The Star Formation Epoch of the Most Massive Early-Type Galaxies
  We present new Keck spectroscopy of early-type galaxies in three galaxy clusters at z~0.5. We focus on the fundamental plane (FP) relation, and combine the kinematics with structural parameters determined from HST images. The galaxies obey clear FP relations, which are offset from the FP of the nearby Coma cluster due to passive evolution of the stellar populations. The z~0.5 data are combined with published data for 11 additional clusters at 0.18<z<1.28, to determine the evolution of the mean M/L(B) ratio of cluster galaxies with masses M>10^11 M_sun, as implied by the FP. We find dlog(M/L(B))/dz = -0.555+-0.042, stronger evolution than was previously inferred from smaller samples. The observed evolution depends on the luminosity-weighted mean age of the stars in the galaxies, the initial mass function (IMF), selection effects due to progenitor bias, and other parameters. Assuming a normal IMF but allowing for various other sources of uncertainty we find z* = 2.01+-0.20 for the luminosity-weighted mean star formation epoch. The main uncertainty is the slope of the IMF in the range 1-2 Solar masses: we find z* = 4.0 for a top-heavy IMF with slope x=0. The M/L(B) ratios of the cluster galaxies are compared to those of recently published samples of field early-type galaxies at 0.32<z<1.14. Assuming that progenitor bias and the IMF do not depend on environment we find that the present-day age of stars in massive field galaxies is 4.1 +- 2.0 % (~0.4 Gyr) less than that of stars in massive cluster galaxies, consistent with most, but not all, previous studies of local and distant early-type galaxies. This relatively small age difference is surprising in the context of expectations from ``standard'' hierarchical galaxy formation models. [ABRIDGED] 
Pieter G. van Dokkum, Roeland P. van der Marel