Dougherty has also played box lacrosse in the National Lacrosse League, and was the starting goalie for 1998 United States Lacrosse team that won the World Lacrosse Championship.
Dougherty has also played box lacrosse in the National Lacrosse League for the Philadelphia Wings and the Baltimore Thunder, though he played sparingly. He was also the starting goalie for 1998 United States Lacrosse team that won the World Lacrosse Championship.