Archive for the ‘Intellectual Property’ Category


Wednesday, September 17th, 2014

By Thomas C. Grella






What You Can Learn From My Summer Vacation

Wednesday, August 21st, 2013

By Sabrina Presnell Rockoff

Our second August post comes from the Chair of our Labor & Employment Team, Sabrina Presnell Rockoff. Sabrina has her own regular blog where she discusses human resources topics at

Well, it happened. This morning we woke up earlier; the sun rose (or I’m assuming it did somewhere despite the rain); we dropped right back into the routine of eating bowls of cheerios at the kitchen bar; we sat through the car pool line; and just like that—school started again. In classrooms all over the country over the next three weeks, kids are going to be asked in one form or another to share what they learned over summer vacation. In homage to this decades-old ritual, I want to share something you can learn from my summer vacation.

The first weekend in August my husband and I took a trip to Nashville, Tennessee –our own three day “grown up” vacation. I had never spent a lot of time in Nashville, and as a fan of great, old country music, I was mesmerized. We visited the Country Music Hall of Fame, the Ryman Auditorium, the Johnny Cash Museum, and the famous bar Tootsies, where Hank Williams, Sr., would go to drink in between Opry sets (sometimes he made it back for the second set; sometimes, he didn’t). By Saturday at noon, all of the restaurants and bars along the main drag were hopping with live bands. We ducked in and out of several places, hearing everything from original music to songs made famous by Alabama, Little Big Town, Merle Haggard, and Buck Owens.

As I happily sang along off-key with each band, I had two thoughts: 1) I wonder if this place is correctly applying the tip credit for those bartenders (perhaps a post for another day); and 2) I wonder who has the license for that music and if this bar should be allowing that band to play that song. This isn’t exactly an employment law topic, but it is a serious one that you should consider if you have an establishment that allows any type of live music or that plays canned music for your patrons. Whether you are a restaurant or bar with a Friday night cover band or a dentist office that plays music in the waiting room for patients, you could be in violation of copyright laws and not even realize it. Based on recent past experience, even if you don’t realize you are in violation, the companies that own the copyrights to the music may—and legally, your ignorance is no excuse from statutory copyright violations.

Federal copyright laws regulate when copyrighted music can be played for the advantage of a business. If you have a cover band or play other music for your customers, even if they are not directly paying you for the chance to listen to the music, you may still be considered to be playing the music for your own financial benefit as a business owner and/or operator. If you have such music playing in your place of business without having the proper license for the music, you may be in violation of the copyright laws, which provide for statutory damages and attorneys’ fees. The federal copyright laws also allow, in certain situations, for personal liability by the owner/operator, regardless of the corporate structure of the entity involved.

All well and good you may say, but practically speaking, how are these laws enforced? The companies that own the copyrights (just a handful own most copyrights to popular songs) are charged with protecting their rights. So these companies hire individuals to go into places with live music or with canned music that the companies know do not have licenses to play their music. These individuals write down each song they hear played and report that back to the companies. The companies then file a lawsuit. Think it can’t happen to you? It is happening in Asheville, Charlotte and Raleigh.

So what should you do? If you play canned music, for example through a cable music channel, ensure that you have the proper license through the company providing the channel to play the music for customers. If you have live music, either restrict the music that can be played in your establishment to the original music of the musician or negotiate a license from the major music copyright holders. You should also have live music acts sign agreements regarding what licenses they hold and the type of music they agree to play or not to play. These agreements are not an absolute defense to a copyright violation claim, but could be helpful. The federal copyright laws are very specific. Before attempting to review your current agreements or draft new ones, you should consult legal counsel. At our Firm   Rick Jackson  focuses in this area of the law and can help you determine the best way to protect yourself and respect the copyright laws.

Meanwhile, if you would be excited, as I was, to see Bobby Bare sing “(Margie’s at) the Lincoln Park Inn” at the Grand Ole Opry live, we should talk music sometime!