 I mean, if you can keep it on the shelf in the store, why not be able to keep it on the shelf at home? I feel like if you buy it off the shelf at the store, it's not in the refrigerator, right? It is nasty if you put it in the refrigerator. Yes, it is. Why would you make a hot dog or a warm hamburger and put cold ketchup on it? It's crazy. On the bottle, it says that you're supposed to refrigerate after opening. So yes, I do think you should keep the ketchup in the refrigerator. Yes, sir.