PENNY SIMMONDS: Thank you, Mr Speaker. Here are the facts—and I will read those because it comes from the facts of the court case, if I may, Mr Speaker. So the Post Primary Teachers' Association took the case to the High Court and it was lost. The fees and the annual certification decisions were quashed at the beginning. They failed on five counts: they failed to consult, they failed to properly consider the merits of the annual certification, they misconstrued and misapplied key elements of the statutory regime, and it amounted to an unlawful tax. So they lost on five counts. 