{'fraction_non_alphanumeric': 0.033340514919745774, 'fraction_numerical': 0.023860820855326943, 'mean_word_length': 4.8719165085389, 'pattern_counts': {'":': 0, '<': 1, '<?xml version=': 0, '>': 0, 'https://': 0, 'lorem ipsum': 0, 'www.': 0, 'xml': 0}, 'pii_count': 0, 'substrings_counts': 0, 'word_list_counts': {'cursed_substrings.json': 0, 'profanity_word_list.json': 0, 'sexual_word_list.json': 0, 'zh_pornsignals.json': 0}}
The Use of Chlorella Vulgaris to Accumulate Magnesium under Different Culture Conditions

We investigated magnesium (Mg 2+ ) ion uptake by Chlorella vulgaris under mixotrophic growth conditions (10 g/L of glucose) in a stirred photo-bioreactor. The culture nitrate and glucose consumption was followed during the experiments. C. vulgaris grew autotrophically, without glucose consumption, until the end of the exponential growth phase and the exhaustion of nitrate. The glucose was then rapidly consumed during the transition phase into the stationary growth phase. The cellular chlorophyll a concentration decreased during exponential growth, indicating a decrease of photosynthetic activity and adaptation to heterotrophic metabolism, then remained low and constant until the end of the experiment. The partition of magnesium between the culture medium, the cell surface and within the cells was determined throughout the experiment. A clear relationship between the microalgal concentration and Mg 2+ ion removal extent from the medium was observed. The removal rate was faster during mixotrophic growth than autotrophic growth and was related to the high biomass production under the latter culture conditions. The Mg 2+ concentration per gram of dry biomass was 3.44 mg/g under heterotrophic conditions and 6.0 mg/g under autotrophic growth. At the end of the experiment (330 h), 90 % of the initial magnesium (17.7 mg/L) in the medium was associated with the biomass, of which 4% was adsorbed and 86% absorbed by cells. This study was consistent with the kinetic model based on a reversible first-order reaction for Mg 2+ bioaccumulation in C. vulgaris . Mixotrophic growth conditions can be used at industrial scale to increase Mg 2+ uptake by microalga in a shorter period of time.


Introduction
The autotrophic green microalgae C. vulgaris can grow heterotrophically if presented with a suitable organic carbon source [1,2,3,4], or mixotrophically by simultaneous autotrophic and heterotrophic metabolisms [2,5]. C. vulgaris can use a number of organic carbon sources such as glucose or acetic acid. Glucose and other organic substrates can stimulate the growth of this alga in the presence or the absence of light [6,7,8]. This is not particularly surprising since the capacity for heterotrophic, photoheterotrophic and mixotrophic growth exists in many species of green algae [9].
Microalgae cultures offer a wide industrial application and a possible solution to some environmental problems [10,11] due to their ability to absorb CO2 [12], take up various nitrogenous compounds [13,14] and assimilate metals [11,15].
We have previously reported that C. vulgaris is not inhibited by up to 500 mg/L Mg 2+ ions and that the alga could accumulate a relatively large amount of Mg 2+ [16,17]. This metal is essential for photosynthesis as it occupies the core of the chlorophyll molecule and influences the activity of various photosynthetic enzymes [18]. The large Mg 2+ accumulation amount renders C. vulgaris of industrial interest for the recovery/elimination of useful metals such as magnesium from aqueous media.
One aim of this study was to examine the way in which C. vulgaris grew under mixotrophic growth conditions by providing it simultaneously with two energy sources, light and glucose, and two carbon sources, CO2 and glucose. A second aim was to investigate the magnesium accumulation (extracellular and intracellular) under these conditions and to further investigate the validity of the previously reported model for the Mg 2+ biomass-association under autotrophic conditions [16].
The intended application of this study is to enrich C. vulgaris with magnesium for cosmetic purposes.

