Meanwhile, Urquhart appoints ambitious backbencher Claire Carlsen as his Parliamentary Private Secretary. Walsall councillor Eddie Hughes defeated the long-serving Labour backbencher David Winnick on a 12-point swing. White remained in parliament as a Liberal backbencher. Nicklin, therefore, entered Parliament as a humble opposition backbencher. He resigned the Liberal leadership, but remained in parliament until 1982 as a backbencher. Churchill was then a backbencher MP representing the Epping constituency. He declined a junior ministerial position, remaining a backbencher until 1922. The previous incumbent for several parliaments was Conservative backbencher David Madel. Douglas returned to Parliament as an ACT backbencher in 2008 before retiring in 2011. After the 1996 Coalition victory Pyne sat as a backbencher. Rudd remained within the government, initially as a backbencher. As a backbencher, he had campaigned on these issues. During his years as an opposition backbencher, Scullin spoke frequently and passionately. Peters remained as a National backbencher, continuing to criticise the party. He sat as a backbencher in Bill Davis's Progressive Conservative government from 1981 to 1985.