What these documents show us is that the economy is forecast to have contracted 4.7 percent this year. So that's not just an economy that's stopped growing; that is an economy that has shrunk and got smaller. It's very easy to get lost in the numbers of the Budget and to think "Well, that's interesting" and economists can analyse them, but a shrinking economy means dreams that are thwarted. It means businesses that are closed down. It means people who have lost their part-time job, who have had their hours reduced, and who have had their pay reduced. We are seeing that impact in our communities, and it hurts. The question that this Budget raises is how long that pain will continue; this Budget certainly does not answer the question of how that pain will be treated.