{'fraction_non_alphanumeric': 0.03216246568505116, 'fraction_numerical': 0.022273521337659096, 'mean_word_length': 4.552918759743634, 'pattern_counts': {'":': 0, '<': 0, '<?xml version=': 0, '>': 1, 'https://': 0, 'lorem ipsum': 0, 'www.': 0, 'xml': 0}, 'pii_count': 0, 'substrings_counts': 0, 'word_list_counts': {'cursed_substrings.json': 0, 'profanity_word_list.json': 0, 'sexual_word_list.json': 0, 'zh_pornsignals.json': 0}}
Synergistic effect of Ni–Ag–rutile TiO2 ternary nanocomposite for efficient visible-light-driven photocatalytic activity

P25 comprising of mixed anatase and rutile phases is known to be highly photocatalytically active compared to the individual phases. Using a facile wet chemical method, we demonstrate a ternary nanocomposite consisting of Ni and Ag nanoparticles, decorated on the surface of XTiO2 (X: P25, rutile (R)) as an efficient visible-light-driven photocatalyst. Contrary to the current perspective, RTiO2-based Ni–Ag–RTiO2 shows the highest activity with the H2 evolution rate of ∼86 μmol g−1 W−1 h−1@535 nm. Together with quantitative assessment of active Ni, Ag and XTiO2 in these ternary systems using high energy synchrotron X-ray diffraction, transmission electron microscopy coupled energy dispersive spectroscopy mapping evidences the metal to semiconductor contact via Ag. The robust photocatalytic activity is attributed to the improved visible light absorption, as noted by the observed band edge of ∼2.67 eV corroborating well with the occurrence of Ti3+ in Ti 2p XPS. The effective charge separation due to intimate contact between Ni and RTiO2via Ag is further evidenced by the plasmon loss peak in Ag 3d XPS. Moreover, density functional theory calculations revealed enhanced adsorption of H2 on Ti8O16 clusters when both Ag and Ni are simultaneously present, owing to the hybridization of the metal atoms with d orbitals of Ti and p orbitals of O leading to enhanced bonding characteristics, as substantiated by the density of states. Additionally, the variation in the electronegativity in Bader charge analysis indicates the possibility of hydrogen evolution at the Ni sites, in agreement with the experimental observations.


Introduction
The lack of clean energy resources is one of the severe problems being presently faced globally, which necessitates the development of next-generation environmentally benign and sustainable energy-efficient technologies. The use of photocatalytic systems, harvesting inexhaustible, and clean solar energy to split water and produce molecular oxygen/hydrogen has been considered as one of the best approaches so far. 1,2 However, even aer decades of active global research, the photocatalytic reaction system remains highly challenging.
Bulk and/or nanostructured semiconductors with superior physicochemical and optical properties are employed for photocatalysis. The semiconductor acts as an active photocatalyst for the light-induced photochemical reactions because of its unique electronic structure characterized by a lled valence band and an empty conduction band. Among various semiconductors, bulk and nanostructured TiO 2 have stood as the central facet because of their high photocatalytic efficiencies, photochemical stability, nontoxicity, and high reactivity. 3,4 However, the large bandgap of TiO 2 ($3.2 eV for anatase and brookite, $2.9 eV for rutile) requires an excitation wavelength that falls in the UV region, which consists of less than $5% of the total sunlight (solar light consists of $5% UV, $45% visible, and $50% infrared) incident at the earth's surface. Thus, the utilization of solar light for a photocatalytic or photoelectrochemical process can be enhanced by tuning the bandgap of TiO 2 to the visible or infrared region. 5 Apart from that, conventional TiO 2 -based homogeneous photocatalysts have inherent drawbacks, such as the fast recombination of photo-induced electron-hole pairs. Whereas, the heterogeneous photocatalysis has proven to be more appealing than its homogeneous counterpart due to the manipulation of the bandgap and enhancement of charge carrier separation. [6][7][8][9] Thus, tailoring the physicochemical and optical properties of TiO 2 is indispensable in utilizing a large fraction of the solar spectrum to realize the photocatalyst's indoor applications.
Heterostructures of nano-sized TiO 2 with 0 dimensional (0D) noble nanoparticles, 6,10,11 and 2D materials 12 have shown remarkable photocatalytic properties. Among 0D particles deposited TiO 2 , Pt and Pd co-catalyst have shown exceptional photocatalytic properties. However, both these materials cannot be used for practical applications; whereas, the usage of metallic Ag is cost-effective. 13 It is well known that Ag exhibits poor photocatalytic activity because of the weaker binding energy of Ag-H (37 kcal mol À1 ). Few of the recent report shows that present of Ni along with Ag is expected to enhance the H 2 generation rate due to stronger binding energy of Ni-H (52 kcal mol À1 ) 13 and reduced contact resistance 14 in ternary nanocomposite. Further, it is to be noted that, among the various available form of TiO 2 , the photocatalytic activity of rutile TiO 2 (RTiO 2 ) is rarely reported as compared with the anatase TiO 2 and P25 (a mixture of 80% wt anatase and 20% wt rutile) because of its lower photocatalytic activity. 15,16 The lower activity of RTiO 2 has been attributed to its low specic surface area, fast recombination, and positive location of its conduction band minimum. 17,18 However, a recent report has shown that RTiO 2 can also act as an active photocatalyst under the appropriate experimental conditions; although, the photocatalytic activity is noted in the UV region. 19 In this work, we report a thorough and systematic experimental study on Ni, Ag, and XTiO 2 (X: P25 and rutile)-based ternary nanocomposite synthesized using a wet chemical method to study the synergistic effects of multiple nanojunctions on the visible-light-driven H 2 generation rate (HER). Synthesized nanocomposites are denoted as Ni-Ag-P25 (PAN), and Ni-Ag-RTiO 2 (RAN) throughout the manuscript. Observed results are further supported with the density functional theory (DFT) simulations, which brings out the signicance of both Ni and Ag in a ternary nanocomposite for H 2 evolution.

