Noes 51Bakshi (P)Jones (P)O'Connor GTirikatene (P)Ball (P)Kanongata'a-Suisuiki (P)O'Connor SUpstonBarry (P)KingParmar (P)van de MolenBaylyLee DPattersonWalker (P)Bridges (P)Lee MPenkWhaitiriBrownMacindoePeters (P)WoodhouseBrownleeMahuta (P)Pugh (P)Young (P)Dean (P)Mark (P)Reti (P)YuleDowie (P)McClay (P)RurawheGarciaMcKelvieSalesa (P)Goldsmith (P)Mitchell C (P)ScottGuy (P)Muller (P)Smith NHayes (P)NgaroStrangeTeller:Hipango (P)O'Connor DTabuteau (P)Loheni