In 2008, the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals reheard the case en banc. To correct this disparity, the court consolidated both cases and reheard them en banc. The Court vacated the Indiana Supreme Court's decision, and remanded Timbs' case to be reheard. The Circuit reheard the case "en banc" with the same result. So the case was remitted to be reheard. Since the Ohio Supreme Court's decision, the Sixth Circuit has not reheard the case. The matter was reheard by a panel of seven Lords of Appeal in Ordinary. Arguments were reheard in November 1972. Janov taped the session and reheard it repeatedly. NBFA called for all those cases to be reheard. The case was reheard with the new panel coming to the same conclusion. The case was reheard on March 19, 2012. On September 12, 1979, the case was reheard before the entire panel.