system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
[Red Dead Redemption] Was Ditch always a fool and a madman?

In the "tutorial" area of the snowy mountains, Dutch will suggest that he and Arthur have already begun to drift, saying things like "I know you haven't liked my ideas as of late." When told about the botched robbery and the murder of a girl before the start of the game, Arthur says "That just don't sound like Dutch". Dutch also says to Hosea and Arthur somewhat jokingly, "I know you two like to talk about the good ol days and what's gone wrong with Dutch."

My question is: was Dutch always a madman and Arthur has only recently been able to question Dutch, or has Dutch recently been pushed to the brink with the recent spread of modernity and desperation to hold on to the power he once had?
gpt
The second. It's easy to keep people together when you're always succeeding and keeping your promises. In the wild frontier their casualties were low, their successes many, and hell even people were maybe liked them because they didn't often kill people in their daring robberies of rich people they didn't like.

That started to stop working and the entire game of Red-Dead 2 was the spiral you got to watch.