It was Bill English who used to stand in this House, and he would often refer to welfarism as nothing more than managing misery. And that's exactly what it is. He would always say that it was easy to borrow money, easy to spend money, easy to print money; it's very difficult to make the right decisions. And we have a socialist Labour Government now who are determined to revert back to the old ways of the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s—mostly to encourage their mates in the trade union, but that's a whole different debate. But the real challenge that Bill English used to talk about was actually that the skill is getting people off welfare. That's the real thing. Growing an economy, creating opportunities for real work—a thriving, growing, productive economy. There's nothing in this Budget that encourages business, there's nothing in this Budget that encourages productivity growth, and there's nothing in this Budget except added cost for business that will ultimately mean fewer people are in work. This is a thoroughly bad socialist Labour Party Budget.