

Sufficiently Less Than Enough: Consent, Sex, And Moral Behaviour

1760 words - 8 pages

Sufficiently Less Than Enough: Consent, Sex, and Moral Behaviour

Consent is uniquely argued position within philosophical analysis of moral and immoral behaviours, especially in regards to positions refuting consents ability to be sufficient enough to legitimize moral behaviour. We must remain critical in our analysis of consent, and ways that it may, or may not legitimize moral behaviours. At first glance, one might assume that; the consent of two people is enough to constitute moral behaviour. Upon further investigation, we become aware of another’s ability to consciously consent and engage in acts that will degrade and cause some form of harm to the other, usually for their own mental or physical pleasure, inducing the fact that consent is not sufficient for ensuring moral behaviour. Consent is certainly a necessary part of contextualizing and legitimizing moral, sexual behaviours, however, consent is not implicitly sufficient for moral behaviour on its own. Consent is not sufficient legitimizing certain behaviours.

One most take into consideration that consent is necessary, however, although a necessary requirement, it does not, by default, qualify as sufficient. I will argue this by using Seiriol Morgan’s views on the nature of human desires, and his discussions of Kant’s moral theories opposing arguments failed to completely analyze in their views of consent as necessary and sufficient. Consent does not, by default, illicit moral behaviour. Moral behaviour is often legitimized through consent; however, immoral behaviour may benefit or even be validated through consent. In our evaluation of consent and ways in which consent is considered morally transformative, we must understand the diverse nature that consent is situated.

Consent is implicitly situated in diverse and complicated human desires, often subject to individualized discourses within the self that can be subject to less virtuous wants and desires. Accounts in opposition to the belief that consent is not sufficient, base their beliefs that consent itself is morally transformative, grounded in the notion that consent is mutually affirming in two parties ability to procure common respect and regard for interpersonal sexual intentionality. To assume that consent procures this universal narrative, would be a gross underestimation of the subjective nature of human desires and ways that desires illicit immoral behaviours at the expense of others. In this paper I will argue that consent is certainly a necessary component of legitimate moral behaviour, however, consent alone is not sufficient because it fails to embody the complex and sometimes dark nature of human desires that may subject individuals to dehumanizing desires benign to their happiness or well-being. However, the counter argument fails to imply

Seiriol Morgan’s Dark Desires produces an excellent account for arguing consent as necessary, but not sufficient in validating sexual morality. Morgan draws on...

Find Another Essay On Sufficiently Less Than Enough: Consent, Sex, and Moral Behaviour

It is a commonly held view that Buddhism has been less misogynistic than other major world religions. Assess this view whilst also explaining how and why is has differed

2437 words - 10 pages . The essence of Buddhism, has been subject to societal prejudices that have permeated the religion and become a part of it. Buddhism has not been any less misogynistic than other world religions, as although religions differ in doctrinal points of contention they all retain largely misogynistic stances.Primary BibliographyBuddha, The. Tripitaka. Buddha Jayanti Tripitaka Series Text. May 2nd, 2003. (



Demonstrate an understanding of human rights legislation and reflect on its implication for people with a learning disability. this reflection looks at personal relationships

1765 words - 7 pages parenting skills, and many have been excellent parents, it is frequently seen as something that should be avoided, and if pregnancy does occur, it is likely to result in the child being removed. (Paul, 2007) Likewise, in relation to homosexuality, these relationships are even less well tolerated and are generally perceived not only as 'inappropriate' behaviour, but also often as 'abusive' sexual behaviour and as challenging behaviour (Annette, 2004

Good Sex? A Critical Review of School Sex Education

5381 words - 22 pages (masturbation, coitus, oral-genital sex, and petting), and an increase in attitudinal tolerance. Spanier (1976) conducted an empirical study to determine how sexual socialising experiences (formal and informal) influenced college students' sexual behaviour. Students' retrospective self-reports indicated their informal sexualisation experiences (e.g., peer information, dating experiences, etc.) had more impact on current sexual behaviours than their

Young people’s views of lowering the age of consent

2217 words - 9 pages process. 4th ed. Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill/Open University Press. Mercer, C. H. et al., 2013. Changes in sexual attitudes and lifestyles in Britain through , London: Lancet. Sawyer, M., 2003. Sex before 16 : how the law is failing, London: Channel 4. Thomson, R. & Holland, J., 2002. Young People, Social Change and the Negotiation of Moral Authority. Children & Society, 16(2), pp. p103-115. Waites, M., 2005. The Age of Consent-Young People

Is there a Solution to Date Rape?

