So after the samples were up, the winner was Benjamin Moore Winter White. It is a shade lighter than Paper White, which is in the playroom. Its light and airy with a tinge of grey. The upper left in the picture below. Black Fireplace Surround, Fireplace Surrounds, Gas Fireplace, Building Windows, Pine Floors, Fireplace Inserts, Floor Finishes, Rustic Barn, <PERSON>