system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
If American Republicans ran their own country how would the economy play out?

I guess I should expand further. 

What if half of America was divided as evenly and fairly as possible into a pure Democratic controlled country and a pure Republican controlled country? How would each of the economies differ?
gpt
I think this question just barely skirts the line between Rule V breaking and not. But in reply, this is a pretty garbage question. There's no elaboration at all. Economics can help you describe the effects of specific policies to at least some extent but this question requires a ton of details including but not limited to governmental style, geographic features, and location of the hypothetical country, actual policy details implemented, demographics, etc. This is why in our guide to asking good questions we recommend straying away from useless hypotheticals like these. The closer you can bring hypotheticals to concrete, the better answers you can expect.