in discussing the concept of justice, particularly in pre-introductory cases, it is essential to commence from the outset with a clear understanding of the nuances involved in nonpublic scenarios. these are situations where information is not widely disseminated for public consumption. an often-underplayed aspect of justice in such contexts is how decisions are made behind closed doors, which can deeply impact the fairness and perception of justice. therefore, embracing transparency where appropriate, while safeguarding necessary confidentiality, is a delicate balance that must be maintained.