NICOLA WILLIS: —of business and its contribution to civil society in New Zealand. And what has provoked her to make these claims and ask these questions? It is Minister Faafoi's amendments in this bill that have given her cause for hope that communism and socialism may yet replace private enterprise and endeavour in New Zealand. And is it any wonder that she has been given pause to ask those questions, when the bill we are debating in front of us retrospectively alters the terms of private contracts?