CHAIRPERSON (Hon Ruth Dyson): It's neither novel nor new, Dr Smith. I outlined the procedure before I started taking the vote. There was no question then—had there been, and as I will now, I will confirm that Speaker's ruling 117/2 from 2010 by Dr the Rt Hon Lockwood Smith says that "A chairperson has to consider the admissibility of amendments that are substantially the same as an amendment that has already been negatived by the committee."