Synthesis of Ni-Ag-XTiO 2 composites samples
Ni-Ag-XTiO 2 (X: P25, and rutile (R)) ternary nanocomposite were synthesized by utilizing sonication based wet chemical synthesis following the method reported earlier. 20 Materials for composites include Ni nanopowder with an average diameter of 200 nm (Ningxia Orient Tantalum Industry, Co. Ltd.), rutile TiO 2 (99.5% assay, Alfa Aesar), P25 (>99.5%, Aeroxide, Evonik), AgNO 3 (0.01 mol L À1 purchased from Sigma-Aldrich). Deionized (DI) water from the laboratory water supply was used for work. Based on the previous report, 20 Ni (6% wt )-Ag (10% wt )-XTiO 2 (84% wt ) has been prepared. We have prepared a whole batch of 100 mg of each Ni-Ag-XTiO 2 ternary composite as follows. Synthesis of the batch was carried out as two 50 mg doses in two 100 mL Erlenmeyer asks with 75 mL DI water. Aer the initial mixing of the Ni, TiO 2, and DI water, water dissolved AgNO 3 was added. The material synthesis was carried out by sonication using a Skymen JTS-1018 water bath ultrasonic cleaner. The cleaner was pre-heated to 70 C, and the materials were then sonicated @39 kHz using maximum power ($3 A current) for a duration of 4 h. Aer the continuous sonication, the samples were kept still at room temperature overnight until separation through sedimentation of particles had cleared the water. Aer sedimentation, water was carefully rinsed without losing synthesized particles, followed by decanting the synthesized particles. Drying the remaining water off from the as-prepared samples was carried out by evaporation of the water in an open beaker by utilizing a hot plate to heat samples to approximately 100 C in the ambient air. Dried samples were then scraped off the beaker and stored in sample bottles as a dry powder. In a similar fashion, controlled samples of Ag-XTiO 2 binary nanocomposites were also prepared. During the growth process, it was noted that Ni-XTiO 2 (P25, R) could not be achieved, which further support the idea of required noble metal glue (Ag) to contact Ni with TiO 2 .

