Actual Like Count Only Appears Once New Like is Added
===

We just implemented the like button on our site to replace the old share button, but when we did so, all of the previous counts no longer appear.

The odd thing is -- if I go and like a story that I know had likes before, but our site says doesn't; once I like it, the old count appears adding the 1 I just added. Therefore, FB knows there were likes in the past but just wasn't displaying them until I clicked Like.

Any ideas?

Thanks,

Mathieu