Hon DAVID PARKER (Minister of Revenue): Well, responding to the member's assertion that the Treasury was saying that support would be better given to people who need it more, now, in Government we believe that we have done the best by people on low incomes. We've increased benefits twice. We have also pegged benefit increases to the higher of inflation or wage growth so that they don't fall back as a proportion of working people's incomes, which they have for many years in New Zealand. We've introduced the winter energy payment—superannuitants get that, as well as all main beneficiary-class categories. So we thought that we were already doing the right thing by those people, together with the transport-related initiatives that I've already traversed. So, in our opinion, we actually disagreed with the Opposition, and sometimes with the Treasury, as to whether there should be some targeted assistance that was short term in the low- to middle-income grouping, people earning up to $70,000 in the year ended 31 March 2022.