system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
[Star Wars] What makes someone a Jedi?

No one would argue that Luke isn’t a Jedi Master but he doesn’t even remotely seem to follow the Jedi Code, either by Canon or Legend standards. 
So I’m legitimately curious now- what makes someone a “Jedi”?
Luke feels emotions and has a family and all that stuff. By the old standards I don’t think they’d even let him train at the Temple. So how is he a Jedi?
Is it merely enough to just use the Light side of the force?
Is that it?
I’m sure you can be an asshole and still use the Light side as a tool but that’s beside the point- is it merely “being good” that makes you a Jedi? How is that a quantifiable standard across the whole of galactic history?

Is it just some self-identification or something?
gpt
Jedi is a philosophy, and one which can have different interpretations as time goes by.

Some general points are:

- Force user

- Serenity, peace

- Following the will of the Force


But there are quite a few ways to interpret that. Do you fight to defend life? Do you act passively? Do you become a hermit and meditate? Do you forsake all attachment, because it might lead to clouded judgment? Do you forsake all passion, or do you use some of it, carefully controlled?