text:
- © 2016 American Society of Plant Biologists. All Rights Reserved.
The phenylpropanoid 3,4-(methylenedioxy)cinnamic acid (MDCA) is a plant-derived compound first extracted from roots of Asparagus officinalis and further characterized as an allelochemical. Later on, MDCA was identified as an efficient inhibitor of 4-COUMARATE-CoA LIGASE (4CL), a key enzyme of the general phenylpropanoid pathway. By blocking 4CL, MDCA affects the biosynthesis of many important metabolites, which might explain its phytotoxicity. To decipher the molecular basis of the allelochemical activity of MDCA, we evaluated the effect of this compound on Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings. Metabolic profiling revealed that MDCA is converted in planta into piperonylic acid (PA), an inhibitor of CINNAMATE-4-HYDROXYLASE (C4H), the enzyme directly upstream of 4CL. The inhibition of C4H was also reflected in the phenolic profile of MDCA-treated plants. Treatment of in vitro grown plants resulted in an inhibition of primary root growth and a proliferation of lateral and adventitious roots. These observed growth defects were not the consequence of lignin perturbation, but rather the result of disturbing auxin homeostasis. Based on DII-VENUS quantification and direct measurement of cellular auxin transport, we concluded that MDCA disturbs auxin gradients by interfering with auxin efflux. In addition, mass spectrometry was used to show that MDCA triggers auxin biosynthesis, conjugation, and catabolism. A similar shift in auxin homeostasis was found in the c4h mutant ref3-2, indicating that MDCA triggers a cross talk between the phenylpropanoid and auxin biosynthetic pathways independent from the observed auxin efflux inhibition. Altogether, our data provide, to our knowledge, a novel molecular explanation for the phytotoxic properties of MDCA.
Plants growing in a tight community are in continuous competition for space, light, water, and nutrients. Potential survival strategies include optimizing plant architecture and maximizing growth rate, allowing the plant to capture light and receive nutrients and water more efficiently, while placing neighboring plants in an unfavorable position (Einhellig, 1995; Weir et al., 2004). Besides developmental shifts, plants release an array of secondary metabolites (allelochemicals) into the rhizosphere to negatively affect the growth and reproduction of neighboring, competitor plants (Putnam, 1988; Bertin et al., 2003). Despite a lot of research effort having been devoted to allelopathic chemical warfare over the past decades, it remains a difficult study object due to the complexity of plant-plant interactions (Zeng, 2014). Nevertheless, the significance of allelochemicals in structuring plant communities and preserving biodiversity has been fully recognized by the scientific community. Moreover, allelochemicals show the potential to be used as an environmentally friendly alternative for weed control to improve agricultural productivity (Zeng, 2014).
Strictly speaking, the term "allelochemical" refers to a compound produced and released by one organism to affect the growth and development of susceptible species (Weir et al., 2004). In practice, compounds derived from plant extracts or exudates are often cataloged as allelochemicals based on their inhibitory effect on seed germination and/or growth of other plant species in an artificial setup. Despite their importance, the molecular mode of action of a given allelochemical compound has rarely been studied in detail; however, toxicity is relatively easily demonstrated, identifying its molecular target is far more challenging. An interesting example is the phenylpropanoid 3,4-(methylenedioxy)cinnamic acid (MDCA), which was isolated from lyophilized root tissues of Asparagus [Asparagus officinalis L.; Hartung et al. (1990)]. It was suggested to be an allelochemical based on its inhibitory effect on root and shoot growth of Lepidium sativum (Hartung et al., 1990). Independent studies revealed that MDCA acts as an efficient competitive inhibitor of 4-COUMARATE-CoA LIGASE (4CL), the enzyme converting hydroxycinnamates to their corresponding CoA-esters (Knobloch and Hahlbrock, 1977; Chakraborty et al., 2009). This conversion is an early step in the general phenylpropanoid pathway leading to a wide array of metabolites, including coumarins, stilbenes, salicylic acid, flavonoids, and monolignols (Vogt, 2010). Given that inhibition of 4CL in this metabolic pathway will have far-reaching effects on plant growth and development (Voelker et al., 2010), it is tempting to link the proposed phytotoxicity of MDCA to this metabolic block.
Here, we evaluate whether the phytotoxicity of MDCA is a direct consequence of the inhibition of 4CL or if MDCA targets also other biological processes in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). We found that MDCA causes strong developmental defects in Arabidopsis seedlings at early developmental stages. Convincing evidence was found that MDCA affects the homeostasis of the plant signaling compound auxin. Our results provide an alternative explanation for the molecular mechanism underlying the phytotoxic properties of MDCA, and suggest that these multiple modes of action make it an attractive candidate as an environmental agrochemical or synergist.
MDCA Affects Plant Growth and Development in a Dose-Dependent Manner
MDCA was put forward as an allelochemical based on the inhibition of L. sativum root and shoot growth when used at a concentration of 260 μM or higher (Hartung et al., 1990). In an attempt to support the idea that MDCA has allelopathic properties, we tested the effect of MDCA on germination of Arabidopsis seeds. None of the tested concentrations (0 µM to 200 µM) had an inhibitory effect on germination as scored by radical emergence (Supplemental Fig. S1A). However, a clear restrictive effect on the postembryonic development of the plants was observed at the different concentrations tested (Supplemental Fig. S1B). To obtain profound insight into the effect of MDCA on plant growth and development, the experiment was repeated using lower MDCA concentrations (0 µM to 40 µM). Twelve d after germination (DAG), both the primary root and rosette growth of the seedlings were analyzed (Fig. 1A). Compared to the control, the MDCA-treated plants had more lateral roots and the roots displayed a marked agravitropic response. In addition, a dose-dependent decrease of both the primary root length and leaf area was observed (Fig. 1B). The MDCA-concentration required to reduce the primary root length by 50% (IC50-root) was determined to be 5.07 μM, while no further development of the primary root was observed from germination onwards at 40 μM MDCA. The effect of MDCA on leaf development was less severe and higher concentrations were needed to reduce the leaf area by half (IC50-leaf of 18.30 µM). Noteworthy, the decline in leaf area could be an indirect effect caused by the severe reduction in primary root length at these relatively high MDCA concentrations.
A reduction in primary root length could point toward a perturbed activity of the apical root meristem, and more detailed analysis of this region revealed a prominent broadening of the main root tip upon MDCA treatment. To test whether this lateral expansion is a direct consequence of an increase in meristematic cell division activity, we treated a pKNOLLE:KNOLLE-GFP translational fusion-line with MDCA (Lukowitz et al., 1996). KNOLLE is a marker for cell plate formation, and under normal conditions the corresponding gene is expressed in the actively dividing cells of the main root tip. A 5-d treatment of Arabidopsis seedlings (3 DAG) with 10 μM MDCA led to an accumulation of fluorescence in the main root tip (Fig. 1C). No fluorescence was observed in the initial QC-cells, which is in line with the known low mitotic activity of these cells (Heyman et al., 2014). As the QC regulates the meristematic region tightly by maintaining the surrounding cells as stem cells, we reasoned that MDCA would induce broadening of the meristem in the QC region. Accordingly, the QC marker line pWOX5:GFP (Haecker et al., 2004) showed a radial expansion of the GFP-signal in the QC area (a 1.48-fold increase in circumference; Fig. 1, D and E) upon MDCA treatment compared to mock-treated plants. The radial expansion of WOX5-positive cells indicates that MDCA either stimulates QC cell division activity or gives the cells surrounding the QC a QC-identity. The former contradicts the absence of strong mitotic activity of the QC cells as observed in the KNOLLE reporter line. However, a putative positive effect of MDCA on QC cell division activity could have gone unnoticed as QC cells self-renew at a low proliferation rate (Dolan et al., 1993). To reveal the effect of MDCA on QC cell proliferation, a reporter line was used in which GUS was driven by the promoter of the transcription factor ERF115, which is a rate-limiting factor for QC cell division (Heyman et al., 2013). In mock-treated Arabidopsis seedlings (3 DAG), ERF115 promoter activity was observed in one or several of the QC cells in 32.6% of the root tips (60/184; Fig. 1F). An additional 34 root tips (18.5%) had GUS activity outside the QC-region. The addition of 10 μM MDCA to the growth medium led to an increase in the number of seedlings with ectopic pERF115-driven GUS expression (52/128; 40.6%; Fig. 1F). Interestingly, pERF115:GUS-positive QC cells were only observed in two of the 128 MDCA-treated seedlings, suggesting that MDCA has a negative impact on QC cell division activity. Together, this suggests that the MDCA-mediated lateral expansion of QC-identity in the stem cell niche is due to changes in cell identity of QC-neighboring cells rather than activation of QC division.
In contrast to its inhibitory effect on primary root growth and leaf development, MDCA stimulated lateral root formation and adventitious rooting in a dose-dependent manner (Fig. 2, A and B). A 1.36-fold and 2.67-fold increase in lateral root density (LRD) was observed in 12-d-old plants treated with 2.5 µM and 5 µM MDCA, respectively. To evaluate the potential effect of MDCA on the spatial activation of the cell cycle in the pericycle and thereby on the spacing between lateral roots, the cell cycle reporter line pCYCB1:GUS was used (Colón-Carmona et al., 1999). In mock-treated plants, GUS-expression was restricted to the cells actively dividing at the lateral root initiation sites. MDCA treatment (0 µM to 10 µM) resulted in a dose-dependent increase in the number of pericycle cells expressing GUS, which is in line with the observed increase in LRD along the primary root (Fig. 2C). The observed perturbation in longitudinal spacing of lateral root primordia lead in some extreme cases to the outgrowth of fasciated lateral roots.
