Can Charge Exchange Explain Anomalous Soft X-ray Emission in the Cygnus   Loop?
  Recent X-ray studies have shown that supernova shock models are unable to satisfactorily explain X-ray emission in the rim of the Cygnus Loop. In an attempt to account for this anomalously enhanced X-ray flux, we fit the region with a model including theoretical charge exchange (CX) data along with shock and background X-ray models. The model includes the CX collisions of $O^{8+}$, $O{7+}$, $N^{7+}$, $N^{6+}$, $C^{6+}$, and $C^{5+}$ with H with an energy of 1 keV/u (438 km/s). The observations reveal a strong emission feature near 0.7 keV that cannot fully be accounted for by a shock model, nor the current CX data. Inclusion of CX, specifically $O^{7+} + H$, does provide for a statistically significant improvement over a pure shock model. 
Renata S. Cumbee, David B. Henley, Phillip C. Stancil, Robin L.   Shelton, Jeff L. Nolte, Yong Wu, and David R. Schultz
astro-ph.HE