Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: Well, the member opposite might be able to help me with that, which is the fact that houses weren't built under her Government's watch, to the extent that we have had to play catch-up, so that supply of rentals are simply not there. That is not to undermine the fact that many New Zealanders, including those who rent, are doing it tough at the moment, and that's why this Government has been providing support to low and middle income New Zealanders rather than proposing tax cuts for the most wealthy.