Rt Hon JACINDA ARDERN: The member is proposing a change in policy that would essentially see someone, for instance, as I've said, who would be on a wage of $45,000 receiving $2.15 per week. At the same time, he has rejected and voted against the family tax credit increases that we proposed that would mean that they were more than $20 a week better off. He does not support increases in the minimum wage. He wants to get rid of the top tax bracket that we have introduced. He's proposing $3 billion worth of cuts to health, education, and all of the services that New Zealanders value; either that or he wants to increase debt. We stand by our policies. They are focused on low and middle income earners, whereas his will give $2.15 instead, where people could be better off by over $20.