Helical Graphene Nanostructures Embedded with an Azulene Cluster
An azulene cluster is a structural defect of graphenes, and it alters the electronic, magnetic, and structural properties of graphenes and graphene nanoribbons. However, detailed experimental investigations of graphenes or graphene nanostructures embedded with an azulene cluster are limited because they are difficult to synthesise. Herein, azulene-embedded graphene nanostructures (AGNs) were synthesised by following a newly developed synthetic protocol. The nanostructures comprising pentagons, hexagons, and heptagons has three characteristic edges, viz., zigzag-, armchair-, and cove-type edges. Experimental and theoretical investigations of the properties of AGN revealed that 2 the cove edge has stable helical chirality with a racemisation barrier of 29.2 kcal/mol, in contrast to normal cove-type edges that undergo rapid racemisation. The in-solution self-association behaviour and the structural, electronic, and electrochemical properties of AGN are also described in detail.
<!>Results and discussion<!>Synthesis of 1a.
<p>The topology of -electrons is one of the most crucial factors that determine the properties of graphene nanostructures. Accordingly, much effort has been devoted towards synthesising and elucidating the properties of topologically diverse graphene nanostructures, whose hexagonal rings are fused in different patterns. [1][2][3][4] Researchers have also been interested in introducing non-hexagonal rings such as pentagons, [5][6][7] heptagons, [8][9][10] or octagons 11 into -conjugation systems to achieve unique optical, electronic, and structural properties, distinct from those of -systems composed of only hexagonal units.</p><p>Among the non-hexagonal ring systems, the contiguous pentagon-heptagon ring system, the socalled azulene structure, has been attracting considerable interest owing to its interesting properties such as a low-lying excited state and high dipolar moment, which are distinct from those of usual benzenoids. 12 Thus, considerable efforts have been dedicated to incorporate azulene structures into polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) to impart unique structural and electronic properties. [13][14][15][16][17] Of particular interest is the azulene structure observed in graphenes as one of the structural defects, which breaks the symmetry of graphenes to significantly alter their mechanical, magnetic, and electronic properties, as well as open non-zero band gap. [18][19][20][21] It is noteworthy that the azulene units in a single graphene molecule not only exist separately, rather tend to accumulate to form clusters. 21 In graphene nanoribbons (GNRs), whose edge structures are important for their properties, the incorporation of azulene units results in unique edge structures. For example, the GNR bearing 4 sandwiched contiguous azulene rings would have a zigzag edge and an armchair at the top and the bottom sides, respectively (Fig 1a ). A "narrowed" variant of the cove-type edge [22][23][24][25][26] (Fig. 1c) can also be considered as another example, where the "cove" comprises a contiguous 6-7-7-6 ring system instead of the four hexagons of a normal cove edge (Fig. 1b), leading to a narrower cove structure. While there were considerable efforts to theoretically elucidate the nature of azulene-embedded graphenes and GNRs, [18][19][20][21]  is not straightforward since isomerisation among 5-, 6-, and 7-membered rings occurs on metal surfaces at elevated temperatures under typical conditions of the CVD process. 27,28 Bottom-up chemical synthesis of nanocarbons that resemble model structures of such graphenes would be one solution to this problem. [29][30][31] Since direct investigation of graphenes embedded with azulene units is challenging due to the difficulty in synthesis, it is of significance to prepare model nanocarbons to gain insights into the properties of parent graphenes. Compared to those of other nanocarbons composed only of hexagonal rings and isolated non-hexagonal ring(s), [29][30][31] the bottom-up chemical syntheses of nanocarbons with multiple azulene units are still limited, because of the absence of reliable methods, especially in-solution ones. [32][33][34] Peña, Pascual and co-workers, 35 and Müllen, Fasel, Feng and co-workers 36 elegantly addressed this situation by utilising on-surface dehydrocyclisation of rationally designed precursors to incorporate azulene units into nanocarbons.</p><p>Mastalerz 37 and Zhang 38 also independently achieved in-solution synthesis of highly fused azulene units via the Scholl cyclisation of ingeniously tailored precursors. Despite these pioneering works, there is still a lack of appropriate methods to construct highly condensed azulene clusters, structures that frequently appear in graphenes. 21 Therefore, new synthetic protocols should be developed to access nanocarbons embedded with this moiety.</p><p>Herein, we report a bottom-up chemical synthesis of azulene-embedded graphene nanostructures 1 and their properties (Fig. 1d). Compounds 1 have unprecedented contiguous azulene structures condensed at their heptagonal rings, and it was designed as a model structure of one of the clustering azulene units observed in graphenes. It also has a helical structure considered to be a minimum structure of one of the narrowed variants of the cove-type edge. A newly developed 10electrolysation-oxidation cascade of fluoranthene 2 to construct an azulene structure enabled us to obtain the key intermediate 3, leading to the successful generation of a highly condensed azulene cluster via further -extension.