Dr SHANE RETI (National): Talofa, Madam Speaker. It's a pleasure to speak to this Budget, a Budget that is clearly going backwards. I will turn my attentions to the health space particularly, and I have three broad concerns with this Budget in health. First of all, clearly not enough spending on the health workforce, I'll give more detail around that. Secondly, dumb spending—and I'd put to you the health reforms is dumb spending. And thirdly, an inability to deliver any health benefits, with a poor track record that portends poorly that anything will actually be delivered in this Budget.