Comments on "Approximate Characterizations for the Gaussian Source   Broadcast Distortion Region"
  Recently, Tian et al. [1] considered joint source-channel coding of transmitting a Gaussian source over $K$-user Gaussian broadcast channel, and derived an outer bound on the admissible distortion region. In [1], they stated "due to its nonlinear form, it appears difficult to determine whether it is always looser than the trivial outer bound in all distortion regimes with bandwidth compression". However, in this correspondence we solve this problem and prove that for the bandwidth expansion case ($K\geq2$), this outer bound is strictly tighter than the trivial outer bound with each user being optimal in the point-to-point setting; while for the bandwidth compression or bandwidth match case, this outer bound actually degenerates to the trivial outer bound. Therefore, our results imply that on one hand, the outer bound given in [1] is nontrivial only for Gaussian broadcast communication ($K\geq2$) with bandwidth expansion; on the other hand, unfortunately, no nontrivial outer bound exists so far for Gaussian broadcast communication ($K\geq2$) with bandwidth compression. 
Lei Yu, Houqiang Li, Weiping Li
cs.IT math.IT