Has the QCD critical point been observed at RHIC? - A Rebuttal
  This note rebuts an old, but recurring claim by Antoniou, Davis and Diakonos [1] that the critical point and associated critical exponents reported in Ref. [2], is based on an erroneous treatment of scaling relations near the critical point. 
Roy A. Lacey (Department of Chemistry, Stony Brook University)
nucl-ex nucl-th