HELEN WHITE (Labour): It's a very interesting and perverse thing to hear the use of terms like "minority" and "privacy" and see some sort of suggestion that there's persecution in a bill like this. This is a bill which is designed to tax people who earn over $180,000, 39c in the dollar—they are well able to actually pay that and they're willing to do so, and they voted to do so in their droves. That's because it is the right thing to do. That is because most of us have moved on from Churchill and, in fact, Adam Smith; we are right up to date at the moment and we are reading Stiglitz. We are talking about how we have a gap between rich and poor, and this tax targets the top 2 percent. We have a gap which is all about the top 1 percent, so this is bang on the money for where it should be.