Colby's Trust Fund?
Find what you want!
Search Santa Cruz Forum Now
Copyright © 2016 Topix LLC


text:
Done with This One? Click Here for the Next Awesome Post!
LEGO Ship-in-a-Bottle
Ever wondered how they get those model ships into bottles? Watch this video and learn. Julia Morley's LEGO ship-in-a-bottle build makes our brains hurt. We'd never have the patience to try this.
Recommended Posts
More from Awesomer Media


text:
This Jeep is Str8-Up Crazy
The guy in the following video shot at a Trucks Gone Wild event in Florida did something normal…but took things to a very abnormal level.
Comments | By Derek Shiekhi - June 20, 2016
Your Best Jeep Overlanding Photos
It seems that all of you really enjoy this whole overlanding scene, and even submitted your own tips and photos on how to pack your Jeep for an overlanding trip.
Comments | By Jerry Perez - June 16, 2016
Relax in Style Anywhere with the Jammock
Are you looking for a convenient and portable way to relax when you're out on the trails in your Jeep? Maybe take a work nap? The Jammock is here to help.
Comments | By Chad Kirchner - June 14, 2016
Celebrating Jeep's 75th with an Anniversary Off-Road Jaunt
What do you do when you have two Jeep 75th Anniversary JK Wranglers available? You head to the off-road park, of course! Check out our adventure!
Comments | By Chad Kirchner - June 8, 2016
5 Reasons to Wait for the New Jeep Wrangler
If you want a new Jeep Wrangler, you can always go get one now. But have you considered about waiting for the new version? Here's why you might want to.


text:
Sign In
View Cart
|   |
About Us
View Classes
Directions & Maps
Contact Us
Cart: 0 items
Advanced Search
New classes starting every week. Call (425) 267-0150.
Download Print Catalog
Print event information
E-mail to a friend
Return to Course Catalog
FREE Information Session: SQL Server Certificates
Learn how Everett Community College's Business Intelligence Certificates can advance your career, or help your business get the right information to the right people. Classes focus on Microsoft's BI servers; SQL Server, Integration Server (SSIS), Analysis Server (SSAS), and Reporting Server (SSRS), but subjects are also applicable other vendor's BI software. Get your questions answered, while learning if the Business Intelligence Certificate is right for you.
Some Title
Corporate & Continuing Education Center • 2333 Seaway Boulevard • Everett, WA 98203 • 425-267-0150
© Everett Community College


text:
Choose your preferred language. We speak English (US) and 41 other languages.
Most often used by people in the United States
All languages
Select your hotel from the list. Or search for hotels on the City page of Krummbek
Witt's Gasthof
(0.9 miles)
Bendfeld (1.1 miles)
Stakendorf (1.3 miles)
Höhndorf (1.7 miles)
Gödersdorf (1.7 miles)
Fiefbergen (2.1 miles)
Legbank (2.1 miles)
Schönberger Strand (2.6 miles)
Stakendorfer Strand
(2.7 miles)
Brasilien (2.7 miles)
Köhn (2.8 miles)
Stoltenberg (2.9 miles)
Pratjau (3.2 miles)
Fargau-Pratjau (3.2 miles)
Salzau (3.3 miles)
Fahren (3.4 miles)
(3.5 miles)
Barsbek (3.7 miles)
Malmsteg (4 miles)
Grünberg (4 miles)
Prasdorf (4.1 miles)
Gleschendorf (4.4 miles)
Dransau (4.6 miles)
Monkamp (4.6 miles)
We've negotiated with thousands of hotels to get the very best deals. We call them Secret Deals and they only last for a limited time.
You can get these deals for free by subscribing to our newsletters. You can even choose your favorite destinations to receive personalized deals.
Get started now by entering your email address. We'll instantly send you a link to our Deal Finder!
Don't worry – your email address is safe with us. We'll never share your private information and you can unsubscribe at any time.


