Male neutering

Re: Spay Early or Spay Later

I have 11 month old male named Leo. He is 25lb and 16inch tall. And my vet says it should be neutered. So I am researching pros and cons. Mostly confusing and conflicting opinions. Instead of neutering is there an option of vasectomy? Does this eliminate all cons of neutering?
How long should we wait for Leo?

There are so many different opinions on this subject.... most all Vets in the US say neuter/spay... in Europe, the opposite. In the end, your choice with what you are most comfortable with. With my litters I do recommend/require neutering on pet placements usually by age 1 1/2

Basenji NOVA Meetup?


I have a 25lb Male who will be 1yr on the 27th. I don't plan on getting him neutered. I will not be breeding him either. He is a house dog and is always on a leash when outside. I see no need for neutering from that standpoint. He doesn't mark in my house and has not made any mistakes in the house since he was three months old. There will obviously be differing opinions on the issue. Do your research.

I have had 2 neutered over the years. IMO, before neutering, they think they are tough, they know all, and everyone should hold them in the highest esteem. After neutering, they were easier to live with, all that went away, and their true, sweet selves were allowed to shine!

I had always heard, and agree, that the best pets are neutered males.

That being said, I placed a spayed female into a home. A WONDERFUL, WONDERFUL, home. A few years later they wanted another, and after talking to them, I placed a male pup in their home, with no agreement to neutered. They were in their 60's, he was a retired sheriff, and I live in farm country where a lot of older men don't like castrating any males they don't have to.
He LIKED the bullheadedness of the intact male, the obstinance, the 'I'm the king!!!' attitude. I was completely sure there would not be a problem, and there never was.

In almost 39 years with Basenjis, I have NEVER neutered a male and never will. We sold our pups on 'do not neuter without good health / better quality of life' conditions in old age, terms.

My objections are manifold. It doesn't calm aggression, it can cause weight gain and lethargy, why mutilate a perfectly normal dog you have taken into your life because you like him as he is ?

I don't spay females either unless I absolutely have to in old age for health reasons. That has happened just twice.

IMO there is absolutely no reason to castrate or spay. Basenjis are so clean anyway and keeping them contained during a season season is not a problem.

I only neuter my females when absolutely necessary for physical health reasons. I do not neuter males. When I was young and very ignorant I had a male neutered because the person from whom I fostered him suggested that I do. I leave them entire for all the reasons that Zande has indicated and many more. Having said that, I accept that it has to become a necessity for some owners because of their circumstances. It doesn't cure any of the problems that are suggested however in my opinion.

My 11 month basenji is also a good boy - not too aggressive , does not mark or pee in the house. We live in typical suburb neighborhood so dog is always on leash when he is outside . Only in dog park or boarding facility he is not on leash. We do not plan to breed or show . Ideally i do not want him neutered unless keeping him intact will create health problem later /when he is older Or if older age neutering is harder?.
I need to board him sometimes when we are out of town and many places want neutered dog or else they will keep him in kennel / not let him play with other dogs which feels cruel.
Also I do not know what other dog owners will think or say when i take him to dog park unneutered as recently i noticed he chases and smells female dogs.

So that's my main concern but i am tempted not to put him under knief for this reason. If there is good reason to neuter (such as health reason) then only i will neuter him and hence i am seeking opinions.

Finally , is 11 month too early or too late for neutering? what's the right age ?

last edited by prasadvaze

He wouldn't stop sniffing other dogs even if he was castrated ! Its what dogs do - meet and greet (and sniff) !

I'd try to find a more amenable boarding kennel to one which insists on neutered dogs !

Health issues are more likely to arise in neutered dogs than in entire ones. Leave him be if you possible can !

@zande - That would never happen in the US.... very, very few boarding kennels will accept dogs that are not neutered or spayed. Very far and few will accept in-tact dogs.

Global Moderator

I can appreciate leaving a dog intact if/when it is owned by a breeder. After all, they are equipped to keep their animals separated during mating season unless they are specifically pairing two lines. However, I personally believe that pets should be nuetered and spayed.

First, because breeders take care to make sure "accidents" don't happen. And an intact male in the presence of a bitch in season is going to do everything he can to "complete his mission!" It doesn't matter if she's the same breed, smaller, larger, cute, a good match, or comes from the wrong side of the tracks. It only matters that she's in season. As a dog park regular, most of us roll our eyes when someone brings in an intact male. I'll let you guess how most of us feel when someone shows up with a bitch in season!

And that's the second issue. Most "dog owners" don't have a clue about what they should look for, or how they can tell if their bitch is in season. They don't know how long it lasts. Or what phases are involved. Or anything else about how to best handle the situation. And many of them really don't care. They think it's cute that their bitch gets knocked up, "it's a great way for the kids to learn" mentality.

