Comment on ``Relativistic kinetic equations for electromagnetic, scalar   and pseudoscalar interactions''
  It is found that the extra quantum constraints to the spinor components of the equal-time Wigner function given in a recent paper by Zhuang and Heinz should vanish identically. We point out here the origin of the error and give an interpretation of the result. However, the principal idea of obtaining a complete equal-time transport theory by energy averaging the covariant theory remains valid. The classical transport equation for the spin density is also found to be incorrect. We give here the correct form of that equation and discuss briefly its structure. 
Abdellatif Abada and Michael C. Birse (Univ. Manchester), Pengfei   Zhuang (GSI), Ulrich Heinz (Univ. Duke and Regensburg)