Finally, we oppose this motion, not only because the Minister has dropped the ball, but also for the fact that he is just very lucky that he didn't get his way in Cabinet—this bill isn't significantly different. The only reason that it is arguably much the same as it was a year ago is because his Cabinet colleagues turned him down on no sunset clause. But the way that the Minister has conducted himself around this has been short of what we would expect from a good Minister and we oppose this motion.