Rt Hon JACINDA ARDERN: Firstly, the member himself has proposed tax cuts for the highest-income earners, which are unquestionably inflationary and do not help the lowest-income earners. As an alternative, we have focused on a cost of living package that, because it is targeted, not only offers higher levels of support for lower and middle income New Zealanders but also is less likely to have an inflationary impact. That is what you do when you're a Government focused on those who need support the most and on not making the problem worse. 