Secondly, I look at the substance and, as has already been traversed, this bill disproportionately benefits those on higher incomes. It has a regressive effect, which is not surprising coming from the National Party and the ACT Party. Our focus is closing the inequality gap; it is not helping the rich get richer. My colleague Barbara Edmonds has already very carefully laid out the ways that we have been able to do that through our support: lifting main benefits, reinstating the training incentive allowance, expanding food in schools, and delivering more insulation and home heating, and so on. And I would just say that the policies that we're implementing as a Government are clearly working. Today, we've seen unemployment has fallen to pre-COVID levels. We've seen that the average hourly wage rose 4 percent to $34.76 an hour. These are relevant to putting more money in the back pocket of everyday New Zealanders. 