In conclusion, the data suggested that MDCA reduces primary root growth of Arabidopsis seedlings by affecting the stem cell niche and the meristem at the main root apex, while stimulating lateral root formation by increasing cell division activity along the pericycle.
Phenolic Profiling Supports Inhibition of the Core Phenylpropanoid Pathway by MDCA
Previous in vitro assays based on heterologous systems provided evidence that MDCA acts as a competitive inhibitor of 4CL (Knobloch and Hahlbrock, 1977; Chakraborty et al., 2009; Fig. 3A). As this enzyme catalyzes a key step of the general phenylpropanoid pathway, we used phenolic profiling to evaluate how the carbon flux over this pathway is redirected in seedlings upon treatment with MDCA. To this end, the methanol-soluble metabolites of 12-d-old in vitro grown Arabidopsis seedlings treated with 10 μM MDCA were analyzed by ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (UHPLC-MS). This method allows the detection of several classes of metabolites (e.g. oligolignols, flavonoids, and glucosinolates) and their corresponding derivatives or pathway intermediates (Fig. 3A). A total of 1247 peaks was detected over the whole experiment. Principal component analysis revealed that MDCA-treated samples separated from control samples based on a combination of the first and second principal components, indicating metabolic shifts upon MDCA treatment (Fig. 3B). Univariate statistical analysis was applied to select peaks with significantly different intensity in the MDCA-treated samples. Among the 383 obtained peaks, 247 were increased in abundance, whereas 136 were reduced upon MDCA treatment. The remarkably high number of differentials might reflect the developmental shift caused by MDCA, adding differentials to the compound lists that are only indirectly related to the treatment.
Of the 10 highest accumulating compounds in MDCA-treated plants (Supplemental Fig. S2), five were conjugates of MDCA, indicating that MDCA is heavily processed by the plant. Four other compounds of the top-10 list were conjugates of cinnamic acid (CA), indicative for the accumulation of CA in MDCA-treated plants. CA is the substrate of C4H, the enzyme preceding 4CL in the phenylpropanoid pathway, and the accumulation of CA conjugates is indicative for an inhibition of C4H in MDCA-treated plants. However, MDCA was unable to inhibit Arabidopsis C4H activity in a heterologous expression system (Fig. 3C), making it unlikely that the accumulation of CA conjugates is due to inhibition of C4H by MDCA. Here, the metabolomics data provided insight into the underlying molecular mechanism. Among the compounds that had accumulated in MDCA-treated plants were several conjugates of piperonylic acid (PA), a compound structurally related to MDCA (Fig. 3 and Supplemental Fig. S3). Based on the fact that PA or PA-derived conjugates were never found in Arabidopsis, and on the previous observation that MDCA is heavily processed in the plant (Supplemental Fig. S2), we concluded that the presence of PA-derived compounds is the consequence of the in planta processing of MDCA. Interestingly, PA is known as a competitive inhibitor of C4H (Schalk et al., 1998; Fig. 3C), explaining the observed accumulation of CA conjugates. Despite the clear indications for a PA-mediated inhibition of C4H, a potential inhibition of 4CL by MDCA could not be excluded at this point. The top-10 list of compounds for which the concentration dropped upon MDCA treatment (Supplemental Fig. S2) holds several glycosylated forms of ferulic acid-containing phenolic dimers, glucosinolates, and flavonoids. A subsequent targeted search for related metabolites revealed an MDCA-dependent reduction in glycosylated oligolignols and p-coumaric acid-derived phenylpropanoids (Supplemental Fig. S4). The observed shift in the phenolic profile of MDCA-treated seedlings is in line with the inhibition of an enzyme catalyzing an early step in the core phenylpropanoid pathway.
Lignin Reduction Is Not at the Basis of the MDCA-Induced Developmental Defects
The MDCA-induced reduction of glycosylated oligolignols is considered indicative for a drop in lignin deposition (Vanholme et al., 2012). To provide supporting evidence for this assumption, we evaluated the effect of MDCA on the formation of the Casparian strip in the main root (Naseer et al., 2012). For this assay, Arabidopsis roots are incubated in propidium iodide (PI), a dye that diffuses in the apoplast of root tissue. At the endodermis, this diffusion is blocked by the lignin-rich Casparian strip, leaving the cell walls of the stele unstained. Only when the Casparian strip is impaired will PI pass the endodermis and stain the underlying cell layers. The number of endodermal cells from the elongation zone to the region where PI is excluded from the stele is used as a measure for Casparian strip integrity and, hence, lignification. In 7-d-old Arabidopsis seedlings treated with 2.5 μM and 10 μM MDCA, the cell count was significantly higher compared to that of the control, indicating a delay in Casparian strip development and an inhibition in lignin deposition (Fig. 4A; Supplemental Fig. S5). Similar results were found with inhibitors targeting other steps of the lignin biosynthetic pathway (Naseer et al., 2012; Van de Wouwer et al., 2016). The formation of the Casparian strip was rescued by supplying MDCA-treated plants with a mixture of coniferyl and sinapyl alcohol (both end-products of the monolignol biosynthetic pathway, and building blocks of lignin), confirming that MDCA affects the biosynthesis of lignin (Fig. 4A; Supplemental Fig. S5).
Having convincing evidence that lignin deposition is indeed affected in MDCA-treated seedlings, we wondered whether the reduced lignin deposition could be at the basis of the observed developmental abnormalities. The underlying idea is that lignin is considered a signature for cell differentiation (Barros et al., 2015) and deferring lignin deposition could extend or perturb the developmental program, resulting in growth defects (Bonawitz and Chapple, 2013). If this were the case, restoring lignin deposition by the addition of monolignols should also rescue the MDCA-induced developmental root phenotype. To examine whether the MDCA-related plant phenotype is a consequence of lignin depletion, we grew Arabidopsis on medium containing coniferyl and sinapyl alcohol and different concentrations of MDCA (0, 2.5, or 10 μM). Twelve DAG the seedlings were analyzed. Interestingly, phenotypes linked to MDCA, such as the reduction of the primary root length and the proliferation of lateral roots, could not be restored by adding monolignols (Fig. 4, B–D).
Based on these results, we concluded that MDCA indeed reduces lignin deposition in Arabidopsis seedlings, but this reduction is not at the basis of the observed developmental defects caused by MDCA.
Salicylic Acid Has No Major Role in the MDCA-Induced Developmental Defects
Treatment of seedlings with MDCA significantly affected the relative abundance of different phenylpropanoid intermediates and derivatives, as shown by the phenolic profiling presented above. A relative shift in the abundance of some of these metabolites might interfere with specific metabolic or signaling pathways and lead to growth inhibition (Bonawitz and Chapple, 2013). Recently, some of the observed growth defects in mutants perturbed in lignin biosynthesis have been linked with the accumulation of salicylic acid (SA), a plant hormone involved in pathogen defense that is biosynthetically related to phenylpropanoids and that can be synthesized from CA (Gallego-Giraldo et al., 2011). Therefore, the MDCA-mediated inhibition of the phenylpropanoid pathway downstream of CA could theoretically lead to the accumulation of SA (Boerjan et al., 2003). SA levels were quantified by UHPLC-MS in 12 DAG Arabidopsis seedlings grown on medium with 10 μM MDCA. Interestingly, MDCA-treated seedlings showed a mild, but significant increase in SA levels (1.35-fold increase; Supplemental Fig. S6). As SA-levels were close to the detection limit, we further evaluated whether this increase in SA-levels could underlie the MDCA-induced phenotypes by checking to what extent SA-treatment of Arabidopsis seedlings could phenocopy the effect of MDCA treatment (Fig. 5A). While stimulation of adventitious rooting was only observed at relatively high concentrations (>10 μM of SA; Fig. 5B), SA had no effect on LRD (Fig. 5C) and its IC50-root (IC50-root of 51.00 μM; Fig. 5D) was one order-of-magnitude higher than that of MDCA (IC50-root of 5.07 μM; Fig. 1B).
Therefore, we concluded that it is unlikely that SA (or a corresponding conjugate) is the bioactive compound causing the root developmental defects observed in MDCA-treated plants, and that SA has no major role in the MDCA-induced developmental defects.
MDCA Triggers Auxin Biosynthesis
As the aberrant root phenotype caused by MDCA resembles typical auxin-induced phenotypes (e.g. reduction of the primary root length and induction of lateral and adventitious roots), the auxin-responsive reporter DR5rev:GFP was used to evaluate whether MDCA alters the auxin response (Ulmasov et al., 1997). Seven DAG Arabidopsis seedlings treated for 4 d with 10 μM MDCA displayed a significant increase in fluorescence in the main root tip compared to mock-treated plants (Fig. 6A), suggesting that free auxin levels are increased in MDCA-treated plants. To detect dynamic changes in endogenous free auxin distribution at high spatial and temporal resolution, the DII-VENUS auxin sensor line was used (Brunoud et al., 2012). A time-lapse analysis of DII-VENUS fluorescence was performed on the main root tip of Arabidopsis seedlings 7 DAG. When 1 μM naphthalene-1-acetic acid (NAA; a synthetic auxin) was added to the root, DII-VENUS fluorescence dropped to 25% of its initial intensity after 42 min, which is in line with previously published data (Brunoud et al., 2012). Replacing NAA by 10 μM MDCA resulted in a drop of DII-VENUS fluorescence to 37% of its initial intensity over the same time interval. Both auxin-sensitive sensors indicate that MDCA depends on the auxin-signaling cascade for its activity (Fig. 6, B and C).
