VanderWaal continued to perform her original songs on the show; for her next performance at the quarterfinals on August 23, 2016, she sang "Beautiful Thing", a song that she wrote for her sister.
VanderWaal i nadále hrála v show pouze své vlastní skladby; ve čtvrtfinále v 23. srpna 2016 zazpívala svoji píseň Beautiful Thing, kterou napsala pro svou sestru.