Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: I know this will come as a shock to the member, but from time to time, Governments disagree with the Treasury. It's hard to believe, but it does happen, and, in fact, the member might want to reflect back on some of the occasions that it occurred for her party. On this side of the House, we faced up to the fact that people were facing—as the member called on us to do—a cost of living crisis, and we designed in that period of time something to reach a group of New Zealanders who had not been supported by actions on 1 April. I stand by that action. 