This bill is a disgrace for what it is going to do to hard-working Kiwis. The Motor Industry Association—if anybody hasn't read a press release that begs a Government like that press release, read it. It says here that this "has demonstrated an appalling lack of understanding of how to effectively reduce emissions". It says, also, "the targets were a nasty surprise." They were unexpected. "There is no obvious rationale and it seems it is a revenue gathering exercise for New Zealand to have targets that are tougher than other jurisdictions like Europe." This is at a time when nobody speaks up against this Government, and yet the Motor Industry Association has slammed them for what is, effectively, a tax grab on middle New Zealanders, and it will never work.