 their boats and they have to pay for their own little minders right and the company said this is going to be such a huge expense we can't bear it and stay in business uh in any you know profitable way so a big win for them today um justice kagan writing for the dissenters um said basically this was a power grab by the court and that this should be left to federal agencies i mean during the arguments they you know there was a lot of probing from the more liberal justices to