First-principles DFT+GW study of oxygen vacancies in rutile TiO2
  We perform first-principles calculations of the quasiparticle defect states, charge transition levels, and formation energies of oxygen vacancies in rutile titanium dioxide. The calculations are done within the recently developed combined DFT+GW formalism, including the necessary electrostatic corrections for the supercells with charged defects. We find the oxygen vacancy to be a negative U defect, where U is the defect electron addition energy. For the values of Fermi level below 2.8 eV (relative to the valence band maximum) we find the +2 charge state of the vacancy to be the most stable, while above 2.8 eV we find that the neutral charge state is the most stable. 
Andrei Malashevich, Manish Jain, Steven G. Louie
cond-mat.mtrl-sci