system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
[Warhammer 40K] How are there chapters of unknown origin, given the practice of sending geneseed tithes to the Adeptus Mechanicus; also, what happens if a loyal chapter is found to be descended from a traitor legion?

There are many Space Marine chapters whose origin is officially "unknown," even discounting the Blood Ravens and the Storm Wardens, which were left up in the air to make things more intriguing for players of the respective games.  However, this is logically inconsistent with the lore.  In the fluff, all chapters are required to send geneseed samples ("tithes") to the Adeptus Mechanicus to screen for mutations, ensure purity, and keep as a reserve stock for founding future chapters.  

Geneseed is a highly controlled, deeply-analyzed substance, arguably one of the Imperium's most valuable strategic resources...do the Adeptus Mechanicus simply lack the ability to compare geneseed from chapter X to known primarch geneseed lines?  It seems to me that the origin of all chapters would be confirmed with every single geneseed tithe.

If this is the case, what would happen to a chapter that is discovered to be descended from a traitor primarch?  Are they declared excommunicatus traitoris/hereticus and purged by the Inquisition?  

I did a quick search, and didn't see this question anywhere...my apologies if I missed something obvious.
gpt
Chapters who know they will have trouble with the Mechanicus and the Inquisition either:


1) Buy the favour of the Mechanicus (Hi there Magos we would love to go on an expedition to help recover some lost technology/kill some tech heretics with you)

2) Position themselves far, far away from any watchful eyes (Can't send any gene seed tithes, we are two years away by Battle Barge) 

3) Make themselves so important that anyone important enough to know about genetithes also knows that it would be troublesome to despatch enough Astartes to kill them without hurting any current war effort that they are involved in 

4) Become besties with a Chapter who have clean and plentiful Geneseed and get them to give you some to send to the Mechanicus. Risky tactic though as that Chapter can out you anytime they want at little risk to themselves by just accusing you of stealing the seed from them


5) Kill anyone who calls them a Heretic. The Astartes go around dispatching the Emporers Justice from one end of reality to the other. This Mech goon only ever stands around calling people Heretics, who is more important?