5.4 申诉人认为，在评估缔约国在《公约》第 3 条之下的义务时，除了申诉人的个人情况以外，还必须考虑到大规模侵犯人权的证据。申诉人说，他有部分俾路支族血统。考虑到他所在的巴基斯坦地区的状况，以及他曾经遭受过酷刑，他认为，得出结论认为如果被遣送回巴基斯坦，他本人不会面临实际、可预见的危险，是毫无道理的，也是武断的。申诉人还提到了缔约国发布的关于巴基斯坦的旅行建议。这项建议指出，在巴基斯坦各地尤其是卡拉奇、俾路支省、普赫图赫瓦省及联盟直辖部落地区，遭绑架的可能性很大，因此，由于“极端危险的安全状况的和仍然在进行的反叛行动”，旅行者最好不要前往这些地区。
5.4 The complainant submits that, in addition to the personal circumstances of a complainant, evidence of mass human rights violations must also be considered in assessing a State party’s obligations under article 3 of the Convention. The complainant recalls that he is of part-Balochi ethnicity. Considering the situation in the region of Pakistan that he comes from, together with the fact that he has previously been subjected to torture, he considers that it is unreasonable and arbitrary to conclude that he would not face a real, personal and foreseeable risk of torture if deported to Pakistan. The complainant also refers to the State party’s travel advice on Pakistan according, to which there is a high threat of kidnapping across Pakistan, but particularly in Karachi, Balochistan, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, and that travellers are accordingly strongly advised not to travel to these areas due to the “extremely dangerous security environment and the ongoing counter-insurgency operation”.