She was cast after Eric Stoltz, who was directing one of the show's episodes, heard about the role of Amelia and remembered Scorsone from working with her on My Horrible Year!
Do role byla obsazena poté, co Eric Stoltz, který režíroval jednu z epizod, uslyšel o roli Amelie a vzpomněl si právě na Caterinu Scorsone, se kterou spolupracoval na My Horrible Year!.