Hon GRANT ROBERTSON: Well, I do think it is important that the member remembers that if we look at the most up-to-date forecast with the Half Year Economic and Fiscal Update, core Crown tax revenue will be below 30 percent of GDP across the forecast period. That is around about where it has been for a number of years. On this side of the House, I think we understand that there has to be a balance when you put a Budget together. Just saying that you're going to spend more but cut taxes and reduce debt does not add up, and that is the problem for the Opposition at the moment. 