The canonical auxin-signaling cascade is activated when auxin interacts with the TRANSPORT INHIBITOR RESPONSE1/AUXIN SIGNALING F-BOX (TIR1/AFB) receptors, whereupon AUXIN/INDOLE-3-ACETIC ACID (AUX/IAA) auxin signaling repressors are degraded and the expression of downstream target genes (e.g. the DR5rev-driven GFP) is activated (Gray et al., 1999). To verify whether MDCA activates this auxin response pathway, we studied the effect of MDCA on Arabidopsis mutants defective in auxin signaling including the solitary root-1 (slr) gain-of-function mutant, the arf7 arf19 double loss-of-function mutant, and the tir1 afb2 afb3 triple loss-of-function mutant (Fig. 7A; Fukaki et al., 2002; Dharmasiri et al., 2005; Okushima et al., 2007). MDCA failed to induce lateral root formation in all mutants tested, suggesting that lateral root formation induced by MDCA is dependent on events close to the TIR1 or TIR1-related receptor complex. This could indicate that MDCA act as an auxin analog and activates an auxin response by interacting directly with TIR1. Interestingly, MDCA has some of the structural requirements for primary auxin activity as stipulated by Went (1949), including a ring system with a double bond and a side chain with the carboxylic group separated from the ring by at least one carbon atom. Regardless of these structural and physicochemical similarities between MDCA and IAA (the endogenous ligand of TIR1), both compounds show particular differences making it unlikely for MDCA to act as an auxin (Supplemental Fig. S7, A–C). For example, the unsubstituted indole ring of IAA is hydrophobic while the unsubstituted dioxole group of MDCA is polar due to the presence of two oxygen atoms. In addition, adjacent to its carboxylic group, IAA has a freely rotatable CH2 group, while the transalkene bond of MDCA is rigid, and does not rotate to position the carboxylic group correctly from the plane of the ring to interact with the polar residues of the TIR1 receptor complex in a way similar to IAA. Molecular docking of MDCA in the auxin receptor pocket of TIR1 indeed showed a clear difference in its orientation as compared to IAA as modeled by Tan et al. (2007) (Supplemental Fig. S7, D and E).
To find supporting evidence for the in silico predictions and further evaluate whether MDCA activates auxin signaling by directly interacting with the TIR1/AFB receptor, surface plasmon resonance (SPR; Lee et al., 2014) was used to measure the interaction kinetics of recombinant TIR1 and AFB5 with an immobilized IAA7 degron peptide. The choice of the interaction partners was based on the requirement of both proteins for the MDCA-induced lateral root proliferation, as deduced from the experiment with the auxin signaling mutants. A strong readout was obtained with the positive control IAA, indicative for a strong agonist, whereas no evidence for a specific binding of MDCA to TIR1 or AFB5 was found (Fig. 7B). It is possible that some ligands bind to TIR1/AFB5 and prevent subsequent binding of the receptor-ligand complex to the degron peptide. Since such antagonists could give auxin-hypersensitive phenotypes (Leyser et al., 1996), we tested MDCA also for antiauxin activity but no activity was found (Fig. 7B). These findings support the prediction that MDCA is not able to replace auxin in the TIR1 binding pocket and, thus, cannot be considered as an auxin analog interacting with the TIR1-related auxin receptors.
As MDCA-induced developmental effects depend on the canonical auxin-signaling cascade whereas MDCA itself is not an auxin analog, we hypothesized that MDCA affects free auxin concentrations in planta. To test this hypothesis, endogenous auxin levels were quantified in Arabidopsis seedlings germinated on 0.5 × MS media containing MDCA (5 μM or 10 μM) and harvested 12 DAG. Compared to mock-treated plants, the MDCA treatment resulted in elevated free IAA levels as well as increased levels of the IAA-conjugates IAA-Glu and IAA-Asp (Fig. 7, C and D). In addition, the concentrations of most of the measured auxin precursors were also significantly higher in the MDCA-treated plants (tryptamine, indole-3-acetamide, indole-3-acetonitrile, indole-3-acetaldoxime, and indole-3-acetaldehyde), indicating that MDCA strongly boosts the auxin biosynthetic pathway (Supplemental Fig. S8). We subsequently checked whether the aberrant lateral root phenotype induced by MDCA could be reduced by artificially lowering free IAA levels in planta by the constitutive overexpression of a bacterial IAA LYS SYNTHETASE (iaaL), coding for an enzyme that inactivates free IAA by conjugating it to Lys (Romano et al., 1991). In contrast to MDCA-treated wild-type plants, MDCA-treated p35S:iaaL plants showed less lateral roots (Fig. 7E), indicating that the increase in lateral roots induced by MDCA is mediated by free IAA.
The observed activation of auxin biosynthesis could either be a consequence of MDCA-mediated perturbation of the phenylpropanoid pathway or an off-target effect. To uncouple these processes, we measured auxin concentrations in the c4h mutant ref3-2 (Schilmiller et al., 2009). Blocking the phenylpropanoid pathway in such an early step could result in the accumulation of upstream compounds, including Trp, the precursor of IAA. This approach allowed us to study putative crosstalk between the auxin biosynthetic and phenylpropanoid pathways independent of MDCA. C4H was preferred over 4CL as target, because the phenolic profile of MDCA-treated seedlings was consistent with inhibition of C4H rather than 4CL. In addition, we showed earlier processing of MDCA toward PA in planta (Supplemental Fig. S3), suggesting the inhibition of C4H in MDCA-treated plants. Auxin profiling performed on leaves of 2-months-old ref3-2 mutants revealed shifts in free auxin as well as auxin intermediates, conjugates, and catabolites resulting in a profile similar to the one observed in MDCA-treated plants (Supplemental Fig. S9). This indicates that auxin biosynthesis is affected as a result of the perturbation of the phenylpropanoid pathway.
In conclusion, the above data suggest that MDCA affects plant growth and development by increasing endogenous auxin (IAA) concentrations in Arabidopsis seedlings.
MDCA Affects Auxin Transport
Although the increase in free IAA levels is in agreement with the observed response of the DII-VENUS reporter, it is unlikely that the rapid drop in DII-VENUS fluorescence is due to the activation of the auxin biosynthetic pathway. In addition, the phenylpropanoid pathway is not activated in the main root tip where the degradation of the DII-VENUS signal was followed over time (Bell-Lelong et al., 1997). These observations question the suggested cross talk with the phenylpropanoid pathway and indicates that other processes might be involved in the MDCA-induced alteration of free auxin levels in the main root tip, such as the redistribution of available auxin over the root by perturbation of intercellular auxin transport. In contrast to the activation of auxin biosynthesis, the inhibition of auxin transport is likely to be a much faster response. To test whether MDCA affects auxin transport, we performed [3H]-NAA accumulation assays in tobacco BY-2 cell cultures (Petrásek et al., 2003, 2006). In tobacco cells, NAA enters the cells mainly by diffusion and it is an excellent substrate for the active auxin efflux (Delbarre et al., 1996). Therefore, a change in intracellular accumulation of radioactively labeled [3H]-NAA over time provides a measure of the rate of auxin efflux from the cells. When treated with 1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA), to inhibit cellular auxin efflux, NAA accumulates inside the cells above the level of untreated cells (Delbarre et al., 1996). Interestingly, intracellular NAA concentrations also increased when NPA was replaced by 50 μM MDCA, indicating that MDCA affects cellular auxin accumulation by blocking auxin efflux (Fig. 8A). Similar results were obtained using Arabidopsis cell suspensions (Supplemental Fig. S10). In contrast to NAA, the transport of 2,4-dichlorophenoxy acetic acid (2,4-D) into tobacco BY-2 cells is largely dependent on auxin uptake carriers making 2,4-D an excellent marker for the auxin influx activity. When added to BY-2 cell cultures 2,4-D rapidly accumulated in the cells, and MDCA had a mild, but positive effect on this profile; however, the mild accumulation likely reflects the partial inhibition of the active cellular efflux of 2,4-D under these conditions as a similar profile was described for the auxin efflux blocker NPA as well (Hosek et al., 2012). In Arabidopsis cell cultures, 2,4-D seems to be a good substrate for both influx and efflux auxin carriers (Seifertová et al., 2014) and, accordingly, the positive effect of MDCA on the accumulation of 2,4-D is more pronounced here than in BY-2 cells (Supplemental Fig. S10). Taken together, these results indicate that MDCA affects the auxin efflux from cells, but not the influx into cells (Fig. 8, A and B).
Flavonoids, as one group of products of the phenylpropanoid pathway, are obvious candidates to link the perturbation of the core phenylpropanoid pathway with the observed inhibition in auxin transport. Indeed, particular flavonoids have been described to alter auxin transport (Brown et al., 2001; Buer and Muday, 2004; Peer and Murphy, 2007; Yin et al., 2014) and phenolic profiling showed that the levels of all detected flavonoids dropped upon MDCA treatment. Intriguingly, the phenotype of the transparent testa-4 (tt4) mutant, which is hampered in the first enzymatic step of flavonoid biosynthesis (CHALCONE SYNTHASE) and hence is depleted of flavonoids, resembles that of MDCA-treated plants at the seedling stage, including a reduction in primary root length and an increase in LRD (Brown et al., 2001). However, these root phenotypes were difficult to confirm in a follow-up study and turned out to depend strongly on the experimental conditions (Buer and Djordjevic, 2009). To check whether the drop in flavonoids could be the cause of the MDCA-induced phenotype, the tt4 mutant was grown under the same growth conditions as those used to study the MDCA-dependent growth defects (Fig. 8C). Under these conditions, the tt4 mutant showed a mild but significant reduction in both primary root length and LRD, as compared to wild-type Arabidopsis (Fig. 8, D and E). This phenotype differs considerably from the MDCA-induced lateral root proliferation, indicating that, although the drop in flavonoids could be responsible for an indirect additive effect in MDCA-treated plants, it is not the preliminary cause of the altered LRD phenotype in MDCA-treated seedlings.
