system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
It is said that if all human scientific discoveries were lost, they could be rediscovered; is this true of philosophy too?

Would humanity, supposing we lost all of our philosophical knowledge, rediscover the same philosophical concepts that we had before, or would something different arise?
gpt
Something different would arise. According to Hans-Georg Gadamer, the way we see the world and read the world is dependent on our culture and tradition. If we lost that tradition, we could not reconstruct the same tradition.

However, we could come up with some of the same concepts depending on your philosophical view. If you believe in Aristotelian natural law (that all knowledge is inscribed in nature) you could reason out the same concepts.

Thus the answer to your question depends on your point of view. If philosophy is a product of culture, then no. But if it is a product of nature, then yes.