The Federal Circuit then agreed to rehear the case en banc. The Coalition to Protect Marriage asked the Ninth Circuit to rehear the case "en banc". On November 12, 2014, the full Ninth Circuit voted to rehear the case en banc. On October 27, 2011, the Ninth Circuit agreed to rehear the case "en banc". Finally on December 2, 2015, the Federal Circuit declined to rehear "en banc". In 2004, Anderson dissented when the 11th circuit refused to rehear a case. The FDA requested that the Court of Appeals rehear the case. The original three-judge panel then agreed to rehear the case itself. That court ruled in favor of Bishop and refused a motion to rehear the case. However, on January 14, 2014 the court declined to rehear the case. On January 23, 2008, the Court voted 5-0 to rehear Caperton's appeal. Judges Jones, Smith, Owen, Elrod, Haynes, Willett, Ho, Engelhardt, and Oldham voted not to rehear. In February 2015, however, the panel withdrew its opinion and agreed to rehear the case.