Why did Jesus say that the demon could only come out by prayer and fasting (Mark 9:29)?

Answer  
  

Mark 9 records a remarkable episode of Jesus casting out an [evil spirit](evil-spirits.html) that His disciples were previously unable to cast out. The same episode contains Jesus’ teaching about the importance of faith. There were other instances when the disciples were able to cast out demons, but Jesus explains that the demon they encountered in Mark 9 could only come out by prayer and fasting (Mark 9:29\).  
  

As Jesus was rejoining His disciples after [the Transfiguration](transfiguration.html), a person in the crowd brought to Jesus his son, who he said was possessed by an evil spirit. The demon in the boy made him mute and had even tried to drown him and burn him with fire (Mark 9:17, 22\). The man had brought his son to Jesus’ disciples to cast the spirit out, but they were not able to do it (Mark 9:18\). Jesus rebuked the crowd for their unbelief and told the man to bring the son to Him (Mark 9:19\).  
  

When he was brought into Jesus’ presence, the boy was thrown into a convulsion by the spirit that possessed him, and the man said to Jesus, “If you can do anything, take pity on us and help us” (Mark 9:22\). Jesus turned the situation back on the man, saying, “If *you* can,” adding that all things are possible for the believing one (Mark 9:23\). The man was not sure if Jesus could accomplish the task, but Jesus challenged the man that the issue was his belief or unbelief. If he would believe in Jesus, Jesus would resolve the situation. The man humbly replied that he did believe but asked Jesus to help him because his belief wasn’t very strong (Mark 9:24\).  
  

As Jesus observed that a large crowd had gathered, He commanded the spirit to leave the boy never to enter him again (Mark 9:25\). After causing more convulsions, the spirit left the boy, who appeared as if he were dead (Mark 9:26\). Jesus took the boy’s hand and lifted him up, alive and well (Mark 9:27\). The spirit that had left the boy was apparently unique, as Jesus would soon explain that such a spirit could only come out by prayer and fasting (Mark 9:29\).  
  

Later, the disciples privately asked Jesus why they could not cast out the unclean spirit (Mark 9:28\), and Jesus replied that this particular kind could only come out “by prayer and fasting” (Mark 9:29, KJV). While the King James Version records Jesus as saying that the demon in Mark 9 could only come out by prayer and fasting, other translations (ASV, NASB, ESV, NIV, etc.) leave out “and fasting” and only mention prayer. The difference is due to some translations’ use of older and less numerous copies of manuscripts, while the KJV translates from some of the more recent and more numerous copies. Sometimes the manuscripts will have slight differences, often referred to as textual variants. Mark 9:29 is an example of a passage with a variant.  
  

While there are many variants in the Greek manuscripts of the New Testament, it is remarkable that none of the variants create any significant doctrinal challenge—they are usually minor and don’t impact the message of a passage at all. Mark 9:29 is one of the more significant variants, as the differing translations make it unclear whether the demon in Mark 9 could only come out by prayer and fasting, or whether prayer alone would work. It is worth noting that in the New Testament [fasting](fasting-Christian.html) was simply prayer so focused and intense that a person did not give attention to things like eating or drinking—so either way, Jesus is emphasizing that the demon in Mark 9 could only come out by intensive prayer.  
  

As Jesus explains to the crowd, the key was the faith of those involved (e.g., Mark 9:19, 23\). So it is evident that [prayer](how-does-prayer-work.html) rooted in faith in Jesus Christ is effective (see James’ assertion that the prayer of a righteous \[believing] person is effective, James 5:16b). Jesus was challenging the crowd, the boy’s father, and the disciples on the importance of believing in Him as the One who could accomplish what would otherwise be impossible.  
  

