She criticized Sullivan's treatment of the biblical background of the "Prohibitionist" view, for his treatment of official Catholic statements on homosexuality, and for ignoring the hostility to homosexuality in religions other than Christianity, especially in Islam.
She criticized Sullivan's treatment of the biblical background of the "Prohibitionist" view, maintaining that he focused too much on Leviticus and ignored Genesis. She also noted that Sullivan failed to clarify the relevance of official Catholic statements on homosexuality to non-Catholics, and ignored the hostility to homosexuality in religions other than Christianity, especially in Islam.