Rt Hon JACINDA ARDERN: The member casts aspersions on this entire House with that statement, given productivity has been an issue that successive Governments have worked to tackle. The member will have seen that over time, of course, we've seen improvements—over a number of years, gradual as they may be. But, again, the very issues that we need to address if we're to improve our productivity as a nation include, for instance, investing in skills and training. I note the member wishes to get rid of the first year free of post-secondary education. We'd also include investment in research and development. I note the member would like to get rid of the R & D tax credit and Callaghan Innovation. It seems we have very different views on what will improve our productivity.