Thursday, November 10, 2016

Will Trump Kill the Core

Apparently one more side effect of Trumpocracy will be the revival of half-baked, ill-informed writing and bloviating about Common Core. Let me do my part to add to that.

Trump has, of course, promised to rid the world of Common Core, even though he has no idea what it is, what's in it, how it works, or how it is implemented. This may well actually happen when pigs fly. But this is the perfect cue for writers like, apparently, NPR's Cory Turner to redistribute some of the same misinformation about the Core.

In "Can President Trump Get Rid of Common Core," Turner brings back the old fiction about where the Core came from:

The Common Core standards were developed by governors and state school superintendents and adopted at the state level. They were not created by the Obama Administration or forced on states. Indeed, several states chose not to make the switch. That said, President Obama did use federal dollars, through the Race to the Top program, to encourage (critics prefer "coerce") states to adopt new, more rigorous standards. And, in the throes of a downturn, that extra school money was a powerful enticement.

Actually, I prefer "blackmail" or "extort," but I suppose "coerce" is politer. It's certainly shorter than, "Either you implement my programs or I use your inevitable and unavoidable violation of No Child Left Behind laws to cut off your federal financial support." But the Common Core Standards were most certainly not developed by governors and state school superintendents. They were written by a handful of education amateurs, pushed by Bill Gates and other well-connected amateurs, financed by many of those same folks, and adopted by states under so much political pressure that some states didn't even wait for the standards to be finished.

Turner fails to talk to anyone outside the circle of Gates-funded Core backers (Achieve, the Fordham Foundation) and when he turns to a critic (Neal McClusky, Cato Institute) still stays within the conservative thinky tank sphere.

What Turner gets right is the effect of the Every Student Succeeds Act (the NCLB replacement) which is pretty firm and direct in forbidding federal meddling in state educational issues. Of course, ESSA still comes down hard for "college and career ready standards," a phrase which is to Common Core what "states' rights" is to segregation.

But the real problem, which folks on at least two sides of this hydra-headed debate fail to acknowledge, is that "Common Core" no longer means a damn thing. It is a term that is only slightly less vague than "Education stuff" and is used to refer to a dozen different versions of standards, the completely different standards being tested on Big Standardized Tests, the completely different sets of standards being pushed in "Common Core" textbooks, and the completely different sets of standards being touted by traveling consultants and college professors. Plus, all the versions that are now hiding in plain sight under an assumed name.

At this point you can't drive a stake through Common Core's heart because it is a vague and diaphanous cloud of toxic mist.

And, as Turner reports, Trump is already slinking away from his pledge. Asked about it by EdWeek, transition team education guy Gerard Robinson had this strong, ringing statement to make--

To be determined. But he will expect his secretary of education to have something to say about common core

Something to say!! Hoo boy-- I bet the Common Core is shaking in its invisible boots right now

Common Core needs to be rooted out, stomped flat, and burned with fire. But none of those things will be accomplished by people who don't even know what they're talking about. Perhaps Trump will appoint someone with real education expertise and knowledge to the secretary position. And perhaps pigs will fly out of my butt.


  1. I am as skeptical as you about the chance of Common Core's expiring on the beach like a Portuguese Man of War no longer able to sting with its filmy tentacles, but I can hope Trump will get it. Not his highest priority, of course.

  2. Junior's comments about education at the convention convinced me that Trump and his kid advisors have no idea about education, period. But they love them some reformy ideas about privatizing education via charterization.

  3. If Trump wants to kill the Core he will have to hunt it down. I suggest the ash heap of smoldering education fadures.

  4. Don't recall Hillary Clinton coming out against charters. Did I miss something?

  5. The policy advisors in the Trump administration will only care about money. It will be a combination of the Reagan and George W. Bush policies on taxes and regulation. They will cut taxes and get rid of many environmental, business, and labor laws. They will try to privatize everything. They will try to get public money flowing to cronies and private business. The rich are going to get richer, and the rest of us are going to get stuck with the bill in terms of much higher annual deficits and a growing national debt.

    They won't even mention the words Common Core. They won't care. Their education policy will center on charters and vouchers: privatization. And Trump will be so busy tweeting that he won't be in charge of anything. He'll just let the Republican insiders run the show. It has already started. He is already tweeting and the Republican insiders, especially from the Heritage Foundation, are taking over his transition team. It was all just big con. Sad.