Altogether, these data suggest that MDCA disturbs auxin homeostasis by two independent mechanisms. The perturbation of auxin biosynthesis is a consequence of the MDCA-mediated inhibition of the phenylpropanoid pathway, whereas the inhibition of auxin transport is a direct effect of MDCA.
MDCA is a naturally occurring compound, initially extracted from root tissues of Asparagus (Hartung et al., 1990) and further characterized as an allelochemical (Weir et al., 2004). Later on, MDCA was identified as an efficient chemical inhibitor of 4CL, a key enzyme of the general phenylpropanoid pathway leading toward a broad range of secondary metabolites (Knobloch and Hahlbrock, 1977; Funk and Brodelius, 1992; Hartung et al., 1990; Funk and Brodelius, 1994; Chakraborty et al., 2009). Substantial inhibition of the phenylpropanoid pathway can be lethal for the plant (Bonawitz and Chapple, 2013), potentially explaining the allelochemical properties of MDCA (Bertin et al., 2003). Besides its assumed role in suppressing growth of neighboring plants, it was also proposed to lead to autotoxicity, manifested by the poor reestablishment of Asparagus plants in soil where it had been grown before (Laufer and Garrison, 1977; Yang, 1982; Young and Chou, 1984; Hartung et al., 1990).
When tested on Arabidopsis seedlings, severe morphological alterations of the root architecture were observed. In an attempt to link the developmental defects to the described inhibitory activity on the phenylpropanoid pathway, phenolic profiling was performed on MDCA-treated seedlings. Interestingly, the observed shift in the profile suggested an inhibition of the phenylpropanoid pathway upstream of p-coumaric acid, but downstream of CA, indicating that the perturbation occurs at the level of C4H. This conclusion contradicts studies describing MDCA as a competitive inhibitor of 4CL (Knobloch and Hahlbrock, 1977; Chakraborty et al., 2009), with only mild inhibitory activity on C4H (Schalk et al., 1998). However, the suggested inhibition of C4H can be explained by the in planta processing of MDCA to PA, which is a well-known inhibitor of C4H (Schalk et al., 1998). Despite the difficulty to conclude whether MDCA or PA is at the basis of the observed perturbation of the phenylpropanoid pathway, treating seedlings with MDCA clearly inhibits in planta lignin deposition as proven by the Casparian strip assay. However, no evidence was found supporting the notion that the reduction in lignin deposition was causative to the observed aberrant root phenotype.
The remarkable accumulation of intermediates upstream of C4H induced by MDCA suggested cinnamic acid-derived SA as a potential candidate to explain the observed developmental defects. In Medicago sativa, a correlation between SA concentration and the level of lignin reduction was found (Gallego-Giraldo et al., 2011; Lee et al., 2011), whereas the growth defects of a lignin biosynthetic mutant in Arabidopsis was partially restored by reducing the elevated SA levels in planta (Gallego-Giraldo et al., 2011). We therefore tested for SA accumulation in MDCA-treated plants. Mass spectrometry revealed a mild, but significant increase upon MDCA treatment. However, replacing MDCA for SA in the culture medium did not phenocopy the MDCA-induced developmental defects in Arabidopsis seedlings. Hence, no strong evidence was found for a role for SA in the MDCA-induced growth defects.
Rather than focusing on the perturbed phenylpropanoid pathway, we reasoned that MDCA itself could have additional targets, not necessarily related to its inhibitory activity on this pathway. Supporting evidence for an alternative target was found in an old study describing the activity of MDCA in a bioassay for auxin-type growth regulators (Aberg, 1961). Based on the growth stimulation of oat and wheat roots, this compound was cataloged as an antiauxin; however, the underlying molecular mechanism was never resolved (Aberg, 1961). Interestingly, the observed reduction in primary root length and the increased lateral root proliferation observed on the MDCA-treated Arabidopsis seedlings hinted for a link to auxin homeostasis (Overvoorde et al., 2010). Also, the induction of cell division activity in the root tip and the broadening of the QC region were indicative of an auxin imbalance, because auxin tightly regulates the cellular organization of the root meristem (Petricka et al., 2012; Takatsuka and Umeda, 2014).
The link with auxin was later underpinned by showing the inability of MDCA to stimulate lateral root proliferation in the auxin signaling mutants slr, arf7 arf19, and tir1 afb2 afb3, demonstrating the necessity of functional auxin signaling for the root-related MDCA-induced phenotypes to occur. Subsequent receptor binding assays showed that MDCA itself is not an auxin analog, suggesting that it acts upstream of TIR1, most likely affecting auxin levels. This was confirmed by measuring the levels of auxin and auxin-related compounds in MDCA-treated plants. Besides an increase in free IAA, the concentrations of IAA conjugates and degradation products, as well as intermediates of the auxin biosynthetic pathway, were increased in MDCA-treated plants. We hypothesized that the MDCA-mediated increase in auxin content could be a direct consequence of blocking the phenylpropanoid pathway at the level of C4H or 4CL. The resulting accumulation of compounds upstream of these enzymatic steps could affect the shikimate pathway, which provides Phe to the phenylpropanoid pathway. Importantly, besides Phe, the shikimate pathway leads to the precursors of the other two aromatic acids: Tyr and Trp (Vogt, 2010). This makes it tempting to speculate that interfering with the phenylpropanoid pathway leads to an increase in Trp, the precursor of IAA. The interaction between phenylpropanoid and auxin biosynthesis was suggested before, when swellings at branch junctions were observed in the ref3-2 mutant (Schilmiller et al., 2009). Although no additional evidence was available, increases in auxin concentration in the cauline leaves that subtend the swollen nodes were considered the cause of the growth defects. Our auxin measurements performed on this mutant are consistent with this hypothesis.
In addition to the link with auxin biosynthesis, the initial trigger altering auxin levels inside the plant could be the inhibition of polar auxin transport. The fast responses observed in the cellular auxin transport assay (both in BY-2 and Arabidopsis cells) as well as in the DII-VENUS experiment support such a direct response, independent of auxin biosynthesis. To explain further the molecular mechanism, we investigated whether flavonoids could act as mediators of the MDCA-related auxin efflux inhibition. Not only was the abundance of these phenylpropanoid-derived compounds dramatically altered in MDCA-treated plants, some have been described as endogenous auxin transport inhibitors (Peer and Murphy, 2007; Yin et al., 2014). Although the latter has been disputed (Li et al., 2010), recent evidence suggests that e.g. rhamnosylated flavonols (namely kaempferol 3-O-rhamnoside-7-O-rhamnoside) are active compounds inhibiting polar auxin transport and/or modifying auxin homeostasis in Arabidopsis shoots (Yin et al., 2014 and Kuhn et al., 2016). Nevertheless, the instant effect of the auxin efflux inhibition in BY-2 cells upon the addition of MDCA is supportive for a fast and most likely direct effect on auxin transport. In addition, the reduction in flavonoid levels is difficult to link with the induction of root proliferation in MDCA-treated plants as the flavonoid depleted tt4-mutant showed a reduction in LRD in our experimental setup. As MDCA affects different molecular processes, we cannot exclude a potential effect of flavonoid reduction that is masked by the MDCA-mediated induction of auxin biosynthesis. Nevertheless, the flavonoid data presented in this study together with the controversy concerning the role of flavonoids in the control of polar auxin transport, suggest that lateral root formation caused by MDCA is largely independent from flavonoids.
An intriguing question is whether MDCA has a more general physiological role in planta besides its potential activity as an allelochemical. The fact that this molecule has so far only been found in A. officinalis L. is not supportive for a universal role in plant development. However, this can be merely due to the fact that it was never searched for in other plant species. Plants produce an enormous number of metabolites of which only a small fraction has been characterized in detail (Fernie et al., 2004). In addition, most of the current metabolic profiling projects deliberately avoid the many unidentified compounds and focus only on the known ones, adding no information to the list of identified or characterized plant metabolites (Fernie et al., 2004). Even if the presence of MDCA itself cannot be demonstrated in other plants, we cannot exclude that other plants make structural analogs that act in a similar way as MDCA. From this perspective, the dioxole group of MDCA is of particular interest. This functional group is found in other plant-derived bioactive molecules belonging to different chemical classes, including (iso)flavonoids (e.g. pisatin), lignans (e.g. sesamin and kobusin), and alkaloids (e.g. sanguinarine, berberin, aristolochic acid, and narciclasine; Bailey, 1970; Trifunovic et al., 2003; Ono et al., 2006; Evidente et al., 1983; Gardiner et al., 2008; Na et al., 2011; Hu et al., 2012; Nakagawa et al., 2012; Hara and Kurita, 2014). Interestingly, the bioactivity of berberin and coptisin has been linked to the dioxole group as a structural analog, but without this functional group (i.e. palmatine), it turned out to be inactive (Nakagawa et al., 2012). Unfortunately, information concerning the molecular targets of the listed compounds is limited, making it nearly impossible to deduce a general in planta target for the dioxole-containing molecules. In animals, cytochrome P450 (CYP450) enzymes were put forward as targets for dioxole-containing compounds (Lafite et al., 2007), making it tempting to extrapolate this to MDCA, especially as several CYP450 enzymes are key in both the phenylpropanoid and auxin biosynthetic pathway. However, MDCA has been shown to inhibit 4CL (Knobloch and Hahlbrock, 1977; Chakraborty et al., 2009), which is not a CYP450 enzyme. Although the phenolic profile of MDCA-treated plants is supportive for an MDCA-mediated inhibition of the CYP450 enzyme C4H in the plant, this is most likely the indirect effect of the metabolism of MDCA into PA, a known C4H-inhibitor (Schalk et al., 1998). Further exploring the similarities and differences caused by the methylenedioxy group containing bioactive molecules could help in unraveling their molecular mechanism. In this perspective, it is interesting to mention narciclasine, a dioxole-containing alkaloid isolated from Narcissus tazetta bulbs (Na et al., 2011; Hu et al., 2012). Similar to MDCA, narciclasine is considered a potential allelochemical affecting postembryonic plant development by inhibiting auxin responses and modulating polar auxin transport in the target plant (Na et al., 2011; Hu et al., 2012).
