(56)  References Cited  US 8,785,686 B2  Page 2  U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS  FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS  OTHER PUBLICATIONS  5,952,530 A  9/1999 Argyropoulos et al.  6,252,121 Bl  6/2001 Argyropoulos et al.  6,291,725 Bl  9/2001 Chopade et al.  6,294,700 Bl  9/2001 Kane! et al.  6,303,829 Bl  10/2001 Kane! et al.  6,307,108 Bl  10/2001 Argyropoulos et al.  6,307,109 Bl  10/2001 Kane! et al.  6,307,110 Bl  10/2001 Argyropoulos et al.  6,310,260 Bl  10/2001 Argyropoulos et al.  6,376,723 B2  *  4/2002 Drent et al.  7,122,698 B2  10/2006 Yoshida et al.  7,164,040 B2  1/2007 Kuroda et al.  7,223,885 B2  5/2007 Van Krieken  7,439,391 B2  10/2008 Gallagher et al.  7,615,671 B2  11/2009 Puckette et al.  7,709,689 B2  5/2010 Kilner et al.  7,772,423 B2  8/2010 Celiket al.  8,466,328 B2  6/2013 Barnicki et al.  2004/0222153 Al  11/2004 Bani el et al.  2006/0160197 Al  7/2006 Li et al.  2007/0123739 Al  5/2007 Crabtree et al.  2008/027 5277 Al  11/2008 Kalagias  2009/0143612 Al  6/2009 Puckette et al.  2011/0144388 Al  6/2011  Sun et al.  2011/0166383 Al  7/2011  Sun et al.  2012/0046481 Al  2/2012 Barnicki et al.  2012/0046500 Al  2/2012 Barnicki et al.  2012/0078010 Al  3/2012 Barnicki et al.  568/864  JP  JP  JP  JP  JP  JP  JP  JP  RU  WO  WO  WO  WO  WO  56131546 A  56133237 A  5746934 A  57040442 A  57102837 A  6228045 A  1999147042 A  2004131411 A  1436453 Al  WO 97/15543 Al  WO 2006/069127 Al  WO 2009/140850 Al  WO 2012/040007 A2  WO 2012/130316 Al  10/1981  10/1981  3/1982  3/1982  6/1982  8/1994  6/1999  4/2004  9/1996  5/1997  6/2006  11/2009  3/2012  10/2012  Hou-Yong, Sun, et al. "Reactive extraction of glycolic acid in high  content solution with tri-n-octylamine" Journal of Chemical Engi› neering of Chinese Universities, Feb. 2007, vol. 21 pp. 26-30.  USPTO Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 13/431,358 dated Nov. 12,  2013.  Notification of Transmittal of the International Search Report and the  Written Opinion of the International Search Authority with Mail Date  of Mar. 15, 2012 for International Application No. PCT/US2011/  051490.  Notification of Transmittal of the International Search Report and the  Written Opinion of the International Search Authority with Mail Date  of Nov. 28, 2011 for International Application No. PCT/US2011/  047842.  Celik et al., "Synthesis of precursors to ethylene glycol from form› aldehyde and methyl formate catalyzed by heteropoly acids", Journal  of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical 288, (2008), pp. 87-96.  Celik et al., "Vapor-phase carbonylation of dimethoxymethane of  H-Faujasite",Angewandte. Chemie Int. Ed. 2009, 48, pp. 4813-4815.  Asci, Yavuz Selim et al. "Extraction of Glycolic Acid from Aqueous  Solutions by Amberlite La-2 in Difference Diluent Solvents" J. Chem  Eng. Data 2009, 54, 2791-2794.  Bizek, Vladislav et al. "Amine Extraction of Hydroxycarboxylic  Acids. 1. Extraction of Citric Acid with 1-Octanol/n-Heptane Solu› tions ofTrialkylarnine" Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1992, 31, 1554-1562.  Li, Tao, et al., "Carbonylation of formaldehyde catalyzed byp-tolu› enesulfonic acid", Catalysis Today, 111, (2006), pp. 288-291.  Soma, Yoshie, et al., "Normal-Pressure CO Addition Reaction of  Formaldehyde and Related Compounds on Copper Carbonyl Cata› lyst", Catalyst 23, (1981), pp. 48-50.  Souma, Yoshie, "Carbonylation at Ambient Pressure in Strong  Acids", Journal of Synthetic Organic Chemistry, vol. 41, No. 6,  (1983), pp. 561-569.  