Dr DEBORAH RUSSELL (Labour—New Lynn): Thank you, Mr Speaker. This is a mistaken bill. It is mistaken in terms of the dollar effect. It is mistaken as to whether it solves any problems. It is mistaken about the nature of taxation. It is mistaken in terms of the assumptions underlying it. It is mistaken in the use of the Consumers Price Index. And it is mistaken as to when this should all happen. Because it is a mistaken bill, the Government will not be supporting this bill. But let me take you through exactly why we won't be supporting this bill, take you through at least some of these problems.