Dr DUNCAN WEBB (Labour—Christchurch Central): What a misery guts! That member, Gerry Brownlee, was so disinterested in what is actually going on that he almost forgot to stand up. He would have us not give the people who most need it, all of the assistance that we possibly can. He'd go back to Ruth Richardson's Budget if he had his way. And members might have noticed that he didn't actually speak about the bill before the House. 