The way this Government has approached the economic platform that they were presented, which was the strongest in a generation—the strongest economic platform that any Government had upon arriving into office. GDP growth of 4 percent a year, job growth 10,000 a month—10,000 a month. Here we are, just a bit over two years later, holding up 1.6 percent growth as somehow a bulwark against what this country is having to face at the moment, as coronavirus is a very real and present danger, not only to people's health but to the health of the economy of New Zealand. They hold up their record of going from 4 percent growth to 1.6 percent growth as some badge of honour. Well, it is hopeless. 