Instrumentation
Room-temperature powder XRD patterns were recorded with Rigaku SmartLab 9 kW equipped with ve-axis q-q goniometer and 1D solid-state detector and scintillator using Co-K a . All three ternary nanocomposites were also measured at the Brockhouse High Energy Wiggler Beamline, CLS, Canada. All these powder samples were loaded in Kapton capillaries of 0.9 mm diameter. The data collection was performed with nominally 33 keV photons. The rened wavelength from a LaB 6 calibrant was 0.35414 A, and the sample to detector distance was 448.58 mm. An exposure time of 2-3 s was used, with 120 frames for each of these data collection using a PerkinElmer area detector, a at panel Xray detector, 200 mm pixel, 40 Â 40 cm 2 . UV-vis spectroscopy was carried with Shimadzu UV-2600 Spectrometer. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was performed with Al K a using Thermo Fisher Scientic ESCALAB 250Xi XPS System. Field emission scanning electron microscope (FESEM)-energy dispersive spectroscopic (EDS) mapping was carried out with Zeiss Ultra plus FESEM. Transmission electron microscope (TEM)-EDS mapping was performed using JEOL JEM-2200FS EFTEM/STEM. For HER, samples were cycled in Perfect Light PCX50B photo reactor through eight monochromatic LED light sources covering near UV regime to visible light (in a range of 365 to 630 nm) equipped with magnetic stirring. Sampling and analysis of gaseous species were carried out using Agilent Micro 490 GC gas chromatograph (GC) equipped with an H 2 sensitive column (10MS5A) aer the end of each illumination round.

Photocatalytic reduction of water for H 2 evolution
The catalytic activity of the pristine and synthesized nanocomposites was carried out in a photoreactor to measure any activity differences. Pristine TiO 2 , their binary and ternary nanocomposites were used to run experiments in the same conditions, such as identical cells, same volume, an equal amount of DI-water, a total weight of 5 mg of each sample, and xed illumination time of 2 h. A magnetic stirring bar for stirring the suspension was carried out during the experiment. The 5 mg samples were added into a quartz bottle with a total volume of 68 mL. For each experiment, 3 s sonication was carried out to provide a consistent starting point in terms of the dispersion of the suspension. The gaseous content was ushed for a xed repeatable starting point by using argon. In the rst round of preparation, we applied careful Ar-ushing, including heating of the water, to minimize the water-dissolved air. The argon ush's primary function was to establish a reliable control method to monitor gas leaks that arose through effusion and, to a lesser extent, diffusion mechanisms, thus detecting potential abnormally high leak rates. By utilizing the available monochromatic wavelengths each at the time, eight experiments per sample were carried out. The repetitive nature of the experiments also provided initial results of the reusability of the samples.

Density functional theory
To corroborate the experimental ndings of observed higher activity in the ternary nanocomposites, DFT simulations were carried out using the plane wave pseudo potential based, Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) to corroborate with the experimental ndings. 21 We have modeled a Ti 8 O 16 cluster using the super cell approach, such that the cluster is placed in the center of a cubic box with dimensions of 20 A. Since a considerably large supercell is used to model the Ti 8 O 16 clusters, a gamma centered k grid was used for the Brillouin zone integration. The plane waves included in the basis set were expanded using kinetic energy cut off of 400 eV, and Gaussian smearing was employed. The exchange and correlation were described using GGA in the PAW-PBE method. 22,23 The atomic positions were relaxed with zero external stress and this is ensured by using energy and force tolerances of 10 À6 eV and 0.001 eV A À1 , respectively. To account for the underestimation of band gaps caused by GGA, the Hubbard U parameter in the Dudarev's method is employed for Ti with the values, U ¼ 4.5 eV and J ¼ 0 eV. 24

Results and discussions
3.1. X-ray diffraction Fig. 1 shows the experimental X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns for the pristine XTiO 2 and ternary nanocomposites along with the XRD pattern of Ag and Ni. Both the ternary nanocomposites, that is, PAN, and RAN contain all the Bragg peaks associated with their respective three individual components, thus, suggesting the successful preparation of ternary nanocomposites. The intensity, peak position and full width at half maximum (FWHM) being the three crucial features of an XRD pattern, have been used to determine the structural effect of Ni and Ag on the unit cell size and shape of TiO 2 (via peak position) and crystalline quality (via peak width). Thus, the insight into XRD analysis has been carried out using representative Bragg reections of P25 vs. PAN, and RTiO 2 vs. RAN (Fig. 2). No signicant change in the relative intensities of XRD peaks suggests no observable changes in the atomic arrangements of TiO 2 . Fig. 2 indicates the possible changes in PAN, and RAN compared to their pristine samples. No signicant changes in the peak positions indicate the unit cell's unaltered size in these ternary nanocomposites. Further, no signicant changes in the FWHM are observed for PAN as compared to P25. However, RAN shows a systematic increase in the FWHM as compared to RTiO 2 . Such compensating change corresponds to the renement of the local atomic arrangement in RAN with degraded crystallinity compared to the pristine RTiO 2 , possibly due to changes in the dielectric environment of RTiO 2 . Rietveld renement on the high-energy synchrotron XRD data has been further carried out (Table 1) to elucidate the phase fraction of Ni, Ag, and XTiO 2 in ternary nanocomposites. According to the previous report, 20 Ni (6% wt )-Ag (10% wt )-XTiO 2 (84% wt ) was chosen for the synthesis process. However, Rietveld renement results (Table 1) show the wt% contribution of TiO 2 as 90% in both the ternary nanocomposites. However, the % wt of Ni and Ag is $5 in RAN, whereas, for PAN, it is $2 and 8, respectively, although the growth parameters used were kept the same.

