system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
ELI5: I tore my ACL/MCL years ago and it still affects me - What's really going on in my knee?

I tore my knee up playing soccer - got hit from the side when I was 18, felt/heard a pop and it swelled up like crazy. Went to osteo and was told that, since I didn't play school sports, I should just rehab it myself (those people are complete DOUCHE BAGS). 

It is a wobbly joint, feels loose, and I've retore it at least three times and it has 'slid around' many more than that without anything drastic occurring. 

What's going on inside my knee? ELI5!

EDIT: Thank you so much for your answers - really helpful, both medical and personal experience. I lost count of how many times I've 'tweaked' it. I used to be extremely active but now live a more cautious lifestyle. I love sports, but definitely feel limited. Likely going to speak to an Ortho specialist and see what my options are. Again, thanks all.
gpt
Sports doc here.  The ACL helps stabilize the two load bearing bones of the leg.  That wobbly feeling is likely the bones actually sliding on one another, which is a major risk for a meniscus tear (the cartilage shock absorbing discs) on top of what you already have.  Some people can live without an ACL which is why most orthopods will consider conservative management ( non-operative) first.  You clearly are one who cannot.  

You should get another eval, most surgeons would fix your ACL now.  I'd be willing to bet after the secondary injuries that you've got meniscal damage too which is ready enough to address during the arthroscopy (knee scope).  Your MCL has probably scarred in already as these rarely need fixed.  

Tl:dr. Perfectly reasonable to get your knee fixed and most orthopedic surgeons wouldn't hesitate to iterate on you at this point.