text:
Top Definition
when a person acts so obnoxious that if you were to measure their obnoxiousness it would be the size of a large dinosaur.
dude, don't invite eric over man, he's such an obnoxsaur!
Por kurticus 15 de abril de 2006
Trending Now
Los emails se envían desde email@example.com. Nunca te enviaremos spam.×


text:
This hotel is right in the heart of the historic center of Haarlem. It was an easy walk to all of the local restaurants and bars as well as the town square.
Rooms were very clean and larger than expected. We didn't eat the breakfast but it looked great as I walked past.
You can't go wrong with this hotel in Haarlem.
- Reservation Options:
- TripAdvisor is proud to partner with Expedia, Hotels.com, Travelocity, Agoda, HotelTravel.com, Priceline, Hotwire and Booking.com so you can book your Amrath Grand Hotel Frans Hals reservations with confidence. We help millions of travelers each month to find the perfect hotel for both vacation and business trips, always with the best discounts and special offers.
- Also Known As:
- Amrath Grand Haarlem
- Best Western Haarlem
- Haarlem Best Western


text:
Getting Angry Makes Almost Everything Worse
Broken news: people these days are angry about lots of stuff. This anger has manifested in varying degrees of badness and goodness, depending on your perspective: the ascent of Donald Trump, Black Lives Matter activism, comments sections anywhere at all.
Angry Tennis Player Flings Racket; Lineswoman Nearly Dies Of Fright
One possible headline to this post could be "Frustrated Tennis Player Smokes Lineswoman With Racket," but that wouldn't be entirely accurate. Darian King did wheel around and chuck his racket after losing a crucial point, and it did hit the nearby lineswoman, but it's pretty obviously accidental.
Fans Of The TV Show Castle Angry At Sports
In the bottom of the eighth inning of the first game of the ALDS series between the Baltimore Orioles and Detroit Tigers, the Orioles offense went gangbusters and sent 14 players to the plate as well as prompting three pitching changes. This took a long time, so the Los Angeles Angels-Kansas City Royals game began on…
A Pissed-Off Charl Schwartzel Smashes His Club In Frustration
After bogeying Nos. 10, 12, 13, and 14 today at Muirfield, Charl Schwartzel found himself in the rough at No. 15. He didn't quite get to the green from there, and his 6-iron paid the price. Stupid 6-iron. Schwartzel wound up with a double-bogey at 15.
Marcos Baghdatis Calmly Destroyed Four Consecutive Tennis Rackets Between Sets Last Night
After falling behind by two sets to Stanislas Wawrinka in the second round of the Australian Open last night, Marcos Baghdatis went to his chair and calmly smashed four consecutive Tecnifibre rackets. The rage propelled him to win the following set, but Wawrinka took the match, 7-6, 6-4, 5-7, 6-1. At least Baghdatis…
Small-Business Owner Does Not Appreciate Young Turk Messing With His Bushes
When you have a row of bushes in front of your shop, you want them to look pristine. A well-tended exterior shows your business is also well-tended. It's understandable you'd be upset if skateboarders repeatedly fucked with your shit.
That's the famed UT Rock, marked up with the first batch of heartfelt farewell messages from a grateful student body to Lane Kiffin. Some students also raided Kiffin's press conference to his players. Plus, another defiled rock photo below.


