Noes 39BakshiHipango (P)O'Connor SUpston (P)BarryKanongata'a-SuisuikiParmarWhaitiriBridges (P)Lee DPenkWoodhouseBrownLee MPugh (P)Young (P)Brownlee (P)MacindoeReti (P)Yule (P)Dean (P)Mahuta (P)RurawheDowie (P)McClay (P)Salesa (P)GarciaMuller (P)Scott (P)GoldsmithNgaroSmith NGuy (P)O'Connor D (P)Strange (P)Teller:HayesO'Connor GTirikatene (P)Loheni