Negative Elliptic Flow of $J/\psi$'s: A Qualitative Signature for Charm   Collectivity at RHIC
  We discuss one of the most prominent features of the very recent preliminary elliptic flow data of $J/\Psi$ meson from the PHENIX collaboration \cite{Silvestre:2008tw}. Even within the the rather large error bars of the measured data a negative elliptic flow parameter ($v_2$) for $J/\Psi$ in the range of $p_T=0.5-2.5 \GeV/c$ is visible. We argue that this negative elliptic flow at intermediate $p_T$ is a clear and qualitative signature for the collectivity of charm quarks produced in nucleus-nucleus reactions at RHIC. Within a parton recombination approach we show that a negative elliptic flow puts a lower limit on the collective transverse velocity of heavy quarks. The numerical value of the transverse flow velocity $\beta_T$ for charm quarks that is necessary to reproduce the data is $\beta_T(charm)\sim 0.55-0.6c$ and therefore compatible with the flow of light quarks. 
Daniel Krieg, Marcus Bleicher