INGRID LEARY (Labour—Taieri): I have some sympathy for what the member Maureen Pugh has tried to do with this bill. The intent of it is really about scaling up something that has been shown to work before, and it is trying to get some economic benefit for people where she lives. So while the intention is pure, I'm afraid I can't support it, because the scale-up element of it simply doesn't work, and that's for three reasons: firstly, it's just simply not ecologically working in the same direction that we're going as a Government and that we know that we need to go with climate change; secondly, the economic arguments don't stack up; and, thirdly, it's simply not needed. 