Nolan left Taking Back Sunday in 2003 and during March 2010 rejoined Taking Back Sunday with Shaun Cooper, who left during his first run with the band, reforming the Tell All Your Friends-era lineup.
Nolan left Taking Back Sunday in 2003 along with bassist Shaun Cooper, who he formed Straylight Run with. During March 2010, he and Cooper rejoined Taking Back Sunday, reforming the "Tell All Your Friends"-era lineup.