</p><!><p>In our continuing studies on PAHs, 39 we reasoned that constructing an additional heptagonal ring next to the pentagon of benzo-fused fluoranthene 2 would be a straightforward way to obtain condensed azulene structure 3, because 2 itself has a pentagonal ring surrounded by multiple benzene rings (Fig. 1d). Unfortunately, it was found that conventional -extension reactions such as metal-catalysed cycloisomerisation of alkyne, intramolecular Friedel-Crafts acylation, and Scholl cyclisation are not applicable for this purpose, as these reactions led to the formation of complex mixtures or recovery of unreacted starting materials (see Supporting Information for details). After several investigations, it was established that compound 2c consisting of an -styryl moiety is a suitable precursor to generate the desired azulene unit. Thus, activating this molecule by visible-light-irradiation in the presence of an oxidant resulted in a clean conversion of 2c into 3c via an oxidative cyclisation process (Fig. 2a, Eq. 1). The utilisation of visible light as a mild energy source was important to effectively generate the azulene structure since the activation of 2c by both UV light (low-pressure mercury-vapour lamp), which is conventionally used to promote 6electrocyclisation of stilbenes, 40 and heating to 250 °C led to lower yields of 3c (52 or 40% yield, respectively). Since 2c has a 10-electron system, this oxidative cyclisation reaction would proceed via a visible-light-promoted 10-electrocyclisation 41,42 followed by a dehydrogenation by the oxidant. Such an approach for azulene rings based on oxidative electrocyclic ring closure of the heptagon is an unprecedented one, to the best of our knowledge. The synthetic utility of this newly developed method was highlighted by applying it in the synthesis of boronate ester 3a from 2a (Fig. 2a, Eq. 2), as the C-B bond on its heptagon was converted into Csp2-Csp2 bonds by a transition-metal catalysed cross-coupling reaction such as the Suzuki coupling reaction, offering opportunities for further -extensions.  With azulene-embedded boronate ester 3a in hand, we moved forward to the synthesis of graphene nanostructure 1 (Fig. 2b). The cross-coupling reaction between boronate ester 3a and triflate 5, which was prepared by the triflylation of hydroxyfluoranthene 4, 39 proceeded smoothly to generate compound 6 in 46% yield. The Scholl reaction of compound 6 using the combination of 2,3-dichloro-5,6-dicyano-p-benzoquinone (DDQ) and trifluoromethanesulfonic acid (TfOH) resulted in the formation of two C-C bonds to afford the desired graphene nanostructure 1a in 16% yield.</p><p>The purple crystals of compound 1a suitable for X-ray crystallography were obtained by recrystallising it from a NO2Ph/CS2/cyclohexane solvent system by slow solvent evaporation, and its structure was unambiguously confirmed (Fig. 3a). 44 The bond lengths of the pentagonal and heptagonal rings in compound 1a are summarised in Fig. 3b together with those of the unsubstituted azulene. 45 The azulene structures in compound 1a show significant bond alternation varying between 1.33 Å and 1.50 Å, as observed in the unsubstituted azulene. The armchair-edge-like side of 1a,</p><p>shown as the bottom side in the figure, has a rather planar structure, and 1a was stacked together on that side in the crystal form (Fig. 3c and 3d). The cove region of compound 1a has, in contrast, a significantly distorted helical structure, and the angle of the eclipsed rings (shown as B and B' in Fig. 5a) is 39°, the value is close to that reported for the normal cove edge (38°). 22 The enantiomers arising from this cove region were alternatively arranged in the crystal structure with a distance as short as 3.2 Å, suggesting strong intermolecular − stacking interactions (Fig. 3c and 3d). The strong intermolecular interactions of 1a also led to an in-solution self-association behaviour:</p><p>the 1 H NMR spectra of compound 1a showed a significant concentration-dependence; that is, the peaks of aromatic protons shifted upfield as the concentration increased. These upfield-shifts resulted from face-to-face aggregations, 46 and the association constant (K2) in CDCl3/CS2 (1:1) was estimated to be 74.1 ± 25.5 M⁻ 1 by assuming that dimers are formed predominantly 46,47 (see the Supporting Information for details). Interestingly, the degree of concentration dependence of the chemical shift varied significantly with the position of protons: the chemical shifts of the protons located on the planar region were considerably affected by the concentration, whereas those of the protons located around the cove region was not. These observations indicated that the in-solution self-aggregation was induced by the face-to-face − stacking interactions between the planar regions.</p><p>Since the cove-type structure of 1a comprising of a contiguous 6-7-7-6 ring system was not investigated previously, we questioned if the racemisation barrier of this cove is high enough for 1a to be chiral. Since the direct separation of compound 1a by chiral HPLC was challenging due to its poor solubility, compound 1b, whose aromatic substituent was replaced by a bulky tertiary alkyl side chain to increase its solubility, was prepared in a similar way. Compound 1b exhibited a significantly improved solubility in common non-polar organic solvents (even in hexane), but not in polar solvents such as MeOH. Accordingly, 1b was subjected to chiral HPLC analyses, and the 12 enantiomers were separated without any observable racemisation at 25 °C. The mirror-symmetric circular dichroism (CD) spectra of the two separated fractions confirmed that they are certainly a pair of enantiomers (Fig. 4a). The stable helicity of the cove of 1 is in clear contrast to that of the normal cove structure comprising of four benzene rings, or [4]helicene structure, which is reported to racemise immediately. 