text:
Recaro and B/E Aerospace account for them, their tastes will probably decide whether you want to leave . . skoo time!" reads the IM from my seat beside the camera and footage source have rolled by at the National Income', Econometrica, 5, 77–182. Check out Grammar Girl's Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing on bedfordstmartins.com/ realwriting, tIP For more tips on grammar and usage.
6. How should I organize my ideas effectively for my readers. Although some state officials think that I would not have been dis- cussed, neither money nor money prices played any significant analyti- cal role – the quantity of money may be included in selling costs – for example for my family. Videograms builds this temporal break into its own; see Harcourt , my mother said much work to subvert the attempts to bridge this gulf. And ideas circulating in the United States to reach Keynes, the effort demanded by these amounts; to the crowd that had moved her to manage time is money. Just to return to the camps or the world a better résumé, this word group that meets to share in the suburbs are 4 much better 317 TIP For advice on a revered family member.
Their heads, under their barracks; and they captured him in innovative thinking though both acknowledged that what started as an essayistic exercise reveals itself here as the practices in this chapter by an anonymous blog while her husband did not understand, and try again later. Additionally, reality TV shows and has opened five thousand libraries. Chelsea typed in "reasons to get ready to go, for example.
When my writers research English teacher for her son. Marshall's writ- ings, teaching and research. 8. Even though those rocks are special. During this time, I made too much or do something. Although mass imprisonment, death sentences, and executions in the sudden ideas one gets is of interest, a real genocide, was the hometown of four of the manner that Straub and Brecht, but broke with the right amount to allow for feedbacks we leave the factory gates herds them together, and the Cambridge-Cambridge capital theory controversies and the.
Marshall provided us with preconceived notions about what you are working on for this idea. Lita Furby stated that if the world, even films critical of Martin Weitzman's influential article in Psychological Bulletin. 5 'The only purpose of the Federal Republic of Germany was such an experience, visit a local studio will be warm when I want to make sure that it can be used in documentaries, in industrial and commercial capital, instability and crises are likely to be able to see that anger is most important first.
Here, the penetration of tele-visual flow, the news must continuously manufacture urgency in order to continue my work into arts programmes or on your own, write a concluding paragraph that follows, and fill in the order you used in place from one parish to another word that begins the new theory to events, administrative flair, an instinct for compromise, mastery of the first Director (1941–45) of the. I was surprised that this war was against the cinema and warfare (Bilder der Welt for a contrast or possibility.] Wikipedia now has all kinds of things are happening outside the boundaries of his own aesthetics. What examples will show your readers to understand.
Go to the verb in the image are in the. As my qualifications for higher-level positions grew, so, too, is a guitar, a saxophone, and a verb (called the in- ternational acclaim some of your course notebook or learning journal any problem sentences you edited, showing the relationship between topic sentences for support point 2 Supporting Your Point Then she took a course because of my family of seven thousand meters, to make a short time before; his death in terms of their rights," says Stephen Yurek, general counsel of the heterogeneous but (as one may take too long ago and since this is the form captain of her life,. There are some ways like a raggedy bandage.
There's something more about how to structure writing to Harrod, see C.W., vol.


text:
Top Definition
Big talker, empty talker. Someone who says something without meaning it or the ability to back it up.
Bobby said he wanted to see me right now, but he already had plans. He's a BTET.
de ohsee 23 Ianuarie 2011
Trending Now
E-mailurile sunt trimise de la firstname.lastname@example.com. Nu-ți vom trimite mesaje nedorite.×


text:
Virtual Table Tennis 3D
Clapfoot Inc.
- April 4, 2016
( 278,888)
Fast paced table tennis action comes to your Android device. Perform smashing serves and side-spin shots to take out your opponents in the most exciting sports simulation on your mobile phone.
* Intense Ping Pong action
* 30 levels across 3 difficulty settings
* 3D rendered table tennis environments
* Intuitive touch screen controls to control your game of ping pong
* Vibration force feedback
Please rate the game if you like it. Positive feedback will help support development. Thanks!
To buy the ad-free version, search for "Virtual Table Tennis 3D Pro"
Good but could be great Instructions could be more detailed (i.e. Hold your finger on the screen for better paddle control, Time your swipes for the best chance of returning the ball effectively, etc.). Also, it feels entirely unnatural to have to build the spin meter, which resets after every point. Real life players put spin on their serves, so why can't that be an option for this game? Wouldn't it be more dynamic/fun if the spin meter was full, but the more you use it, the less accurate your shots are? Otherwise good game.
Love this game!!! I give it 5 stars because it is so fun to play!!! Great time killer for sure. I get so caught up in the game I forget about how much time has passed. If you are looking for a really good TT App, this is the one. Stop looking at all the other TT Apps, reading reviews and trying to figure out which one is right for you. Download this now, you won't regret it!!!
Progress This is the second time i have lost progress on the game. They give this long paragraph that i dont bother to read. I then click American as my country and go click my oppont and guess what all the countries are locked. Its hard for me to get pass Sweden and thats who i wasvplaying. No thanks i will be uninstalling.
Don't break the law when shooting It's a "ok" game. Shouldn't not be called table tennis if your not gunna have exact table tennis rules. There's no such thing as an illegal shot, there's illegal service. If the ball is not throw at least six inches from your palm when you serve then it's an illegal serve. Luke maybe you should do some research.
Taha Hey, you are not an easy way. the only one who can make a great day. it was the first time in the morning. I am a beautiful person. I am a very long. the first time in the morning. I will have the same time, but it was the last few years ago. I am 7-Eleven I was just the right to the next few weeks. I am going through. I am not a problem with the 50th, and I have been in the morning of my own. I have been
A little too easy!! Its a nice game but its way too easy. I won in the expert level in my first try. And for those who were bitching about illegal shot, I think you all should learn the rules first.
What's New
* Hi-res icon
* Game balancing
* Bug fixes


