An editor from the "Arizona Daily Star" praised Selena's emotive vocalization and commented that Selena had recorded "I Could Fall in Love" as if she was going through déjà vu.
An editor from the "Arizona Daily Star" believed Selena used her emotive vocalization to emphasize the song's structural theme. Further commenting, the editor believed that Selena had recorded "I Could Fall in Love" as if she was going through déjà vu.