Hon PAUL GOLDSMITH (National): My pleasure to speak on this bill—although not a great pleasure, in the sense that we are not supportive of this bill and we're not supportive of this Budget. Fundamentally, we don't think their plan for dealing with the cost of living crisis that New Zealanders face is any good, and our plan would be a lot better. That's why we're standing up for our plan, which is actually about leaving more money in the hands of New Zealanders, not using inflation that has been partly created by Government activities, partly by global factors, to sneak more taxes out of the hands of New Zealanders.