Noes 28BakshiHipango (P)PenkWhaitiriBarryKanongata'a-SuisuikiPugh (P)WoodhouseBridges (P)Lee MReti (P)Young (P)BrownMacindoeRurawheDean (P)Mahuta (P)Salesa (P)GarciaNgaroSmith NGoldsmithO'Connor SStrange (P)Teller:HayesParmarTirikatene (P)Loheni