While the Second Circuit's decision set the precedent, Judge Woosley's trial court opinion has been reproduced in all Random House printings of the novel, and that opinion has been recognized as a perceptive analysis of Joyce's work.
The Second Circuit's decision set the precedent. Judge Woosley's trial court opinion has been reproduced in all Random House printings of the novel. The Second Circuit's decision set the precedent. That opinion has been recognized as a perceptive analysis of Joyce's work.