 And when he pulls it out, Tommy reveals that the milk has soaked into the cookie, making it soft and even creamier than it started. The video has been watched millions of times, and commenters haven't been kind. Those who tried it complained it didn't work and warned how hot the glass and cookie would be after 45 seconds in the microwave. Others called out the finished product for what it actually was, an Oreo Cakester, rather than some new fusion of milk and Oreos. I like the idea.