O'Keefe was born in and reared in Delmar, New York, where he attended Bethlehem Central High School (1997-2001), before studying political science at American University (2001-2005) in their School of Public Affairs.
O'Keefe was born in. O'Keefe was reared in Delmar. Delmar was New York. He attended Bethlehem Central High School (1997-2001). This was before. He was studying political science at American University (2001-2005) in their School of Public Affairs.