In GameSpot's 2011 Game of the Year awards, To the Moon was given the "Best Story" award, which was won against Catherine, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective, Portal 2, and Xenoblade Chronicles. which were also voted in the same category.
Током GameSpot доделе награда 2011, To the Moon је освојио "Best Story" награду, против Catherine, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective, Portal 2, и Xenoblade Chronicles. који су се такође такмичили у истој категорији.