 Judge Rebecca Frank Dallet authored the court opinion, writing that, quote, even if Aish's statements were true threats, an issue we do not decide, the harassment injunction still violates the First Amendment because the circuit court did not make the necessary finding that Aish consciously disregarded a substantial risk that his communications would be viewed as threatening violence. Justice Rebecca Bradley wrote a concurring opinion, including that the circuit court had failed to show that Aish had made true threats against Kinski or any other clinic staff.