Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: I challenge the premise of the figures that the member has put out in front of us. We have an economy that has been growing at a faster rate than most of our trading partners and that has strong momentum in its labour market, with 4 percent unemployment, and that has strong momentum in its wages, with wages around a 3.6 percent increase. This is an economy that is doing well. I would really encourage the member to focus on the positive and let's all get together and actually make sure that New Zealand gets through this coronavirus crisis.