Noes 70AdamsHenare (P)McAnultyStanford (P)Allan (P)Hipkins (P)McKelvieSwarbrick (P)Andersen (P)HudsonMitchell C (P)Tabuteau (P)Ardern (P)Hughes (P)Nash (P)Tinetti (P)BallHuo (P)ParkerTolleyBennett P (P)Jackson (P)Patterson (P)Twyford (P)Bishop (P)Jones (P)Peters (P)Wagner (P)Clark (P)Kaye (P)Prime (P)WallCoffey (P)Kuriger (P)Radhakrishnan (P)Warren-ClarkCollins (P)Lees-Galloway (P)Robertson (P)Webb (P)Craig (P)LittleRoss (P)WilliamsCurranLogieRussellWillisDavidson (P)LubeckSage (P)WoodDavis (P)Luxton (P)Sepuloni (P)Woods (P)Eagle (P)Mallard (P)SeymourYang (P)Faafoi (P)MarcroftShaw (P)Genter (P)Mark (P)Simpson (P)Teller:Ghahraman (P)Martin (P)Sio (P)Dyson