Many questioned the legality of Apple's arrangement, and in October 2007 a class-action lawsuit was filed against Apple, claiming that its exclusive agreement with AT&T violates California antitrust law.
Many questioned the legality of Apple's arrangement. A class-action lawsuit was filed against Apple. This was in October 2007. Its exclusive agreement with AT&T violates California antitrust law. This was what a class-action lawsuit was claiming in October 2007.