 So then Representative Paul Baumbach, who is retiring, Democrat, called for Patton to be removed as president. But Patton won 4-3. All these 4-3 votes. Shelton lost a 4-3 vote. Board President Donald Patton, who Baumbach wanted to get rid of as president. Also Vice President Althea Smith-Tucker, who Althea, by the way, also won her re-election.