The argument only works if you believe that mathematics is eternal and precedes the universe.
Math has always been around.
Math is new.
With twelve people there deciding his guilt and punishment, you have a stronger discussion.
A woman has a caricature done where she is a ballerina.
The aliens are pushing a stroller.
The ideologies of the parties have remained the same.
A man is checking out at the grocery store.
The man relaxed near the mountainside.