Three-dimensional noncompact $\kappa$-solutions that are Type I forward   and backward
  As indicated by the third author in [19], there is a gap in the previous version of this paper by the first two authors [5]. We provide in this version an argument to fix the aforementioned gap. The main proposition, whose proof uses Perelman's techniques, is implied by Ding [9] and is covered by [19]. Our approach, however, is different from theirs. In addition, we prove a necessary and sufficient condition for a three-dimensional $\kappa$-solution to form a forward singularity. We hope that this condition is helpful in the classification of all three-dimensional $\kappa$-solutions. Up to now, the only main progress on such a classification, as conjectured by Perelman, is by Brendle [2]. 
Xiaodong Cao, Bennett Chow, Yongjia Zhang
math.DG