On 27 January 2006, Robert was indicted in Luxembourg for insult, calumny and slander. Hidden enemies, danger, calumny, darkness, terror, deception, occult forces, error. New punitive decrees against calumny were issued by Pope Gregory IX in his Decretals. He has gone where "envy and calumny and hate and pain" cannot reach him. This calumny was afterwards most severely avenged upon Agave. Benton called the statement an "atrocious calumny". Yiu publicly accuses him of calumny and punches him, which results in a brawl. The spreading of evil reports, even when true, is branded as calumny. However, Knox's conviction for committing "calunnia" (calumny) against Lumumba was upheld by all courts. Kinchev filed a suit for calumny and moral loss compensation. Seeking to defend themselves against the calumny, they returned to Italy. The latter sued him for calumny and obtained 4,000 francs in damages. The Whig press, with Keppel's friends, began a campaign of calumny. The English word "calumny" derives from the Latin. Scaramella was a suspect by the Italian justice department for calumny.