"Spin" gave the record an 8/10 rating, calling it "irresistibly gaudy" and "catchier, glitzier, ballsier". It even sounds catchier than the chorus. The self-produced album features catchier melodies and more synth playing from Alcaraz. A near-pop sensibility was embraced, with shorter and catchier tunes. Such songs are often catchier and attract attention toward listeners. He also said that the song is catchier than "Beautiful Monster". According to AllMusic, the album's music is "catchier" and has an "intoxicating sense of fun". Eric Skelton of "Complex" thinks that the song shows Ma's "catchier, more radio-friendly side". A catchier name was later suggested and Old Bay seasoning was born.