system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
CMV: Mentally ill people that kill are inherently evil people.

I myself am mentally ill and have had voices tell me to do terrible things such as burn down a church, stab an aquatence, shoot up my old school.  I fought these voices and didn't do what they tried to convince me to do.  I told the voices it was wrong, and the closest I came was almost killing myself so the voices would stop.  I think the people that listen to the voices and kill were always evil people and they just used the voices as an excuse.  I'm open to changing my point of view, but currently I think if I told the voices no, why couldn't they?
gpt
I think that you are approaching this from a very specific viewpoint: that the people who are mentally ill and hurt people are doing so because they hear voices.  But there are a lot of different ways to be mentally ill, and pretty much every case of severe mental illness is unique.  For instance someone can also have visual hallucinations.  Are they an evil person if they stab someone who looks like a monster to them, and who they believe to be a monster?  Or a lot of people have paranoid delusions, which can lead them to take actions which they believe to be in self defense due to said delusions.  Do you think that's evil - to do hurt someone when you wholly and completely believe it is in self defense?