Let's just put this in a little bit of perspective. Now, James Shaw, he got up and he huffed and he puffed and he told us this, then he told us that, and then he said the Green Party was going to—wait for it—abstain! Abstinence makes the heart grow fonder for Green Party co-leaders, it seems! They can't decide if they're coming or going. The ACT Party says it is crystal clear. When James Shaw says it's time to tax the rich, he doesn't even know what bill he's speaking on, because this income tax bill does not tax wealth; it is all about taxing income. And what this bill will do—introducing a 39 percent tax rate—is simply punish people who work hard, save, invest, and try to make tomorrow better than today. If James Shaw wants to tax the rich, if the Labour Party wants to tax high-income earners, they are not going to do it by adding this new tax rate. And one reason for that is very simple: they already are.