The effect of the tortoise coordinate on the stable study of the   Schwarzschild black hole
  Carefully analyze influence of the tortoise coordinates r* and t on the stable study of the Schwarzschild black hole. Actually, one should be cautious in using the compact property of the perturbation field: it is true only with respect with the coordinate r and proper time or "good time", not the tortoise coordinates r* and t. Therefore, the mathematical proof used in reference [7] is incorrect because of it relying on the compact property of the perturbation fields. The Schwarzschild black hole might be unstable[1]-[5] 
Tian Gui-hua, Shi-kun Wang, Shuquan Zhong