34. 来文方称，对这批学生的拘留是任意拘留，属于工作组工作方法规定的第一、第二、第三和第五类情况。来文方补充说，对这批学生实施的侵权行为还构成违反国际人道法的情况，因为西撒哈拉是被占领土，这批学生属于受《陆战法规和惯例公约》、《关于保护国际性武装冲突受难者的日内瓦四公约》(1949 年日内瓦四公约)，特别是《关于战时保护平民之日内瓦公约》(《日内瓦第四公约》)和习惯国际法保护的人员。
34. The source asserts that the detention of the group of students is arbitrary under categories I, II, III and V as defined in the Working Group’s methods of work. The source adds that the violations committed against the group of students also constitute violations of international humanitarian law, since Western Sahara is an occupied territory and the group of students are among the persons protected by the Convention respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land, the Geneva Conventions for the protection of war victims (Geneva Conventions of 1949), in particular the Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War (Fourth Geneva Convention), and customary international law.