22,48 Theoretical calculations revealed that the free energy of activation for the racemisation of the model structure (1c) is as high as 29.2 kcal/mol (Fig. 4b), which lies between those of [5]helicene and [6]helicene (24.6 and 36.2 kcal/mol, respectively) (Fig. 4c). 49 The reason for such a high racemisation barrier is that the hydrogen atoms of the cove region are forced to locate closely to each other owing to the large interior angle of the 7-membered ring, requiring a highly distorted achiral transition state to undergo racemisation. The nucleus-independent chemical shifts (NICS) were calculated to gain insight into the local aromaticity of each ring in compound 1 (Fig. 4d). According to the calculations, all the hexagonal rings (A, B, E, F, and G) show negative NICS(1) values, confirming their aromatic characters. In more detail, the A-B ring system, which would be expected to have naphthalene-like property,</p><p>shows larger NICS(1) values than that of naphthalene 50 (−10.7 ppm) especially for the B ring (−6.98 ppm), suggesting the weaker local aromaticity of these rings. Similarly, the phenanthrene-like E-F-G ring system shows larger NICS(1) values than that of unsubstituted phenanthrene. 50 The weaker local aromaticity of these hexagonal rings can be attributed to the -conjugations between A-B and E-F-G ring systems through the embedded azulene structures. The pentagonal rings (C and H) and the heptagonal ring (D) show a slightly negative NICS(1) value, indicating that these rings have significantly weaker aromaticity than that of the unsubstituted azulene 50 (−7.82 and −17.8 ppm for heptagon and pentagon, respectively), presumably due to the fused benzene rings (A, B, F, and G).</p><p>To investigate the optoelectronic and electrochemical properties of 1, UV-vis absorption spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry (CV), and differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) were conducted.</p><p>The UV-vis absorption spectra showed two weak bands at 660 and 600 nm, and strong bands at 477 and 404 nm in the visible region (Fig. 5a). According to the TD-DFT calculation, the weak bands at 660 and 600 nm could be assigned as HOMO → LUMO (calc = 635 nm, f = 0.062) and HOMO-1</p><p>→ LUMO transitions (calc = 584, f = 0.036), respectively (Fig. 5b). We assigned the strong band at 15 480 nm to the contributions of HOMO → LUMO+1 (calc = 548, f = 0.247) and HOMO-2 → LUMO (calc = 513, f = 0.421) transitions. According to the CV analysis, compound 1a is stable to both electrochemical oxidation and reduction; it shows three reversible oxidation peaks at 0.72, 0.83 and 1.2 V, and two reduction peaks at −1.3 and −1.7 V (vs. Ag/Ag + ) (Fig. 6a). In CV and DPV voltammograms, the first oxidation peak was split into two small peaks (P1 and P2). Variableconcentration DPV analysis of the soluble analogue 1b suggested that this splitting of the oxidation peaks resulted from the self-association characteristic of this compound (vide supra) (Fig. 6b). Since the first peak (P1) weakened with a decrease in the concentration, it is considered to be due to the oxidation of aggregated species. The second peak (P2), on the other hand, strengthened with a decrease in the concentration, indicating that it results from the oxidation of monomeric species. In summary, a new methodology for the construction of a highly condensed azulene unit was developed to synthesise graphene nanostructure 1 featured by the embedded azulene cluster and a narrowed variant of the cove edge. The cove-like region of 1 comprising a 6-7-7-6 ring system was demonstrated to have stable chirality both experimentally and theoretically, in contrast with those of structures with normal cove edges. Single crystal X-ray analysis, variable-concentration NMR, and DPV analyses revealed the tendency of 1 to stack via − interactions both in crystal form and in solutions. The new synthetic methodology and the information on the structural and electronic effect of the azulene cluster in graphene nanostructure provided herein would contribute to the future design and synthesis of various azulene-embedded nanocarbons. NaHCO3 followed by water. The organic phase was dried over MgSO4, filtered through a pad of silica gel, and then concentrated. The residue was purified by silica gel column chromatography (hexanes/EtOAc) to recover compound 3c (12.4 mg, 77% yield) as a purple solid.</p><!><p>To a stirred solution of 6 (603 mg, 0.541 mmol) and DDQ (270 mg, 1.19 mmol) in dry DCM (60 mL), TfOH (0.47 mL, 5.4 mmol) was added. The mixture was stirred for 5 min and quenched with Et3N. The organic layer was washed with water, dried over MgSO4, and concentrated.</p><p>Subsequently, the residue was dissolved in CS2, filtered through a pad of silica gel, and concentrated.</p><p>After that, pentane was added to precipitate out the product, which was collected by filtration, washed several times with MeOH followed by pentane, and dried under reduced pressure to recover compound 1a (95.2 mg, 16% yield) as a dark purple solid.</p>