40. 关于第二类任意拘留，政府认为来文方的说法是错误的。与来文方的报告相反，政府声称 Ghadde 先生不是因为反对宪法修正案而被捕，而是因为腐败行为被捕。为证明这一点，政府指出，许多其他政界人士参加了示威游行，但没有被捕。至于他在事件发生时的豁免权，政府说，Ghadde 先生被指控的行为是在他担任参议员期间犯下的，可以与他职责的履行分开。
40. With regard to category II, the Government deems the source’s claims to be erroneous. Contrary to what the source reported, the Government asserts that Mr. Ghadde was not arrested for opposing the constitutional amendments but, rather, for acts of corruption. As evidence of this, the Government notes that many other politicians took part in demonstrations and were not arrested. As for his immunity at the time of the events, the Government argues that the acts of which Mr. Ghadde is accused were committed during his term as a senator and can be separated from the exercise of his functions.