The clustering morphology of freely rising deformable bubbles
  We investigate the clustering morphology of a swarm of freely rising deformable bubbles. A three-dimensional Vorono\"i analysis enables us to quantitatively distinguish between two typical clustering configurations: preferential clustering and a grid-like structure. The bubble data is obtained from direct numerical simulations (DNS) using the front-tracking method. It is found that the bubble deformation, represented by the aspect ratio \chi, plays a significant role in determining which type of clustering is realized: Nearly spherical bubbles with \chi <~ 1.015 form a grid-like structure, while more deformed bubbles show preferential clustering. Remarkably, this criteria for the clustering morphology holds for different diameters of the bubbles, surface tension, and viscosity of the liquid in the studied parameter regime. The mechanism of this clustering behavior is connected to the amount of vorticity generated at the bubble surfaces. 
Yoshiyuki Tagawa, Ivo Roghair, Vivek N. Prakash, Martin van Sint   Annaland, Hans Kuipers, Chao Sun, Detlef Lohse
physics.flu-dyn