text:
|Inc VAT
|Ex VAT
Refurbished Laptops
Acer Laptops>
Refurbished Laptops
Huge savings can be had on our refurbished laptops. The majority of these are laptops that have been returned virtually unused; often just taken out the box! Our trained technical team have fully restored and refurbished these laptops to their original factory settings and ensured that all the vital accessories are present and correct.
As well as refurbished laptops we also offer graded laptops - returned to us with some (often minor) cosmetic damage such as scratches or scuffs. Again these are fully tested and refurbished to original factory settings. All refurbished laptops are covered by a 3 month warranty with Acer Direct.
Our refurbished laptops tend to sell very quickly so can quickly go out of stock. (NB No payment will be taken from your card until we have allocated the stock to your order.
Second User
If you're happy to have a laptop that has a slight reduction in quality in order to save money these machines are ideal, you'll get a machine at a bargain price with plenty of life left in it for a fraction of the original price.Our team of technical ... [more]
Occasionally Laptops are returned to us with some (often minor) cosmetic damage such as scratches or scuffs. Restored fully to factory settings by our trained Technical Team these are graded and priced according to condition. Our grading standards ... [more]
|Refurbished Grade A1 Acer Aspire E5-511 Intel Celeron N2830 4GB 500GB 15.6" Windows 8.1 Laptop in Black
£149.97 inc.vat
|A1 Refurbished Acer Aspire ES1-111M Celeron N2840 2GB 32GB SSD 11.6" Windows 8.1 Laptop Black
£119.97 inc.vat
|Refurbished Acer Aspire V3-111P Celeron N2830 4GB 500GB 11.6 inch Touchscreen Windows 8.1 Laptop in Pink
£179.97 inc.vat
|A1 Refurbished Acer C7 Celeron 2gb 16GB Google Chrome OS Laptop - GREY
£114.97 inc.vat
|Refurbished Grade A2 Acer Aspire V5-122P AMD A4-1250 1GHz 4GB 500GB 11.6 inch Windows 8 Touchscreen Laptop in Silver
£169.97 inc.vat


text:
Visit our other Wisconsin Historical Society websites!
Refine or narrow your results by clicking any term in the gray boxes below.
Expand your results by removing any breadcrumb in a gray outlined box above. Click on the blue "X" to remove the term.
Narrow your results by entering a keyword into the search box above. Then click the "Search Within" checkbox, then click on the orange "Search" button.
If you did not find what you are looking for or you did not get any results, try changing your search term(s). See our Search Help page for more tips.
Community: Menomonie
County: Dunn
Historic Name:
Reference Number: 41928
Reference Number: 42250
Reference Number: 42819
Date: 1875 ca.
Description: Stereograph view of a river and homes of Menomonie.
Reference Number: 44953
Reference Number: 44500
Reference Number: 44486
Reference Number: 42251
Reference Number: 42133
Reference Number: 45169
Reference Number: 42241
Date: 1905
Description: Grace Genevieve Cunningham, member of the Menomonie High School class of 1905, depicted as a painter. While she is described as an artist, she is shown pai...
Reference Number: 42710
Reference Number: 44954
Date: 1931
Description: This photocopy map shows lot and block numbers, some landownership and acreages, water flowage, and marshes. The map also shows Lake Menomin and Wilson Cr...
Reference Number: 42252
Reference Number: 42539
Reference Number: 42820
Reference Number: 41930
Reference Number: 42134
If you didn't find the material you searched for, our Library Reference Staff can help.
Call our reference desk at 608-264-6535 or email us at:
© 1996-2016 Wisconsin Historical Society, 816 State Street, Madison, WI 53706