Sano, Tsunejo, et al., "Synthesis ofl,3-dioxolan-4-one from trioxane  and carbon monoxide on HZSM-5 zeolite", Chem. Community,  (1997), pp. 1827-1828.  Wang, Zheng Bao, et al., Carbonylation of Formaldehyde with Car› bon Monoxide over Cation-Exchange Resin Catalysts, Bull. Chem.  Soc. Jpn., 72, (1999), pp. 1935-1940.  Suzuki, S., eta!., "Ethylene Glycol from Methanol and Synthesis Gas  via Glycolic Acid", Catalytic Conversions of Synthesis Gas and  Alcohols to Chemicals, (1984). pp. 221-247.  Xu, Qiang, "Metal carbonyl cations: generation, characterization and  catalytic application", Coordination Chemistry Reviews, 231,  (2002), pp. 83-108.  Xu, Qiang, et al., "Preparation and Catalytic Application of Cationic  Metal Carbonyls", Science and Technology in Catalysis, (2002), pp.  215-218.  Seader, J.D., Ph.D, et al., "Distillation", Perry’s HandbookofChemi› cal Engineering, Section 13,  7 $^{th }$Ed., McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1999.  Lee, Sang Young, et al., "Carbonylation of Formaldehyde over Ion  Exchange Resin Catalysts. 1. Batch Reactor Studies", Ind. Eng.  Chem. Res., 32, (1993), pp. 253-259.  "Packing Design and Operation", Distillation Design, McGraw-Hill,  New York, (1992), Chapter 8, pp. 421-521.  "Tray Design and Operation", Distillation Design, McGraw-Hill,  New York (1992), Chapter 6, pp. 259-363.  Lynch, Kathleen M., et al., "Improved Preparations of 3-Chloro- 2( chloromethyl)-1-propene  and  1, l-Dibromo-2,2- bis( chloromethyl)-cyclopropane: Intermediates in the Synthesis of  [1.1.l]Propellane", J. Org. Chem, 60, (1995), pp. 4666-4668.  Treybal, Robert E., Liquid Extraction,  2 $^{nd }$Ed., McGraw Hill Book  Company, 1963, pp. 248-252.  Gerberich, H. Robert, et al., "Formaldehyde", Kirk-Othmer Ency› clopedia of Chemical Technology, vol. 11,  4 th  Edition, 1994, pp.  929-951.  Treybal, Robert E., Liquid Extraction,  2 $^{nd }$Ed., McGraw-Hill Book  Company, New York, NY, 1963, pp. 349-366.  Treybal, Robert E. "Methods of Calculation II. Stagewise Contact,  Multicomponent Systems", Liquid Extraction,  2 $^{nd }$Edition, McGraw› Hill Book Company, New York. 1963, pp. 275-276.  Handbook of Solvent Extraction, Krieger Publishing Company,  Malabar, FL, 1991, pp. 275-501.  Eyal, Aharon, et al. "Extraction of Strong Mineral Acids by Organic  Acid-Base Couples", Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev., (1982), vol.  21, No. 2, pp. 334-337.  Eyal, A.M., et al. "Recovery and Concentration of Strong Mineral  Acids from Dilute Solutions Through LLX. II. Reversible Extraction  with Branched-Chain Amines",  Solvent Extraction and Ion  Exchange, 9(2), pp. 211-222 (1991).  Eyal, A.M., et al. "Recovery and Concentration of Strong Mineral  Acids from Dilute Soltions Through LLX. I: Review of Parameters  for Adjusting Extractant Properties and Analysis of Process  Options", Solvent Extraction and Ion Exchange, 9 (2), pp. 195-210  (1991).  Eyal, A., et al. "Recovery and Concentration of Strong Mineral Acids  from Dilute Solutions Through LLX III. A "Temperature Swing"  Based Process", Solvent Extraction and Ion Exchange, 9 (2), pp.  223-236 (1991).  Walker, "Formaldehyde", ACS Monograph, Washington, DC.,  (1964), p. 95.  Smith, E. Lester, et al., "The Acid-Binding Properties of Long-Chain  Aliphatic Amines", J.S.C.I., 67, Feb. 1948 pp. 48-51.  Tarnada, Janet A. et al. "Extraction ofCarboxylic Acids with Amine  Extractants. 1. Equilibria and Law of Mass Action Modeling" Ind.  Eng. Chem. Res. 1990, 29, 1319-1326. 