Even so, Banten Province is a multi-ethnic society consisting of various ethnics and religions. The key groups were low-skilled ethnics, especially Catholics, Jews, and blacks. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies . The ethnics (especially the Germans) and the Democrats lost their political base. He argues that white ethnics will reject assimilation and live separately from other races. The different scholars link their affinities to different ethnics. During the early 20th century, many white ethnics were relegated to menial or unskilled labor. Mr. Khalid was appointed as Minister of Borders, ethnics and tribal Affairs in 2008. Even Ptolemy refers to two Kamboja territories/and or ethnics - viz. The strip presented multiple perceptions of Irish Catholic ethnics during the early 20th century. The Boston public schools included a conglomerate of white ethnics with very few WASPs. German American ethnics strongly supported neutrality; very few spoke out on behalf of Germany itself. Historian Mark Holler argues that organized crime provided upward mobility to ambitious ethnics.