Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: We on this side of the House understand that to get through COVID, small businesses had to work extremely hard, and I'm very proud of the fact that we supported them. In 2020 over 60 percent of jobs were supported by the wage subsidy scheme. In 2021 47 percent of jobs were supported by the wage subsidy scheme. We are working to make sure that businesses can access the skilled staff they need, and through the course of the pandemic we have trained more New Zealanders to be able to work as well. This is a global situation. New Zealand's economic performance is regarded by the likes of Moody's as being very strong compared to our peers. I'll listen to those advisers rather than the member on that matter.