Microorganism and growth medium
The strain Chlorella vulgaris CCAP211/e 11B (trebouxiophycae) was obtained from the Culture Collection of Algae and Protozoa, CCAP (UK). The growth medium used was the modified 3N-Bristol medium [12,19], in which the sole nitrogen source is nitrate at a concentration of 547.03 mg/L. The glucose concentration of 10 g/L was added to the medium prior to sterilisation. The base Mg 2+ ion concentration was enriched to approximately 18 mg/L in order to compare with previous autotrophic culture of C. vulgaris at the same Mg 2+ concentration [17].
The culture temperature was maintained at 25 °C by circulating water through a jaketed vessel (Figure1). Continuous aeration with sterile air (0.2 µm Sartorius gas filter) at 500 mL air/min (1 atm. 25 °C) was used to supply both oxygen and CO2 to the culture. The inlet and outlet airflow rates were measured daily.
The sterile medium was inoculated with a shake-flask (50 mL in 250 mL flask) culture of C. vulgaris at the end exponential growth (72-96 h). The inoculum volume constituted 1 % (v/v) of the bioreactor working volume (5 L), which gave a cell concentration of 2 × 10 6 cells/mL at the beginning of the experiment. The inoculum was prepared in the same medium as that used in the bioreactor (MBM medium containing 10 g/L of glucose).

Analytical techniques 5.3.1. Growth measurement
Three methods were used to measure the biomass concentration: absorbance at 800 nm; cell count; dry weight biomass concentration.
The cell number per liquid volume was determined by counting the cells using a microscope (Carl Zeiss axioplan imaging 2, Germany) and a Thomas counting chamber of 0.1 mm depth. The absorbance (A800) of the algal cultures was measured at 800 nm (Spectrophotometer Cary 300 Scan UV-visible, Varian Inc., Netherlands) after appropriate dilution. The cell viability was measured using a GUAVA easyCyte™ flow cytometer (Merck Millipore, France) with the ViaCount (14-0155) method.
The dry weight (DW) biomass concentration (g/L) was determined by the following method. The culture sample was first centrifuged (10 minutes, 1800 g). The pellet was washed through resuspension in an equal volume of deionized water and centrifuged again (10 minutes, 1800 g). The resulting pellet was transferred into a dry pre-weighted ceramic thimble and heated (24 h, 105 °C) in an oven. After drying, the thimble was weighed.
In order to follow the growth rate, three samples (10-15 mL) were removed daily from the bioreactor during the exponential growth phase (0-74 h) and only one sample a day was analysed in the other growth phases.

Determination of the Glucose concentration
Glucose consumption was followed by measuring glucose concentration in the culture medium (supernatant) obtained from all the samples. This measurement was performed with a High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC) (Ultimate 3000, column: HPX-87H). A total pressure of approximately 870 psi at 45 °C was applied. The eluent was sulphuric acid (2 mM). All samples were first filtered through 0.2 µm and C18 columns to retain all particles and proteins that could influence the HPLC analysis.

Determination of the Nitrate concentration
The NO3 -analyses were performed by ionic chromatography using a Dionex AS11-HC column installed in a Class 10.000 clean room under the following conditions: system Dionex DX-500, column (CR-ATC, P/N 060477) (4 mm) with a guard column AG11-HC and a total pressure of 2.300 psi at 30 °C, conductimetric detector CD20. The eluent (KOH) concentration was 30 mmol/L at 1.5 mL/min.

Determination of the chlorophyll concentration
Triplicate samples were removed daily from the bioreactor in order to extract and calculate the cellular chlorophyll a concentration during the experiment according to method of Porra [20].

Determination of the magnesium ion concentration
An Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer (Hitachi Z-2300, Japan) was used in order to measure the Mg 2+ ion concentration using an air-acetylene flame and by measuring the absorbance at a The use of Chlorella vulgaris to accumulate magnesium under different culture conditions 5 wavelength of 202.6 nm with the specific magnesium lamp (Agilent technologies, France). The standard deviations for the calibration curve (0.15 to 20.0 mg/L) were in the range 1 to 2 %.
The sample dilutions were carried out with Milli Q water acidified with HCl (pH < 3) to prevent metal precipitation. The calibration solutions were prepared from 1000 mg/L magnesium stock solution (Fischer scientific) and measured 5 times in order to determine the precision of the analysis.

Estimation of adsorbed and absorbed magnesium concentrations
The concentrations of adsorbed (extracellular) and absorbed (intracellular) magnesium were determined by the procedure described by Franklin et al. [21] and Ma et al. [22] with minor modifications as published in our previous work [16].

