Was the Universe Reionized at Redshift 10?
  Recently, Pello et al. (2004) claimed to have discovered a galaxy at a redshift z=10, and identified a feature in its spectrum with a hydrogen Lyman-alpha emission line. If this identification is correct, we show that the intergalactic medium (IGM) around the galaxy must be significantly ionized; otherwise, the damping wing of Lyman-alpha absorption by the neutral IGM would have greatly suppressed the emission line. We find either that the large-scale region surrounding this galaxy must have been largely reionized by z=10 (with a neutral fraction <0.4) or that the stars within the galaxy must be massive (>100 solar masses), and hence capable of producing a sufficiently large HII region around it. We generalize these conclusions and derive the maximum Lyman-alpha line flux for a given UV continuum flux of galaxies prior to the epoch of reionization. 
Abraham Loeb, Rennan Barkana, Lars Hernquist