Ayes 36Bakshi (P)GarciaMcClay (P)Upston (P)BarryGoldsmith (P)Mitchell MWalkerBayly (P)Guy (P)Muller (P)WoodBennett D (P)Hayes (P)NgaroYoung (P)BidoisHipango (P)ParmarYule (P)Bridges (P)Hudson (P)PenkBrownLee DPugh (P)Brownlee (P)Lee MScott (P)Dean (P)LoheniSmith N (P)Teller:Dowie (P)Macindoe (P)TolleyO'Connor S