OPINION ~ ‘Convention of States’ Project Head Seeks To Rein In Federal Overreach, Calls HR 1 ‘Death of Democracy’


By Tom Ozimek and Joshua Philipp   March 16, 2021 Updated: March 16, 2021

Political activist Mark Meckler, who heads the Convention of States Action project, warned that the Democrat-led election reform bill is a threat to democracy, while touting his initiative as a constitutionally-enshrined way to fight back and rein in federal overreach.

Meckler, in an interview with The Epoch Times’ “Crossroads” program, took aim at H.R. 1, or For the People Act of 2021, which passed the Democrat-controlled House on March 3 on a largely party-line vote of 220-210, with all Republicans and a lone Democrat—Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.)—voting against it.

“They call it the For the People Act, I actually call it the Destruction of Democracy Act or the Death of Democracy Act,” Meckler said. “They intend to take the power away from the states—the fundamental power to decide how their elections are run.”

Democrats have framed the bill as a crucial step against voter suppression and other alleged problems.

“Our democracy is in a state of deep disrepair,” said House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) after reintroducing the bill in January. “During the 2020 election, Americans had to overcome rampant voter suppression, gerrymandering and a torrent of special interest dark money just to exercise their right to vote.”

President Joe Biden has strongly advocated for the bill, praising its passage and in a statement saying the legislation is urgently needed to protect the right to vote, as well as to “safeguard the integrity of our elections, and to repair and strengthen our democracy.”

Calling H.R. 1 “dangerous,” Meckler said it means to do away with voter ID laws, which he called one of the simplest protections “we can and should have in states against voter fraud.” Provisions that ostensibly seek to limit dark money in politics would force organizations like his to expose their donor lists, potentially chilling their activity.

“The intent is that the woke mob, the cancel culture, will go after any donors that support the convention of states,” Meckler said, adding that it would have a negative impact on the work of churches and charities. “So I think this is very dangerous,” he added.

An expert at the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, told The Epoch Times in a recent interview that H.R. 1 would eviscerate ballot security measures and called the Democrats’ voter suppression argument “a ridiculous claim.”

“There’s no voter suppression going on. In fact, we have seen turnout in U.S. elections consistently go up in the last few elections that we’ve had, while the states have been doing things like putting in voter ID laws,” said Hans von Spakovsky, senior fellow and manager of the election law reform initiative at the Heritage Foundation.

“Frankly, I really can’t see any reason for these provisions, other than to make it easy to cheat and easy to manipulate election results,” he added, echoing remarks by other critics who have called the measure a power grab.

“It takes all the problems we saw in last year’s election and now cements them into federal law, and actually makes things worse,” von Spakovsky said.

Touting his project as a bulwark against federal overreach in the administration of federal elections and beyond, Meckler explained that the U.S. Constitution allows for states to muster a so-called convention—a body that could assemble and act independently of Congress to adopt constitutional amendments.

“The second clause of Article 5 says that the states—when two thirds of them request it—can gather in convention and propose amendments, and it was specifically inserted there to give the states power to push back against federal tyranny,” said Meckler, who identifies as a constitutional originalist who believes America’s foundational document should be interpreted as close as possible to the original text and intent of its authors, rather than modified in line with the prevailing social or political trends.

“The most important piece of this is that Congress is not involved, the president’s not involved,” Meckler said of the convention, adding that the measure would allow states to bypass Washington and “restore” the Constitution.

“What we’re looking to do is not change the Constitution, but restore the Constitution,” he said, arguing that, over the years, the courts have “dramatically” expanded the limited powers given to the federal government.

“They’re now basically unlimited, unenumerated, and the power pyramid has been flipped on its head—most of the power now resides at the level of the federal government instead of the states,” he said, adding that the convention of states that he is pushing for is “just trying to right the ship and put the power back in the states instead of the federal government.”

He said that, by law, it takes 34 states to call the convention and 38 to ratify any proposed constitutional amendments. His Convention of States Action project would be restricted to considering amendments that would limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government, place term limits on federal officials, and impose fiscal restraints.

So far, 15 states have taken all the necessary legal steps to call the convention, which he said has been attempted over 400 times since the United States was founded, but never successfully.

“Today, there are 21 states in session considering this. I expect that we will pass somewhere between five and 10 states this year, taking us well past the halfway mark” of the 34 needed for the movement to get off the ground.

Follow Tom on Twitter: @OZImekTOM   Follow Joshua on Twitter: @JoshJPhilipp
Posted by C-VINE Volunteer Citizen Journalist: Phil Ingram
Bookmarks:*C-VINE-MeWe, https://mewe.com/join/C-VINE
*C-VINE YouTube Channel, https://www.youtube.com/c/CVINENewsNetwork/videosFacebook Groups :
*C-VINE Commentary & Analysis


  1. tried sharing to FaceBook ~ wouldn’t allow it
    couldn’t even place it in the comments!!
    Says it goes against the community standards….

    1. You won’t be able to Deborah. FB does not like what C-VINE reports. Thank you for trying to share it, though. We are grateful for our supporters and fellow Patriots. 🇺🇸

Comments are closed.