I also want to acknowledge this side of the House's comments around the so-called negative effects of benefit dependency, because the only negative effects of being on the benefit come from benefits being too low to begin with. All the research tells us that incomes are one of the largest and most important determinants of health, and consecutive Governments who have kept benefits far too low have created the conditions for people on the benefit to struggle. It is not the caregiver's fault, while they're providing incredible labour to our society. 