system
Given the following post, respond as if you're commenting on Reddit:
human
[Lord of the Rings] What if, when Isildur refused to destroy the Ring, Elrond had straight up thrown him into the volcano?

I’m sure there would be repercussions, assuming Elrond couldn’t lie his way out of it, but would those repercussions really be worse than all the war and darkness that came of allowing Sauron to endure for millennia longer?
gpt
Human and Elves would go to war, no question about it. Tens of thousands would die, the elves either killed off or driven West, and Man would forever despise the Valar and their servants.

Perhaps the world would be a better place, but then again perhaps hundreds of years later some foolish King would try to sail west for vengeance again.