Can I just say with regards to clause 88—where the Minister has said, "Well, it came back from the select committee unamended."—that, as everyone in this House knows, the select committee process was ridiculously short. It was a very fast process, hurried through, and under a time frame that probably didn't allow the full extent of coverage or scrutiny on all of these passages. It's why we actually have a House committee session as well, and, of course, interestingly, the Government was in such a hurry to get this bill through that it failed to put in front of the select committee the 50-page Supplementary Order Paper that's been provided today. So it's not unreasonable to ask that simple question about what it is that makes, or appears to make, some of these provisions so retrospective. 