Hon Dr NICK SMITH (National): This is a very important amendment that tests the integrity of the Government's assurance that it is a temporary bill. I've checked. The Minister has said "This is temporary law." over 20 times. In the earlier clause that we've debated, she has repeatedly said it is a short-term fix. The line of argument that the Minister has used is this: I'm using this appalling process, giving people a day to make submissions, a six-day select committee process—a law that would normally take nine months to get through Parliament is being introduced and rammed through under urgency. She says, "I'm doing all of that because further down the track the Government's going to have a proper consultation process to have an in-depth look around these laws and to come up with a proper answer." Well, if that is the case, then every law reform that's been done in that way has had an expiry clause.