Magnesium Bioaccumulation Modelling
A reversible reaction of first order with respect to the magnesium concentration in the culture liquid was assumed for Mg 2+ ions uptake by cells. This model has been already published with all details [16]. The model is given by the following Equation (1): Where k.a is the kinetic constant, the concentrations C, C0 and Ceq are the Mg 2+ ion concentrations at times: t, t0 and at equilibrium respectively (mg/L).

Results and Discussion
6.1. Algal growth characteristics in a stirred photo-bioreactor C. vulgaris was grown independently and in duplicate in stirred photo-bioreactor cultures under mixotrophic conditions in order to investigate magnesium accumulation. Each experiment lasted 310 h. The initial glucose and Mg 2+ ion concentrations were 10 g/L and 17.7 mg/L in medium, respectively. The absorbance A800, the cell concentration Nb (number of cells/mL) and the dry weight concentration DW (g/L) were measured daily except during the exponential growth phase where they were measure three times per day. These three growth parameters showed a satisfying degree of proportionality for the duplicate experiments ( Figure 2), and confirmed the results of Rocha et al. [23] "Corrected absorbance" refers to the absorbance measured with diluted samples and multiplied by the dilution factor.
The following correlations were obtained: The dry weight of an average individual C. vulgaris cell was calculated and found to remain constant at 1.0×10 -11 g throughout the experiments, which corresponds to published values for this alga [24].
Cell viability remained at 96 ± 2% throughout the experiments.
The growth curves under both autotrophic (765 h) and mixotrophic (310 h) culture conditions are presented in the same Figure (Figure 3). The specific growth rate (µ) for the culture was determined The cell concentration after 310 h of culture was higher (A800 = 23 corresponding to 8.8 × 10 8 cells/mL) in mixotrophic growth conditions than the biomass concentration obtained (A800=5 corresponding to 2 × 10 7 cells/mL) after 765 h of autotrophic culture in the photo-bioreactor ( Figure  3). These results are in good agreement with Lee et al.
[27] which investigated the mixotrophic growth (glucose 18 g/L) of Chlorella sorokiniana) and reported a higher cell concentration compared to autotrophic growth. For mixotrophic culture conditions, glucose and nitrate (NO3 -) concentrations were measured (Figure 4). Figure 4 shows that no significant consumption of glucose was observed during the exponential growth phase; this demonstrates autotrophic growth during this growth phase. The end of the exponential growth phase coincided with nitrate exhaustion, suggesting a limitation of growth by nitrogen. Three growth phases can be observed: exponential, transition and stationary phases. During the transition phase, glucose was rapidly removed from the growth medium suggesting mixotrophic growth. The exhaustion of glucose corresponded approximately to the start of the stationary phase as the cell concentration became stable. C. vulgaris exhibited a preference for autotrophic growth as long as nitrogen was available but after complete nitrogen exhaustion, glucose consumption occurred. There were slight differences in glucose consumption and cell growth between the duplicate experiments during the transition phase; elsewhere the repeatability between the experiments was very high.
The average cellular chlorophyll a content (mg chlorophyll a per g DW) decreased sharply during the exponential phase and remained approximately constant at a low value afterwards ( Figure 5). This could be explained firstly by the decreasing of nitrates concentration in the medium that influence the chlorophyll production and secondly by the change of cell physiology upon glucose metabolism. This behaviour was also observed by Illman et al.
[28] and Li et al. [29] for the same microorganism in mixotrophic cultures. In this study, after exponential growth, the cellular chlorophyll content decreased to a constant value of 5× 10 -11 mg/cell. According to Kong et al.

Dissolved Mg 2+ ion concentration
The dissolved and biomass-associated Mg 2+ ion concentrations (adsorbed and absorbed) were measured early on (74 h), in the middle (170 h) and at the end (310 h) of the experiment. Each measurement was performed in triplicate.
From the dissolved Mg 2+ ion concentration the removal yield from the growth medium was calculated (C0-C)/C0 and plotted against the time of culture ( Figure 6). A relationship emerged between Mg 2+ ion removal from the medium and the biomass growth.
Magnesium removal continued even after the end of the exponential phase until almost total removal ( Figure 6). Mg 2+ ion uptake continued during the heterotrophic growth phase; the uptake of this ion did not seem to be only related to chlorophyll synthesis. Mg 2+ ion is also implicated in the activation of glycolytic enzymes for glucose metabolism [31].