UV-vis spectroscopy
The UV-vis spectra of P25, PAN, RTiO 2, and RAN ternary nanocomposites are shown in Fig. 3a. The bandgap energy of the prepared nanocomposites is further determined from (ahn) 2 versus hn. 25 For indirect transition, that is, (ahn) 1/2 versus hn, the E g estimated from the a ¼ 0 extrapolation is $2.25 and 2.1 eV for P25 and RTiO 2 , respectively, which does not seem realistic. Thus, the direct transition is considered to be most probable in the current case, which is a better t than the corresponding indirect bandgap t, resulting in bandgap values of 3.1 eV (P25) and 2.85 eV (RTiO 2 ). Fig. 3b shows that the optical bandgap of PAN, and RAN ternary nanocomposites is $2.85, and 2.67 eV, which is relatively lower than that of P25 (3.1 eV), and RTiO 2 (2.85 eV). The absorption edge of the PAN, and RAN ternary nanocomposites extended an unambiguous red shi compared to the P25, and RTiO 2 , which reects that the electronic structure and optical properties of ternary nanocomposites have been modied due to the presence of Ag and Ni nanoparticles. These results thus suggest that the incorporation of Ag and Ni with pristine TiO 2 caused a redshi of the UV-vis absorption spectrum. Moreover, the PAN and RAN ternary nanocomposites exhibited higher absorption, suggesting that the enhanced electron transfer among the individual components. Beneting from such visible light absorption and high absorption intensity, the ternary nanocomposite is expected to show improved utilization of solar energy and perhaps possesses an enhanced visible-light-driven photocatalytic performance. The observed redshi in the band edge can be understood due to band edge alignment when metal gets in contact with a semiconductor. 26 Further, it is to be noted that no signicant change in the band gap of Ag-P25, and Ag-RTiO 2 binary nanocomposites (ESI Fig. S1 †) has been found.
Apart from the above observations, RAN shows a clear absorption peak in the range of 500-700 nm (Fig. 3a), which could be assigned to Ag NPs (absorption peak $ 539 nm) and Ni NPs ($700 nm).

