This is probably something for the member who's sponsoring the bill to listen to: inflation is not uniform across income groups. That is a basic economic and tax principle. That's why you have transfers if you want to help the cost of living, and you should be targeting it. That's why you have Working for Families tax credits. That's why you have the winter energy payment: to reduce expenses by targeting lower-income families. Lunches in schools, the removal of school donations—but the member sponsoring this bill wanted to challenge us, to say, "Did you actually look at the bill?" Well, for a number of years before I became an MP I was actually a tax adviser to, actually, some of the members on the opposite side of the House. So I technically reviewed this bill. If this bill had come before me when I was an adviser in a Minister's office, I would have put a bright red line through it—bright red—because, fundamentally, it is a poor bill. I'm surprised the Opposition, which claims to be the most fiscally responsible economic manager, cannot see how much this fiscally is inflexible. 