Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: I reject various parts of the premises of that question. What I would say to the member is that over the last 18 months New Zealand has experienced the greatest economic shock in a century. Therefore, as a country and as a Government, we have had to respond to that in a variety of ways. That includes both immediate response but also recovery measures to ensure that the New Zealand economy continues to work well, and the good news is that it has, relative to the rest of the world.