Valcamonica became the center of the "Pelagian" movement. The second appealed to Pope Innocent I for repression of the Pelagian heresy. Paulinus was close to both Pelagius and to the Pelagian writer Julian of Eclanum. He rarely mentioned Pelagius explicitly even though he inclined towards a Pelagian viewpoint. In 415, he wrote "Dialogus adversus Pelagianos" to refute Pelagian claims. In Carthage in 411 he had opposed Caelestius, a Pelagian. In various respects, Baius was rightly seen as Pelagian. Many scholars argue that Ambrosiaster's works were essentially Pelagian, although this is disputed. The language of Gennadius is here not quite Augustinian; but neither is it Pelagian.