Comment on "Fission Mass Widths in $^{19}$F + $^{232}$Th, $^{16}$O +   $^{235,238}$ U reactions at near barrier energies
  A critical re-analysis of the experimental data to reject transfer fission component did not change the fragment mass widths and hence the conclusion regarding abrupt rise in mass widths with decreasing energy around Coulomb barrier remains unchanged 
T. K. Ghosh and P.Bhattacharya