system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
CMV: If Marvel makes Captain America 3 faithful to the Civil War comics, the movie will ruin the MCU

While I think the idea behind Civil War (should people with super abilities and/or powerful tools be regulated by the government)  is great and should be used in a movie, being faithful to the story of the comic won't make sense and will ruin a lot of the MCU. Here are the reasons while I believe that:

1.Secret identities just aren't a big deal in the MCU. Everyone knows who are the Avengers, and they were already with the government in a way (SHIELD). I don't see why it would be such a big deal that the government would have their personal information, specially because they already have that.

2.There aren't enough people to justify something like the Civil War. With Age of Ultron, we'll have what, two or three more super-beings? With Ant-Man it will be at least one more. And even if in the end we have a reverse House of M, with a bunch of people getting powers, it's not like they would all decide to run around fighting bad guys, so it wouldn't work having them taking one side or the other so strongly. How would an argument between a group of seven people turn into a war? It would make no sense.

3.Tony Stark is a dick in the comics. Even if you agree with his point of view, you can't deny that he was very unlikable by the end of the story, specially if you went after the tie-ins. Meanwhile, the character is the most popular thing in the MCU, and adapting the story faithfully would ruin this completely.

These aren't the only reasons, but they are my three strongest ones why I think a faithful Civil War movie would be terrible for the MCU. Yes, I know they aren't faithfully adapting anything so far, but Civil War was such a big event, and it can change so much, that I fear they'll try to follow the comic a lot more than before. And I've seen a lot of people arguing for this, so, change my view.
gpt
1. People may know the Avengers, but they don't know Cap, Hawkeye or Black Widow. They kind of need their secret identities. SHIELD ceased being "the government" after the events of Captain America 2 and is now a rogue undercover organisation. The USA doesn't have superheroes' identities.

2. There are superheroes introduced by the Agents of SHIELD canon. Minor ones, kind of "monster of the week" but enough to justify there being supers all over the place. It's not just the movies. And it's Marvel Comics. If you tell the audience "there are lots of superheroes now", they'll buy it.

3. He's a dick in the movies. He's just entertaining. And having people like both Cap and Iron Man allows for a more interesting story when they fight, tbf.