To catch my eye means to attract my interest, which is what the girl was trying to do by being visually appealing.
Context: After a couple of more songs, a familiar-looking blonde girl that had been trying to get my attention all night asked me to play lips of an angel.
Hypothesis: After a couple of more songs, a familiar-looking blonde girl that had been trying to catch my eye all night asked me to play lips of an angel.

Is the hypothesis incorrect? (Yes, no, or unknown)?