Noes 43Bakshi (P)GarciaMartinSmith N (P)Ball (P)Goldsmith (P)Mitchell C (P)Smith S (P)Bayly (P)Guy (P)Muller (P)Tabuteau (P)Bennett D (P)Hayes (P)NgaroWalkerBidoisHipango (P)O'Connor SYoung (P)Bridges (P)Hudson (P)ParmarYule (P)BrownJones (P)Patterson (P)Brownlee (P)Lee MPenkCarter (P)LoheniPeters (P)Clark (P)Macindoe (P)Pugh (P)Dean (P)MarcroftReti (P)Teller:Dowie (P)Mark (P)Scott (P)Barry