Hon Dr DAVID CLARK (Minister for State Owned Enterprises): I rise to speak into this debate, and the point that I do want to make at the outset is that Minister Robertson has set out a very clear letter with very clear expectations to Air New Zealand, and the point that he made in his contribution, which I would underline, is that those expectations have been discussed with the airline for at least a year. What Mr Robertson has done, in putting these down in writing, is make sure that they are crystal clear for everyone. If anybody here believes in markets and the value of markets and the value of information to markets, they will be celebrating—they will be celebrating—the value of having these things laid out clearly for all other shareholders and all other stakeholders to understand. It seems very unfortunate that that is not the view that came across with the person who called for this debate.