Status of some P-wave baryon resonances and importance of inelastic   channels
  We analyze the current status of three P-wave baryon states $N(1710){1/ 2}^+$, $N(1900){3/2}^+$, and $\Delta(1600){3/2}^+$ as given in the Review of Particles Physics (RPP). Since the evidence for a particle's existence is linked to its RPP "star" rating, we discuss its subjective present definition. We also present the accumulating evidence supporting these states and give our new "star" rating recommendations. 
Volker D. Burkert, Hiroyuki Kamano, Eberhard Klempt, Deborah Ronchen,   Andrey V. Sarantsev, Toru Sato, Alfred Svarc, Lotha...
nucl-ex nucl-th