Comment on "Negative Refractive Index in Artificial Metamaterials" [A.   N. Grigorenko, Opt. Lett., 31, 2483 (2006)]
  A key optical parameter characterizing the existence of negative refraction in a thin layer of a composite material is the effective refractive index of an equivalent, homogenized layer with the same physical thickness as the initial inhomogeneous composite. Measuring the complex transmission and reflection coefficients is one of the most rigorous ways to obtain this parameter. We dispute Grigorenko's statement (Optics Letters 31, 2483 (2006)) that measuring only the reflection intensity spectrum is sufficient for determining the effective refractive index. We discuss fundamental drawbacks of Grigorenko's technique of using a best-fit approximation with an a priori prescribed dispersive behavior for a given metamaterial and an 'effective optical thickness' that is smaller than the actual thickness of the sample. Our simulations do not confirm the Grigorenko paper conclusions regarding the negative refractive index and the negative permeability of the nanopillar sample in the visible spectral range. 
Alexander V. Kildishev, Vladimir P. Drachev, Uday K. Chettiar, Douglas   Werner, Do-Hoon Kwon, and Vladimir M. Shalaev