Combine the first two points and you can begin to understand where Basenji mixes come from. It is my understanding that Basenji breeders frown on diluting the breed.

The third point is how dogs (especially in a dog park environment) behave around a bitch in heat. Any given dog can go from mildly agressive to murderous in seconds if they believe they will not be the winning suitor of a bitch in heat.

I was unaware when my Doberman bitch went into season (several decades ago). Two dogs followed her home and stood on the stoop (at the door) waiting for me to let her come back out to "play"... In a split second, much to my horror, the larger of the dogs lowered his head and broke the neck of the smaller contender. There was no aggression. No warning growl. No blood. No "I'll fight you for her." Just "survival of the fittest" instincts. (All of my bitches have gotten spayed since then!)

So, in summary: it makes sense for breeders to keep their dogs intact, not necessarily the "average" dog owner. Make the best decision for your individual situation, but try to think through all the potential outcomes.


That's terrible ! It forces people to neuter there dogs. But I do realise USA has totally different ideas about neutering than we do. ☹


I'd better bow out of this thread, Elbrant. Over here, I know many breeders, but nary a one who would just sell a Basenji puppy without making sure the new owner knew a great deal about the breed, characteristics, health, et al. We all make sure they've read as much as they can find, and hand out loads of information. You give the impression - at least, this is the impression I get - that US breeders sell puppies without doing any checks on people they sell to ? Never mind. Don't answer that ! We are poles apart on this issue, and I should hate for us to fall out over it..

When I was growing up, most male dogs I encountered were left intact, including our family Sheltie. Bitches kept as pets were mostly spayed, but not always. There were no leash laws, but a law stating that dogs off their own property should be "under the control" of the owner/handler, and a lot of people (including us) walked their dogs off leash on a regular basis. We would encounter loose dogs several times on a walk, and generally these dogs were not quarrelsome, although males were intact. My Basenji bitches were all spayed, but the two I raised from pups had seasons before spaying, my show bitch had several, without incident. Although there were intact and running loose males in the area, we had zero problems with them hanging around. I realize this isn't always the case, but with a little care there is no reason for unwanted puppies.

My "other" breed was Border Collie. In season bitches can run at trials, and a male trial dog is said to be insufficiently serious about his work if he is distracted! Some trials request an in season bitch to run last, but not all.

Just to say it doesn't have to be a big deal if the owner is responsible, and for that matter breeders who insist their pups be neutered really have no good way to enforce this unless they do the deed before the pup is placed. Of course, if they want the pup shown it can't be neutered until the end of the show career anyhow.....

@zande - Yes different for different parts of the world and there is a huge problem with people breeding "whatever" just to have puppies.... to see (puppy mills/BYB) and never doing any health testing. And yes Sally..... puppy mills/BYB selling to whoever has the dollars. They ship puppies all over the US, never met the new owners, do NO background checking, tell the people exactly what they want to hear.

last edited by tanza

I have a male and female and experienced heat season for the first time and it lasted 6 weeks! My boy is the sweetest, gentleman. She became very attached to me. On the last two weeks or so, he became insane and all he could think about was getting to her. She hated him and did not want him near her. We did a great job at keeping eye on them at all times, sleeping in separate rooms, hanging out in separate rooms, and doggy diapers helped, separate walks...After going through it; I am now debating which one to spay or neuter. I really don’t want to put them through it. Other than when she is in heat, we love their personalities just the way they are and they are developing so well.

I believe keeping a close eye and noticing their hormonal changes is really the key to preventing unwanted litters. Especially for females. Males do show signs too and you just have to be vigilant during that time.

@eliefig Not always easy to tell when a bitch is coming into heat. My Teddy can sense a female coming into heat before her handler sees any signs. As an example, one day in class he began to get agitated, air sniffing, and totally distracted. I asked my classmates if any of their females were in heat. Oh no they all said. The next day one friend said her dog just started to show signs that day. Males can tell sooner than we!

@wizard My boys always knew, up to two full weeks before, that at least one of the girls was coming in. But keeping written records is never a bad idea. Observe signs, write notes and watch the calendar.

last edited by Zande

Although it was the 1st for my girl, I knew a couple of weeks before, slight changes in her attitude. I am able to communicate well with her. I am sure the 2nd time is going to be different. My boy had no experience so it took him longer. It’s so difficult to make a decision. I am so torn about it. Wondering if next time is going to be harder.

@zande, how do you handle having males and females at that time. It was hard watching my boy acting completely different, he didn’t even want to eat and boy he loves to eat.