In conclusion, we found that MDCA not only perturbs the phenylpropanoid pathway but also affects auxin homeostasis by triggering auxin biosynthesis and interfering with polar auxin transport. The inhibition of the phenylpropanoid pathway combined with the modified auxin homeostasis is most likely at the basis of its property as allelochemical. The activity of MDCA represents an example of polypharmacology, a little explored mechanism in which active pharmaceuticals exert their influence by multiple, instead of single sites of action (Reddy and Zhang, 2013). The relative importance of both processes in the phytotoxicity of MDCA remains unknown, but the effectiveness of hormone perturbation agrees well with the fact that phytohormonal superauxins have been among the most successful herbicides used in agriculture for decades (Grossmann, 2010), making MDCA an attractive candidate to become an agrochemical or synergist.
Plants, Chemicals, and Growth Conditions
All experiments whereby the effect of MDCA on the plant phenotype was studied were performed with Arabidopsis [Arabidopsis thaliana Columbia 0 (Col-0)] unless otherwise stated. The transgenic lines were in the same ecotype: p35S:iaaL, DII-VENUS, DR5rev:GFP, pCYCB1:GUS, pWOX5:GFP, pKNOLLE:KNOLLE-GFP, pERF115:GUS, tir1 afb2 afb3, slr, arf7 arf19 (Romano et al., 1991; Lukowitz et al., 1996; Colón-Carmona et al., 1999; Fukaki et al., 2002; Friml et al., 2003; Dharmasiri et al., 2005; Okushima et al., 2007; Brunoud et al., 2012; Heyman et al., 2013). Seeds were vapor-phase-sterilized and grown on 0.5 × MS-medium. The medium was supplemented with one of following compounds: PA, MDCA, NAA, and SA (Sigma Aldrich). After sowing, seeds were incubated at 4°C for at least 2 d, whereupon they were placed in the growth chamber under a 16-h-light/8-h-dark photoperiod regime (long d photoperiod) at 21°C (24°C for the pERF115:GUS line). Chemical compounds were dissolved in DMSO and added to the autoclaved medium prior to pouring the plates. For the Casparian strip method, PI (Sigma Aldrich) was used to counterstain the cell wall. The adventitious rooting assay was performed by placing plates in the dark for 7 d (after a short light pulse of 4 h). Plates were then exposed to light for 7 d under long d photoperiod. The number of adventitious roots (above the root-shoot junction) was counted on each seedling. The ref3-2 mutants used for auxin profiling were grown for 8 weeks on soil under long d photoperiod.
Plant Phenotyping
To quantify growth parameters and check for aberrant phenotypes, seeds were grown on round (square) plates for leaf (primary root) growth analysis, respectively. Twelve DAG plates were scanned using the Scanmaker 9800XL and root length was measured using the ImageJ software. For leaf area measurements, pictures were converted to black and white figures, after which the leaf area was measured using the ImageJ software. For each compound, the inhibitory concentration (IC50) was calculated, by plotting a dose-response curve in SigmaPlot. The dose-response curve giving the highest R2-value was used. The emerged lateral roots and adventitious roots were counted using a binocular microscope.
Confocal Microscopy and Casparian Strip Assays
Visualization and quantification of the appearance of Casparian strips was performed as previously described in Naseer et al. (2012). Arabidopsis Col-0 seeds were germinated on 0.5 × MS-Medium agar plates after 2 d in darkness at 4°C. Seedlings were grown vertically on 0.5 × MS-Medium agar supplied with 2.5 µM or 10 µM MDCA. When needed, 100 µM of a monolignol mixture containing coniferyl and sinapyl alcohol (1:1) was added. For visualization of the apoplastic barrier, seedlings were incubated in the dark for 2 min in a fresh solution of 10 µg/mL PI and rinsed in water twice. Confocal laser scanning microscopy was performed on a LSM5 Exciter confocal microscope (Carl Zeiss). An excitation window of 543 nm was used and detection was done using LP560. For quantification, "onset of elongation" was defined as the point where an endodermal cell in a median optical section was more than twice its width. From this point onwards, cells in the file were counted until PI could no longer diffuse through the apoplastic barrier, indicating that the Casparian strip was formed. For each treatment, 10 seedlings were used.
Root cell walls were counterstained with 30 µM PI for Arabidopsis plants transformed with pKNOLLE:KNOLLE-GFP, pWOX5:GFP, and DR5rev:GFP constructs. The excitation energy 488 nm was from an argon laser. The PI fluorescence emission was collected between 550 nm and 650 nm, and that of GFP/YFP between 500 nm and 550 nm. All images were captured with an inverted LSM 710 META confocal microscope equipped with 20× air objectives (Carl Zeiss). GUS assays were performed and inspected using differential interference contrast optics.
Time-Lapse DII-Venus
Seven-d-old Arabidopsis seedlings grown on vertical 0.5 × MS plates were used to analyze the effect of MDCA on the DII:VENUS reporter. At the initiation of the time-lapse, three seedlings (biological repeats) were transferred to glass-bottomed dishes and covered with media containing 1 µM NAA and 10 µM MDCA. The time series started 5 min after the seedlings had been placed in contact with the media and captured over 42 min (every 3 min) with a LSM 710 META confocal microscope (Carl Zeiss; 20× air objective). Images were analyzed by using the Fiji software by means of total signal from z-projection of defined region (always the same area).
Arabidopsis seedlings were flash-frozen in liquid N2 and ground in 2-mL Eppendorf tubes using a Retsch mill (1 min, 20 Hz, 5-mm bead). For metabolite profiling, 10 to 20 seedlings of each treatment were pooled as one biological repeat. Samples were extracted with 1 mL methanol and the lyophilized pellets were subjected to liquid/liquid extraction (80 μL water/80 μL cyclohexane). A 15 μL aliquot of each sample was used for LC-MS analysis. The LC-MS system consists of an Acquity UPLC system (Waters Corporation) connected to a Synapt HDMS quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer (Waters MS Technologies). Chromatographic separation was performed on an Acquity UPLC BEH C18 column (2.1 × 150 mm, 1.7 μm; Waters Corporation) using a water-acetonitrile gradient as described in Vanholme et al. (2012). The eluent was directed to the mass spectrometer equipped with an electrospray ionization source and lockspray interface for accurate mass measurements. The MS source parameters were as follows: capillary voltage, 2.5 kV; sampling cone, 37 V; extraction cone, 3.5 V; source temperature, 120°C; desolvation temperature, 400°C; cone gas flow, 50 L h−1; and desolvation gas flow, 550 L h−1. The collision energy for the trap and transfer cells was 6 V and 4 V, respectively. For data acquisition, the dynamic range enhancement mode was activated. Full-scan data were recorded in negative centroid V-mode; the mass range between m/z 100 and 1000, with a scan speed of 0.2 s scan−1, was recorded with Masslynx software (Ver. 4.1; Waters Corporation). Leucin-enkephalin (250 pg μL−1; solubilized in water: acetonitrile 1:1 [v/v] with 0.1% [v/v] formic acid) was used for lock mass calibration, with scanning every 10 s with a scan time of 0.5 s. Data processing was done with Progenesis QI ver. 2.1 (Nonlinear Dynamics). Peak areas were normalized with the function "normalize to external standard", with dry weight (mg) of the pellet remaining after methanol extraction used as "external standard". The peaks were further filtered on (1) their detection in all replicates of at least one treatment and (2) to have an average normalized peak intensity area higher than 500 in either MDCA- or mock-treated seedlings. Next, t tests were applied on the 1238 peaks that fulfilled these criteria. A total of 860 peaks had a P value < 0.01. Of these, 247 peaks were at least 10-fold increased in MDCA-treated seedlings and 136 were at least 10-fold reduced. The top-10 UP list was selected from the 247 increased peaks as those with the highest normalized peak area in MDCA-treated seedlings, whereas the top-10 DOWN were selected from the 136 decreased peaks as those with the highest normalized peak area in mock-treated seedlings. For the detection of SA all UPLC-MS parameters were the same as above, except (1) a mass range between m/z 100 and 4000 was used; (2) the dynamic range enhancement mode was not activated; and (3) the enhanced duty cycle mass was set at 137.02. In addition, peak integration was done with Targetlynx (Waters Corporation) using standard settings and the peak area of m/z 137.02 eluting at 10.4 min (corresponding to SA) was divided by the dry weight of the pellet remaining after methanol extraction in milligrams.
Auxin Metabolite Profiling
Auxin measurements were performed on Arabidopsis seedlings or leaves in case of the ref3-2 mutant. Samples were flash-frozen in liquid N2. For auxin metabolite profiling, 10 seedlings from each treatment were pooled to form one biological replicate. Extraction and purification of auxin and its metabolites were done as described previously with minor modifications (Novák et al., 2012). Frozen samples were homogenized using a MixerMill ball grinder (Retsch) and extracted in 1 mL 50 mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH 7.0) containing 1% sodium diethyldithiocarbamate, with the addition of deuterium and 13C6-labeled internal standards. The pH was adjusted to 2.7 with 1 M hydrochloric acid, and the extracts were purified on Oasis HLB columns (30 mg; Waters Corporation), conditioned with 1 mL methanol, 1 mL water, and 0.5 mL sodium phosphate buffer (pH 2.7). After sample application, the column was washed with 2 mL 5% methanol and then eluted with 2 mL 80% methanol. Eluates were evaporated to dryness and dissolved in 20 μL of mobile phase prior to mass spectrometry analysis using a 1290 Infinity LC system and a 6460 Triple Quad LC/MS system (Agilent Technologies; Novák et al., 2012).