X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy
X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis is carried out to determine the composition and identify the chemical states of grown nanocomposites ( Table 2). The high-resolution XPS spectra of Ti 2p (Fig. 4(a) and (c)) for pristine P25 and RTiO 2 show the two strong peaks corresponding to Ti 2p 3/2 and Ti 2p 1/ 2 . The observed peak position ( Table 2) and peak separation of 5.8 eV of the Ti 2p doublet agree well with that reported for TiO 2 . XPS spectra of PAN and RAN are shown in Fig. 5. Fig. 5(a-c) shows XPS spectra for Ti 2p, O 1s, and Ag 3d for PAN. Apart from an increase in the B.E. by $0.5 eV and an increase in FWHM (Table 2), no other changes are observed for the Ti 2p spectrum. Observed changes in B.E. and FWHM could be due to change in the chemical environment due to the presence of Ag and Ni. Further, no changes are observed in the O 1s XPS spectrum. The Ag 3d spectrum for the PAN consists of two individual peaks located at ca. 368 eV and ca. 374 eV, which can be assigned to Ag 3d 5/2 and Ag 3d 3/2 of metallic Ag, respectively. For Ag 3d, a broad peak at ca. 368.70 eV is also detected in addition to the metallic peak at 368 eV. This peak has been attributed to the presence of metallic sub-nanoparticles that are smaller than 4 nm. 27 This peak has been shown to change its position depending on the size and distribution of sub-nanoparticle. The observed large FWHM ($1.36 eV) of this peak points to a large distribution of sizes. Thus, no signicant changes are observed for PAN as compared to P25.       Table 2). High-resolution XPS spectrum for Ti 2p can be divided into two different peaks, one centered at ca. 458.97 eV, ascribed to Ti 3+ species, and the other centered at ca. 459.33 eV, corresponding to Ti 4+ . Observance of Ti 4+ with increased B.E. and Ti 3+ peak as compared to bare RTiO 2 suggests a lower electron density of the TiO 2 , possibly due to intimate contact of RTiO 2 with Ag and/or Ni nanoparticles. The presence of Ti 3+ oxide with a narrow band gap 28 (well corroborates with UV-vis spectrum) can be advantageous to the higher photocatalytic activity of the RAN driven by visible light. The presence of satellite peak suggests changes in the coulombic potential of RTiO 2 as the photo-ejected electron passes through the valence band, which is possibly due to the presence of Ag/Ni. Further, the wide and asymmetric O 1s spectra indicate that there would be more than two components, which can be further tted into three peaks including crystal lattice oxygen (O Ti-O at ca. 529.4 eV), surface hydroxyl groups (O O-H at ca. 531.7 eV), and adsorbed O 2 (at ca. 533.5 eV). In Fig. 5e, the Ag 3d spectrum for the RAN consists of two individual peaks corresponding to Ag 3d 5/2 and Ag 3d 3/2 , a broad peak corresponding to metallic sub-nanoparticles as also observed for PAN. Further, the peak related to plasmon loss in Ag has also been detected for RAN, as evidenced by the separation of $4 eV between the main peak and plasmon peak. 29,30 The presence of a plasmon loss peak suggests the charge transfer from RTiO 2 to Ag, indicating the intimate interaction between Ag and TiO 2 via O in  This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 RSC Adv., 2020, 10, 36930-36940 | 36935 RAN, which is further supported via DFT simulation discussed later.
Furthermore, the absence of Ti 3+ oxide peak in the XPS spectrum for Ti 2p (ESI Fig. S2 †) in Ag-RTiO 2 nanocomposite corroborates well with no change in the band gap in the same.
Concerning the question of the chemical state of Ni, it was clearly seen by XAS-photoemission electron microscopy14 (a highly surface sensitive local probe down to 10 nm spatial resolution) that the Ni-Ag-TiO 2 ternary composites do not show any higher states of Ni, for example, Ni 2+ .
Thus, XPS analysis indicates that Ni and TiO 2 are connected to each other via Ag. The observed interaction between Ni and TiO 2 via Ag in RAN is further conrmed using eld emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM)-based energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) mapping.

Energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) mapping
A morphological examination of RAN is carried out with FESEM-EDS (Fig. 6). The FESEM imaging, along with EDS mapping, suggests the homogenous distribution of RTiO 2 , Ag, and Ni nanoparticles in RAN. Further, TEM-EDS imaging (Fig.   7) suggests the successful formation of RAN ternary nanocomposite, wherein Ni nanoparticle of size $200 nm is attached to RTiO 2 via Ag nanoparticle of size $20 nm. However, the same could not be observed for PAN. For instance, in the case of PAN, Ag decorated onto P25 is mainly observed, that is, the formation of the binary nanocomposite. This observation suggests RTiO 2 as the primary phase to provide the base for the formation of the targeted nanocomposite.
Based on these observations, the HER efficiency is accordingly expected to be highest in RAN followed by PAN, wherein, our primary goal was to study the potential activation and increment of HER in the visible light range in these ternary nanocomposites as discussed in the next sub-section.

HER experiment
TiO 2 based ternary nanocomposites (PAN and RAN) dispersed in DI water were used for photocatalytic H 2 generation in the light range of 365 to 630 nm, thus covering a signicant part of sunlight. In a control experiment, samples of bare XTiO 2 and binary Ag-XTiO 2 were also tested for comparison. The most signicant and distinctive difference being that hydrogen evolution can also be observed in the visible light range.    shows the H 2 production rate of PAN and RAN. It is to be noted that the HER of RAN (86 mmol g À1 W À1 h À1 ) is highest at the excitation wavelength of 535 nm, which is 3 folds higher than PAN (28 mmol g À1 W À1 h À1 ) at the same irradiation. Further, the observed HER of RAN ternary nanocomposites is found to be much higher than the pristine XTiO 2 , which showed negligible H 2 yield in the above-noted excitation range and Ag-RTiO 2 binary nanocomposite (3.23 mmol g À1 W À1 h À1 @535 nm). The observation of hydrogen formation in the experiments is systematic and repeatable. The observed higher hydrogen yield of RAN compared to PAN over the whole excitation range corroborates well with the formation of intimate contact between Ni and RTiO 2 via Ag, as evidenced by XPS and EDS mapping. The observed superior photocatalytic activity of rutile TiO 2 -based RAN as compared to P25-based PAN is intriguing and contrast with the previous reports, which shows higher catalytic efficiency of P25 as compared to rutile TiO 2 . 16 The observed intriguing results of RTiO 2 outperforming anatase-rich P25 can be attributed to the formation of intimate contact between Ni and RTiO 2 via Ag, the % wt of Ni and Ag, absorption edge in the visible region and electron transfer among the individual components in RAN, as evidenced by the EDS mapping and Ti 3+ in the XPS. This observation is further supported with the observed lower H 2 yield in RA nanocomposite, which is attributed to the absence of Ti 3+ oxide peak in the XPS spectrum for Ti 2p and no change in band gap.

