Jar Decoding: Non-Asymptotic Converse Coding Theorems, Taylor-Type   Expansion, and Optimality
  Recently, a new decoding rule called jar decoding was proposed; under jar decoding, a non-asymptotic achievable tradeoff between the coding rate and word error probability was also established for any discrete input memoryless channel with discrete or continuous output (DIMC). Along the path of non-asymptotic analysis, in this paper, it is further shown that jar decoding is actually optimal up to the second order coding performance by establishing new non-asymptotic converse coding theorems, and determining the Taylor expansion of the (best) coding rate $R_n (\epsilon)$ of finite block length for any block length $n$ and word error probability $\epsilon$ up to the second order. Finally, based on the Taylor-type expansion and the new converses, two approximation formulas for $R_n (\epsilon)$ (dubbed "SO" and "NEP") are provided; they are further evaluated and compared against some of the best bounds known so far, as well as the normal approximation of $R_n (\epsilon)$ revisited recently in the literature. It turns out that while the normal approximation is all over the map, i.e. sometime below achievable bounds and sometime above converse bounds, the SO approximation is much more reliable as it is always below converses; in the meantime, the NEP approximation is the best among the three and always provides an accurate estimation for $R_n (\epsilon)$. An important implication arising from the Taylor-type expansion of $R_n (\epsilon)$ is that in the practical non-asymptotic regime, the optimal marginal codeword symbol distribution is not necessarily a capacity achieving distribution. 
En-Hui Yang and Jin Meng
cs.IT math.IT