Hon TODD McCLAY (National—Rotorua): Kris Faafoi, as Minister, started this many, many years ago, and today, as a formerly hard-working constituent MP for Mana, he is retiring. Can I say to that member, she should be as hard-working as he was and retire as well, because that was an appalling speech. All that we actually see from the Government is a desire from Government backbench MPs to read their notes, not to actually have any understanding of what it means. That member said the Labour Party stands up for consumers; she forgot to say by making everything more expensive. And that's the problem here. 