Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: On behalf of the Prime Minister, all of the options that were considered by the Minister of Revenue and other Ministers had both pros and cons. The example that the member gives would have seen smaller New Zealand providers potentially be far worse off than the current status quo situation. I repeat for the member: if the member wants to think about tax policy that is going to make New Zealanders better off, she should consider taking the advice of the Minister of Finance and ditching a tax cut for the highest-earning New Zealanders.