BARBARA EDMONDS (Labour—Mana): Kia orana tatou katoatoa to the House; thank you, Madam Speaker. There are times when the House comes together, and tonight, the very first bill that you saw on the Order Paper, which was in the name of Andrew Bayly, was an opportunity for the House to come together to support some residency changes to superannuation, which had consequential tax amendments. This bill is clearly not one of those times. I'd like to reference the comments by the member Dr Deborah Russell, which can be easily summarised as "This bill is a mistake"—a mistake—and one more time, it's a mistake. The explanatory note of the bill makes reference to the cost of living, and, as Dr Deborah Russell had said tonight, for those on a medium income—she'd actually practically crunched the numbers—it's $8 a week. For those on a higher income of $200k, it is $23 a week. This side of the House does not support this bill, as it disproportionately benefits those on higher incomes more than those on lower incomes, who tend to have greater need. 