SPEAKER: If the member would just give me a little time. Thank you. I think it's fair to say that the member went up to the edge of that. She was asked very directly a question about it. She addressed the question. I think if she had answered the question in that particular manner, it might well have breached 44/1. I think the Minister answering the question successfully skirted around the Speaker's ruling by using the suggestion that a narrative was being promoted. She did not say a member was racist.