Nobody suggests that every job can be saved. Nobody suggests that every job should be saved. What's needed, though, is a plan to grow jobs, to give small businesses, the engine room of the New Zealand economy, the confidence to invest, to grow, and to take on the chance of hiring somebody new. The cost of not doing so is incredibly high: people out of work for a lengthy period, which we know makes it all the more challenging to get them back into the workforce when the time is right. But on that, there is nothing in this Budget. There's more spending—a lot more spending: $160 billion of new spending and new debt—but no plan for how to create jobs for those that we lost.