Density functional theory
To get further insight into the observed properties, we have modeled a Ti 8 O 16 cluster using the supercell approach, and total energy optimization was carried out to nd the most stable geometry. Using this optimized geometry, H 2 adsorption was studied for pristine as well as Ag and/or Ni adsorbed clusters. The optimized geometries are shown in Fig. 9. The adsorption energies calculated to understand the energetics are shown in Tables 3 and 4.
The calculated adsorption energies indicate that Ni and Ag atoms prefer to attach to the O atom rather than the Ti atom (Table 3). Hence, for further calculations involving H 2 adsorption, these geometries were considered and compared with H 2 adsorption on the pristine cluster. Comparing Ag and Ni, Ni lowers the adsorption energy for H 2 , and hence, when both Ag and Ni are present in the cluster, the adsorption happens more easily ( Table 4). The bond lengths for the optimized clusters are presented in Table 5. For the pristine cluster, the Ti-O bond length in the cage is 2.13 A, while for outer Ti-O, it is 1.69 A. Interestingly, the H-H bond distances are larger when Ni and/or Ag are present in the cluster, and this indicates that the H 2 molecule dissociates to H atoms, and that gets attached to the metal atoms in the ternary cluster. On the other hand, in the case of pristine Ti 8 O 16 , it stays as H 2 , during adsorption, retaining its molecular bond distance of 0.75 A. It is also seen that there is a signicant increase in bond distances when Ag and/or Ni are present in the cluster, and these changes in crystal environment will aid in the dissociative adsorption of hydrogen. Further, to understand the charge transfer mechanism, the charge density difference (CHD) between Ti 8 O 16 H 2 and   Fig. 10, and the Bader charge analysis is shown in Table 5. The charge density difference shows that the O atoms gain charge, while the other atoms bonded to them lose charge. The more or less inert nature of Ag, as observed from the charge density difference plot, indicates that the electronegativity of Ag remains the same regardless of the presence of Ni. However, the signicant charge isosurface surrounding Ni atom indicates that changes in the chemical environment in the near vicinity affects the electronegativity of Ni. This is evident from the Bader charge analysis, as Ni atom loses less in the presence of Ag, while for Ag, the Bader charges stay consistent irrespective of Ni atom's presence. It can be seen from Tables 3 and 4 that for all cases, O atoms being more electronegative, gain charge, whereas Ti, Ag, and Ni lose charge. The H-H bond distances increase in the presence of both Ag and Ni (0.80 to 0.87 A) compared to that of the H 2 bond length in the pristine Ti 8 O 16 cluster (0.75 A). This has also been evident from the increase in H-H bond distances and the shortened Ag/Ni-H bonds, compared to Ag/Ni-Ti and Ag/Ni-O bonds. This indicates that the presence of Ag and Ni helps the splitting up of hydrogen into H* atoms, which later recombines to evolve as H 2 molecule. The change in electronegativity of Ni, as seen from the Bader charge analysis, indicates the possibility of hydrogen evolution happening at the Ni sites.
The density of states (DOS) was further calculated for the clusters with and without H 2 adsorption using the generalized gradient approximation (GGA)+U approximation. The DOS plotted for pristine, and AgNi adsorbed clusters are shown in Fig. 11, while that with H 2 adsorption is shown in Fig. 12. It can be seen from Fig. 12 that pristine Ti 8 O 16 is an insulator with a gap of 1.58 eV. Whereas in the presence of Ag + Ni adsorbed on the Ti 8 O 16 cluster, the bandgap is considerably reduced to 0.04 eV. This indicates that in the presence of metallic atoms, the bandgap of Ti 8 O 16 clusters can be tuned for application purposes. Further, DOS shows that in the presence of Ni and Ag, the CB minimum (CBM) moves towards VB maximum (VBM), as new states are introduced in the energy gap. The shi in CBM towards the lower energy region is more pronounced with Ni addition than that of Ag, while with Ag addition, the VBM moves to a higher energy region. The net effect in both cases is the reduced bandgap and the introduction of additional energy levels in the gap. Nevertheless, when both Ag and Ni are together adsorbed on the cluster, the VBM moves to a higher energy region, combined with additional band gap levels. The atom and orbital resolved DOS presented in Fig. 13 shows Ni alone in the cluster pushes the VBM to lower energy levels and, on the other hand, moves the VBM to higher energy levels. The possibility of hybridization of the transition metals with d orbital of Ti and p orbitals of O is evident from the DOS, leading to enhanced bonding characteristics. When both Ag and Ni are present, this hybridization is more strengthened due to the introduction of multiple levels in the energy gap, further corroborating the experimental ndings.