Biomass associated magnesium ions
The adsorbed and absorbed (extracellular and intracellular) Mg 2+ ion increased during the experiment (Figure 7), the amount of absorbed Mg 2+ ion was always greater than the amount that was adsorbed. By the end of the experiment (310 h), 90 % of the initial Mg 2+ ion content (17.7 mg/L) of the medium had been taken up by C. vulgaris, of which 4 % of the total Mg 2+ ions had been adsorbed on the cell wall and 86 % had been absorbed into the cells. The calculated magnesium mass balances accounted for 97±2.0 % of the initial amounts of the ion (Figure7).
Compared with our previous publication [17], the accumulation of magnesium by algae in mixotrophic culture was lower than that in autotrophic culture. At the end of the experiment (310 h), C. vulgaris absorbed on average 3.44 mg of Mg 2+ ions per g of dry biomass whereas in autotrophic photo-bioreactor cultures (765 h), 6.0 mg were absorbed per g of dry cell weight. In terms of volumetric productivity and efficiency of accumulation from the medium, of course the mixotrophic conditions provide and advantage.
It is then effective strategy to use autotrophic followed by heterotrophic conditions to produce more biomass and to maximize Mg 2+ ion uptake.
As an interpretation, the Mg 2+ bioaccumulation mechanism is as a result of a coupling between biochemical reactions and mass transfer. The external transfer of Mg 2+ from the solution to the algae depends essentially on the hydrodynamics and the biochemical reactions largely depend on the cells physiology and the growth limitations (light…). A greater extent of growth would present a larger surface area though which transfers could occur.

Model for Mg 2+ ion accumulation by C. vulgaris
The experimental results were plotted versus the predicted model curve (Figure 8). They fitted well with the exponential model for magnesium uptake by C. vulgaris confirming its applicability.
These results were in good agreement with our previous published work [16], where we developed an exponential model for the Mg 2+ ion uptake by C. vulgaris in shake-flask autotrophic cultures with different initial Mg 2+ ion concentrations (8.9-465 mg/L). Two differences were found with our previous work [16,17]; firstly Ceq seems to be negligible and secondly Mg 2+ ion uptake starts after a lag time of 45 h from the start of the experiments. This shows that the majority of the ion is accumulated while growth occurs under heterotrophic conditions. In other words, the exchange surface produced by the greater growth brought about by heterotrophic growth dominated the Mg 2+ ion adsorption and absorption phenomena.
This model described well the Mg 2+ ion uptake by C. vulgaris. Future experiments will be performed to explore Mg 2+ ion uptake under different glucose and initial Mg 2+ ion concentrations and to find suitable explanations for the different behaviours observed in this study.

Conclusion
The biomass production of C. vulgaris under mixotrophic conditions was significantly higher than in autotrophic cultures. The nitrate exhaustion brought about the end of the exponential phase and it coincided with the start of glucose consumption; there was nevertheless no direct evidence of true The use of Chlorella vulgaris to accumulate magnesium under different culture conditions 8 mixotrophy where glucose and CO2 would be incorporated into the biomass simultaneously. C. vulgaris adopted an autotrophic metabolism before the exhaustion of the nitrogen source even in the presence of glucose. The specific growth rate was 0.056 h -1 close to that reported by Perner Nochta et al.
[26] at 0.058 h -1 for the same strain in a batch tubular bioreactor culture. The chlorophyll a was an indicator of photosynthetic activity and was followed during the experiment. Starting with an initial Mg 2+ ion concentration of 17.7 mg/L in the growth medium, C. vulgaris accumulated 3.44 mg of Mg per g of dry biomass under mixotrophic growth and 6.0 mg of Mg 2+ per g of dry biomass under autotrophic growth. Mg 2+ ion removal by biomass from growth medium was directly related to the cell concentration and physiology. During autotrophy, the cells need magnesium to synthesize chlorophyll for photosynthesis, so they accumulate a larger amount of magnesium. In contrast, during heterotrophic growth less Mg 2+ is required by the cells as they switch to using glycolysis and respiration. The micro-organism showed a preference for autotrophic growth even in the presence of glucose. Later on during the experiment, there was no evidence for mixotrophic growth although this could not be excluded neither. The duplicate experiments were highly reproducible, throughout the entire duration of the experiments (310 h) and for all the different parameters measured. This study supported our previous results [16,17]       The use of Chlorella vulgaris to accumulate magnesium under different culture conditions 14