Auxin Accumulation Assays
The assays were performed as described before in Petrásek et al. (2003). Auxin accumulation was measured in tobacco BY-2 cells (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv Bright Yellow 2; Nagata et al., 1992) or Arabidopsis T87 cells (ecotype Columbia 0; Axelos et al., 1992) 48 h (BY-2) or 96 h (T87) after subcultivation in 0.5 mL aliquots of cell suspension (target working cell density 7 × 105 cells × mL−1 (BY-2) as precisely determined by counting in the Fuchs-Rosenthal hemocytometer, and 20 mg FW × mL−1 (T87)). Cultivation medium was removed by filtration on 20 μm mesh nylon filters and cells were resuspended in uptake buffer (20 mM MES, 10 mM Suc, 0.5 mM CaSO4, pH adjusted to 5.7 with KOH) and equilibrated for 45 min on the orbital shaker at 27°C in darkness. Equilibrated cells were collected by filtration, resuspended in fresh uptake buffer, and incubated with continuous orbital shaking for another 90 min under the same conditions. Radiolabeled auxins [3H]-naphthalene-1-acetic acid ([3H]-NAA) and [3H]-2,4-dichlorophenoxy acetic acid ([3H]-2,4-D); specific (molar) radioactivity 20 Ci/mmol each; American Radiolabeled Chemicals) were added to the cell suspension to give a final concentration of 2 nM. At indicated time points, aliquots of cell suspension were sampled and accumulation of radiolabeled auxins was terminated by rapid filtration under reduced pressure on cellulose filters (22 mm in diameter). Cell cakes with filters were transferred into scintillation vials, extracted with ethanol (UV-spectroscopy grade) for 30 min and radioactivity was determined by liquid scintillation counting (Tri-Carb 2900TR Scintillation Counter; Packard Instrument). Counting efficiency was determined by automatic external standardization and counts were corrected for quenching automatically. Then counts were corrected for remaining surface radioactivity by subtracting counts of aliquots collected immediately after addition of radiolabeled auxin. Inhibitors were added as required from stock solutions to give appropriate final concentration and proper controls (solvent) were applied. All accumulation measurements were done at least in triplicate. Recorded accumulation values were recalculated to 1 million cells (BY-2) or to 10 mg FW (T87).
Auxin-Binding and Antiauxin Experiments Using Surface Plasmon Resonance
Auxin receptor proteins AtTIR1 and AtAFB5 were expressed in insect cells (T. ni High5) and purified as described previously in Calderón Villalobos et al. (2012) and Lee et al. (2014). The biotinylated degron peptide representing Aux/IAA7/14 was purchased from ThermoFisher Scientific and immobilized on streptavidin-coated SPR chips (GE Healthcare). SPR experiments were run as described previously in Calderón Villalobos et al. (2012) and Lee et al. (2014). Briefly, compounds were added to purified receptor proteins from stock solutions in DMSO to give working concentrations that were 50 μM unless stated otherwise (DMSO 0.1% final). Controls lacking auxin/compound and controls containing IAA (50 μM) were run as references at the start and end of every set of sensorgrams on every protein preparation. Compounds were run in three separate experiments, with characteristic results shown. For antiauxin runs, receptor proteins were mixed with 5 μM IAA plus compound at 50 μM. An antiauxin effect was then determined if the compound competed with IAA, reducing the amplitude of TIR1/AFB5 binding on the sensorgram.
Microsome Assay
The microsome assay was performed as described in Van de Wouwer et al. (2016).
Supplemental Data
The following supplemental materials are available.
Supplemental Figure S1. Effect of MDCA on germination of Arabidopsis.
Supplemental Figure S2. Metabolites with an altered abundance in 10 μΜ MDCA-treated Arabidopsis seedlings.
Supplemental Figure S3. UHPLC-MS based detection of PA + hexose and PA + malate in MDCA-treated Arabidopsis seedlings.
Supplemental Figure S4. Metabolites with an altered abundance in 10 μΜ MDCA-treated Arabidopsis seedlings.
Supplemental Figure S5. The impact of the MDCA-induced lignin reduction on the plant phenotype.
Supplemental Figure S6. Detection of SA in 10 μΜ MDCA-treated Arabidopsis seedlings.
Supplemental Figure S7. Chemical and physical characteristics and docking of MDCA for TIR1.
Supplemental Figure S8. Concentration of auxin and auxin metabolites after MDCA treatment of Arabidopsis seedlings.
Supplemental Figure S9. Concentration of auxin and auxin metabolites in the c4h mutant ref3-2.
Supplemental Figure S10. The impact of MDCA on auxin transport in suspension-grown Arabidopsis T87 cells.
We thank Victor Flors (Plant Physiology, Department of CAMN, Castellón 12071, Spain) and John Dean (DePaul University, Department of Biological Sciences, Chicago, IL 60614) for providing us with an aliquot of salicylic acid glucoside. In addition, we are grateful to Ottoline Leyser (Sainsbury Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 1LR) and Jeffrey Heyman (VIB Department of Plant Systems Biology, Universiteit Ghent) for providing us with p35S:iaaL and pERF115:GUS Arabidopsis seeds, respectively. Finally, we thank Wim Grunewald and Toon Babylon for technical support and Karel Spruyt for imaging assistance.
The author responsible for distribution of materials integral to the findings presented in this article in accordance with the policy described in the Instructions for Authors (www.plantphysiol.org) is: Bartel Vanholme (bartel.vanholme{at}psb.vib-ugent.be).
W.S. designed the experiments, performed most of the experiments, analyzed the data, and wrote the article; I.C. assisted in designing the experiments, provided technical assistance in plant phenotyping, and complemented the writing; P.K. performed the auxin accumulation assays; M.Q. performed (anti-) auxin-binding experiments and docking-analysis; R.V. and G.G. performed phenolic profiling; S.C. performed experiments and provided technical assistance in plant phenotyping; R.P.K. performed confocal microscopy together with W.S.; D.V.d.W. performed the C4H microsome assay and provided technical assistance in microscopy; O.N. did the auxin metabolite profiling; K.L., E.Z., and R.N. assisted in designing the experiments and complemented the writing; and B.V. and W.B. conceived the project, assisted in designing the experiments, supervised the experiments, and wrote the article.
↵1 This work has been supported by grants from the Hercules Foundation for the Synapt quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer (grant no. AUGE/014), by the Multidisciplinary Research Partnership "Biotechnology for a Sustainable Economy" (grant no. 01MRB510W) of Ghent University and the Stanford University Global Climate and Energy Project (Lignin Management: Optimizing Yield and Composition in Lignin-Modified Plants). R.V. and S.C. are indebted to the Research Foundation Flanders for a postdoctoral (grant no. 12B0412N) and a predoctoral (grant no. G032912N) fellowship, respectively, and W.S. and D.V.d.W. are indebted to the Agency for Innovation by Science and Technology in Flanders (I.W.T.) for a predoctoral fellowship. P.K. and E.Z. were supported by the Czech Science Foundation (project no. 16-10948S) and the EU Operational Programme Prague-Competitiveness (project no. CZ.2.16/3.1.00/21519). O.N. acknowledges the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport of the Czech Republic (the National Program for Sustainability I, grant no. LO1204) and the internal Grant Agency of Palacký University (grant No. IGA-PrF-2016-011). K.L. acknowledges the Swedish Governmental Agency for Innovation Systems and the Swedish Research Council. R.N. acknowledges the support of the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (grant no. BB/L009366), I.C. acknowledges the Foundation for Research of the State of São Paulo for the Young Investigators Awards research fellowship (grant 2015/02527-1), and R.P.K. acknowledges the VIB for the OMICS@VIB Marie Curie COFUND fellowship.
↵2 These authors contributed equally to this work and share last authorship.
↵[OPEN] Articles can be viewed without a subscription.
- Received December 18, 2015.
- Accepted August 3, 2016.
- Published August 9, 2016.


text:
It was good to welcome the Police Minister, Nick Hurd to Chelmsford. He came to meet the Chief Constable of Essex Police and to hear from police officers and staff as part of the Front Line Review. This is a very detailed piece of work looking at the pressures police face across the country. It makes clear recommendations about the need to continue increasing both the total number of police officers and to improve the support and equipment we give them. Another 74 new officers have just completed their training in Essex, so it was good to tell the minister about the local plans to increase the force. Officers told us of their experiences in recent anti-drugs gangs operations which led to the arrest of over 50 people across Essex. They also took the minister on a patrol through the City Centre.
Good news about our local NHS – the Mid Essex Clinical Commissioning Group which is responsible for planning our local health services including GP services has received a "Good" rating in a recent inspection. Broomfield, Basildon and Southend Hospitals have recently completed recruiting 300 new nurses. Well done to all and welcome to our new nurses!
I am delighted that Essex County Council has announced that all of Chelmsford's libraries will remain open. They are a vital part of our local communities. I have always been a massive supporter of local libraries and was very opposed to any suggestions of potential closures. Thank you to all those who worked so hard to campaign for our libraries, especially to Springfield and Galleywood Parish Councils and Anthony McQuiggan and Susan Sullivan who chaired the Parish Councils through much of this period.
Many people in Chelmsford care about the environment both locally and across the world. Over the past two years in Westminster I have been working with a group of MPs to set up the Conservative Environment Network. This has grown and grown. Last week we launched a detailed manifesto covering a wide range of different policy areas, from energy production to wildlife protection. The UK is the first major economy in the world to commit to end greenhouse gas emissions, "Net Zero" by 2050. Over the next few years we need to see the real policies that will make a difference. I look forward to making sure our next Prime Minister keeps up the focus on the environment.
