Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: The issue for the member is what constitutes meaningful tax changes when we have got a worker getting $2 as a result of the changes that the member is replacing. I repeat what I said in my answer to an earlier oral question: there are no easy decisions when you're in Government; it is always a matter of balancing different needs. It is important that we support people through increases in the cost of living at the same time as investing in health, education, housing, and other essential items.