Noes 60Allan (P)Ghahraman (P)McAnulty (P)Swarbrick (P)Andersen (P)Henare (P)Mitchell C (P)Tabuteau (P)Ardern (P)Hipkins (P)Nash (P)Tinetti (P)BallHughes (P)O'Connor GTwyford (P)Bennett DHuo (P)Parker (P)WallCarter (P)Jackson (P)PattersonWarren-Clark (P)Clark (P)Jones (P)Peters (P)Webb (P)Coffey (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Prime (P)WilliamsCraig (P)LittleRadhakrishnanWoodCurran (P)LogieRobertson (P)WoodhouseDavidson (P)LubeckRoss (P)Woods (P)Davis (P)Luxton (P)RussellEagle (P)Mallard (P)Sage (P)Faafoi (P)MarcroftSepuloni (P)FalloonMark (P)SeymourTeller:Genter (P)Martin (P)Shaw (P)Dyson