At a recent rail conference in Chelmsford it was made clear that the project for our second railway station is now considered a strategic priority for the entire Great Eastern Mail Line, all the way from Liverpool Street to Norwich. The station will include a vital passing loop which will bring capacity for additional trains along the line. The funding bid is being reviewed by the Government.
I am very honoured to have been asked to join the board of Anglia Ruskin University which has been doing an exceptional job in Chelmsford. The state-of-the-art new Medical School opened last September and is already training 100 students to become doctors. It specialises in training GPs and metal health doctors which are so much needed in our area. This has been so successful that in the House of Commons I have been asking ministers to increase the number of doctor training posts. Anglia Ruskin University is also the third largest provider of degree apprenticeships in the country. The board member role is unpaid.

subset: commoncrawl


text:
RoxyVespa blog readers are the best!
I really appreciate all of you who have stopped by and those that have subscribed to this here little 'ol blog. I happen to believe that I have some pretty quality readers and feel really proud of that fact. (Subjective, I know, but you people are fabulous!) I recently had one of those fabulous readers, Glenn Barnett, send me these first two photos and thought I would share them with you all.
Here is his info, if you would like to connect:
email@example.com // http://convertassets.com/wanted.aspx
Nice ride!
He is a fellow Texan and joked about sending me some cheesy enchiladas. I miss Tex-Mex food so much right now, I might have even had one little glistening tear roll down my face at the thought of it all. Thanks Glen for your support and for connecting with me.
If you have any photos or come across any interesting Vespa-type culture in your own adventures out there and want to send them my way, I would love to see them! Just get in touch with me via email, email@example.com and I'll send a shout out to you here with your photo. Thanks everyone!
Happy riding y'all. Yeehaw! Have a lovely weekend!


text:
News just in from Simpson Marine of a $400,000 price cut on the 40.33 metre motor yacht Lady Arraya, jointly listed for sale with Northrop & Johnson.
Built by Australian superyacht yard Oceanfast to a design by Jon Bannenberg, Lady Arraya was delivered in 1990 and last refitted in 2003.
Formerly known as Opal C, she was one of the largest all-aluminium yachts in the world at the time of her launch. Easily recognisable by her large round windows, the spoiler on her stern makes her unique.
Lady Arraya has accommodation for eight guests in a master suite, VIP stateroom and two twin cabins, all with en suite bathroom facilities.
Her spacious saloon is very bright with natural daylight filtering through her large oval windows. There is a lounging area with comfortable sofas on the port side and to starboard there are very deep comfortable chairs facing the sea views. She also boasts a circular dining area surrounded by a semi-circular glass enclosure.
Powered by twin 3,480hp MTU engines linked to KaMeWa water jets, she has a range of 2,200 nautical miles at 12 knots. Lying in Thailand, Lady Arraya is down from $3.2 million to $2.8 million.


text:
You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser to improve your experience.
To ensure optimal security, this website will soon be unavailable on this browser. Please upgrade your browser to allow continued use of ACP websites.
Hundreds of curated CME and MOC activities that match your interests and meet your needs for modular education, many free to members.
Browse Activities
The most comprehensive meeting in Internal Medicine.
April 29-May 1, 2021
Internal Medicine Meeting 2021
Ensure you're board-exam ready with ACP's Board Prep Course Recordings—a multimedia, self-study program that delivers multiple study tools. Ideal for reviewing knowledge.
Board Prep Course Recordings: MOC
Treating a patient? Researching a topic? Get answers now.
Visit AnnalsLearn More
Visit MKSAP 18Learn More
Visit DynaMed
Billing and coding, accessing financial assistance, payer policies, and other updated guidance.
Practice Management during COVID-19
Offering guidance on clinical use cases, technology, regulations and waivers, and billing and coding.
Telehealth Resources
ACP advocates on behalf on internists and their patients on a number of timely issues. Learn about where ACP stands on the following areas:
© Copyright 2019 American College of Physicians. All Rights Reserved. 190 North Independence Mall West, Philadelphia, PA 19106-1572
800-ACP-1915 (800-227-1915) or 215-351-2600
Plan shifts from fee-for-service to set monthly rates for some groups, starting in 2020.
ACP takes aim at issues that confront physicians and patients.
Members urged to use their voice to make a difference for patients and physicians alike.
As part of the American Medical Association Opioid Task Force, the California Medical Association is asking physicians to complete two online surveys on optimal pain care and treatment for substance use disorders. The surveys, which aim to allow physicians to better understand and remove barriers to treatment, will close on Wednesday, May 8. Click here to access and complete the surveys.
Hospitals and practices interested in joining the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement (BPCI) Advanced Model starting in January 2020 can submit an application via the BPCI Advanced Application Portal now through June 24. For more information about the model and its requirements, or to download a Request for Applications document (RFA), the application template, and the necessary attachments, click here.
In a new ACP Advocate Blog post, Bob Doherty, SVP of Government Affairs and Public Policy, outlines what the new payment and delivery models unveiled by CMS mean for primary care physicians. To read the full blog post, click here.
ACP Advocate is copyrighted ©2019 by the American College of Physicians.


text:
The Alternative To Brauncewell Prostitutes.
The Alternative To Escorts. Women Looking For Sex In Your Local Area
Tired of Cold Disinterested Enounters?
The UKs Largest Married Dating Site. A discreet and confidential extra marital affairs dating service for women and men… Join Free Now! Brauncewell
Gorgeous lady available now in Brauncewell
Hi guys. My name is Diana. I LOVE what I do, and you will too (...) Brauncewell
Prostitutes Brauncewell
That night I slept in mama's bed, no we didn't fuck any more. That early morning after I took a long shower I drove over to my mommy's buddy Sandy's home.
I simply kept fucking this slut's ass, feeling her cunt leaking juice onto my slapping balls. I offered her a couple of more tough thrusts prior to I ripped my cock out, she dropped to her knees to satisfy me and I let my gush of orgasm blast her beautiful sweating face. She got my cock and milked every drop out onto her face.
She shook her head however I might inform she enjoyed the sensation of her ass on fire. I took my nails and scratched from her thighs up her ass, leaving 4 red lines up her curvy ass. Her mouth simply opened as if she was either taking in a deep breath or shouting escort agency Brauncewell, escort service Brauncewell, escort girl Brauncewell, mature escorts Brauncewell, adult escorts Brauncewell, cheap escorts Brauncewell, local escort Brauncewell, independent escorts Brauncewell.
Don't pay for Prostitutes Brauncewell - Meet with Fuck Buddies for sex insteead
When Sandy came to the door she was blushing and currently looked ashamed. Sandy was constantly a bit peaceful and shy however now she was looking at the flooring and hardly speaking loud enough for me to hear her. Thankfully mother had actually informed me what she desired.
In her normal peaceful way, "yes".
She simply stood there not moving. Now if you do not follow me I will penalize you.".
I have actually never ever had my cock in anything so hot and tight in the past. I kept spanking and squeezing that company ass as I tilled it raw. Her ass was hot and tight, and she would squeeze it even tighter every time I spanked her.
This got her attention. She was about my very same height however her heels made her tower over me, they likewise made her big ass sit completely on her legs and jerk when she strolled. I might not wait to make that ass jerk from humping.
Looking for Prostitutes in Brauncewell - Meet for sex for free
I didn't provide her any caution prior to I pushed the whole length of my tool directly into her cunt. I fucked her in long strokes feeling as much of her withins as I could. I got her ass as I pounded her, offering her difficult smacks every when in a while.
call girl Brauncewell, brothels Brauncewell, prostitutes Brauncewell, hookers Brauncewell, sluts Brauncewell, whores Brauncewell, gfe Brauncewell, girlfriend experience Brauncewell, shagging Brauncewell, dogging Brauncewell, fuck buddy Brauncewell, hookups Brauncewell, free sex Brauncewell, sex meet Brauncewell, nsa sex Brauncewell


text:
- View all products (0)
- Your cart is currently empty.
Aukey [CB-D16] [Apple MFI Certified] 1.2m Nylon Braided Lightning Cable
- PREMIUM QUALITY: Extra-Strong USB Lightning Cable with special tangle-free design, and woven nylon braid sleeve jacket for long-term, rugged durability.
- APPLE MFI CERTIFIED: 100% compatible with any lightning products, iPhone, iPad, iTouch. No more error messages.
- The AUKEY® Edge: High quality internal with thinker power wire increase charging speed up to 10%, more efficient and saves power.
- BUILT TO LAST: Eco-friendly premium materials, strengthened stress points, enhanced durability testing and safety technology ensure it outlasts most cables on the market.
- WHAT YOU GET: AUKEY® Premium 1.2m / 3.95ft Nylon Braided USB Cable with Lightning Connector, 18 Months worry-free warranty & 100% Customer Satisfaction.
Unmatched Performance
Enjoy super-fast charging, sync and data transfer delivered through Aukey 100% Apple MFI certified 3-in-1 lighting cable. This single cable solution is perfect for the home, office, hotel or car use, it's the only Lightning cable you'll ever need. Get it all: charge smarter, faster and safer every time.
Tough Evolved
Perfect for long term, heavy duty use, the cable features premium copper wire core wrapped in a special woven nylon braid sleeve jacket for enhanced tensile strength and the ultimate protection. Tangle-free and durable, enjoy high speed charging and high performance data sync/transfer. With safety technology for additional level of protection, dedicated heat-resistant connectors and rigorous stress testing processes for thousands of bends, this cable handles everything.
