There were certain defects in detinue sur trover. Glanvill described one action which had features of both debt and detinue. This argument represents the realization of a theory of contract in detinue. It entirely replaced detinue, which fell into complete disuse. By this case, trover became virtually concurrent with detinue. In colonial America, replevin was used more often than detinue. Historically, detinue came in two forms&colon; "detinue sur bailment" and "detinue sur trover". The standard remedy in a detinue action is an order that the property be returned. In those days, action in "detinue sur trover" could not lie against a third party. Book suggests that in 1294 detinue could be brought against a finder of a chattel. In 1315, an action in detinue was allowed for "breaking the bulk". The first of these was called "detinue sur trover". Under the act, Detinue was abolished. Detinue also replaced the more ancient action of res adiratae. Just as forms of assumpsit replaced debt, so in the seventeenth century trover replaced detinue.