Dr DUNCAN WEBB (Labour—Christchurch Central) (remote): Kia ora, Mr Chair. Thank you for that, and, look, I want to absolutely endorse the comments of Minister Parker in this matter. I heard Brooke van Velden speaking before about the average New Zealander, and, of course, the danger with the average New Zealander is that if we have a small amount of very wealthy people, then it skews entirely what the average is. I want to talk about people who are earning under $48,000 a year, of which there are many, and, of course, the tax proposals put forward by the ACT Party would do absolutely nothing for them—but everyone over that, including the people who would benefit most? Those earning over $180,000 a year. It's absolutely extraordinary to me that Brooke van Velden can come to this committee and talk about the costs of her $150 shopping bag, when some people are struggling to feed many children on that. Yet she's trying to create tax breaks through her Supplementary Order Paper for people who are earning even more than she is. Truly extraordinary. 