Compatibility Guaranteed
Compatibility is everything: this premium charge and sync cable is fully Apple® MFI-certified to guarantee compatibility with iPhone 6s Plus, 6s, 6 Plus, 6, 5S, 5C, 5, iPad Air 2, Air, iPad Mini, Mini 2, Mini 3, iPad 4th gen and iPod Nano 7th gen devices.
Compelling Design
Stylish and precision crafted, the minimalist form factor effortlessly is designed to complement your favourite Apple devices. Available in either black and white or gold and silver dual colors, the woven nylon fiber cable jacket is attractive as well as functional; highly flexible yet extremely durable, the design ensures maximum resistance to both breaking and tangling.
Get the Aukey® Edge:
18 Months worry-free warranty
24 hr dedicated email customer support
100% customer satisfaction
Premium quality, cutting edge technology at affordable prices


text:
– Fire bowl and stand
– Features cast iron fire bowl with steel stand
– Includes 1 fire bowl and 1 stand
– Designed to be a wood-burning fire pit
– Lightweight and portable
– Dimensions: 23.75″ diameter x 8.5″ H; 12.4 lbs
Spend a summer evening gathered around a crackling wood fire with this fire bowl and stand. Portable and lightweight, this fire bowl and stand are perfect to take along on the next camping trip or beach excursion. Constructed of fire-resistant cast iron, the fire bowl sits on top of a stylish geometric steel stand. This combo is easy to assemble; simply place the fire bowl on top of the stand. Just add firewood for a cozy backyard bonfire.
Sunnydaze Decor is a manufacturer of high-quality home and garden products. They travel the globe to find the most innovative and beautiful products for your interior and exterior living space. The goal is to provide you with products that truly calm, relax, and bring peacefulness into your life and home. Their talented designers create high end products using a manufacturing process and materials that leave you, the valued customer, with a beautiful addition to your home. They pride themselves on providing customers with a vast selection of products available in a variety of different colors and styles to ensure that you are able to find items and accessories that perfectly match the style and theme of your home's personality.
LIGHTWEIGHT AND PORTABLE: Outside firepit has a 23.75 inch diameter x 8.5 inches tall; Weighs 12.4 pounds; Fire bowl measures 23.75 inch diameter x 5.5 inches deep x 3.5 millimeters thick; Stand is 6.75 inches tall; Great to take outdoors along on camping trips, to the beach, or backyard barbecues for cooking and socialization
WELL-MADE: Small cast iron firebowl cauldron with high-temperature paint finish for fire resistance; Stand is made of iron for strength and stability; Safely enjoy the ambiance that a wood-burning fire can add to your backyard or outdoor living space
EASY TO ASSEMBLE: Bonfire pit set includes fire bowl and stand for simple assembly; Can be easily put together or taken apart; Simple assembly makes it effortless to store this fire bowl and stand for the winter or during inclement weather
CONTEMPORARY STYLING: Clean, simple lines of this fire bowl and geometric stand put the focus on the natural beauty of the fire inside; Works well with different styles of back yard outdoor decor
WORRY-FREE PURCHASING: Sunnydaze Decor backs its products with a 1-year manufacturer's warranty


text:
Successful music producers are ordinary people who do ordinary things and maintain daily schedules. They have telephones, email addresses, a social life and a network of friends. Their success depends upon meeting new people and finding up-and-coming talent. If you are a musician, band, filmmaker, writer or simply interested in meeting an important music producer, there are several ways to accomplish this.
Make connections in the music business. Networking and making contacts is a vital skill and strategy in the business world. The best way to meet important movers and shakers in the music industry is to have a common acquaintance introduce you.
Stay up-to-date on the music business, which ebbs and flows. Keep informed on the identities of major music producers. Read trade magazines and spend time perusing music industry websites. Sign up for Billboard's online newsletter that will keep you informed about all aspects of the business. Hitquarters.com provides names and contact information for music producers and record labels.
Attend charity events and music conferences. Be alert for opportunities to meet music producers. Seize those moments, but do not be a nuisance.
Send an email. Some music producers have websites listing their email addresses. Write a brief message describing who you are and the type of music you perform. Ask for a meeting or appointment. You may be surprised when they say yes.
Find out where they hang out. Utilize your music business connections to learn the nightclubs and other spots where the producers like to unwind. Go have a few drinks and take the opportunity to introduce yourself.
Don't be overbearing when you meet them. Be cool and casual. Develop a plan on what you want to say. You will have just a few minutes to make an impression.
Photo Credits
- bman_search image by Andrey Kiselev from Fotolia.com


text:
Steve Watson
Sept 4, 2012
Hacker group Antisec has leaked what it says is evidence that the FBI is actively monitoring the communications of every American using an iPhone.
The hackers released a statement Tuesday claiming that it had obtained detailed information on some 12 million iphone users, taken from an FBI agent's laptop.
The group, long associated with the more notorious Anonymous hacktivist organisation, released 1 million iOS device IDs to back up its claims.
With some identifying information removed, the data proves, according to Antisec, that
A more detailed passage in the statement notes:
During the second week of March 2012, a Dell Vostro notebook, used by Supervisor Special Agent Christopher K. Stangl from FBI Regional Cyber Action Team and New York FBI Office Evidence Response Team was breached using the AtomicReferenceArray vulnerability on Java, during the shell session some files were downloaded from his Desktop folder one of them with the name of "NCFTA_iOS_devices_intel.csv" turned to be a list of 12,367,232 Apple iOS devices including Unique Device Identifiers (UDID), user names, name of device, type of device, Apple Push Notification Service tokens, zipcodes, cellphone numbers, addresses, etc. the personal details fields referring to people appears many times empty leaving the whole list incompleted on many parts. no other file on the same folder makes mention about this list or its purpose.
"We have learnt it seems quite clear nobody pays attention if you just come and say 'Hey, FBI is using your device details and info'," the group states.
The full profanity laced AntiSec post can be read in full here.
Neither the FBI, nor Apple has commented on the leak.
If it is genuine, and there is no reason to believe it is not, this case once again goes to show that whether it be mandatory Homeland security alerts, wirelessly disabling your communications on a whim, or secretly tracking you where ever you go, the rise of smart phones brings with it a huge threat to privacy and the rights of the individual.
Again, this is another case not of smart phones and technology in general being intrusive, but of the technology being co-opted and abused by those who could care less for the constitutional rights of free Americans.
Below is a recent video detailing how two security researchers discovered that Apple's iPhone keeps track of a user's location and saves that information to a file that is stored both on the device and on a user's computer when they sync or back it up in iTunes.
The researchers, Pete Warden and Alasdair Allan, discovered the hidden file while collaborating on a potential data visualization project. "At first we weren't sure how much data was there, but after we dug further and visualised the extracted data, it became clear that there was a scary amount of detail on our movements," Warden told The Guardian.
As we reported at the time, the controversy was treated as a shocking revelation by the media, and yet since October 2001, the FCC has mandated that all wireless carriers track the location of their users down to within 50 feet.


text:
Positive School Culture Thrives When Relationships Abound –
By Jim Grout
I had an "Ah Ha" moment when I read a recent article titled What Makes a Good School Culture? It is written by Harvard's Leah Shafer and published under the column Usable Knowledge, Relevant research for today's educators. (https://www.gse.harvard.edu/news/uk/18/07/what-makes-good-school-culture) I encourage you to click the link and read the article – its value can't be understated. The article suggests that "…connections—strong and overlapping interactions among all members of the school community" are the key to shaping and maintaining a good school culture. That quote hits the mark in my mind. It seems like this is an intuitive concept, but for many reasons, that basic human skill of connecting with others is absent in so many settings and is in dire need of a reboot. It goes on to describe those interactions as beginning at the top, with the principal, and continuing down through and including the school's adult community, from administrators to teachers. This theory is solid but missing from the approach is an important constituency in the culture puzzle: the students. Why do students matter so much in the formation of a strong school culture?
Our experience at High 5 is that school culture begins in the classroom with the relationship between teachers and students. Forming a strong school culture includes a trickle-up process, in addition to a trickle-down. Can you remember a teacher from your past with whom you had a strong connection, someone who believed in your abilities when you didn't have the courage or capacity to believe in yourself? Teachers by nature want to care about their students. The result of this caring shapes the classroom culture. A good school culture will arise out of an environment where communication is open, and where behaviors that promote values like empathy, honesty, and good citizenship, are present in the room each, and every day. The Harvard article supports this contention as it clearly states, "Culture is Connections." A healthy partnership in learning between teachers, administrators, other adults in the academic community AND students, is the foundation and the ultimate measure of school culture.
For 5 years, High 5 has had the opportunity to partner with the SAU #29 Keene, NH school district to test our theories about school culture and to examine our findings in a real-world setting through our Edge of Leadership (EOL) Program. What began as a pilot program involving EOL and the 5th-grade classes of one elementary school, is now active in every school in the Keene district and has recently been approved for inclusion in the district's curriculum map, making it a permanent part of the educational experience.
EOL is an enhancement curriculum framework, combining social and emotional learning, leadership training and team-building activities. It has resulted in
statistically significant improvements in self-awareness, leadership skills, awareness of and respect for others and successful relationship building and collaboration. School attendance rates among those participating in the EOL program has increased, while disciplinary referrals for the same group have decreased by as much as 33%. As the quality and intentionality of interactions grow, the resulting classroom culture is one of increased opportunities for learning and decreased need for classroom management.
At High 5, we are working every day on groundbreaking ways to improve school culture and thereby improve the quality of education. It is the same recipe that we employ at High 5 to create an organizational culture that motivates people to work hard and stay true to our motto:
Connect – Empower – Lead…Be the Example!
To learn more about EOL click here to watch a short video=>https://youtu.be/0LD6ygQwNKg