1491 words - 6 pages to obtain sexual pleasure without being raped. There are several arguments against this myth found on page 457 of Pineau’s essay. The sexual provocative behavior of a woman does not provide a contract of consent. Both women and men are not sexually pleased with a lack of communication. Another argument is that men can actually display moral behavior in these situations. The last is that women are not entitled to be sexually provocative, therefore

Sexual Use and What to Do about It

1003 words - 5 pages temperate in our indulgences,” in his article “Kant on Sex and Marriage: What Kant Should Have Said” (Stacey 20). For this to be possible a person’s control would seem to be on a level that is nearly inhuman. Soble’s solution is presented in two different theories, each with sub-categories. Internalist solutions do not find consent to be adequate enough to constitute sex as moral, but of a new adaptation so that sex fulfills the Second Formulation. The

Human Genetic Engineering

1675 words - 7 pages would not have consent. In “Genetic Engineering and the Consent of Future Persons,” Martin Gunderson discusses the difference between individual autonomy and moral autonomy. He says that according to bioethicists, autonomy is defined in terms of self-governance --when one can act in accord with one’s personal or authentic values (Gunderson 91). Gunderson says that individual autonomy is characterized in terms of individual desires and values, and

Tearoom Trade: Impersonal Sex in Public Places

1940 words - 8 pages avoid social disapproval. The image that these deviants project is respectable to society in what Humphreys refers to as “the breastplate of righteousness.” The motivation for participation in tearoom sex outweighs the risk of losing moral standing and reputation. Humphreys states that for many participants, the risk-taking behaviour is a form of psychological charge intertwined in a game of chance that had a winning payoff. The invisibility of

Comprehensive Sexual Education or Bust

2452 words - 10 pages teens that live in states that teach the use on contraception and personal health. While in many parts of the country teen birthrates are declining slightly, the instances of teenagers infected with sexually transmitted infections are on the rise. Students who are taught comprehensive sexual education are fifty percent less likely to have an unintended pregnancy than those who receive sex educations that are abstinence-only. (“Do Something

My View and Opinion on Underage Sex

1273 words - 5 pages , causing the country many more problems than the already have. Religion can play a huge part in whether the age to consent to sex is right or not. In the town of Lubbock in Texas, where a lot of people take the bible literally, the church is powerful enough to ensure that teenagers receive no education about sex, and defiantly none about safe sex. Their teachers tell them that condoms don't work and that sex brings diseases

Similar Essays

Choose A Topic That Interests You, It Should Be Within Your Abilities , There Should Be Enough Information Available On It To Give A Complete Paper. It Should Be No Less Than 2 Pages Long

1596 words - 6 pages see. The verse mentions that above the waves there are clouds. What about the first waves? Scientists have recently discovered "Internal Waves" which occur on density interfaces between layers of different densities. The internal waves cover the deep waters of seas and oceans. Deep waters have a higher density than the waters above them. Internal waves break like surface waves. The human eye cannot detect them. They can only be detected by

The Relation Between Sex, Gender, And Moral Behavior

1526 words - 6 pages The Relation Between Sex, Gender, and Moral Behavior Our history is an account of changes, struggles and progress. It mostly contains writings and deeds of great 'men'. However, in this century, many nations' talent pools have been doubled by the introduction of Women's Suffrage. With that event women in many societies have been able to elevate themselves to a point where they can work towards gaining recognition in domains in which they

Attention Deficit / Hyperactivity Disorder (Adhd) And Gender: Why Are Girls Less Diagnosed Than Boys?

2073 words - 8 pages Behavior Checklist; GAF; and other clinical sub-scales that test for different social difficulties.According to the SAICA girls with ADHD did suffer from more social impairment than did girls without ADHD although they didn't suffer more or less than did their male counterparts with ADHD. They also reported that they found that girls with ADHD and al least one comorbid disorder had a much higher level of social impairment than did girls with only

Scientists, Psychologists And The Media Do Not Have Enough Evidence To Support The Claim Of The Relationship Between Criminal Activity Or Criminal Behaviour And Video Games

1989 words - 8 pages Thesis Statement: Scientists, Psychologists and the Media do not have enough evidence to support the claim of the relationship between criminal activity or criminal behaviour and video games.The public debate regarding the relationship between video games and violence has brewed for decades. The emergence of video games, dramatically changed children's media environment, and this new form of entertainment raised concern because the negative