The photocatalytic mechanism for water splitting
Based on the above experimental and theoretical ndings, the remarkable enhancement in the photocatalytic activity of ternary nanocomposites can be attributed to the unique design of Ni-Ag-RTiO 2 nanocomposite that allows for efficient charge separation in the visible region. A tentative mechanism proposed for the high H 2 production is illustrated in schematic in Fig. 13. Upon light excitation, the VB electrons are excited to the CB of TiO 2 , leaving holes in the VB. Previous studies have shown that the CB electrons of TiO 2 can be rapidly injected into Ag nanoparticle due to the formation of heterojunction between semiconductor and metal nanoparticle. 31 The rapidly injected electrons can either reduce H + to H 2 , or they can further move to Ni nanoparticle, which can also act as an active site for H 2 generation. Thus, the mediator Ag nanoparticle has a double role, (i) rapidly capture photogenerated electrons to reduce H + and (ii) transfers these captured electrons to Ni nanoparticle to  carry out the H 2 evolution reaction step. Hence, the observed HER difference might arise from the lower bandgap allowing activity due to lower energy photon excitation by visible light and possibly delayed recombination of the electron-hole pair due to intimate contact between various components in ternary heterostructure to allow more time for redox chemistry occurrence. We would like to emphasize here that, despite the possibility of oxidation of Ni, which is in fact a natural phenomenon for transition metal nanoparticle, we believe that the proposed synergetic effect primarily appears due to the Ni metallic nature only based on the observation of Ni0 in the X-ray absorption spectroscopy-photoemission electron microscopy14.

Conclusion
The Ni-Ag-RTiO 2 ternary nanocomposite was successfully constructed through the decoration of Ni nanoparticles onto Ag-RTiO 2 . The results of XRD, FESEM/TEM-EDS mapping, and XPS spectroscopy demonstrated that the successful formation of rutile TiO 2 -based ternary nanocomposite. This ternary design builds up a unique transfer path for the photoexcited electrons of RTiO 2 to the Ni nanoparticles via Ag nanoparticle bridge and thus effectively suppresses the electron-hole recombination in the RTiO 2 photocatalyst. This ternary nanocomposite exhibits a remarkably high photocatalytic H 2 -generation rate under visible-light irradiation compare to that of pristine RTiO 2 , Ag-RTiO 2 binary nanocomposite, and Ni-Ag-P25TiO 2 ternary nanocomposite. We believe that this work demonstrates a promising way for the rational design of metal-semiconductor hybrid photocatalysts that can achieve a high photocatalytic efficiency for use in solar fuel production. Observed higher activity of ternary nanocomposites is further supported with DFT simulation carried out on Ti 8 O 16 clusters.
The results on these ternary systems show $3 times higher photocatalytic performances in RTiO 2 -based ternary nanocomposite over P25-based ternary system and $28 times higher than Ag-RTiO 2 binary nanocomposite. Intriguingly, the highest activity of the rutile TiO 2 -based system is in contrast with the reported literature, which suggests that P25 has the highest activity among different forms of TiO 2 . Thus, this work opens a new preposition in clean energy technology and production.

Conflicts of interest
There are no conicts to declare.  This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 RSC Adv., 2020, 10, 36930-36940 | 36939