In GameSpot's 2011 Game of the Year awards, To the Moon was given the "Best Story" award, which was won against Catherine, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective, Portal 2, and Xenoblade Chronicles. which were also voted in the same category.
На GameSpot в номинации «Игра года 2011», To the Moon получила награду «Лучшая история», тем самым обойдя Catherine, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective, Portal 2 и Xenoblade Chronicles, которые тоже были выставлены на голосование в этой категории.