 jurisprudence symmetrical on the criminal side so you know if there's a criticism of the court that i would have here is that it didn't give enough guidance on where that line is drawn between public and private but i think as a general matter what the court did was entirely predictable and you know thomas soul had this great line that when sort of the left comes out at you with their heads exploding and the moral outrage the question you should always ask them as compared to what