system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
if pi = circumference/diameter and if the circumference and diameter are whole numbers, then doesn't pi=p/q? then how is it considered irrational? or is this just an approximation?
gpt
If the diameter of a circle is a whole number, the circumference cannot be.  If the circumference of a circle is a whole number, the diameter cannot be. You will never find a circle where both the diameter and the circumference are both whole numbers.