Vigorous star formation in a bulge-dominated ERO at z = 1.34
  We present near-IR spectroscopy of three Extremely Red Objects (EROs) using the OHS/CISCO spectrograph at Subaru telescope. One target exhibits a strong emission line which we identify as H-alpha at z = 1.34. Using new and existing ground-based optical and near-IR imaging, and archival HST imaging, we argue that this target is essentially an elliptical galaxy, with an old stellar population of around 4E11 solar masses, but having a dust-enshrouded star-forming component with a SFR of some 50--100 solar masses per yr. There is no evidence that the galaxy contains an AGN. Analysis of a further two targets, which do not exhibit any features in our near-IR spectra, suggests that one is a quiescent galaxy in the redshift range 1.2 < z < 1.6, but that the other cannot be conclusively categorised as either star-forming or quiescent.   Even though our first target has many of the properties of an old elliptical, the ongoing star formation means that it cannot have formed_all_ of its stellar population at high redshift. While we cannot infer any robust values for the star formation rate in ellipticals at z > 1 from this one object, we argue that the presence of an object with such a high SFR in such a small sample suggests that a non-negligible fraction of the elliptical galaxy population may have formed a component of their stellar population at redshifts z ~ 1--2. We suggest that this is evidence for ongoing star formation in the history of elliptical galaxies. 
Garret Cotter (Oxford), Chris Simpson (Durham) & Rosemary C. Bolton   (Cambridge)